Streaming music apps and access to music through smartphones and similar devices make it easy to provide many different genres of music and modalities that can ease surgical patients’ fears. The use of music in both pre- and postoperative settings has been extensively researched, but less is known about how to implement a holistic music-listening program and which modalities are most effective.
At the 2020 OR Manager Conference’s ASC Leader Summit, Carol Pehotsky, DNP, RN, NEA-BC, ACNS-BC, CPAN, associate chief nursing officer, surgical services nursing, Cleveland Clinic Enterprise, and Kristen Vargo, DNP, RN, NE-BC, nurse manager, same day surgery and pediatric postanesthesia care unit (PACU), Cleveland Clinic Main Campus, Cleveland, Ohio, discussed their work on implementation of streaming, music-listening programs for their pre- and postoperative patients, demonstrating how this approach helped reduce preoperative anxiety and postoperative pain.
Pehotsky, who was a music therapist before she went into nursing, says providing music-therapy services for patients on a burn unit opened her eyes to “the power of nursing.”
She points out that nurses should not refer to providing music to their patients as music therapy. Music therapists are trained and certified individuals who assess a patient’s needs and determine how to use music as a medium to accomplish those needs.
Listening to music can have emotional, cognitive, and physiological effects.
Emotional effects. Someone who is having a down day can suddenly feel better when they hear a favorite song. “That is not just by coincidence, and it is not just because of the words,” says Pehotsky. “It is because music helps our brains release dopamine, which can improve depressive symptoms.”
As part of music- therapy research, some patients are writing songs to help them release emotions and choosing listening programs that help them redirect their thoughts and feelings to trigger a dopamine release.
Cognitive effects. Music can enhance learning and improve memory. “The association of information with music helps our brains recall it more quickly,” Pehotsky says. For example, the ABC song children are taught helps them learn and remember the alphabet.
The transfer effect, which is similar to the effect of the ABC song, helps the brain remember a specific thing learned by setting it to music.
Research also has shown that students who study with the right music in the background can focus better, and the music enhances their learning and can help improve academic performance.
In addition, many studies have shown that music helps patients recover cognitive function after a stroke. For example, music tempo can be slowly adjusted to help patients structure their gait as they learn how to walk again.
Studies also show the benefits of using music to enhance verbal ability in those with learning challenges.
Physiological effects. Music enhances exercise performance, which is why it is not unusual to see headphones on people who are running, cycling, or working out in the gym. “When people do this, they’re not just occupying their minds with something while on a not-very-stimulating treadmill, it truly does enhance exercise performance,” says Pehotsky. “If they play music with an upbeat tempo, their bodies will sync with the tempo of the music. This is why people run faster, farther, and with less tax on their bodies—because their bodies are in tune, so to speak, to the rhythm and tempo of the music.”
Music also reduces cortisol levels and stress hormones, and improves sleep. “It’s no coincidence that there are a lot of apps and programs containing guided imagery to music,” she says, “because music helps our brains stop thinking and worrying about the work of the day to focus on the work of sleep.”
Research has examined whether there is a “right or a wrong” music for certain activities, such as soothing music for yoga. For patients trying to relax for surgery, loud music with a heavy beat would not help manage anxiety. However, Pehotsky says, in many situations there is nothing wrong with using music with a heavy beat if that is what the patients prefer. “It’s really what works best for them,” she says.
Pehotsky notes that research has shown if patients don’t like new-age music, for example, telling them they have to listen to it to relax will have the opposite effect. “If they don’t enjoy that type of music, you are not going to accomplish your goals,” she says.
Studies have shown that listening to music with headphones has the most positive effect on patients. Headphones minimize ambient and distracting noise so patients can focus more on the music, and they have control over what’s being played.
For those considering implementing music in their practice settings, Pehotsky notes that both in research and her own experience, ambient “background” music in PACUs is largely ineffective. After receiving feedback about background music being an irritant and an impediment to patients’ communication with nurses, she says, they turned off the ambient music in her PACU.
Pehotsky says the literature on the effects of music listening in the perioperative experience highlights those effects in four categories:
• Vital signs—a trained music therapist can lower a patient’s heart rate by selecting a piece of music at the tempo of the heart rate and gradually slowing the tempo to bring the patient’s heart rate down.
• Anxiolytic effects—music is able to combat patient anxiety both on its own and in conjunction with medications.
• Subjective pain ratings and opiate use—music has a positive effect on both the subjective pain ratings patients give and their actual opiate use.
• Patient experience—music can enhance patients’ experiences by distracting them from their fears. Having something familiar, even a familiar song on their own iPods or cell phones and being able to interact with their own playlists, can provide great comfort.
“Being perioperative leaders, we know the anxiety our patients can experience in the preoperative setting,” says Vargo.
Preoperative anxiety is a physiological disorder that can cause adverse effects intraoperatively and postoperatively. It is one of the most common emotional responses that surgical patients experience, and it occurs even when the risk of death is low and the chance of success is high.
Studies suggest that preoperative anxiety can lead to poor outcomes, increased risk of infection, and unwarranted movement during surgery, like coughing. Vargo implemented a music-listening project in the preoperative setting for adult surgery patients on a preoperative nursing unit at Cleveland Clinic academic medical center. Most patients receiving care in this setting are those having abdominal surgery. Anxiolytic medications previously had been used as calming agents, but these can result in prolonged recovery from anesthesia and thereby increase length of stay.
“The scope and purpose of my project was to understand factors that influence our perioperative patients to listen to music,” says Vargo. The project drilled down into demographic factors and looked at the level of anxiety patients were experiencing. It also looked at factors that inhibited patients from listening to music.
Her PICOT [Population/Patient Problem, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome, Time] question for the project was: “Do patients with low, moderate, and severe anxiety react differently to the implementation of music listening guidelines?”
Guidelines for the project, which was implemented over 9 weeks, included:
• an anxiety scale of 0 to 10, with 0 meaning no anxiety and 10 meaning the highest level of anxiety—0 to 3 was considered low, 4 to 6 was moderate, and 7 to 10 was severe
• a theoretical framework based on Florence Nightingale’s Environmental Theory, which is defined as “the act of utilizing the environment of the patient to assist him in his recovery.”
Nightingale’s theory includes 11 factors that nurses should focus on to promote patients’ health and well-being, and she was one of the first nurses to use music for healing.
Patients scheduled as first round were excluded from the music-listening project because they generally were not in the preoperative setting long enough to implement the music intervention. Hard-of-hearing and deaf patients also were excluded, as were those with an aversion to headphones.
Recent advancements in technology and streaming services made implementation of the project and sanitization of the headphones and music devices much easier, says Vargo. Fifth-generation, iPod Touch music devices with waterproof case covers were chosen because they are easy to use and sanitize between patients. Over-the-ear headphones were used to provide an easy way to apply headphones to the patient while ensuring they could be cleaned without damage.
Internet streaming apps offer many different music options for patients. Looking at the Spotify app and Pandora app, Vargo says she found that the Pandora app gave users the option to like and dislike music they were listening to, which then affected subsequent songs played in the app.
“When an app is going to be used for multiple patients, you don’t want them to be able to alter the music options they have available to them,” Vargo says.
The Spotify app was selected for this project because the app’s playlists could not be adjusted by the user. Six stations were offered based on their variety and content, which included songs with no lyrics, those with a minimal variation in volume, and songs with a slow and steady tempo. The six stations were representative of the following music types: jazz, piano, classical, guitar, new age, and world music.

This preoperative music listening protocol was developed to help guide nurses with implementation. Source: Cleveland Clinic. Used with permission.
Vargo developed a protocol to guide the nursing staff with implementation of the preoperative intervention (sidebar, “Preoperative Intervention”).
At the start of each day, chart reviews were conducted to obtain basic demographic information, including age, gender, race, and surgical procedure, and this information was documented on an audit tool. During the preoperative assessment, the nurse collected an anxiety rating from each patient, which also was documented on the audit tool.
Next the nurses discussed the music-listening project with the patients, including the method in which the music was offered, the music stations, and how to control the volume. If a patient agreed to listen to the music and provided verbal consent, the nurse pulled up the station the patient selected and started their music listening.
Vargo says they tracked the amount of time patients listened to the music, if they had any interruption in their music, and if they received any anxiolytic medications.
They asked the patients, on a scale of 0 (not likely at all) to 10 (very likely), how likely they would be to listen to music for a future surgical procedure.
Additionally, data were collected on patients who were not given the opportunity to listen to music and patients who didn’t want to listen to music. Anecdotal notes were logged to document the reason the music was not offered or declined.
A total of 483 patients were enrolled in the project. Of those, 270 declined the music, 122 agreed to music, and 91 were not offered music. The primary reason patients were not offered the music intervention was because they were called to the OR during the preoperative assessment, not allowing enough time for the intervention.
The mean age of patients in both the listening and declined groups was 52 years; both groups had a higher number of female patients and white/Caucasian patients; and the patients were primarily admitted for abdominal and colorectal surgery.
When analyzing the demographic data, there was no association found between whether patients listened to the music or declined the music intervention and their gender, age, ethnicity, or surgical procedure.
The preoperative mean anxiety rating was higher in the patients who chose to listen to the music compared with the patients who declined the music. In addition, there was a lower percentage of patients in the low anxiety category and a higher percentage of patients in the high anxiety category in the group that listened to the music.
Those in the listening group listened to music a mean of 69.54 minutes. The mean rating of the likelihood they would listen to music in the future was 8.0 in a range of 0 to 10. Only 12 patients rated this question below a five, citing that they did not like the music genre selections.
Of the patients who listened to music, only 10% also received an anxiolytic medication, and 50% experienced one or more interruptions, such as unavoidable visits by surgeons and anesthesiologists.
