June 24, 2024

Rural hospitals contend with challenging opportunities

Rural hospitals in the US have been facing a prolonged, multifaceted crisis. The literature presents several reasons for why healthcare facilities in rural areas struggle, including shrinking budgets, rising chronic illness and public health issues like addiction and obesity, poor telehealth and broadband access, aging populations, deteriorating mental health, and outdated infrastructure. The lingering effects of the COVID-19 pandemic and soaring consumer prices have only exacerbated challenges for healthcare staff.

According to a recent report from consulting firm Chartis, 50% of the nation’s rural hospitals are operating at a loss. The impact of such closures extends beyond the loss of medical services, affecting local economies and leaving many without employment or essential services. The loss of a hospital is a compounded tragedy, affecting not only medical staff, but also local businesses that rely on that facility’s presence.

 

Pursuing Rural Emergency Hospital status

George H. Pink, PhD

Professor George H. Pink, PhD, is senior research fellow at the Cecil G. Sheps Center for Health Services Research, and deputy director of the North Carolina Rural Health Research Program, all at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. He monitors rural hospital finances and related conditions across the nation.  According to him, shifts in government assistance before, during, and after COVID-19 have slowed hospital closures.

“The pandemic relief caused a significant positive impact on closures in the past several years,” he says. That relief, however, has dried up. “Provider funds have been distributed, and more funding isn’t coming unless Congress acts again.” With relief funds exhausted, Dr Pink predicts an increase in hospital closures. “We’re returning to prepandemic financial pressures,” he says. “Only they’re worse because [staff recruitment] is even more difficult than before.” Persistent staffing shortages and rising operational costs only add to the strain felt by rural hospitals.

Despite this, Dr Pink remains cautiously optimistic about the future, citing Medicare’s Rural Emergency Hospital (REH) initiative as a potentially transformative model for struggling rural hospitals. Announced in December 2020, the REH “designation aims to curb rural hospital closures by offering them a chance to close infrequently used inpatient beds and focus on outpatient and emergency department services,” as explained in a February 2024 Becker’s Hospital CFO Report. CMS started receiving applications from interested hospitals in January 2023.

The REH program represents a significant shift in provider type; it is the first new Medicare payment designation in 26 years. REHs receive a 5% increase in Medicare outpatient payments—what Dr Pink says are “enhanced reimbursements for outpatient services”—and a facility fee payment of more than $276,000 per month that leads to an annual average of over $3 million. According to a March article in US News and World Report, only 19 of over 1,000 eligible hospitals have converted to the REH model. However, Dr Pink believes REH could provide a lifeline for many communities at high risk of losing their hospitals.

Christina Campos, MBA

Such was the case for Christina Campos, MBA, president and CEO of Guadalupe County Hospital in Santa Rosa, New Mexico. Her hospital, serving a community of about 2,500, transitioned to the REH model due to diminishing inpatient admissions. This transition is easier for small PPS [prospective payment system] hospitals like hers than for hospitals with swing beds or 340B status (sidebars, Swing beds facilitate transitional care; Drug discount program expands health services), where “it’s harder to give those up along with inpatient admissions,” she says. At her hospital, the transition was facilitated by strong chronic care management programs that reduced unnecessary admissions and readmissions. However, she warns that operating expenses remain a significant challenge, and rural hospitals must develop plans to build financial resiliency.

Dr Pink advises stakeholders to give REH a chance, urging them to keep these considerations in mind: Do REH hospitals meet the communities’ needs? Are they financially viable in the long-term? Do they attract and retain providers? “If the answers to these questions are ‘yes,’ that gives me hope,” he says. “For many communities, [REH] may be a viable model,” even if the initiative is still somewhat new.

Despite some resistance to the REH model—some, Dr Pink explains, do not agree with the mandate to cut certain inpatient services to gain REH designation—he urges stakeholders to keep an eye on the REH initiative and on mergers and acquisitions (M&A) activity, as both are areas of concern for Congress and the public.

“Sometimes, the only viable option for [financially struggling rural hospitals] is to sell to a health system,” Dr Pink says. As a June 2023 OR Manager article posed, “rural hospital acquisitions have accelerated in the past 2 decades.” M&A can provide rural hospitals with much needed financial resources, specialty care expertise, and access to innovative technologies, though they sometimes fail.

 

Expanding connectivity

For rural hospitals, telehealth is another example of an opportunity that also presents complications. According to 2021 survey data from the Pew Research Center, only 72% of Americans living in rural areas report access to high-speed broadband internet. With the US Department of Agriculture estimating that nearly 46 million Americans—14% of the country’s population—live in rural communities, that means almost 14 million people in the US are virtually cut off from potentially life-saving, technology-delivered care.

For Campos, telehealth has emerged as a critical tool for improving healthcare access in her community. Each household there has robust broadband infrastructure that enables the use of telehealth for various medical services, including radiology, cardiology, neurology, and critical care. Still, she agrees that many isolated rural communities, “especially in Native American reservations,” still struggle with limited broadband access, hindering the widespread adoption of telehealth.

Brad Noe

To address this, some rural communities are developing innovative solutions such as telehealth “kiosks” (sidebar, Telehealth kiosks extend care to rural communities). “A local FQHC [Federally Qualified Health Center] lookalike developed a network of telehealth kiosks in schools across northeast New Mexico, and they plan to expand into libraries and senior citizen centers, most of which have broadband access,” Campos says. These initiatives can significantly improve healthcare access for underserved populations. Campos notes while broadband expansion is necessary, other obstacles, such as right-of-way and eminent domain issues, also must be addressed.

Such technology will not solve all problems in rural areas, Pink cautions. For starters, interconnectivity is a deterrent for many rural hospitals because they lack modern communication systems. Brad Noe, a marketing executive at Medline Industries with expertise in rural care and supply chain, highlights the importance of upgrading legacy phone systems and not overlooking what other computer systems and software may need to be upgraded for telehealth services.

 

Transforming transportation

Transportation issues are a critical but often overlooked aspect of the rural-associated difficulties. Like all hospitals, rural hospitals are not exempt from the need to cope with unforeseen emergency cases on top of their regular patient volume. Emergency Medical Services (EMS) in rural areas vary widely in quality and quantity, with some regions lacking adequate staff and equipment.

“Some areas have excellent EMS systems boasting good transfer relationships with trauma centers and adequate supply of staff and ambulances,” Dr Pink says. That includes REH designees, which he says should “have the necessary EMS services; otherwise, they wouldn’t have converted.” But many other rural areas are struggling with severe shortages. He emphasizes the need for more research to understand which hospitals will need support to ensure adequate transportation, EMS, and the overall success of the REH model.

Supply chain services depend completely on robust transportation. During the pandemic, many vendors scrambled to continue delivering personal protective equipment and other essential supplies to hospitals across the country, Noe recalls. “Our primary challenge was getting supplies to rural hospitals,” he says.

A practice called domicile routing proved effective in circumventing that challenge, Noe says. In domicile routing, supply trucks drop off full trailers at remote locations, which are then picked up by local drivers who deliver supplies to various sites. “The full trailer, after it’s picked up by a local driver, goes from location to location dropping off supplies until the trailer is empty,” he explains. “The empty trailer is then dropped off at the initial location for our driver to pick it up.”

Other innovative delivery methods could help address transportation and supply chain challenges in the future. “The idea of supply drones is very interesting,” he says, cautioning that the technology is not yet fully developed in the US. However, some examples can be found overseas. Zipline, a US-based manufacturer and operator of delivery drones, “has formed several partnerships throughout Africa for delivering vaccines, blood products, and other medical supplies to rural and remote areas,” notes a June 2023 News Medical Lifesciences article.

 

Staying ahead of the curve

All interviewed experts agree that however daunting the challenges rural hospitals face, there are pathways to sustainability. The key is to be prepared and be proactive.

For Dr Pink, the REH initiative is a promising model that can stave off imminent closure for rural hospitals facing a precarious financial situation. He adds that local talent is an underappreciated asset in rural areas. “There’s a lot of innovation in rural communities that goes unreported because it’s not an exciting story,” he says. “They’re finding new models of care, forging partnerships and relationships with other facilities, and finding new types of providers.”

For Campos, an important consideration is creating reserves, both financial and professional. She stresses rural hospitals need to ensure fair payment agreements with commercial payers and maintain an emergency fund to weather financial shortfalls. For instance, in New Mexico, an emergency fund was established to support standalone or independent rural hospitals over the next 2 years, though Campos cautions that is a stopgap measure. “Hospitals need to develop a plan to reach 100 days of operating cash on hand,” she says. “Create a reserve over time—even if it takes years—balancing reinvestment in the hospital with funding that nest egg.”

Her facility stays ahead of the staff shortage by serving as a rural residency training site, which helps maintain a steady flow of healthcare professionals. “We’re always in recruitment mode, even if we have no job vacancies,” she says. “Still, staffing nurses remains a challenge. It will take a long time to right the staff supply and demand imbalance.”

For Noe, proactive inventory management is critical for rural hospitals to circumvent disaster. “Rural hospitals often don’t see the volume most suburban and urban hospitals see, so they order supplies in smaller quantities,” he says. Given the geographical challenges, they face a higher potential for supply chain disruptions. “And with extremely rural areas, the challenge is often with the supplier, not the hospital,” he adds. Noe advises rural hospitals to keep more than usual amounts of supplies and gear to handle emergencies, emphasizing the importance of having a full set of OR instruments and basic trauma unit supplies in particular ready at all times.

All three say that at the end of the day, stakeholders must remain vigilant, adapt to changing circumstances, and invest in long-term solutions. By leveraging regulatory options, improving telehealth access, engaging local talent, and maintaining robust transportation and supply chains, rural hospitals can continue to provide essential services and ensure survival in the face of mounting pressures.

 

—David C. Walsh is proprietor of pixwords.com and a onetime US Air Force medic.

**This article has been changed to correct mistakes to the title and role of George H. Pink, PhD. The date of the creation of the Rural Emergency Hospital designation also has been corrected (to 2020 from 2023), as has the dollar amount of the monthly REH facility payment (“more than 276,000” rather than “$300,000”). Finally, the 5% Medicare payment increase has been specified as an outpatient payment.

Resources

American Hospital Association (AHA) Fast Facts

AHA Knowledge Exchange: Strengthening Financial Performance in Rural Hospitals

Rural Health Information Hub

Rural Health Redesign Center

Rural Health Rising: A Podcast from Hillsdale Hospital

Rural Hospital Interconnectivity Issues

 

References

Bose D. A New Kind of Hospital Is Coming to Rural America. The Associated Press. March 16, 2024.

Condon A. Becker’s Hospital Review. More CEOs Consider Rural Emergency Hospital Designation. February 12, 2024.

Dutta S S. How are Drones Used in Healthcare? News-Medical.Net. June 16, 2023.

Falcone S. How rural hospital acquisitions are impacting surgical care access. OR Manager. June 21, 2023.

Johnson S R. States With the Most Rural Hospital Closures. US News & World Report. June 22, 2023.

Medsphere video Interview with Guadalupe County Hospital’s Christina Campos.

Swing Bed Providers. Center for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). Accessed June 2024.

The Crisis in Rural Health Care. Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform. Accessed June 2024.

Topchik M, Brown T, Pinette M, et al. Unrelenting pressure pushes rural safety net into uncharted territory. Chartis. February 13, 2024.

Vogels E A. Some Digital Divides Persist Between Rural and Suburban America. Pew Research Center. August 19, 2021.

Why are 800 rural US hospitals at the risk of closure? Advisory Board. July 28, 2023.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat