September 27, 2022

Potential solutions to the perioperative nursing shortage

By: James X Stobinski, PhD, RN, CNOR, CSSM(E), CNAMB
Share

Surgical volume is rising, and the need for perioperative nurses continues to grow. Same-day procedures are becoming more common, even for complex cases such as total joint replacements and spine surgery. With the decrease in in-patient, post-surgical stays and more surgeries being performed in various ambulatory settings, the skillset for perioperative and perianesthesia nurses must shift.

Evidence shows that as the number of perioperative nurses continues to increase, the ratio of perioperative and perianesthesia nurses among all American nurses will also continue to increase. This may be due to the increasing demand for surgery and the shift to the ambulatory setting, which accelerated during the pandemic.

In previous 2022 articles published by OR Manager, I discussed what we know about the perioperative nursing shortage and shared demographic information to include the results of recent research studies funded by the Competency and Credentialing Institute (CCI) Research Foundation.

To summarize: The 2020 National Nursing Workforce Survey showed that the percentage of nurses who consider perioperative nursing their primary specialty has increased from 5.8% in 2017 to 6.7% in 2020. The nursing workforce continues to grow, and an increasing percentage of that number are perioperative nurses. Our current staffing shortfalls, perhaps exacerbated by the pandemic, are compounded by large numbers of perioperative nurses ageing out of the profession as the demand for surgery continues to increase.

It is unlikely that the shortage of perioperative nurses will lessen if the current system does not change. Based on nearly 40 years of experience in the OR and the recent research conducted by CCI, I offer here some prospective strategies to address what might seem an insoluble problem. My intention is to start a dialogue, which may prompt innovation and new approaches to address this long-standing issue. No single intervention or approach will solve the issue of staffing, but the information provided lays out some promising possibilities that may lead to a more complete solution.

 

Better workforce data

The 2011 Future of Nursing Report stressed the importance of reliable data for nursing workforce planning. Certification bodies such as CCI, membership organizations, trade publications, and other stakeholders should all contribute to data collection to facilitate workforce planning. Collaboration between these various entities would be the most efficient tactic for workforce data collection, but such teamwork has not been prioritized. High-quality data on the perioperative nursing workforce is needed and must be made available to all stakeholders.

According to the 2011 Institute of Medicine Report, The Future of Nursing: Leading Change, Advancing Health, “Workforce planning and policy making require better data collection and an improved information infrastructure.” The purpose of such efforts is to “collect better data on the healthcare workforce to inform planning for the necessary changes to the nursing profession and the overall health care system.” If adequate data were available, then the perioperative nursing specialty could better plan for the future workforce.

In the 11 years since the release of that report, the perioperative nursing specialty has not made meaningful progress regarding workforce planning. Although there are frequent anecdotal reports of staffing shortages and some periodic survey data, no entity has taken responsibility for gathering workforce data.

Establishing more reliable data on the perioperative nursing workforce would be a realistic and achievable first step. The recent CCI study established that there are 470,179 RNs who state that perioperative nursing is either their primary or secondary specialty. This study is the first report in the literature of the total number of perioperative nurses. And still, more detailed information is needed about the specialty.

A nagging long-term issue for perioperative nursing is that no one body has responsibility for overall workforce planning. By default, employers, who control access to the profession, have an outsize role relative to the specialty. Hospitals and health systems that employ perioperative nurses lack any collaborative reporting methods. Even if this data were collected and analyzed, no one entity could coordinate bringing more nurses into the specialty. At present, we have a diversity of employers, both large and small, that provide anecdotal reports of the difficulty in staffing perioperative nurses.

 

Focused research

There are a wide variety of methods used to bring graduate nurses and experienced nurses into the OR. Both the multiple paths for accession into the profession and the outsize influence of employers on this process has a profound influence on the supply of perioperative nurses. It is very uncommon for nurses to enter the profession without a connection to an employer that is willing to devote the time and energy to their education and training.

As the CEO of CCI, I often visit hospitals and attempt to meet with the nurses in perioperative nursing orientation. My recent interactions have been with nurses in Virginia, Houston, and all around the Denver metro area. I am impressed by the dedication of the perioperative nurse educators, the diversity of the nurses entering the specialty, and the multiplicity of approaches to training and education.

In a recent study conducted by CCI, about 24% of the respondents had taken a commonly used commercial course; however, over 34% reported their entry program was a facility-, system-, or employer-developed course. In additon, 37% reported that they did not take a formalized training course upon accession to the specialty.

The range of programs used for accession to the perioperative specialty is staggering. The assortment of programs was detailed in a 2021 article by Cynthia Saver in OR Manager. At a time when staffing shortages are widespread, we cannot rule out any methods that bring nurses into the OR—but perioperative nursing must determine the most effective methods for accession into the specialty.

In addition, there are residency and fellowship programs to facilitate transition into practice for novice perioperative nurses, like the American Nurses Credentialing Center Practice Transition Accreditation Program® (PTAP). However, there are few perioperative-specific PTAP accredited transition programs with unknown long-term impact on perioperative nursing.

The programs provide rich research opportunities on the myriad of factors that correlate with perioperative nursing competency to include diverse orientation/residency programs and fellowships. Exploring how perioperative nurses learn and acquire skills is also a promising area of research. An example of this focused research is a 2021 study by Kinlaw, Stobinski, Irvin, et al, which conducted a longitudinal assessment of perioperative specific competency using PPCS-R [Perceived Perioperative Competence Scale-Revised].

Objective Structured Clinical Examinations (OSCE) are frequently used in medical education. The use of OSCE allows students “to practice and demonstrate clinical skills in a standardized medical scenario.” In theory, it is possible to include OSCE in perioperative specialty training, but it has yet to be implemented.

A more realistic option is simulation training, which increased rapidly during COVID-19. Simulation-based training holds great promise for perioperative nursing, but it is not yet utilized universally.

Conventional wisdom hypothesizes that certain personality traits are associated with success as a perioperative nurse. Prior to the recently developed CFPN [Certified Foundational Perioperative Nurse] credential, these traits had not been extensively studied. CCI has begun gathering data using 16pf, a test that identifies strengths and areas for improvements in personality traits that correlate with perioperative nursing competency. The next step is to examine these correlations with other demographic and workplace characteristics.

Research-based evidence is needed to ascertain which of the current accession programs and education methodologies are most productive and efficient for the specialty. CCI believes that one of the criteria for program effectiveness is the competency level of perioperative nurses after completing orientation. PPCS-R is an instrument to measure perioperative nursing competency, but it is only routinely used by the CFPN credential.

 

An unrealized potential

There are three educational paths to enter the nursing profession: Diploma of Nursing, associate degree (AD) programs, and Bachelor of Science in Nursing. Yet, none of these pre-licensure courses contain a significant amount of perioperative nursing experience.

A recent article in OR Manager spoke to innovative approaches for perioperative clinical exposure. Substantial exposure to the OR is needed to ensure that new nurses are aware of the perioperative specialty and consider it among their practice choices. This year, AORN announced a partnership with Chamberlain University to offer an online training module in perioperative nursing to pre-licensure students. All these approaches, if more widely used, could help attract pre-licensure students to the perioperative specialty.

CCI nurses serve as adjunct faculty at Edgewood College in Madison, Wisconsin, teaching a pre-licensure course in perioperative nursing. This course, NRS 480: Special Topics in Nursing and Health Care: Pre-Licensure Perioperative Services Training Program, was developed in partnership with CCI, Edgewood College School of Nursing, and hospitals and health systems in the region. We readily share the NRS 480 course syllabus and materials without charge. Anyone interested in these materials can contact jstobinski@cc-institute.org for more information.

CCI believes there is great opportunity for a variety of stakeholders to participate in diverse partnerships. The sum of these approaches is greater visibility for the potential career path as a perioperative nurse. While the return of perioperative nursing to pre-licensure education as in the days of diploma schools is unlikely, there are other opportunities—local AORN chapters, individual facilities, and health systems can all contribute to initiatives, including engagement with high school students.

 

Need for additional education

I believe that there is an opportunity to emphasize lifelong learning as an engagement and retention strategy for our specialty. With perioperative nursing education, our current emphasis revolves around accession to the specialty, followed by education and training requirements for accreditation compliance. The need for perioperative-specific continuing education is minimal relative to licensing requirements. Certified nurses may need such education to maintain their credentials, but only a minority of perioperative nurses hold these voluntary certifications.

In a rapidly changing, technology intensive setting such as surgical services, the need for lifelong, Continuous Professional Development (CPD) is evident. CCI believes that perioperative focused, purposeful, lifelong CPD with a Nursing Professional Development (NPD) approach would be beneficial to the specialty. NPD is defined as a nursing practice specialty that improves the professional practice and role competence of nurses and other healthcare personnel by facilitating ongoing learning, change, and role competence and growth.

A pivot to an NPD approach over the span of a career versus episodic perioperative nursing education would be a large change for the profession. It would entail a shift from the needs of the employer to the needs of the perioperative nursing specialty. Perioperative nurse educators have traditionally not considered themselves as working in NPD, secondary to their close link to perioperative nursing. An NPD-focused approach could facilitate longitudinal competency assessment tracking to determine which factors correlate with measurable perioperative nursing competency. This would exceed the current widely used skills checklists.

NPD practice broadly supports a diversity of nursing specialties. A shift to supporting the professional practice of perioperative nursing over the span of a career would further engage these nurses and provide additional resources and assistance. An NPD approach might also establish best practices in accession strategies for the specialty and increase evidence-based research.

 

Strengthen DEI initiatives

Some of what determines the career path of a nurse is constrained by the pre-licensure resources available to students. Many students may have only one viable option for their pre-licensure education: The local community college offering an AD. Few AD programs have any meaningful perioperative nursing content. Those students have a low probability of a favorable exposure to the OR in their initial education. Ideally, any nursing student who aspired to work in perioperative nursing could chart a course to enter and then progress in the specialty. Pre-licensure experience in the OR would create a larger pool of accession candidates.

We must also have more nursing school faculty with perioperative experience. Nurses who enter the field with baccalaureate level education are far more likely to earn the advanced degrees needed for faculty appointments. Nurses with clinical perioperative experience and advanced nursing degrees are uncommon among nursing school faculty, leading to the absence of role models for students who could aspire to perioperative nursing.

Prior to the last few years, there was little reliable information on the demographics of our specialty. Recently, many nursing organizations, including AORN and CCI, have begun Diversity Equity and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives. There are many opportunities to further diversify our specialty to reflect the populations we serve. It is likely that there are nursing students and experienced nurses working in other specialties who aspire to perioperative nursing but lack the resources or exposure to meet that goal. DEI initiatives may facilitate a chance for more nurses to come into the specialty.

 

Conclusion

At CCI, we believe there is value in establishing a standardized, efficient, and widely available path to enter the perioperative nursing specialty. This path should be well known and publicized. We also believe there is rich potential for stakeholders to partner in meeting that goal. I have also spoken to the need for additional research. That will require a cadre of researchers at the PhD level with a sufficient career trajectory to carry such an agenda through. New partnerships and innovation will be needed to address the challenge of staffing the ORs of the future. I believe the current staffing challenges can be solved, and that there is rich opportunity for collaboration in these efforts. As an organization, CCI looks forward to being part of the solution.

 

—James X Stobinski, PhD, RN, CNOR, CSSM(E), CNAMB, is CEO of the Competency and Credentialing Institute (CCI).

 

References

ANA Enterprise. Practice Transition Accreditation Program®. Accessed July 31, 2022.

Chamberlain University and the Association of periOperative Registered Nurses Announce Partnership to Address Critical Shortage of Operating Room Nurses. AORN. July 28, 2021.

The Future of Nursing: Leading Change, Advancing Health. Institute of Medicine: The National Academies Press. 2021.

Kinlaw T S, Stobinski J X, Irvin S A, et al. Professional development in perioperative nursing begins with the certified foundational perioperative nurse (CFPN) credential. Perioperative Care and Operating Room Management. March 2022.

Life Science Intelligence. Surgical Procedure Volumes in the US from 2018–2026. 2021.

Nursing Professional Development Scope & Standards of Practice. Association for Nursing Professional Development. 2022 (4th edition).

PSI Services LLC (2022). The New PSI 16pf® 6th Edition. Accessed July 31, 2022.

Saver C. Engaging student nurses to prime the OR nurse pump: Part 1. OR Manager. 38(6) 14-18.

Saver C. Effective orientation vital for a sustainable workforce: Part 1. OR Manager. 38(4). 1, 9-13.

Simulation training. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. Department of Health and Human Services. 2019.

Smiley R A, Ruttinger C, Oliveira C M, et al. The 2020 national nursing workforce survey. J Nurs Reg. 2021;12(1):S1-S96.

Stobinski J X, Maio S and Homme C. Results of a competency assessment study of OR nurses in the US. OR Manager, 38(6). 22-25.

The use of OSCE: ​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​General information. UW Medicine. 2019.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat