• Determining the return on investment (ROI) for a robot-assisted surgery (RAS) program should include anticipated surgeon volume and past cases where RAS could have been used.
• Some organizations dedicate staff to RAS cases, while others orient all to these procedures.
• Offering ROI after hours require careful planning of staff and resources.
A robot-assisted surgery (RAS) program can be an integral part of a successful OR’s portfolio, but only if properly planned, implemented, and sustained. In Part 2 of this two-part series, OR Manager shares insights from robotics experts and OR leaders who have robust RAS programs. For an overview of RAS, see Part 1 in the September/October issue (pp 1, 16–20).
Katie Kentner, MSN, RN, NE-BC, CNOR, director of perioperative services at Vanderbilt University Medical Center in Nashville, encourages those starting a robotics program or those who want to grow an existing program to reach out to their colleagues. “There’s no need to reinvent the wheel,” she says. “In the medical world, we all want to help each other grow.” Visiting other facilities can provide valuable ideas and insights, which can help in making decisions, such as which robot to purchase.
Robots require a capital investment, making return on investment (ROI) a crucial part of a business plan. When calculating ROI, leaders need to determine how long it will take to perform the number of surgical procedures required to recoup the cost of the robot. Bhushan Jayeshkumar Patel, MEng, MBA, a surgical robot technology expert and senior member of the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE), recommends reviewing the past 5 years of data to identify the number of patients who could have had RAS.
June Hill, BSN, RN, CNOR(E), system clinical director for robotic surgery at Inova in Falls Church, Virginia, says that at another facility, she used Survey Monkey to quickly assess how many additional cases surgeons could perform with more robot access. “They were very honest about whether they would do more cases and, if so, how many,” she says. She used the data to justify the need for more robots, which were quickly used to their full capacity.
Patel says OR leaders should look at Food and Drug Administration approved robots with an eye to their specific organization. “Every OR has different needs, different budgets, and different space availability,” he says. In a hospital with fewer ORs, for example, a robot that is particularly easy to transport may be a priority. “You also want to look at how it can be integrated into your IT system and into the existing workflow,” Patel adds. That requires considering the number of staff and staff competency with RAS.
Susan Scully, MSN, RN, CNOR-ROBO, RNFA, an assistant nurse manager for robotics at Penn Medicine Princeton Health in Plainsboro, New Jersey, cautions leaders not to make the mistake of factoring in only the robot’s cost. “You’ll need all the instruments required for the different cases you’re going to do,” she says. In addition, special beds that are integrated with the robot are needed, so the surgeon can move the bed while it is still attached to the robot patient cart. Other items to consider, depending on the types of cases, include additional positioning devices and an ultrasound machine. Patel adds special equipment also is needed for the sterile processing department (SPD).
Kentner says most hospitals choose to purchase robots because leasing may lower a facility’s bond rating and “leasing equipment can be more expensive in the long term.” However, Patel notes in some cases, such as when utilization estimates are not robust, leasing may be a viable option.
Hospitals may want to stay with one company when purchasing robots, says Andrew Hung, MD, a urologist based at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles who specializes in robotic surgery for diseases of the kidney and prostate. Using multiple brands might be difficult because of variations in instrumentation and sterilization. Working with multiple vendors also lessens the opportunity for bulk purchasing. Dr Hung uses the analogy of an airline choosing either Airbus or Boeing instead of having a mixed fleet. “There will be differences in pilot training and maintenance considerations because of different spare parts that might make it harder than purchasing from a single company,” he says.
Although the cost per case is higher for RAS than traditional minimally invasive surgery, John Doerr, BSN, robotic surgery program manager for Johns Hopkins, Baltimore, MD, says, “You have to look at the whole context.” Using a robot can shave a day or two off total patient hospitalization, saving money.
Finally, OR managers should consider ethical implications when purchasing a robot (sidebar, Robot purchasing ethics). For example, Johns Hopkins worked with Intuitive Surgical to address how data in the system are collected and used. Surgical robots collect data for safety reasons and for quality improvement, and the organization is happy to be part of the feedback process. “But we also need to stick to our ethical principles and make sure the information that’s being collected is not being used inappropriately or purely for financial gain,” Doerr says, adding it took almost 2 years to negotiate the data collection and use before the purchase of da Vinci 5 moved forward.
Vanderbilt, which has been performing RAS since May 2003, dedicates six ORs for RAS. “The equipment is delicate and expensive, so you don’t want to move it around,” Kentner says. Hill agrees that avoiding the movement of equipment is desirable even though it is now easier to do so; therefore, Inova mostly limits RAS to certain rooms. She adds it is important to verify that electrical outlets can support the robotic components along with traditional equipment such as suction. “Some hospitals may have older ORs that aren’t up to par” for heavier electrical demands, she says.
Scully says while RAS can be performed in any OR at Princeton Health, the preference is to limit the procedures to three rooms. This helps to avoid time lost in moving the robotic components. “It’s not an easy feat to move them, so it might take 20 to 30 minutes,” she says. “It also increases the risk of damaging the equipment.”
The time needed for surgeon training in RAS is substantial. In a Discover Artificial Intelligence article, David Power writes that, early on, inadequate training resulted in a significant number of errors related to RAS. Now the need for training is well-recognized; in fact, the IDEAL framework, which describes five stages of surgical therapy innovation, emphasizes the importance of training.
Currently, credentialing is typically granted after a surgeon completes a course and performs a certain number of cases. Much variability in requirements exist. As noted in Part 1, Dr Hung’s lab is working on ways to make assessment more objective. For example, the lab has established a method for assessing a surgeon’s suturing skills during robot-assisted prostatectomy that predicts how a patient does after surgery. Once the method is in wider use, hospitals could use it as part of its credential requirements, and national boards could use it in determining which surgeons are eligible for certification. “I think many stakeholders will be interested from a quality perspective,” Dr Hung says. “It would take out the subjectivity that comes from relying on peers reviewing cases.”
Some hospitals, like Johns Hopkins and Princeton Health, require all staff to work with the robots. “New staff are oriented to robotic surgery the same way they’re oriented to everything else,” Scully says. After staff complete education modules provided by Intuitive, they work with the company’s representative to complete individual practice time with the robot in a room without a patient. Staff are then partnered with an experienced nurse until they feel comfortable with the robot. Scully and other managers ensure staff have regular experience with RAS to keep their skills sharp. It is not only surgery staff who need training, Hill says. Those in the SPD need to learn how to process instruments. Educators from Intuitive supply that education, along with online modules for SPD and OR staff.
Other hospitals choose to have special teams. For example, at Vanderbilt, the “gold” team staff cover urology and thoracic service lines and any RAS.
Scully says in addition to the surgical technologist and the circulator, sometimes a third person acting in the role of bedside assistant is needed for RAS. That person may help with inserting instruments into the robot sleeves, or they may manipulate the uterus in the case of gynecological surgery. Those needs are identified ahead of time so the third person can be scheduled. At Princeton Health, a resident, fellow, or physician assistant often fills that role, but Scully says a second surgical technologist might fill the role at other hospitals.
Ongoing education is essential for maintaining skills. Hill provides Inova staff in five hospitals with annual training. In addition, she runs an annual symposium that features lectures and stations where staff have hands-on practice time with the various robots.
Doerr emphasizes selecting the right staff and providing training is essential for success. “You can buy the most amazing robots, but without excellent nurses to manage them and care for the patient, it’s all for naught,” he says.
Scully agrees. “Surgery isn’t just about having the latest and greatest equipment, it’s about the people who operate, support, and manage that technology,” she says. “You need to cultivate a strong, cohesive team.” That includes understanding the strengths of staff from different generations. For example, younger staff may troubleshoot problems more seamlessly, like turning something off and on when it is not working. “I’m trying to figure out why something won’t work, and they simply fix it and move on,” Scully says. She values the unique approach, as well as the perspective of staff from an older generation who recognize the importance of understanding why something happened to prevent recurrence. “We can learn from each other,” she says.
As with traditional surgery, block scheduling is used most for RAS. At Princeton Health, RAS block time is released 2 weeks before surgery. Vanderbilt runs three RAS rooms on the weekend. “Having a weekend option helps if a surgeon can’t get access to the robot during the week or if the patient has difficulty scheduling,” Kentner says. Staff who work the weekend are trained on the robots. It is important that SPD knows the number of RAS cases expected for the following day since these may require quicker turnover of trays compared to traditional cases because of robot-specific equipment.
In addition to scheduled cases, OR leaders need to consider how they will manage emergent cases during standard OR hours and after hours. Scully says at Princeton Health, RAS for emergent cases can be done off hours, including the weekend, and assistant managers are on call to answer questions. At Inova, RAS is performed 24/7. “It required us to do a lot of training, but has worked well,” Hill says.
In addition to training, preparing for round-the-clock RAS requires determining workflow. In an article on establishing such a program at Ohio State University (OSU), Gage and colleagues write the implementation team included surgeons, anesthesiology and SPD representatives, OR front desk staff, circulating nurses, surgical technologists, and staff from the robot’s manufacturer.
SPD is an area that may get overlooked. “You can’t do cases if you don’t have your instruments cleaned properly and ready to go,” Hill says. At OSU, SPD prepares universal robotic case carts in anticipation of add-on cases.
Kentner says key performance indicators for an RAS program include volume, case time, complications, cost per case, and equipment needs. The steering committee for the robotics program she started at another hospital reviewed these measures monthly. (Reviews may be less frequent as a program matures.) It is also important to anticipate future needs, such as new surgeons with RAS experience coming on staff.
At Vanderbilt, a monthly robotics committee discusses issues such as block utilization and optimization, new equipment needs, and training. The perioperative risk management team monitors complications.
Doerr says one of his primary tasks is to remove barriers so surgeons can explore new options. When a surgeon approaches him with an idea, his default position is, “How can we make that happen?” Doerr also works with surgeons to expand services—currently, the organization is doubling the number of robotic trained pediatric general surgeons. “We’re going to be able to shape that field in the years to come by being some of the first to pioneer it,” he says.
Having a director of RAS helps ensure growth, Hill says. “My job is to just focus on robotics and grow the program, compared to a director of the OR, who has many things to focus on,” she notes. Hill also collects data that helps to identify the best time to add a robot.
Overall, OR managers are playing a leading role in creating and growing RAS service lines. “We’re in a great age for healthcare technology that will improve outcomes,” Kentner says. “It’s great for both the surgeons and patients.” ORM
—Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, of CLS Development, Columbia, Maryland, provides. editorial services to healthcare publications.
Click here for part one of this series.