Second in a series on selecting and hiring perioperative nurses and integrating them into the staff.

It has become increasingly evident that ORs need to train their own circulators. St Luke’s Boise Medical Center in Idaho has developed a 14-step onboarding program that helps to recruit and retain qualified RN circulating nurses. The program has achieved a long-term retention rate, and 50% of the present perioperative clinical RN staff are a product of this process. In the past year, the training program attracted over 100 applicants. The onboarding program has 14 steps in 3 categories:
The first article in September 2010 covered Steps 1-4: developing selection criteria, advertising, initial screening, and the phone interview. This article covers Steps 5-9, from OR observation through the interview and job offer.
St Luke’s Boise has 17 ORs and a perioperative staff of over 160 who support the daily schedule of 55 to 80 cases. The ORs are staffed around the clock.
After the initial screening, the next stage in ensuring a candidate makes an informed decision is 4 to 8 hours of OR observation. In most RN education programs, students at best get 1 to 2 days of observation, which doesn’t give them a realistic view of the circulator role.
There are some essential aspects of the observation. I have the candidate arrive at least 5 minutes early and sit in the lounge awaiting our morning report. The goal is for the candidate to observe the interactions of the employees: Are they happy? What are they talking about? Are they grumbling? Do they greet the newcomer?
At morning report, the candidate is introduced as someone who is exploring the OR as a potential next stop in their career. I direct the candidate to the locker room with basic expectations of how to dress. We check in at the front desk, look at our patient load for the day, and choose a room. I’m looking for the right combination of surgeon, surgery, and circulator while reminding the candidate that the goal is to observe the RN circulator and imagine being in this role.
As we walk to the room, I measure whether the person keeps up. Does he or she have the energy for this fast-paced environment?
I see the whole spectrum of interest from candidates. Some are looking for me after 2 hours of observation, wanting to find the locker room. If I had signed them up without this experience, they would have been my first casualties. Others are so engaged that they neglect breaks or lunch until I arrive to take them to the next stage of onboarding.
After about 4 to 5 hours of observation, at an agreed-upon time, I return to their room to retrieve them. I evaluate how they communicate with the staff in the room. Do they simply leave, or have they built a relationship to the point that they at least thank the circulator or even the surgeon? I’ll double back later to get feedback from the circulator.
On the way back to my office, I ask some routine questions. “How did it go? Can you see yourself doing this? Tell me about the surgery.”
Upon arriving at the office, I ask them to reflect on their morning and describe the role of the circulator. This tells me a lot about whether they got the essence of the job.
I restate the training program process and ask if they have questions. I direct the conversation to small talk to further evaluate their communication skills and then assess their passion. Why the OR? What has prepared them for this? What got them through those tough moments in RN school when fellow classmates quit? When you get to that point when you say you are never going back to that job again, what makes you go back anyway?
I talk of the obstacles they will encounter, balanced with the great benefits of an OR career. They will be their own worst critic. They will not feel like quitting in the first few months but will likely question their choice in about month 5 when they realize what they do and don’t know.
I then direct them to class photos of the past 10 years and talk about successes. In all, 85% who joined this program completed at least 2 years in our OR. Over 50% of our present clinical staff are graduates of this program. Several have gone on to leadership roles. I affirm that they will be part of a tested process where successes build on each other. Preceptors volunteer to mentor new people because they know the likelihood of success.
Addressing the vulnerability of adult learners, I cap this off by stating that if they are selected for the program, the screening process is over, and we are into success. But this depends on them making an informed choice. Their response leads me to an important question: “On a scale of 0 to 10, how badly do you want to be an OR circulator?” I value a qualified 7 or 8 more than a flippant 10. Based on the outcomes of this conversation, I may or may not invite them to the next stage of onboarding, the official interview.
Many facilities rely on the manager or director to interview potential candidates and make a job offer. I was hired by an interim director on a Saturday as I was traveling through the state! When that candidate does not work out, the staff legitimately points to the manager for making poor choices.
Our process now is interdisciplinary. While this may seem expensive to productivity, the discerning leader also sees the long-term benefits of reduced attrition and increased morale. On some occasions, I have asked the staff on the interview panel: “Would our staff rather pick up the slack with extra call and added shifts or hire this individual to fill those gaps for us?” Their willingness to pick up the slack has saved us from hiring bitter or dysfunctional individuals even in times of desperation.
Our interview process uses a uniform tool designed to provide consistency for each candidate. The tool itself is a behavioral interview. While we include fun questions like: “What 3 things in your car would tell us about you?” we also include other scenario-based questions. Here is a sample:
I introduce the tool to the candidate, indicating that there isn’t necessarily a right or wrong answer. The goal is to get to know each other. Around the table are a variety of individuals including an RN circulator, a supervisor, a certified surgical technologist, a previous program participant, and an unlicensed assistive person as well as myself. The goal is to have the same individuals present for all interviews to give consistency to the scoring tool.
The scoring tool has a 0-5 point scale. Each answer is scored. The result is a total score that is averaged and entered into a comparative spreadsheet. Some may question whether you can measure an answer to a question such as: “Do you have any questions for us?” Every question has a purpose, including this one. It tells me the level of preparation of the candidate. Some open a binder with typewritten questions and, in essence, begin their interview of us. Others are quick to state they have no questions.
Though a group interview may be intimidating, our goal is to use a friendly approach with introductions, humor, and icebreaker questions. The interview aims to ascertain whether the individual has a passion for this career, willingness to return to the novice role, and suitability to our culture. We know the person’s attitude today will likely resemble his or her attitude 10 years from now, though the skill set will be much different.
Our goal is to have a conversation allowing candidates to ask questions as well. They need to get to know us as much as we need to get to know them.
At the end of the interview, candidates are informed that the next contact will come through human resources after our decisions have been reached, although they are free to call if they have further questions.
After the candidate leaves, the group spends a few minutes finishing the scoring on the interview tool before briefly listing the pros and cons of including this individual. At the end of the interview tool, I include 6 subjective questions. The last question holds a lot of weight. It asks the interviewers to sum up the interview by ranking on the scale of 0-5 their “confidence that candidate is likely to succeed in the perioperative training program.” The averages of this indicator are included in the overall scoring spreadsheet. These numbers are telling when we get to the next stage of onboarding.
At the conclusion of the interview, I work through the scores on a spreadsheet and reassemble the group for deliberations. Often, the top and bottom candidates are quickly identified. The ones in between take the majority of our discussion. Unless we approach this conversation openly not campaigning for a particular candidate, we will not arrive at unanimous decisions or at least a consensus. It has amazed us how we come to solid group decisions on which candidates to invite to the training program.
As part of a health system, our department competes for candidates with other surgical departments. If more than one department wants to make a job offer, the offers are combined through HR, and the final choice belongs to the candidate. Again, observation time is indispensable in drawing the right person to the right department.
The offers are coordinated and emailed to the HR recruiter, who contacts the desired candidates, holding some in reserve and sending polite emails to those who will not be considered this year.
On several occasions, we have had an individual take 10 days to 3 weeks to respond to the job offer. In both cases, these individuals did not last through the initial training. We strongly believe that if, after going through the first 8 steps of this process, a person is not able to make an affirmative decision within the first 3 days, we will withdraw the offer. Those who accept sign a 2-year agreement with a prorated financial obligation. The financial amount is not a reflection of the cost of training but a measure of the depth of their commitment to proceed with the specialty training. Now that we have arrived at a 2-way commitment, it is time to move to the second phase of onboarding, integration.
–Reuben J. DeKastle, RN, MHSA, CNOR
Clinical Educator
St Luke’s Boise Medical Center
Boise, Idaho
The third article will explore the integration phase of onboarding. The first 2 articles addressed screening of candidates. The rest of the series focuses on ensuring success for the new employee.