The end of the COVID-19 pandemic is in sight, but hospital surgery departments will not likely see a rapid return to normal. Since the start of the pandemic, perioperative leaders have had to stay flexible and act quickly. Over the next 12 months, OR leaders will need to reassess the environment frequently and make course corrections as needed.
The focus this year should be on surviving financially. Because of the surge in COVID-19 cases, many hospitals and hospital-owned ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) are again being forced to cancel or restrict elective surgery. OR leaders can address this issue proactively by collaborating with their surgeon and anesthesia partners on a handful of key issues.
Elective surgery cancellations in spring 2020 severely stressed hospital financial goals. In addition, 28% of hospitals reported losing money during the recent COVID-19 resurgence. In 2021, OR leaders must continue to seek opportunities to cut waste and manage expenses:
Reduce excess capacity. In a recent issue of OR Manager, my colleagues described how to use predictive analytics to optimize the schedule (“Using advanced analytics to maximize OR utilization,” December 2020, pp 22-23, 25). In 2021, OR leaders will have many opportunities to use this data-driven approach to streamline operations.
For example, recent volume declines have not hit all specialties equally. OR leaders can use predictive modeling to identify the specialties and surgeons experiencing the greatest fluctuations in case volume. Consolidating these providers’ baseline volume to fewer blocks can reduce OR costs. This approach can also increase surgeon satisfaction by reducing the number of days they have to go into the hospital.
OR leaders can also consider tightening block utilization requirements. Surgery departments that now require 75% utilization to maintain a block could increase that threshold to 80%. This small daily gain could net several million dollars of additional case revenue per year.
Build flexibility into nursing compensation. Many OR nurses were furloughed during the pandemic. Although demand is starting to even out, 2021 will continue to be a year of flux for OR labor. Staffing needs will likely remain depressed during the early part of the year before a strong rebound occurs in summer and fall.
OR leaders should consider instituting a new compensation arrangement that is partially untied to work hours. By reclassifying OR nurses to salaried positions, nurses’ current compensation would stay intact even if work hours were reduced early in the year. In exchange, nurses would agree to work more hours in the second half of the year as demand rebounds. Nurses could maintain an even income stream while accommodating the uncertain staffing needs of the OR.
Even though OR schedules have opened in some geographic regions, many patients are still afraid to come to the hospital for surgery. To build a strong recovery in 2021, OR leaders need to win back patients by establishing a strong safety brand.
Audit surgical safety measures. OR leaders should confirm that staff are following all COVID-19-specific infection control measures consistently. Some practices are now well established, such as terminal cleanings between all cases. Other risk-reduction measures may need more attention. For example, some procedures (such as certain otolaryngology cases) carry additional risk for airborne contamination. For these cases, add a 15-minute “room empty” step to turnover processes.
Make sure OR staff are vaccinated. A healthcare system in Texas recently offered employees a $500 incentive to receive a COVID-19 vaccine. This may not be possible in many settings, but it underscores the importance of promoting staff vaccination.
Build safety into presurgical processes. The preadmission process should adhere to American College of Surgeons guidelines for presurgical COVID-19 testing. To protect patients, hospitals should consider adding COVID-19 vaccination to the presurgical workup for procedures scheduled at least a month in advance.
Communicate safety efforts to patients. To win back customers during COVID-19, major airlines have reengineered every step of the travel process to enhance safety—from preflight processes, through lobby and gate procedures, to the onboard experience and baggage pickup. Just as important, they have spared no expense in communicating these efforts to their customers.
OR leaders should work with their colleagues in hospital marketing departments to create a communication plan around surgical safety. Show surgery patients what is being done in every step of the perioperative process to create a safe environment. Publicize changes such as daily staff screenings, restrictions on who can enter the facility, and the construction of solid walls (if applicable) between beds in the recovery area.
Extend these efforts to surgeon partners. Most surgeons have seen a significant drop-off in the number of patients willing to come to the office to be evaluated for surgery. This is not only a leading indicator of softening OR volume. Because many surgeons are now employed by hospitals and health systems, lower surgeon productivity is further undercutting surgical service line profitability.
OR leaders can help surgeons by providing workshops on how to communicate with patients about the safety precautions in place to reduce their risk of exposure. Surgeons’ office staff should also be encouraged to call all scheduled patients to reconfirm their appointments and provide personal reassurance of their safety.
Just like hospitals, ASCs, and surgeons, anesthesia providers are under significant financial pressure. The 2021 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule has reduced the conversion factor for anesthesia reimbursement by nearly 10%. This pay cut comes on top of 2020 income losses driven by declines in elective surgery, the most profitable case volume for anesthesia providers.
In response to these losses, many anesthesia groups are expected to request an increase in their hospital stipends. Most organizations cannot afford to increase anesthesia stipends, but they can provide nonfinancial support to anesthesia providers.
Work with anesthesia providers to reduce expenses. Most anesthesia groups can improve their profit margin by better conforming their staffing schedules to the OR case schedule. OR leaders can support this goal by helping anesthesia providers use predictive modeling to improve staff scheduling and deployment. Some of the biggest opportunities can be found in managing OR and non-operating room anesthesia (NORA) locations in a more coordinated manner.
OR leaders can also work with anesthesia providers to evaluate coverage ratios. For example, many ambulatory cases do not require full medical direction, but can be performed safely with anesthesia medical supervision alone. The surgical services director can work with anesthesia leaders to create ambulatory blocks that maximize the use of lower-intensity anesthesia coverage.
In addition, many hospitals may want to consider migrating to a “ZONE Model” of anesthesia coverage. Under this model, physician anesthesiologists are present in key areas (such as pre-anesthesia holding, the OR itself, and the postanesthesia care unit), certified registered nurse anesthetists provide most direct care while practicing at or near the top of their license, and extensive care protocols help ensure quality and safety.
Help anesthesia providers optimize practice revenue. Many practices can increase billing 10% or more by simply ensuring that all charges are submitted daily, not just for OR cases but for all NORA sites such as endoscopy suites and catheterization labs. In addition, OR leaders can help anesthesia groups verify insurance coverage prior to surgery and work out payment plans for the patient responsibility portion of the anesthesia bill.
Consider renegotiating the anesthesia contract. In the current economic climate, employing anesthesia providers may be more cost-effective than supporting them with a stipend. An 11-OR facility in the South recently terminated its coverage contract with a national anesthesia company and began employing providers directly. This move resulted in a total cost reduction of approximately $4 million.
Much of 2021 will be devoted to managing fluctuations in demand, staffing, and resources. Surgical services directors who keep their eye on the environment and flex accordingly will be able to lead their organizations out of the pandemic.
However, OR leaders should also realize that COVID-19 is a wake-up call that the traditional inpatient surgery business is in decline. The pandemic has demonstrated the value of a large, distributed network of outpatient surgery sites. Even after the COVID-19 crisis subsides, ambulatory surgery will continue to be the future of surgical services.
Perceptive OR leaders will use 2021 to plan a decisive pivot toward an ambulatory strategy. This approach will help hospitals secure new surgical volume while increasing efficiency and improving the patient experience. It will also help protect the entire organization against future disruptions in the inpatient surgery market. ✥
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. CY 2021 Physician Fee Schedule. Federal Register. December 28, 2020. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2020-12-28/pdf/2020-26815.pdf.
Gibson K. Houston hospital offers workers $500 to get COVID-19 vaccine. CBS News. January 5, 2021. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/covid-vaccine-houston-hospital-500-dollars/.
Pugh T. Hospitals lose money, volume as COVID-19 fears keep patients away. Bloomberg Law. November 23, 2020. https://news.bloomberglaw.com/health-law-and-business/hospitals-lose-money-volume-as-covid-fears-keep-patients-away.