Hospitals are facing stiff economic winds. They are challenged by shrinking reimbursement from Medicare and Medicare, even as more patients will be covered by these publicly funded programs. Perioperative managers and directors are under pressure to make the most of their department’s resources. You’re being asked to measure every aspect of your OR’s performance from on-time starts to turnover time to OR utilization.
An analysis from the OR Benchmarks Collaborative (ORBC), a service of McKesson, provides information you can use to compare your department’s performance (sidebar, p 14).
To provide a picture of how US facilities are performing on ORBC’s key performance indicators, an independent analysis was performed for McKesson by the QI Project, a unit of Press Ganey. The QI Project has long experience in data collection and analysis of quality improvement measures.
The analysis included a subset of 134 US facilities and 107 Canadian facilities that had submitted a full 12 months of validated data for all 55 data elements for 2010.
This article focuses on the US hospital sample. Of the US facilities, 87% were short-term acute care hospitals, 11% were ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs), and 2% were specialty hospitals, such as orthopedic, cardiac, or children’s facilities.
The median number of ORs for the hospitals was 11.1; the largest group (35%) had 6 to 10 ORs. A third (30%) had an academic program, as defined by the Council of Teaching Hospitals.
In all, 27% had an open-heart program, 23% had an oncology program, and 10% had a transplant program. About three-fourths (78%) were located in urban areas, and 16% were rural (charts).
The most common procedures these hospitals performed in the aggregate are cataracts (6.8%), cystoscopy (3.8%), knee/hip/shoulder arthroscopy (3.4%), laparoscopic cholecystectomy (3.1%), and total knee replacements (2.5%).
The sample has a similar demographic profile to hospitals nationally, as indicated by a comparison with the American Hospital Association database, though the sample has a higher percentage of academic hospitals (31% versus 8%).
| Sample demographics | ||
| ORBC sample | American Hospital Association sample | |
| Median no. of ORs | 11.1 | 8.4 |
| Academic program | 30.9% | 8.3% |
| Location | ||
| Urban | 78.3% | 78.4% |
| Rural | 15.8% | 21.6% |
| Benchmarking participant demographics | |
| Type of US facility | |
| Hospital | 87% |
| ASC | 11% |
| Other | 2% |
| Other includes specialty hospitals, such as eye, orthopedic, and heart hospitals. | |
| US ambulatory surgery centers | |
| 1-5 ORs | 48% |
| 6-10 ORs | 43% |
| >16 ORs | 9% |
The chart on page 14 illustrates how these hospitals performed on a selected group of the key performance indicators, such as first-case on-time starts and turnover time, reporting performance levels for the median as well as the 90th and 95th percentiles.
Some indicators show a fairly large spread between the median and the 90th and 95th percentiles, indicating these measures are still challenging, despite the considerable effort many ORs have made to improve on them. Examples are the accuracy of case-duration estimates and on-time starts for first cases of the day and for subsequent cases.
For instance, if your facility is 60% accurate in estimating case durations, you know you’re close to the 95th percentile for this sample of hospitals. But if you’re at 65% for first-case on-time starts, which is close to the median, you know there’s room to improve. Thus, you might decide to focus more time on improving first-case starts than on improving scheduling accuracy. (ORBC defines “on time” for first cases as the patient in the room early or within 5 minutes after the scheduled start time. For subsequent cases, “on time” means the patient is in the room early or within 15 minutes after the scheduled start time.)
Though much of the focus is on first-case starts, there was also a large gap in performance in being on time for subsequent cases. At the median, just over half (53.5%) of these cases started on time.
For turnover time, the median overall was 28.5 minutes, while at the 95th percentile, turnover time was 21.4 minutes. Turnover time is measured from when the prior patient exits the room until the succeeding patient enters the room.
In addition to measuring turnover time, it can be useful to compare in-room time segments for surgical cases, including patient entry to incision and last incision closed to patient exit, to see if there is room to improve. The chart on this page shows case times for common procedures and compares time segments for hospitals and ASCs as well as US and Canada.
Prime-time utilization (7 am to 3 pm) at the median was 75% for this group of hospitals. Utilization is defined in ORBC as rooms in use for patient care plus turnover time.
Regarding preadmission screening, at the median, about half (49%) of patients were screened prior to the day of surgery. At the 90th and 95th percentile, the level was much higher, with 80% of patients screened.
| Key performance indicator results | |||
| Indicator | Median | 90th percentile | 95th percentile |
| Accurate case-duration estimate | 41.7% | 56.1% | 61.4% |
| First case on time/early | 64.3% | 88.3% | 91.4% |
| Subsequent case on time/early | 53.5% | 71.6% | 74.9% |
| Patient in to incision (minutes) | 25.7 | 20.4 | 19.7 |
| Patient close to out (minutes) | 9.6 | 6.9 | 6.5 |
| Turnover time (minutes) | 28.5 | 22.7 | 21.4 |
| Preadmission screening | 49.0% | 80.4% | 80.4% |
| Surgical checklist | 100% | 100% | 100% |
| Prime-time utilization (7 am to 3 pm) | 75.3% | 93.9% | 100.0% |
| Indicator definitions | ||
| Accurate case-duration estimate | Patient in to incision | Preadmission screening |
| Measures the percentage of cases where patient-in-room duration is within 15 minutes of the estimated in-room duration. | Measures the average time (in minutes) that elapsed between the patient entering the operating room and the first incision. | Measures the percentage of cases that were recorded as screened prior to surgery. Only cases specifically recorded as yes (screened) or no (not screened) are included in the measure. |
| First case on time/early | Patient close to out | Surgical checklist |
| Measures percentage of first cases with an in-room start time that is either early or not more than 5 minutes after the scheduled start time. | Measures the average time (in minutes) that elapsed between the close of the last incision and the time the patient left the operating room. | Compliance with the surgical pause before incision. |
| Subsequent case on time/early | Average turnover minutes | Prime-time utilization |
| Measures percentage of subsequent cases with an in-room start time that is either early or not more than 15 minutes after the scheduled start time. | Measures the time (in minutes) that elapsed between the prior patient exiting the room and the succeeding patient entering the room. | Measures percentage of total available time between 7 am and 3 pm with all rooms in use for patient care plus turnover time. |
| Source: McKesson. OR Benchmarks Collaborative. Reprinted with permission. | ||
A well-managed block schedule provides predictable operating times for high-volume surgeons and specialties, but blocks that are not managed well leave gaps in the schedule that hinder productivity.
The ORBC hospitals in the sample, on average, allocated 80% of their available OR time to blocks. Most of the block time (78% on average) was allocated to services rather than to the individual surgeon (22%).
Average block utilization was 82%, indicating ORs are managing their blocks fairly tightly. The top 5 service lines to which blocks are allocated are:
• orthopedics
• general surgery
• gynecology
• urology
• ophthalmology.
As part of the study, the QI Project used statistical modeling to examine correlations between performance and hospital characteristics such as country (US or Canada), facility type, and number of operating rooms.
Though the number of ORs had a complex relationship with most measures, in general, facilities with the most ORs showed a trend toward less efficient use of resources.
In highlights:
• US hospitals on average were 10 percentage points lower in scheduling accuracy than their Canadian counterparts.
• For turnover time, US hospitals took 15 minutes longer on average than Canadian hospitals.
• Acute care facilities have turnover times that average 22 minutes longer than ASCs.
Hospitals that conducted preadmission screening for 100% of their patients had a statistically significant higher rate (69.3%) of on-time first-case starts than hospitals that did not screen 100% of their patients (58.5%). But preadmission screening was not statistically associated with a significant difference in on-time starts for subsequent cases.
The case cancellation rate was 1.7% for hospitals and 1.0% for ASCs. On average, hospital ORs lost 19 hours of surgery time per month because of cancellations, while ASCs on average lost 5 hours per month. The average time lost was much higher for hospitals in urban areas (21 hours/month) than for those in rural areas (6 hours/month) and other types of facilities (5 hours/month).
The data from the ORBC analysis offers benchmarks of actual performance from this sample of hospitals. It is information hospitals can use to see what others have achieved, gauge their own performance, and set realistic priorities and goals.❖
More information on the McKesson OR Benchmarks Collaborative is at http://sites.mckesson.com/orbc/webinars.htm