June 17, 2020

Proactive payment collection reduces bad debt risk

By: Jennifer Lubell
Share

Establishing policies to collect payment before surgery has grown in importance as high-deductible health plans impose larger out-of-pocket costs on patients. To help manage patients’ expectations about costs and increase the likelihood of collecting payment, some experts believe a culture shift is in order. They say healthcare facilities should be looking to consumer-centric organizations such as Amazon, Uber, and Airbnb to adopt more effective communication models.

Florian Otto, MD

Doing so would remove barriers to engaging with patients, Florian Otto, MD, believes. Currently, innovation is mostly taking place on the medical side, leaving facilities to grapple with antiquated tools on the administrative side, says Otto, cofounder and chief executive officer of Cedar, a healthcare financial engagement platform. “You’ve got top-of-the-line surgical robots existing in tandem with fax machines, paper bills, and highly inefficient message systems at some facilities. This needs to change,” he says.

Ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) have an advantage in that their procedures are often less complex than those performed in hospitals. “For a straightforward procedure such as a knee replacement, it should be pretty clear what the patient needs to pay,” says Otto. Still, variables in some outpatient procedures make it difficult to assess what the upfront costs will be. Often there is more than one bill—one for the anesthesiologist, one for the surgeon, and sometimes one for radiology. Patients must pay separately for the different procedures.

Especially with high-deductible plans, patients don’t always know what a procedure will cost, says Otto. And out-of-pocket costs are going up, as employer-based insurance transfers more of the cost to employees. In 2019, the Kaiser Family Foundation reported that 58% of covered employees worked in firms that offered one or more high-deductible plan.

Ten years ago, the average deductible was $300. Today, it’s more like $1,300, Otto says. Studies have shown that more than half of those in the highest deductible plans report their personal savings is less than the amount of their deductible, he adds.

 

Skyrocketing out-of-pocket costs

Nonpayment for high-cost cases can happen at ASCs as well as hospitals. Otto has seen cases in which an ASC bills patients for amounts sometimes exceeding $30,000 to $50,000—much higher than amounts billed to those with private or public insurance. A patient scheduled for spinal or cardiac surgery, for example, may submit a claim to insurance, and the insurer denies it, stating that the patient needed prior authorization for the procedure. “All of a sudden, there’s a balance of $10,000 that comes back to the patient. And the patient says they’re not paying it,” he says.

Chad Furgason, administrator of Saint Luke’s South Surgery Center in Overland Park, Kansas, has seen this happen with ob-gyn procedures. A woman may need a dilation and curettage within 24 hours, for example. “Oftentimes, the patient is distraught about the situation. In those cases, we try to be considerate of what the patient is going through, in regard to up-front collections,” he says.

In addition to ob-gyn procedures, orthopedic procedures can be expensive, requiring higher copays and deductibles and necessitating more flexible payment arrangements, he says.

Educating patients about payment plans and providing guidelines is crucial to prepare them for the bills they will inevitably receive, notes Thomas Hyatt, manager of client services for in2itive Business Solutions, an ASC-specific billing company based in Overland Park. Patients who aren’t familiar with their insurance or how it works may not understand what their obligations will be down the road, Hyatt says. “When shopping for insurance, consumers are more likely to look at monthly cost versus what it could cost them on the back end.” They need to know what procedure they’re getting based on scheduled codes, what the insurance will reimburse, and what they’ll owe after the procedure, he says.

This means that ASCs may need to adjust—and update—their collection and communication procedures.

 

Alerts through apps

Otto believes that ASCs could take a page from the playbook of other industries to better inform patients about anticipated costs.

The goal with collections is to improve patient engagement and the bottom line. One way the Cedar platform does this is through personalized messaging. Texts, emails, and telephone calls can present billing information in different ways, Otto says. This is how Amazon communicates. It’s amazing how the rate of upfront payments increases through the use of this model, he adds.

Cedar has seen close to 70% of all patients paying through a mobile app, a tool that also generates high collection rates. Mailing checks is an administrative burden for ASCs, Otto says. Having a convenient app for Apple pay, credit card, or PayPal would go a long way toward reducing administrative hassles for providers and patients alike.

“When was the last time you went to a travel agency to get a plane ticket? Or to the counter at an airport to get a boarding pass? Maybe 10 years ago? You can do all of those things via a mobile app—even order food for the plane trip,” he says.

A 24/7 chat bot is another popular feature. ASCs are usually open 8 am to 5 pm. Patients at work normally don’t want to make calls about healthcare bills, so having a 24/7 support system is a game changer for organizations, Otto says. It frees up staff to do tasks other than answering calls, and gives patients greater flexibility to ask questions. “They are more likely to pay after getting those questions answered,” he adds.