“This analysis confirmed that music listening is an effective intervention in the preoperative setting, and that patients would listen to music in the future,” Vargo says.
In a project that complements Vargo’s, Pehotsky examined postoperative pain management and the effects of music on the need for analgesics in the PACU.
The PICOT question for her study was: “Do patients in the PACU recovering from abdominal surgery experience less pain, as measured by subjective pain rating, vital signs, time to PACU discharge readiness, and opioid usage, when provided with relaxation music via an Internet radio provider than those patients receiving usual care for pain management?”
Pehotsky notes that she also looked at how to adopt a music-listening program and how to encourage nurses to continue offering the program to patients once the study was completed.
Though the patients wouldn’t be listening to the music until after surgery, the project was discussed with them before surgery to get their consent and understand their music preferences. Patients were assured they could discontinue the music anytime they wanted to by taking the headphones off or by saying they didn’t want to listen anymore and a nurse would help them. They also had the option of changing stations.
Only one patient had a very short listening experience—because of high levels of pain, the music was an aggravant rather than a relaxant.
The participants in this project were compared to a similar group of patients who had surgery in the 4-week period before implementation. The groups were matched by gender, ethnicity, surgical approach (open vs laparoscopic), and age.
Subjective pain ratings revealed a statistically significant difference from PACU admission to discharge for the intervention group, which went from 6.92 down to 4, compared with 7.6 down to 5 in the comparison group. Notable is that 64% of the intervention group had previous diagnoses of chronic pain, compared to 37% in the comparison group.

Hydromorphone use was lower in the intervention group than in the comparison group. Source: Cleveland Clinic. Used with permission.
Heart rates for the intervention group went down from 76.84 to 75.83 beats per minute (BPM) compared to a rise from 79.08 to 82.52 BPM for the comparison group.
In terms of other vital signs, there were differences but none were statistically significant. Overall hydromorphone use was 1.35 mg for intervention patients and 1.87 mg for comparison patients, across their PACU stays. By hour, hydromorphone use was 0.47 mg for intervention patients and 0.75 mg for comparison patients. These differences were not statistically significant.
For patients with a history of chronic pain, however, the differences were statistically significant, with overall hydromorphone use at 1.13 mg in the intervention group versus 2.89 mg in the comparison group. By hour, hydromorphone use was 0.42 mg in the intervention group versus 1.21 mg in the comparison group (sidebar, “Hydromorphone Use”).
Vargo noted that her project helped establish guidelines for implementing a preoperative music-listening program, and it showed the benefits music has on preoperative patients. The results of this project support that patients with all levels of preoperative anxiety can benefit from the use of music listening preoperatively.
“The nurses noted that their patients were more at ease and resting more preoperatively because the music was calming,” she says.
Though her project was specific to one preoperative unit, Vargo says there is huge potential to implement it in all service lines. “It really has shown to be a positive preoperative intervention,” she says.
Looking at the results of the postoperative study in relation to her PICOT question, Pehotsky notes the positive impact the music had on vital signs and analgesic use, especially as an adjunct for patients with chronic pain.
Although there was not a major difference shown in time to PACU discharge between groups, she believes the benefits found in the other variables, combined with its ease of use and implementation, make this modality an important offering for pre- and postoperative nursing units.
In both studies, the patients, both in numeric value as well as in their anecdotal comments, expressed a great level of satisfaction with the music. ✥
Beccaloni A M. The medicine of music: A systematic approach for adoption into perianesthesia practice. J PeriAnesthes Nurs. 2011;26(5):323-330.
Bradt J, Dileo C, Shim M. Music interventions for preoperative anxiety. Cochrane Library. 2013;3:1-81.
Cole L C, LoBiondo-Wood G. Music as an adjuvant therapy in control of pain and symptoms in hospitalized adults: A systematic review. Pain Man Nurs. 2014;15(1):406-425.
Easter B, DeBoer L, Settlemyre G, et al. The impact of music on the PACU patient’s perception of discomfort. J PeriAnesthes Nurs. 2010;25(2):79-87.
Elliott D, Polman R, McGregor R. Relaxing music for anxiety control. J Music Therapy. 2011;48(3):264-288.
Glasziou P. Comment to “Music as an aid for postoperative recovery in adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Lancet. 2015;386(10004):1672-1673.
Hole J, Hirsh M, Ball E, et al. Music as an aid for postoperative recovery in adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Lancet. 2015;386(10004):1659-1671.
Kuhlmann A, de Rooij A, Kroese L, et al. Meta-analysis evaluating music interventions for anxiety and pain in surgery. B J Surg. 2018;105(7):773-783.
Pehotsky C, Vargo K. Music can change the (perioperative) world: Streaming music programs in the PACU. OR Manager Conference/PACU Manager Summit, 2020.
Tan X, Yowler C, Super D, et al. The interplay of preference, familiarity, and psychophysical properties in defining relaxation music. J Music Therapy. 2012;49(2):150-179.