The number of specimens that are mishandled on a nationwide basis is difficult to know, but even one such incident is too much for any patient who is affected.
“If a specimen is placed in a fixative and it wasn’t supposed to be, additional testing may be compromised,” says Ann Marie Morris, MSN, RN, CNOR, nurse manager for perioperative quality and safety at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania (HUP) in Philadelphia. HUP has about 50 ORs, and patient volume averages about 26,000 per year.
Common errors include unlabeled containers, discrepancies between source and orientation (right vs left, upper vs lower), and discrepancies in the number of specimens listed on the requisition and the number of specimen containers received, according to Donna Shaw, MS, MLS(ASCP)CM, laboratory quality and accreditation specialist at MedStar Montgomery Medical Center (MMMC) in Olney, Maryland, and a spokesperson for the American Society for Clinical Pathology.
“Communication and collaboration between the lab and the OR staff is key so that specimens are collected, handled, and labeled appropriately to protect patients,” says Shaw.
Various strategies can be used to help reduce errors, including adhering to national standards (sidebar, p 12).
Shaw was part of a task force at MMMC that reduced specimen-handling errors by 75%.
The task force included the laboratory administrator, laboratory staff, OR staff, and Shaw. “We looked at the entire process from the time the specimen was collected in the OR to when it was received in the lab,” she says. “We identified where errors could occur and took steps to eliminate them.”
The interventions that came out of the task force led to such a low rate of problems that Shaw can follow up with individuals as incidents occur, and the task force is no longer active. “We hold the person responsible for the error accountable and provide education,” Shaw says.
HUP created a lab/OR specimen committee to address issues such as variation in how specimens were handled. The committee, which meets monthly, includes Morris; Colleen Mattioni, DNP, RN, CNOR, the clinical director of perioperative nursing; the surgeon in charge of perioperative quality; staff from the lab and the OR; an information technology representative; and leadership from the clinical and anatomical pathology labs.
In many hospitals, staff in the pathology lab aren’t available 24/7, so it’s important to have resources for OR staff. At MMMC, the laboratory manual for the nursing department is available online for ready reference.
Morris says one of the challenges at HUP was that staff were obtaining specimen-handling information from a printed PDF document, which made it difficult to revise and to ensure staff were working from the most current version.
“We decided to develop an electronic database that staff could access for information,” she says. Staff can search by key word, for example, “lymph node,” to learn how to handle the specimen.
“It includes detailed information to help avoid making an error,” Morris says. Those details include basic instructions such as labeling the specimen correctly and indicating whether the sample needs to be sent preserved or fresh.
“Staff nurses worked with Ann Marie [Morris] on the information so that it would be user-friendly,” Mattioni says. “We needed input from the staff since they are the frontline users.”
As starting point for developing the database, Morris asked staff to list specimens they commonly send. “We conducted a needs assessment to evaluate the information they were most challenged by,” she says. That was really important information to put on the website [for the database]” (sidebar, p 13).
As a result of these efforts, “the website is very intuitive to use,” Morris says.
OR and lab staff co-presented the database at an OR education meeting before it went live. Morris also notes that it was important to remove all the paper copies of the previous manual in the OR and to ensure that the database is kept current.
Since the launch, staff have been accessing the database 50 to 60 times a month.
“Staff are very surgery specific, so when they worked outside their specialty, they found the database particularly helpful,” Morris says.
Sometimes the solution to a problem is simple. For example, Shaw says that in many cases, the number of specimens noted on the log didn’t match what was on the requisition or the number of specimens received in the lab.
“We changed the log so that now there is one label for each specimen,” she says. “When the lab picks up, they compare the number of specimens to the log.”
At HUP, Morris says, the requisition forms were revised to be simpler to use. “Sharing a common language between disciplines can be challenging,” she says. “The nurses were not familiar with some of the lab terminology and test requests, so they had difficulty completing the form.” As a result, staff would leave fields blank.
Now the form is limited to provide only essential information. “We eliminated redundancy, so everything that is there is important.”
A step-by-step guide to collecting specimens is on the reverse side. HUP is moving from paper to an electronic system for requisitions.
Another simple step taken at HUP was to increase the number of times the lab picks up specimens to hourly during the week and daily on the weekends.
“Staff would place specimens in a fixative, even though the samples didn’t necessarily need to be preserved, because they were afraid they wouldn’t last until they were picked up,” Morris says.
Increasing pickup times helped to ease those fears.
In addition, OR staff at HUP can call a 24-hour hotline, answered by the pathology resident on call, to ask questions related to information not included in the database.
In describing their efforts to reduce specimen-handling errors, staff at the Carle Foundation Hospital and Carle Clinic Association in Urbana, Illinois, listed several strategies, including the following:
• Require the proceduralist to verify correct specimens are in the correct containers and that information on the label and requisitions is complete and correct before leaving the procedure area. Have a second person double-check the information.
• Create a standard label to be used for all pathology specimens.
• Develop a specimen tracking system.
• Create quick reference wall charts and posters for reference.
• Standardize the guidelines used for specimen transport.
• Include specimen handling in orientation for staff, and check competency annually.
More information can be found on the Institute for Healthcare Improvement website at http://www.ihi.org/resources/Pages/ImprovementStories/EliminatingPathologySpecimenHandlingandLabelingErrorsDeficiencies.aspx.
The HUP committee is continuing its work. Mattioni says that the committee tracks specimen issues monthly and categorizes them by type to identify trends and develop processes to make improvements.
“It’s so important that the lab and OR staff work together to break down each step, think about what improvements can be made, and act on them,” Shaw says. ✥
Recommendations put forth in AORN’s Guideline for Specimen Management (part of the 2015 Guidelines for Perioperative Practice) include the following:
• The perioperative registered nurse (RN) should incorporate specimen management needs when developing the plan of care.
• The perioperative RN should complete a preoperative assessment that confirms the site identification of specimens to be collected.
• Specimens should be collected and handled in a manner that protects and preserves the integrity of the specimen.
• Specimens should be transferred from the sterile field in a manner that maintains the integrity of the specimen.
• Containment of the specimen should be completed in a manner that protects and secures the specimen and prevents exposure of healthcare personnel to blood, body fluids, or other potentially infectious materials.
• Specimen containers should be labeled to communicate patient, specimen, preservative, and other biohazard information.
• Specimens should be preserved in a manner that protects the integrity of the specimen and prevents exposure of healthcare personnel to chemicals, blood, body fluids, or other potentially infectious materials.
• Specimens should be transported in a manner that protects the integrity of the specimen, prevents exposure of healthcare personnel to chemicals, blood, body fluids, or other potentially infectious materials, and maintains the confidentiality of protected patient information.
• Policies and procedures for disposition of specimens should be established in accordance with local, state, and federal regulations by a multidisciplinary team that includes pathology laboratory representatives, facility or healthcare organization physicians, and perioperative RNs.
• Nursing activities related to specimen management should be documented in a manner consistent with facility or healthcare organization policies and procedures and regulatory and accrediting agency requirements.
Donna Shaw, MS, MLS(ASCP)CM, laboratory quality and accreditation specialist at MedStar Montgomery Medical Center in Olney, Maryland, notes that most labs are certified by the College of American Pathologists, which also has standards for specimen handling. These include the need to have at least two identifiers, preoperative and postoperative diagnoses, and clinical data.
Any clinical information that would help the pathologist in examining the specimen, including what the surgeon is looking for, is important, says Shaw.
The Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, performed a needs assessment to evaluate clinical nursing staff knowledge of how to handle specimens. Here are two sample questions:
1. You have a kidney that needs to be sent to surgical pathology. The only thing the surgeon tells you is to send it “routine.” Where can you get the most accurate information on how to handle and send the specimen?
a. Call surgical pathology and ask
b. Reference the written Specimen Handling Guidelines
c. Call a friend
d. Both a and b
Answer: D. The term “routine” can be interpreted differently by different team members. Written specimen handling guidelines are available in each OR and posted on the pathology refrigerator, or you can always contact the surgical pathology resident on call and ask.
2. Your patient has ascites, and the surgeon has acquired a sample for testing. The surgeon simply tells you to “send to the lab.” What should you do?
a. Confirm with the surgeon which type of testing he or she wants and then send the sample to the lab that performs that test.
b. Send the specimen to the cytology lab
c. Send the specimen to microbiology
d. Send a sample to all the labs
Answer: A. Always ask when you are unsure. Many times surgeons assume you are thinking what they are thinking, and sometimes they really don’t know. You must always verify which testing they are requesting, choose the appropriate requisition, and send it to the appropriate lab. Talking this through can eliminate any miscommunication. If you still are unsure, reference the requisition forms and call the lab and ask.
Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc., Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.
Ann Marie Morris and Colleen Mattioni will be presenters at the annual OR Manager Conference, October 7-9, in Nashville. Visit www.ormanagerconference.com.
AORN. Guidelines for perioperative practice. Specimen management. Denver, CO: AORN, 2015. 389-418. www.aorn.org.
Rinehart A, Vannice A, Duncan B, et al. Eliminating pathology specimen handling and labeling errors/deficiencies. Cambridge, MA: Institute for Healthcare Improvement. http://www.ihi.org/resources/Pages/ImprovementStories/EliminatingPathologySpecimenHandlingandLabelingErrorsDeficiencies.aspx.