Recruiting and retaining OR nurses is harder than ever in the COVID-19 era. Many healthcare facilities are reconstructing their surgical case schedules after the mandatory pause in elective procedures, and some are still on hold. OR leaders are focused largely on guiding staff through the crisis and working toward a normal surgical volume. But to sustain a healthy workforce, they must also focus on developing competent staff who will want to stay with the organization.
I recommend partnering with hospital leadership and human resources and establishing a task force to create a long-term strategy for staff development.
Nursing has always been a career path of security and flexibility. But the pandemic has changed healthcare delivery, interrupting some surgical patient care and requiring some staff to be furloughed or redeployed temporarily.
Nurses no longer have the comfort of knowing they will always be working in the surgical services department with familiar schedules. Hospitals may not have the option to grant OR staff low-census hours or paid time off when the OR is not busy.
Some nurses were furloughed for 6 to 8 weeks, and some are still waiting to be called back to work. Some were transferred to other units where they felt inadequately prepared to work. The need to help staff in other units of the hospital is a new reality, but one that comes with a silver lining: Staff returning to the OR from inpatient units will bring insights into patient throughput that can help improve patient care.
On the other hand, many OR nurses who have experienced reduced staffing, lack of personal protective equipment, new safety-related processes, and longer shifts feel that they have never worked so hard with so few surgical cases. In addition, some nurses have had to quarantine, home-school their children, and support extended family members.
As they return to the OR, many nurses are frustrated by the lack of transparency regarding departmental decisions or other poor communication. They ask: “How were decisions made? Is my job safe now? Do I need to look elsewhere to protect my career? If a second wave of the virus strikes, will I be furloughed again?”
Directors, managers, and human resources staff need to be ready to address the professional and personal needs of staff as they return to work. Processes, policies, and patient care delivery have changed. There must be a reorientation day to formally introduce staff to new processes and guidelines for successful and safe care. Bringing staff up to speed on the “why” behind the new guidelines will help them better understand the halt in operations to evaluate and redesign safe OR care.
Perioperative leaders also need to be cognizant of the emotional needs of their returning staff and make sure support services and wellness programs are available. Staff may face personal issues at home, such as the need to take care of their children and other family members.
Review workflows, modify as necessary, and address any issues so that they do not develop into bigger ones. Leaders must nurture existing staff while also working to attract new staff. They do not want to lose staff and drive physicians to competing hospitals.
Some hospitals have reduced call requirements based on age and seniority, and as a result, OR staff are required to rotate call assignments more often. The combination of reduced call for some and increased call for others is a major dissatisfier for younger generations who prioritize work/life balance and the ability to care for their growing families.
Creating a call environment that meets the needs of the facility and its staff is a win-win endeavor. Hospital leaders need to explore the feasibility of hiring one RN and one OR technician to work Sunday night through Thursday night full time to cover call. Regular OR staff can cover weekends and holidays.
Performing a financial analysis of call pay and called-in on call pay will help determine whether a regular night team is advantageous. Surprisingly, some facilities have found it is financially beneficial to have regular call staff. A retrospective analysis of the weekend surgical schedule may support the notion of recruiting permanent weekend call staff. Some staff members may want call hours and pay to meet their financial needs.
A formal OR nurse internship program that provides adequate orientation and supports personal and professional growth is the best way to nurture new nurses. The perioperative director should meet with the nursing students who have clinical assignments within their facility. Often, OR rotation is not part of the student nurse experience. Senior students who request perioperative experience should be given an opportunity to see the OR life. They may develop their capstone project based on their OR experience. Prudent selection of the student is best to align with the facility’s goal to attract staff.
A nurse educator supported plan should include an assigned clinical coach and personal mentor to guide the intern through each surgical specialty, in collaboration with the nurse educator. Each intern must satisfy the requirements of the program to move through each specialty. A key specialty physician should review clinical practice performance and recommendations.
A second clinical mentor can help interns move through each phase, addressing their concerns and fears. The highly intensive environment of the surgical suite can be overwhelming. It is important for new staff to be able to read the OR environment and understand their roles and how to respond.
It usually takes 12 months to launch new OR staff. Some facilities support a sign-on bonus for new staff who successfully achieve milestones. An agreement can be developed at the beginning of the program with retention goals. It is recommended that candidates meet the staff and tour the department as part of the hiring process.
In 2019, 69% of new nurses entering the job force had an average of $29,800 in school loans. In 2013, research showed that financial incentives were the most commonly reported retention strategy. Nurses looking for employment will not consider a hospital that does not have an education allowance or student loan forgiveness program.
Can your organization support loan forgiveness or an award paid directly to the employee’s student financial service? If so, perhaps the award can be scheduled according to milestones for successful orientation and launching to independence, annual review goals, participation in the shared governance team, or department quality initiatives.
Pathways to achieve advanced levels of expertise and responsibility are key for retention. Involvement in unit education, mentorship, orientation of new employees, hospital committees, research, and quality audits are some of the ways OR nurses can advance in their careers. They should also be encouraged to obtain certifications. Setting performance goals and recognizing accomplishments within each specified category will help motivate and energize staff.
As much as 25% of all hired staff quit within 1 year, and it costs an estimated $80,000 to train one specialty nurse. So often during exit interviews, we hear that the staff are “just not nice.” Why are we so cruel to our new peers? Where is our nursing conscience? Are we rude to our patients and families?
Unhealthy practice environments have serious negative impacts on recruitment and retention of healthcare professionals. A positive, supportive, and empowered clinical unit is key to retaining staff. Staff ownership in department decisions and opportunities to improve processes are paramount for successful retention and patient safety. Direct relationships with clinical leaders and administration are valued and promote a positive atmosphere.
Leaders need to manage the clinical practice and set behavioral expectations to ensure retention and delivery of quality patient care. Orientation is time intensive and exhausting. Repeating that process frequently is a burden on the department and can create an unsafe environment. It is to everyone’s advantage to help new staff succeed.
Regular one-on-one meetings between managers and new hires is a good way to address any issues.
Remind staff that new hires are their relief for lunches, breaks, and vacation. Encourage everyone to bond through social activities, and hold people accountable for disruptive behavior. When there is a healthy work environment, quality patient care and satisfaction will rise.
COVID-19 has changed our lives forever. With the added stressors at work and at home, healthcare facilities should make wellness a priority. Staff appreciate onsite programs such as yoga, exercise, self-improvement programs, weight-loss clubs, and focus groups. Promoting well-being and self-care creates a healthy atmosphere for long-term retention and low turnover.
As surgical volume ramps up during COVID-19, it’s important for OR leaders to anticipate needs and take steps to solidify their teams. Often, healthcare staff forgo personal needs to provide services to their patients and physicians. All OR team members—anesthesia providers, surgeons, and nursing staff—depend on one another to perform at the highest level. There is no room for mediocrity.
Recruiting and retaining excellent nursing staff is crucial for physician retention and excellent patient outcomes, which, in turn, ensure the sustainability of the organization. ✥
Foster S. Making retention strategies work. Br J Nurs. 2017;26(4):251.
Gaines K. Interventions to promote nursing retention. Webinar. 2019. www.nursing.org.
Hairr D, Salisbury H, Johannsson M, et al. Nurse staffing and the relationship to job satisfaction. Nurs Econ. 2014;32(3):142-147.
Hirschkorn C, West T, Hill K, et al. Experienced nurse retention strategies: What can be learned from top-performing organizations. J Nurs Admin. 2010;40(11):463-467.
Mbemba G, Gagnon M-P, Pare G, et al. Interventions for supporting nurse retention in rural and remote areas: An umbrella review. Hum Resour Health. 2013;11(44). Published online September 11, 2013.
Merlino M. (2019). Creating our future through mentoring. AORN J. 2019;110(2):127-129.
Snavely T M. A brief economic analysis of the looming nursing shortage in the United States. Nurs Econ. 2016;34(2):98-100.
Tucker S, Gallagher-Ford L, Baker M, et al. Promoting nurse retention through career development planning. Am J Nurs. 2019;119(6):62-66.