January 13, 2020

OR nurse pipeline expands through clinical immersion program

By: OR Manager
Share

Most hospital leaders are well aware of the coming wave of nurse retirements. However, few leaders understand that this wave will likely hit the OR even earlier than other departments. According to research from NSI Nursing Solutions, surgical services nurses are on average older than other nursing professionals. Because OR nurses as a group are more experienced than others, retirements from perioperative nursing represent not just a reduction in headcount but a loss of decades of valuable experience. As the general population ages and older patients increasingly become eligible for complex procedures, a dramatic drop in perioperative nursing skill is particularly concerning.

At the same time, the education establishment is struggling to supply enough replacements for retiring nurses. For OR leaders, this problem is not just a question of raw numbers. In recent decades, nursing colleges have reduced the amount of instruction devoted to perioperative nursing. Where OR nursing courses still exist, they are almost always electives. As a result, very few nursing students have any exposure to perioperative career opportunities.

In addition, some senior nursing students report that their instructors counsel them to avoid specializing too early. There is some value to this advice, especially for new graduates who do not yet have a sense of their career options. However, to the extent that this attitude exists, it is harder to recruit new graduates into the OR.

Faced with all these challenges, NYU Langone Orthopedic Hospital (one of four campuses within the NYU Langone Health system) implemented the AORN Perioperative 101 training program to increase the supply of OR nurses. A major challenge, however, was attracting new nurse graduates to the program. To build a supply of future potential candidates, it was critical to partner with a nursing college to create a Perioperative Immersion Program (PIP).

 

Building the program

As we set out to develop the PIP, our thesis was simple: No one can fall in love with perioperative nursing if they don’t know anything about it.

The first step was to bring together a project leadership team consisting of executive nurse leaders, nursing education, nursing recruitment, and perioperative nurse leaders. An informal literature review underscored that OR immersion programs had been implemented in only a few hospitals nationwide. However, results from institutions in Ohio, Massachussetts, and other states demonstrated that clinical immersion programs can effectively boost OR recruiting efforts.

After developing some broad ideas, we approached the leadership of NYU Rory Meyers College of Nursing (NYUCON), the health system’s affiliated nursing college. A three-credit elective on perioperative nursing was already part of the college’s senior year curriculum. However, the course did not include a clinical component. NYUCON leaders were very open to the idea of enhancing their existing elective with a clinical immersion experience.

With conceptual agreement established, the nursing leadership team collaborated with the college’s undergraduate dean to hammer out the details. We opened the program to senior BSN students with a cumulative GPA of 3.5 or higher. Students can apply for the PIP by submitting a one-page essay on why they are interested in OR nursing. College faculty members review the applications and select up to 12 students per program session. Clinical rotations take place at two different campuses within the healthcare system: NYU Langone Medical Center (main campus) and the NYU Langone Orthopedic Hospital.

 

How the PIP works

The PIP is an 8-day program, and each day consists of 10 hours of clinical experience, hands-on exercises, and/or lecture. The program takes place over 2 weeks during the last semester before graduation, near the end of NYUCON’s perioperative nursing course. Students are required to keep a journal during the program to document their experience, reflect on what they have learned, and solidify their educational gains.

Day 1: Introduction to perioperative nursing

The focus is understanding basic principles of the AORN Guidelines for Perioperative Practice, including aseptic technique, skin prep, and proper traffic patterns. Students also learn about individual roles within the OR team and the communication principles that underlie high-reliability organizations. Other topics include surgical safety concepts (such as procedure verification and site marking), medication safety, and fire safety.

Day 1 also includes a lab component in a simulated perioperative environment. Using a “demonstration and return demonstration” approach, the instructor teaches the basic skills of working within sterile and nonsterile fields. Students practice setting up an OR, gowning and gloving, and prepping and draping patients.

Day 2: Introduction to an actual OR

Following some additional classroom time, the entire group tours the perioperative services department at one of our two participating hospitals. The tour covers the operating suite, supply and equipment rooms, and other perioperative areas.

Students learn the role of various procedure carts, how to manage specimens, and how to maintain the specimen and autoclave log books. They also learn basic OR safety processes and the location of oxygen shutoff valves, fire extinguishers, fire doors, and exits.

At 2:30 pm, students observe and discuss the change-of-shift handoff. At the end of the day, they meet the preceptors who will supervise their rotations. In our institution, OR preceptors are required to have at least 3 years of experience in perioperative nursing. They must also be knowledgeable in OR processes, demonstrate a positive attitude, and have good communication skills. In addition, we prefer nurses who have completed a professional development program in preceptorship.

 

Days 3 to 8: Clinical rotations throughout all of perioperative services

Students spend 3 full days in the OR, and their remaining 3 days are divided between the postanesthesia care unit (PACU), preadmission testing (PAT), and preoperative holding (sidebar at right).

The students scrub in during one of their OR days and circulate during the remaining two. In addition, each student spends 1 hour with the anesthesia team (guided by either an anesthesiologist or a certified registered nurse anesthetist) and 1 hour in central sterile processing. The emphasis is on deepening the student’s understanding of the different roles within a perioperative team and beginning to develop a surgical conscience.

Day 8 (end of day): Graduation

Members of our perioperative leadership team visit the class, congratulate the group, and hand out certificates of program completion. The aim is to constantly improve the student experience and, as such, a “round robin” is conducted to gather participant feedback.

Participants are asked to share what worked well about the PIP and what could be improved. They are also asked to write a paragraph or two about their experience in the program and how it may have helped them solidify their career goals.

Lastly, a nursing recruiter from our institution speaks to the class about pursuing a perioperative nursing career at NYU Langone. The recruiter describes the opportunity in detail, answers questions, and explains how to apply for a job in our organization.

 

Key lessons

NYU Langone launched the PIP in 2015. As of spring 2019, a total of 118 students had completed the program. Of these participants, 19 were hired by our institution—a 16% hire rate so far.

During the 4 years this program has been in existence, the PIP leadership team has learned several lessons about how to plan and manage an effective clinical immersion program for perioperative services:

Make sure the schedule works for students. When the PIP was first implemented, clinical rotations were inadvertently scheduled to coincide with a license exam review course that many students were also taking. Understandably, students found it hard to focus on this important review course and give their full attention to the program. For later sessions, the PIP schedule was moved forward by about a week to prevent this problem.

In addition, when the PIP was originally launched, it was designed as a 10-day program with 8-hour days. However, this schedule did not allow students to experience a full 10-hour shift in perioperative nursing. To improve the learning experience, we transitioned the program to its current format of eight 10-hour days.

Establish written expectations and policies. At the beginning of the program, we focused intently on designing robust and practical educational content. In retrospect, not enough attention was given to the mundane logistical issues of navigating a group of nursing students through a demanding off-site program. Specifically, we found that we needed to establish basic policies covering attendance requirements and communicating with preceptors.

Get feedback and adjust the program. The student input solicited on the last day of the program has proven to be essential. For example, one early piece of feedback was that students wanted to experience more of the full sweep of perioperative care, not just what goes on in the OR. In response to this suggestion, the clinical rotations were redesigned to include PAT, the PACU, and preoperative holding.

Build recruiting into the program. As noted above, the nursing recruiter meets with the students on the last day of the program to discuss employment opportunities. In addition, the recruiter remains in close contact with students as they move through graduation and licensure. The core goal of a perioperative immersion experience is to build a pool of potential hires, so program leaders should not be shy about asking for what they want.

Establish a tracking system. Whereas the PIP students are currently placed at two campuses, they could be hired at other campuses within the NYU Langone Health system. For immersion programs serving multihospital organizations, a central tracking system would save time and increase the accuracy in identifying the immersion hires from across all campuses. It would also help nursing leaders track retention rates.

 

Cost-effective strategy

As the nursing shortage intensifies, OR management teams will naturally consider devoting more resources to recruiting efforts. However, these efforts can be costly. Recruitment advertising alone can approach $10,000 per hire. If a new

hire later decides that he/she does not want to work in the OR, the organization will incur even more expenses in the form of additional recruiting and orientation costs. In addition, if nursing agencies are used to fill workforce gaps, the costs can go even higher.

Compared to these expenditures, an OR clinical immersion program is very cost-effective. Once the program has been established, it requires relatively little in terms of staff time and attention, and it yields significant returns in the form of new hires. We have found that the PIP students who convert to employees are focused, prepared, and eager to make a commitment to a career in perioperative services.

Acknowledgments

The authors would like to acknowledge Maria Cristina Uy, MSN, RN-BC, CNOR; the perioperative educators, nurse leaders, and staff at NYU Langone Orthopedic Hospital and NYU Langone Medical Center; and colleagues at NYU Rory Meyers College of Nursing for their invaluable contributions to the Perioperative Immersion Program. ✥

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

References

AORN. AORN Guidelines for perioperative practice 2019 (1st ed). Denver, CO: AORN, 2019.

 

Ball K, Doyle D, Oocumma N I. Nursing shortages in the OR: Solutions for new models of education. AORN J. 2015;101(1):115-136.

 

Battie R N. The IOM report on the future of nursing: What perioperative nurses need to know. AORN J. 2013;98(3):227-234.

 

Buerhaus P L, Skinner L E, Auerbach D I, et al. Four challenges facing the nursing workforce in the United States. J Nurs Regul. 2017;8(2):40-46.

 

Edwards D, Hawker C, Carrier J, et al. A systematic review of the effectiveness of strategies and interventions to improve the transition from student to newly qualified nurse. Int J Nurs Stud. 2015;52(7):1254-1268.

 

Gorgone P, Arsenault L, Milliman-Richard Y, et al. Development of a new graduate perioperative nursing program at an urban pediatric institution. AORN J. 2016;104(1):23-29.e2.

 

Mollohan J K, Morales M. Strategies for successful perioperative orientation. AORN J. 2016;104(2):100–110.

 

NSI Nursing Solutions, Inc. 2019 National Health Care Retention & RN Staffing Report. http://www.nsinursingsolutions.com/Files/assets/library/retention-institute/2019%20National%20Health%20Care%20Retention%20Report.pdf.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat