February 21, 2020

Resiliency reinforced through peer support programs

By: Elizabeth Wood
Share

High rates of burnout among healthcare providers—between 35% and 54% of US nurses and physicians, and between 45% and 60% of medical students and residents—have raised concerns about patient and provider safety. Burnout, a psychological syndrome featuring emotional exhaustion, depersonalization, and a reduced sense of personal accomplishment, is increasingly prevalent in healthcare, and is linked to the more than 400 physician suicides that occur each year.

Bernadette Melnyk, PhD, APRN-CNP, FAANP, FNAP, FAAN

Developing greater resiliency is considered crucial for surviving and thriving in the stressful OR environment, especially when adverse events occur. In addition to counseling and other resources, some organizations have found peer support to be especially helpful for dealing with the aftermath of such events.

“It is critical to find solutions for healthcare system problems that contribute to this public health epidemic and quickly translate evidence-based interventions—including peer support and cognitive-behavioral skills building—into clinical settings,” Bernadette Melnyk, PhD, APRN-CNP, FAANP, FNAP, FAAN, told OR Manager. These kinds of interventions are designed to enhance resiliency and coping skills in order to decrease symptoms of burnout and depression in clinicians, says Melnyk, vice president for health promotion, university chief wellness officer, and dean of the Ohio State University College of Nursing in Columbus.

 

When bad things happen

Buffy Krauser Lupear, DNP, CRNA, APRN

Like most healthcare organizations and other businesses, Vanderbilt University Medical Center in Nashville, Tennessee, has an Employee Assistance Program (EAP) to help people whose problems are affecting their work performance. Adding a Peer Support Program has helped build trust and empathy among staff struggling to recover from a critical incident.

“In nursing school, we weren’t educated about how to get past a critical incident,” says Buffy Krauser Lupear, DNP, CRNA, APRN, Vanderbilt’s director of professional development for the Office of Advanced Practice. “And we know it’s not possible for us to sustain that emotional toll through the years and be an engaging, compassionate nurse.”

Responses to a critical incident survey conducted at Vanderbilt a few years ago were illuminating. Out of 1,100 people who received the survey, 250 responded, Lupear says. Sadness, cited by 65% of respondents, was the dominant reaction, followed by feeling anxious, angry, guilty, fearful, or depressed—although 14% of respondents said they did not perceive a difference in how they felt after the incident.

“Most of our team members were able to move past the incident within a month, but about 5% were still experiencing emotional and physical stressors after a year,” Lupear says. “When we asked our team their preferred method of coping, 68% of respondents said they wanted to talk to their peers.”

 

Program development

Cindy L. Kildgore, MHSA, BSN, RN, CNOR

Lupear collaborated with Cindy L. Kildgore, MHSA, BSN, RN, CNOR, perioperative services director at Vanderbilt, and Jim Kendall, LCSW, CEAP, their EAP counselor, to begin building a program. They decided to teach interested nurse leaders and staff how to be the first line of support for their colleagues—not to act as social workers, counselors, or psychiatrists, but rather to make themselves available for emotional support and direct coworkers to resources like the EAP.

Perioperative staff—including anesthesia providers, surgeons, and radiology staff—receive annual education consisting of two 1-hour sessions with the manager of Vanderbilt’s EAP program.

Module 1 consists of:

• open communication about the impact of critical incidents

• awareness of peer support and resources

• identification of team members interested in additional education to become a peer supporter.

Module 2 consists of:

• recognition of the signs and symptoms of provider distress after a difficult case and an opportunity to talk with a nonjudgmental, supportive coworker

• pearls for preparing for a difficult conversation

• pearls for being a good listener

• recognition of when something needs to be reported, the importance of confidentiality, and the importance of critical incident stress management.

“We encourage our team members not to discuss the specifics of the case but rather the emotions people are experiencing—this helps to maintain confidentiality,” Lupear notes.

“Training for peer-to-peer support means garnering the support of nursing and anesthesia providers,” Kildgore says. On Wednesdays and Fridays, cases start later, so some of that time is used for training leaders and then staff. “You want to train the trainers—make sure people are getting the same message,” Kildgore advises.

The Peer Support Program is introduced during the onboarding process so that new staff learn about it and have the opportunity to participate. “Everyone starts hearing about it and wants to be part of it, so the program will grow,” Kildgore says. However, she recommends explaining the emotional stress people may experience as leaders in this program. Peer support leaders, once they become known and trusted, will probably be sought out for help.

To spread the word about the program, a web page lists the steps involved (sidebar, at right). In addition, Kildgore says, the program is discussed during some of Vanderbilt’s morbidity and mortality conferences. “We’ve been at this for several years, and to be able to get in front of about 800 colleagues and talk about this program was phenomenal. I never thought we’d be able to capture that kind of audience in our own institution,” she says.

Considering the crescendo effect highlighted by Epstein and Hamric in 2009, Lupear says, “We all begin our nursing careers with an emotional baseline: We care about people, and we want to make their lives better. But when things go wrong, we can have some moral distress, and that takes us away from our emotional baseline. And if we don’t cope, the next time we experience a critical incident, it takes us even farther away from our emotional baseline, which puts us at increased risk of compassion fatigue, disengagement, burnout, depression, and even self-harm.”

She adds that new nurses are particularly vulnerable to the effects of critical incidents and need to feel supported or they will leave the organization and possibly the nursing profession (sidebar below).

 

What about surgeons?

Major complications, errors, and adverse events occur in 3% to 16% of all inpatient surgical procedures, according to the World Health Organization (WHO).

Not surprisingly, many surgeons feel personally responsible for such outcomes. In a 2017 study conducted at three US hospitals, 83% of surgeons reported psychological effects including sadness, guilt, shame, embarrassment, anxiety, and anger stemming from adverse events. The study also revealed that surgeons relied more on their colleagues than on family and friends for support.

Researchers from Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston and the Cleveland Clinic in Cleveland created a surgery-specific peer support program to help these “second victims”—healthcare providers who experience psychological and emotional trauma from adverse events.

Participants included attending surgeons and surgical trainees in a large academic teaching hospital representing several surgical specialties. One-year results, published in late 2019, were promising: 81% of participants said the program had a positive impact on the safety and support culture because it raised awareness of the need to support colleagues experiencing difficult patient situations.

 

Program design and implementation

To identify peer supporters, the department chair asked all surgical staff and trainees to nominate colleagues they would turn to for nonjudgmental support after an adverse event. The top nominees were then selected, with balanced representation by sex and years of surgical experience.

Training consisted of 4-hour sessions with peer support experts and included a review of literature on physician health and second victims, role-playing, and education about resources. Peer supporters were taught how to:

• communicate their commitment to confidentiality

• listen in a nonjudgmental manner and offer empathy

• identify common symptoms and feelings associated with adverse events

• suggest coping strategies.

Examples of do’s and do not’s are listed in the sidebar at right.

After adverse events, confidential outreach emails offering the services of a peer supporter were sent to the affected providers. Peer supporters followed up unless the provider declined the initial offer, and 47 outreach interventions took place during the year.

Although 19% of surgeons opted out of receiving peer support, most participants said they were satisfied with the confidentiality, safe and trusting environment peer support provided, and timeliness of the intervention.

 

Building resiliency

Circumstances less dire than adverse events can and do debilitate healthcare professionals, so the increased focus on burnout and resiliency is not surprising. In October 2019, the National Academy of Medicine issued a report, Taking Action Against Clinician Burnout: A Systems Approach to Professional Well-Being, with recommendations for how to reduce burnout. Among them:

• Create positive work environments. Healthcare organizations should have executive leadership roles dedicated to clinician well-being and assess how business and management decisions, such as implementing new technologies, may affect job demands and levels of burnout.

• Address burnout in training and at the early career stage. Actions include monitoring workload (including preparation for licensure examinations and required training activities), implementing pass-fail grading, improving access to scholarships and affordable loans, and building new loan repayment systems.

• Reduce tasks that do not improve patient care. Some clinician burnout is related to laws, regulations, and policies, and those that contribute little or no value to patient care should be eliminated.

• Improve usability and relevance of health information technology (IT). Health IT, including electronic health records, should be as user-friendly and easy to operate as possible, and clinicians and patients should make decisions together.

• Reduce stigma and improve burnout recovery services. Many clinicians do not report burnout. State legislative bodies should facilitate access to EAPs, peer support programs, and mental health providers without the information being admissible in malpractice litigation.

• Create a national research agenda on clinician well-being. By the end of 2020, federal agencies—including the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, the Health Resources and Services Administration, and the US Department of Veterans Affairs—should develop a coordinated research agenda on clinician burnout. The research should focus on the drivers of burnout across career and life stages for different types of clinicians, implications for workers and patients, and potential systems-level interventions to improve clinician and learner well-being.

The WHO has designated 2020 as the International Year of the Nurse and the Midwife to celebrate the work of nurses and midwives, highlight the challenging conditions they often face, and advocate for increased investments in this workforce. Programs like those described in this article align with this recognition and may play an increasing role in helping nurses and other healthcare providers survive and thrive. ✥

References

El Hechi M W, Bohnen J D, Westfal M, et al. Design and impact of a novel surgery-specific second victim peer support program. J Am Coll Surg. Published online December 16, 2019.

 

Epstein E G, Hamric A B. Moral distress, moral residue, and the crescendo effect. J Clin Ethics. 2009;20(4):330-342.

 

https://www.who.int/campaigns/year-of-the-nurse-and-the-midwife-2020.

 

Kildgore C L, Krauser Lupear B. Where we are today: Nurses supporting nurses. OR Manager Conference. 2019.

 

National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. 2019. Taking action against clinician burnout: A systems approach to professional well-being. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.

 

Sampson M, Melnyk B M, Hoying J. Intervention effects of the MINDBODYSTRONG cognitive behavioral skills building program on newly licensed registered nurses’ mental health, healthy lifestyle behaviors, and job satisfaction. J Nurs Admin. 2019;49(10):487-494.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat