Operation Desert Storm begins. Tim Berners-Lee introduces the web browser. Thelma & Louise light up movie screens. All these events—and many more—happened in 1991, the first year of the annual OR Manager Salary/Career Survey. Twenty-five years later, the survey continues to reflect nationwide trends in OR nurse leaders’ salaries and other benefits, as well as staffing issues (reported in the September issue).
In this article, we have included some interesting comparisons to that first survey from 1991.
In 2015, OR leaders’ incomes fell slightly, even as volume increased (43% of respondents reported an increase in surgical volume in the past year, up from 33% in 2014). Survey respondents earned an average salary of $115,986, down slightly from $123,000 last year.
The average salary in 1991 was $47,724. Based on the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U), the 1991 salary would have a purchasing power of $83,741 in today’s dollars, indicating that OR leaders’ incomes have risen significantly over the years as their roles and responsibilities have expanded.
The average raise was 3.14%, up from last year’s 2.6%, but still lower than the 3.3% seen in 2013; in 1991 the average raise was a remarkable 6%. Given these numbers, it’s not surprising that only half of respondents were satisfied with their total compensation. However, the CPI-U increased by only 0.1% for the year ending in June 2015, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, putting the salary numbers in a different light.
Only 22% of OR leaders work in hospitals with Magnet designation, even though leaders working in these facilities believe it helps with recruiting.
One clear message from the survey is that OR leaders are engaged in their work. On a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being “not engaged at all” and 10 being “totally engaged,” the average was an impressive 9.06. OR leaders in both teaching and community hospitals are equally engaged.
About 37% of respondents plan to retire in 2030 or later, compared to only 12% in 2014. This good news is tempered by the 20% who plan to retire by 2019. This, combined with the fact that only 5% of respondents were younger than 35 years, means that the danger of a future experience gap remains very real.
Other key findings from the survey include:
• Average total compensation dropped from $149,000 to $136,069.
• Satisfaction levels for some elements vary significantly between OR leaders in teaching and community hospitals, although satisfaction with current position is about the same in both types of facilities.

• The gap in earnings between OR leaders in teaching and community hospitals has narrowed.
• Benefits remain stable.
Average salary was highest in the West ($124,000), followed closely by the Northeast ($123,000), with the South and Midwest significantly lower at $107,000 and $105,000, respectively. All averages were lower than in 2014.
Total compensation (wages, bonuses, and benefits) was higher in the West ($151,000) and the Northeast (148,000) than in the South ($131,000) and Midwest ($126,000).
The gap in salary between OR leaders in teaching and community hospitals narrowed to $18,712, in favor of those in teaching hospitals. That figure is significantly lower than the $29,000 difference in 2014.
The difference in total compensation was $30,350, compared to $40,000 in 2014. These results should be interpreted cautiously because only 19% of respondents work in teaching hospitals.
OR leaders with the title of director/administrative director earn the highest average salary ($147,870) and average total compensation ($180,326), followed by directors (average salary, $126,707; average total compensation, $144,038) and nurse managers (average salary, $96,243; average total compensation, $116,090).

More than 8 of 10 respondents reported receiving paid time off (93%), health insurance (89% vs 95% in 1991), retirement plan (85%, unchanged from 1991), and dental insurance (82% vs 75% in 1991).
Pensions continue to decline (28%, compared to 34% in 2014 and 43% in 2013), as well as bonuses/profit sharing (29%, compared to 31% in 2014 and 55% in 2013).
As expected, teaching hospitals offer greater benefits than do community hospitals, but some of the differences are striking. For instance, 82% of OR leaders in teaching hospitals have tuition reimbursement, compared to only 65% of leaders in community hospitals, and 80% of those in teaching hospitals have disability insurance, compared to 66% of leaders in community hospitals.

The percentage for the last raise was similar for OR leaders in teaching and community hospitals (3.26% vs 3.17%). Only 9% have not received a raise in the past year.
Consistent with past surveys, 73% of respondents work in a community hospital, 19% in a teaching hospital, and 8% in another type of setting. Most respondents have director as their title (46%), followed by nurse manager (33%) and administrator/administrative director (10%).
No matter what the title, OR leaders work hard, averaging 51 hours a week, similar to the 50 hours reported in 1991.
OR leaders who responded to the survey are in charge of an average of six departments, compared to seven last year.
In addition to the OR, the most common areas supervised are central processing (67% vs 32% in 1991), preoperative area (62%), and gastrointestinal/endoscopy (60% vs 47% in 1991).
Respondents oversee an average of 94 full-time equivalents (FTEs), compared to 113 last year, 123 in 2013, and 55 in 1991. The average in 2015 is 79.5 for clinical employees and 15 for nonclinical employees.
OR leaders in teaching hospitals supervise significantly more FTEs than those in community hospitals (179 vs 75), and those holding an administrator/administrative director title supervise a higher average number (183) than directors (100) and nurse managers (55).
Fewer than one-third (29%) of respondents reported that their department has designated specific times for patient rounding. When rounding occurs, most said it happens daily (42%), followed by hourly (38%), and in most settings (63%) both staff and managers round.

Engagement represents a person’s willingness to work hard, contribute fully, and be a valued contributor. Although OR leaders are highly engaged, only 62% said they are satisfied with the engagement level of their staffs.
SatisfactionOR leaders’ satisfaction with their current position (74% favorable) is comparable to those in other fields of work, including education (75%), real estate (77%), and financial services (73%).
Satisfaction rates related to benefits (59%), total compensation (50%), and top leadership (58%) were similar to those working in education.
Interestingly, favorable satisfaction with top leadership is 71% for those in financial services and 75% for real estate. Respondents rated patient satisfaction with OR service as 80%.
Significant differences exist between OR leaders in teaching and community hospitals. For example, 80% of OR leaders in teaching hospitals are satisfied with the support provided by their bosses, compared to only 63% in community hospitals. On the other hand, 85% of community hospital leaders are satisfied with patient satisfaction with OR services, compared to 60% of those in teaching hospitals.
Job stability and retirementJob stability is high for OR leaders. More than half (55%) of respondents plan to stay with their current employer until they retire, followed by 19% who plan to stay for 3 to 5 years.
Only 34% said they plan to stay less than 2 years. Most of those who plan to leave within the next 2 years are seeking career advancements; other reasons include high stress and lack of leadership support.
One person said, “I continue to have more departments added to my team, my salary is frozen for the past 3 years, and I am on 24/7 call as administrator on call at least 8 weeks/year plus my own 24/7 coverage for my 10 departments. The last three departments added to my team were all in significant regulatory and HR [human resources] trouble. I just accepted a new job; I will be in this role only 8 more work days.”
Most respondents (37%) plan to retire in 2030 or later, 26% in 2020-2014, and 19% in 2016-2019.
Only 15% of OR leaders who responded to the survey were men, up slightly from the 10% in 1991.
More than half (53%) of respondents were certified in perioperative nursing, although only 6% require their staff to obtain certification. Most leaders (24%) are aged 55 to 59 years, followed by 19% aged 60 to 64 years, reflecting a continuation of an aging workforce. In 1991, the average age of an OR leader was 44.4 years.
Most OR leaders (44%) hold a master’s as their highest degree, followed by 34% with a bachelor’s degree and 12% with an associate degree in nursing. Only one respondent held a doctorate degree. Interestingly, 65% of respondents said they require an associate degree in nursing for staff, and 26% require a bachelor’s.
In 1991, 30% of nurse leaders listed a diploma as their highest level of education (vs only 4% this year), 22% held a bachelor’s of science in nursing, and 13% held a bachelor’s in a field other than nursing.
Much has changed for OR leaders since 1991. The scope of their jobs has broadened, as they have assumed responsibility for more people and more departments.
OR leaders have always faced challenges, but recent years have brought new challenges, such as participating in organization efforts to reduce readmissions (see related story, p 1).
What will the OR Manager Salary/Career Survey find in the next 25 years? Watch for next year’s survey to get the first answer to that question. ✥
About the survey Data for the OR Manager Salary/Career Survey were collected from March 23 to May 1, 2015. The survey list comprised OR directors, managers, or similar positions within hospital ORs. The survey was closed with 348 usable responses. To ensure representation of the target audience, results were filtered to include only the 343 respondents who work full time as a manager or director. The margin of error is±5 percentage points at the 95% confidence level. This article features the compensation and management findings from the survey. Results of the staffing portion of the survey appeared in the September 2015 issue.We thank everyone who generously took time to complete this year’s survey and provide the information for our readers.