Productivity is a foundational concept for leaders of ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs). “Measuring productivity is essential to be successful,” says Beverly Kirchner, BSN, RN, CNOR, CASC, chief compliance officer for SurgeryDirect, LLC, Salt Lake City, Utah. “When you’re measuring productivity, you’re looking at efficiency, which affects the types and numbers of cases you can do.”
Time invested in productivity measurement yields dividends for ASC leaders. “It helps leaders be more effective in managing staff and working with surgeons,” says Becky Ziegler-Otis, MHA, CASC, RHIA, CPHQ, CHC, an ASC healthcare consultant in Plover, Wisconsin, and a member of the board of directors for the Ambulatory Surgery Center Association (ASCA). Ziegler-Otis also is assistant executive director for the ASC Quality Collaboration, which partners with outcome measure developers and payers on measure development projects impacting the ASC industry. “Productivity measures can help you assess processes that impact center operations and help pinpoint and focus efforts on what needs attention.” For example, a leader who identifies under-utilized block time might learn that the problem is not lack of volume from the surgeon, but rather that the surgeon’s office staff finds it cumbersome to schedule cases with the ASC. Smoothing the process could increase volume.
But productivity measurement is not without its challenges, as indicated by results from the 2023 OR Manager Salary/Career Survey. In response to an open-ended question, respondents cited issues such as difficulty in obtaining data and lack of time. (For more information, see the September 2023 article “Survey: ASC volumes continue to rise amid staffing challenges,” pp 30–33.) To overcome these challenges, ASC leaders need to establish a measurement process that is both effective and efficient, and they need to closely analyze and communicate results.
A recurring productivity theme from ASC leaders is to “keep it simple.” Start by looking at the big picture, then drill down as needed. “The more complex you make the information gathering, the more likely an error is going to creep into it,” says John Goehle, MBA, CASC, CPA, chief operating officer for Ambulatory Healthcare Strategies, Inc, in Rochester, New York, and host of The ASC Podcast. Kirchner agrees, adding, “If you ask staff to track every time they pick up the phone to make a preop call to a patient and the end time, you’ll never get accurate numbers.”
Ziegler-Otis says ASC leaders should realize that they do not have to be looking at multiple metrics all the time. “If you’ve been tracking a lot of metrics, it’s easy to get data analysis paralysis,” she says. She recommends focusing efforts and working on improving a few key measures at a time. Ziegler-Otis says this approach aligns productivity metrics with continuous quality improvement principles.
Kirchner adds that productivity goals, quality goals, and patient satisfaction are all linked. “When we look at productivity, we want to make sure we don’t cut staffing so short that we’re not delivering quality care, or that the patient feels they didn’t receive individualized care that met their needs,” she says.
“The most important productivity measure for ASCs is nurse staffing,” Goehle says. “How do we staff efficiently?” To answer that question, he recommends ASC leaders use a simple measure: clinical hours per case. “It is one of the most useful tools and one of the easiest to calculate, but it can be very powerful,” he says (sidebar, Calculating hours per case).
This simple calculation has several advantages. First, it does not require obtaining information from an electronic health record (EHR), which many ASCs still lack. Second, it avoids more complicated calculations that ASCs may not have the resources to perform. And third, ASC leaders can use historical data to make the calculation and establish trends. “Every surgical center in the country can use clinical hours per case,” Goehle says.
Kirchner also uses hours per case as the primary productivity measure, but she includes nonclinical staff in the calculation. She tracks productivity daily but primarily focuses on monthly results. “If we keep our staff hours per case at 12 or less, we are profitable that month, our patients don’t complain, and our staff have gotten their hours,” she says. The data are kept in an Excel sheet for easy reference, and an iris recognition time clock helps ensure accuracy of staff hours.
Rena Courtay, MBA, BCN, RN, CASC, CPPM, CNOR(e), does not include nonclinical staff such as schedulers in productivity measures. “Those positions don’t change on a daily basis the way clinical staff do,” says Courtay, who is assistant vice president for perioperative ambulatory surgery at Duke Health and an ASCA board member. Instead, nonclinical staff are considered a fixed cost, so part of the annual budget process is determining the appropriate number for the anticipated volume.
For OR staffing, Courtay uses the formula of 2.5 fulltime equivalent employees (RNs and surgical technologists) for each OR. “That will cover you for nonproductive hours such as meetings and for things like breaks and lunch,” she says.
For the most part, ASCs do not have detailed productivity measurements for the postanesthesia care unit (PACU) or sterile processing department (SPD). “That isn’t information that’s easy to gather and benchmark nationally,” Goehle says. Duke uses number of trays processed for the SPD, but Courtay acknowledges it should not be the sole measure because it fails to account for the complexity of processing some trays. She adds that keeping up with the increasing volume of trays as surgical procedures become more complex is challenging, and that last-minute arrival of loaner trays also is a problem. “We’re needing a lot more people in SPD than we ever did before to keep up with the load,” she says.
Compared to hospitals, the role of technology in obtaining productivity measures is more limited in the ASC because of cost and, in some cases, not having an EHR. Courtay says Duke was able to negotiate a special price for iQueue for Operating Rooms (LeanTaas), which uses predictive analytics and machine learning to provide information used to manage capacity. The detailed information has helped facilitate her discussions about block utilization with surgeons.
Ziegler-Otis says that even ASCs without an EHR usually have a practice management system for scheduling that leaders can leverage to obtain useful productivity data. “Most scheduling software has the ability to run analytics and data reports,” she says. For example, practice management software typically can track surgeon-specific surgical procedure time and calculate an average case time that can be used to schedule future cases, resulting in effective utilization of a surgeon or group block time. As with any system, data entry must be precise to obtain useful data.
Benchmarking can be a challenge for ASC leaders because few national resources exist. One resource is Intellimarker (VMG Health), which has data for multispecialty ASCs, including revenue, expenses, case volume and mix, payor mix, reimbursement, and staffing. Courtay adds that Becker’s sometimes publishes articles with benchmarking data, and that the ASC management company often sets benchmarks. Another resource is ASCA’s Clinical & Operational Benchmarking Survey (sidebar, Benchmarking resource).
In addition to external sources, ASC leaders can benchmark productivity measures, such as clinical hours per case, against their own performance over time to determine operational efficiency levels. Goehle gives the example of an ASC that has been running at 8 hours per case for the past four quarters but slipped to 7 (a number the center has never seen). In this case, more staff are likely needed, unless staff is complaining about their workload, which may indicate that the center was properly staffed before the decline. “The beauty of this is that you can sell it to the doctors,” Goehle says. For instance, the ASC leader could say, “We’ve never been as low as 7 and staff and patients are complaining; it may be time for us to staff up a bit more.”
Clinical hours per case can serve as an early warning sign for other problems. If, for instance, the number of hours increases from 10 to 13 and staff satisfaction has not changed, an ASC leader would want to examine other possible reasons, such as an increase in delays in first case on-time starts as a result of adding a new surgeon.
A key factor to consider when analyzing data is knowing when to dive deeper into the data. “You have to understand the whole picture,” Kirchner says. “When you break processes down too much, you lose focus of what your end goal is.” For example, if the first case is 15 minutes late, but the time is made up by the end of the day, a leader would not want to criticize staff for the late start.
On the other hand, if overall productivity measures are declining, the ASC leader should look at the process in more detail to identify problem areas. Kirchner cites the example of focusing on preoperative patient preparation. “The preop process drives the ASC’s efficiency,” she says. The centers she works with spend time educating patients and families to improve time to discharge and establish parameters for what is needed before each case. For instance, patients who will undergo complex spine procedures must have a full history and physical at least 7 days pre-surgery, or the case gets cancelled.
After making a change, Ziegler-Otis says ASC leaders should continue monitoring to ensure the change had the desired impact. For example, a leader might implement 10-hour shifts as a staff satisfier and to improve productivity, only to discover that staff do not support the change and productivity does not improve; unintended staff turnover could occur as a result. In addition, solutions should be tailored to the ASC’s need. “What works at one center doesn’t necessarily work at another,” she says. “Each ASC is unique, so you might have to tweak things based on your needs.”
The results of productivity measures should be shared with the ASC’s board and staff. Kirchner says boards usually comprise mostly surgeons (who also may be owners), often making communication easier for ASC leaders compared to their hospital counterparts. “Surgeons understand productivity because it hits them in the wallet,” she says. “The more productive we are, the more money they make.”
When meeting with owners and boards, Ziegler-Otis recommends ASC leaders always include labor and supply costs as a percentage of revenue. Discussing these and other productivity measures regularly helps foster buy-in when the leader needs additional staff or to make changes to improve efficiency. One example is when labor costs go up, but block time utilization goes down (the target is usually 75%). “A leader could then work with surgeons to compress the schedule and use block time more effectively to ensure cases flow as efficiently as possible,” Ziegler-Otis says.
Communicating productivity results can help with planning for the future. Courtay keeps a spreadsheet that includes daily case volume and staff for the preoperative area, OR, and PACU in each ASC in the Duke Health System and uses this simple tool to show senior leadership the scope of what is needed. “I can explain it to the CEO of the hospital, and he gets it,” she says. Courtay recently used the spreadsheet to help her obtain approval for needed positions. “We were able to show that we are already below where we are supposed to be for staffing,” she says. Leaders at each ASC setting also use the tool to help determine daily staffing needs. “It holds them accountable for maximizing productivity.”
Staff productivity depends on having staff work to the top of their license. “You don’t have nurses doing things like cleaning or pulling cases that lower-paid positions could do,” Courtay says. She adds that Duke has an advantage in that it can shift staff from one ASC to another to optimize productivity at each location.
Courtay says ASC leaders should not establish staffing levels based on peak volume, but rather focus on minimum requirements, then use per diem staff to supplement as needed. This strategy helps avoid needing to send staff home because of low volume.
Staff sometimes feel pressured to increase their productivity, believing they already have too much work. They may even say patient safety is at risk. In this case, Courtay focuses on whether standards are being met. If they are, it helps take the emotion out of the discussion. For staff who complain about being required to go to other ASCs when census is low, Courtay frames it as a way to help staff get their hours.
“The best way to boost productivity is to make your employees happy,” Goehle says. “You want to make sure people are totally trained for the position, that they’re properly mentored, and that they’re given the proper amount of time to acclimate to the job.” He recommends ASC leaders have new staff meet with those working in other areas. For instance, an OR nurse should spend time in PACU. In addition to building relationships, “they might see things that no one else noticed but could be changed to improve care and productivity,” Goehle says. It can be difficult to invest in onboarding time when staff shortages exist, but doing so will reduce staff turnover and ultimately save the center money.
Keeping employees happy depends on maintaining a positive culture, Courtay says. “You want to explain why you are doing things, how they can be a part of it, and get their ideas about how things can work better.” She adds that ongoing recognition is key, “They want to hear ‘thank you’ and know that what they’re doing is appreciated.”
A positive culture includes positioning productivity as a positive force. “Try to have staff look at productivity in a positive way,” Ziegler-Otis says. Leaders can work with staff to identify ways to change work processes so they are more productive but also are doing the clinical work they are trained for, rather than less satisfying work that others or technology can do. Listening to staff’s ideas and concerns is key. For example, if staff are concerned about an added task, leaders can work with them to see if there are other activities that could be eliminated, such as those that are only being done because of tradition but are hindering productivity.
Ziegler-Otis adds that to maintain efficiency, leaders need to address staff issues promptly to avoid a drop in morale. “The efficiency of an organization is directly related to the morale of employees,” she says. “If an employee is behaving inappropriately or causing team issues, it’s important to address the issue, work through it in a timely manner, and not let it persist.”
“With value-based care moving into the ASC, productivity is going to become more and more important to us,” Kirchner says. By keeping measures simple and using data to make thoughtful changes, ASC leaders can enhance the success of their centers. “The metrics can help you think through ways to be a more effective leader and to enable your staff to be more effective as well,” Ziegler-Otis says.
—Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.