OR Manager asked Dale Bratzler, DO, MPH, who coordinates the Surgical Care Improvement Project (SCIP) to respond to readers’questions about the project and getting all practitioners on board

Q Who develops the SCIP measures? Are practicing physicians involved?
Dr Bratzler: SCIP performance measures are developed by Technical Expert Panels, which for the most part are made up of practicing physicians. Members also are often the authors of clinical guidelines. For example, when we were developing the measures for antibiotic prophylaxis, we consulted all of the guidelines published and gathered the lead authors and other clinical experts. Two examples are E. Patchen Dellinger, MD, a recognized expert on surgical site infection, who is chairman of general surgery at the University of Washington, Seattle, and Jason H. Calhoun, MD, FACS, who is now chairman of orthopedics at Ohio State University, Columbus. We also have infectious disease physicians on the panel.
As the measures are developed, we coordinate the process with the Joint Commission. Then the measures are submitted to the National Quality Forum and are subject to the NQF review process. (NQF is a nonprofit organization that develops consensus standards for health care quality.) The measures must be endorsed by NQF before the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services will publicly report performance on them.
Q How do you make sure SCIP measures are up-to-date?
Dr Bratzler: That is one of the reasons we try to keep guideline authors on our Technical Expert Panels. We meet with the panels every 3 months to review the measures. We actively solicit from the guideline developers any changes they are planning to make. We need lead time to change the measures. If science changed today on one of the performance measures, we can’t change the specifications hospitals use for reporting until 2010.
The specifications manual for the hospital inpatient quality measures is updated every 6 months and posted at www.qualitynet.org. The literature backing each SCIP measure can be found in the manual.
Q Some say the SCIP measures are “cookbook medicine.” How do you respond?
Dr Bratzler: Some may call it cookbook medicine—we call it evidence-based medicine. We are trying to reduce variation on measures such as the delivery of antibiotics for surgery, venous thromboembolism prophylaxis, etc. I’m not apologetic about that. We know there is much variation among
Surgical Care Improvement Project measures
Inpatient measures applicable to acute care hospitals providers that is not explained, is not based on evidence, and doesn’t result in good outcomes of care.
| Fiscal 2010 10/01/09-03/31/10 | Fiscal 2011 | |
| Measure | Reporting required for annual pay update | Proposed for required reporting |
| Infection | ||
| SCIP-Inf-1: Prophylatic antibiotic received within 1 hour of incision | X | X |
| SCIP-Inf-2: Prophylactic antibiotic selection for surgical patients | X | X |
| SCIP-Inf-3: Prophylactic antibiotic discontinued within 24 hours after surgery end time (48 hours for cardiac surgery) | X | X |
| SCIP-Inf-4: Cardiac surgery patients with controlled 6 am postoperative blood glucose | X | X |
| SCIP-Inf-6: Surgery patients with appropriate hair removal | X | X |
| *SCIP-Inf-7: Colorectal surgery patients with immediate postoperative normothermia | ||
| SCIP-Inf-9: Urinary catheter removed on postoperative day 1 or postoperative day 2 with day of surgery being day 0 | **X | |
| SCIP-Inf-10: Surgery patients with perioperative temperature management | **X | |
| Cardiac | ||
| SCIP-Card-2: Surgery patients on beta-blocker therapy prior to arrival who received a beta-blocker during perioperative period | X | X |
| VTE | ||
| SCIP-VTE-1: Surgery patients with recommended venous thromboembolism prophylaxis ordered | X | X |
| SCIP-VTE-2: Surgery patients who received appropriate VTE prophylaxis within 24 hours prior to surgery to 24 hours after surgery | X | X |
*Data collection to be discontinued 4Q 2009.
**Proposed for FY 2011 payment determination in IPPS proposed rule, May 1, 2009.
We are trying to get clinicians to follow evidence-based guidelines. For example, the SCIP measure on use of antibiotics for prevention of surgical site infection was developed by reviewing all of the published guidelines, which are remarkably consistent. If an antibiotic is recommended in any of the guidelines, we include it in the performance measures. But if no guideline recommends an antibiotic, we do not include it.
Keep in mind that the performance measures are not intended to address every single case. There are almost 1.5 million surgical operations reported to the SCIP database every year. Occasionally, there is legitimate reason to exclude a case or to give an antibiotic to a patient that is not consistent with the performance measure. That case will fail the performance measure because we don’t have that exclusion built into the measure. Thus, the target rates of performance are high, but they are not 100% because the performance measures are not perfect.
Q How can we get all of our physicians on board with SCIP?
Dr Bratzler: We like the approach advocated by the Institute for Healthcare Improvement (www.ihi.org). First, you focus on the early adopters, those who are following evidence-based medicine. You focus on the successes first and demonstrate improvement.
Some common themes we have observed that are successful:
If there are still physicians who hold down the institution’s rates, some hospitals include performance on SCIP measures in the physician’s cre-dentialing file. It becomes part of the credentialing process.
I think many hospital administrators and boards understand that eventually performance on these measures is in some way going to be tied to payment. At some point in the future, they won’t be able to tolerate a physician who won’t participate in evidence-based performance measures.