 

Setting a fixed price

Payment plans are another tried-and-true strategy to reduce the likelihood of bad debt.

Thomas Hyatt

Under a payment bundling arrangement, the ASC guarantees what a certain standard procedure will cost for one price. Uber and Lyft have adopted this model, Otto says. Their apps list a price up front for a specific destination rather than charging by the mile or how many minutes a ride may take. This effectively guarantees the price. Some ASCs are already doing this, “but it would be fantastic if all facilities adopted the guaranteed price model,” he says.

Care credit of a third-party entity offers a win-win for patients and ASCs alike, Hyatt says. The patient applies for credit through a third-party entity. If credit is approved, the ASC gets paid up front for the procedure, and the patient works with the credit care company to pay off the balance.

An interest rate often applies, but care credit gives the patient another option if the ASC has only 6 months to repay a bill, but the patient needs more time, Hyatt says.

Saint Luke’s South Surgery Center has seen good results with the care credit approach. The facility offers an 18-month, no interest financing plan. “We take a hit for a small fee and have all of our money up front. It’s a better alternative than losing money down the line,” explains Meagan Schwab, Saint Luke’s business office manager.

The ASC also offers an in-house payment plan. Patients must provide a 25% down payment, and can pay their remaining bill through a tiered system that allocates 3 months for bills up to $1,000; 5 months for bills ranging from $1,001 to 3,000; and 8 months for anything over $3,000.

Since adopting this plan, the facility has noticed a significant decline in outstanding patient balances. “Currently we sit at 1% patient balances over 90 days,” a significant drop from 13% in 2019, before the new plan started, Schwab says.

Meagan Schwab

Many ASCs offer hardship assistance for patients who are unable to make payments. Patients fill out forms that outline their monthly income and expenses. If they’re approved, the ASC applies a discount to the procedure. “We want to acknowledge patients aren’t just names and numbers in a system,” says Hyatt.

All of this goes back to upfront education for patients—trying to let them know what their responsibility is, so there’s no surprise when individual bills start coming in, Hyatt adds. This allows patients to recuperate and recover from procedures instead of making multiple telephone calls to clarify bills.

 

Crunching the numbers

ASCs should consider using insurance verification software, which explains coverage for procedures before patients have surgery. in2itive Business Solutions uses this tool to determine how much of the deductible will be met and what the patient’s obligation will be prior to surgery, factoring in how far in advance the surgery has been scheduled.

Billing companies sell performance indicators, which are benchmarks that look at total AR (accounts receivable). “We use metrics to determine how well an ASC is performing on a monthly basis,” Hyatt explains.

To arrive at an AR balance, the billing company looks at the collectable balance as one whole number, the total bucket that every dollar goes into, and breaks down that balance over several time periods: 30 days old, 30 to 60 days, 61 to 90 days, 91 to 120 days, and 120 days and beyond. “We look at dollar totals, how long it’s been since the procedure, and how long the collectable money has been outstanding,” Hyatt says.

ASCs and their board members determine what payment plans they’re comfortable with, based on the types of insurance they see in the market. They may choose an 8- or 12-month payment plan, depending on what works best for their aging and outstanding AR balances.

Saint Luke’s uses Clariti, an insurance verification product from Clariti Health that creates estimates based on a patient’s benefits. Patients can track payment schedules on their phones, and the facility can track when patients use this app, to see if they’re following up on their payment obligation. “The patient can make payment arrangements on the spot, based on a text they receive,” Schwab says. The facility usually follows up with a telephone call several days before a payment is due.

ASC staff should carefully document the information provided to patients in the event of a payment problem. This way, someone can pick up where another staff member left off, Hyatt says. “Each person, regardless of their role in an ASC, should be able to take a step forward and accelerate reimbursement.” ✥

–Jennifer Lubell is a healthcare writer based in Rockville, Maryland.

 

References

Hamel L, Munana C, Brodie M. Kaiser Family Foundation/LA Times survey of adults with employer-sponsored insurance. May 2, 2019. https://www.kff.org/report-section/kaiser-family-foundation-la-times-survey-of-adults-with-employer-sponsored-insurance-section-3-the-experiences-of-those-with-high-deductibles-and-those-with-chronic-conditions/.

 

Levey N N. Health insurance deductibles soar, leaving Americans with unaffordable bills. Los Angeles Times. May 2, 2019. https://www.latimes.com/politics/la-na-pol-health-insurance-medical-bills-20190502-story.html.

 

Tozzi J, Tracer Z. Sky-high deductibles broke the US health insurance system. Bloomberg. June 26, 2018. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-06-26/sky-high-deductibles-broke-the-u-s-health-insurance-system.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat