August 21, 2023

Supplementing staff with travelers helps reduce burnout

By: Angela Lewellyn, LPN, CRCST, CER, CHL
Share

OR leaders face numerous challenges in managing high patient volumes and complex procedures, as well as in maintaining staff morale. To meet these demands, many ORs have turned to nurse travelers for temporary staffing support.

With the addition of nurse travelers, the responsibilities of OR leaders increase, putting them at an additional risk of burnout. These responsibilities include reception and orientation of the nurse travelers and their integration into the OR team. It is crucial for leaders to prioritize their well-being and find ways to integrate and support staff nurses and travelers effectively.

Over time, the pressure to meet the expectations placed on OR leaders by staff, colleagues, and surgeons can contribute to burnout and a loss of well-being. The World Health Organization recognizes nurse burnout as an “occupational phenomenon” resulting from “chronic workplace stress that has not been successfully managed.”

Recognizing the signs of burnout while providing support and resources to team members can help alleviate its impact.

 

Addressing work-life balance

OR leaders need to be mindful of their well-being and that of their team members and take proactive measures to prevent and address burnout. Creating a culture that encourages self-care, work-life balance, and open communication is paramount.

For that, OR leaders should foster an environment where team members feel comfortable discussing their challenges and seeking assistance when needed. Implementing initiatives such as wellness programs, stress reduction strategies, and professional development opportunities can promote a healthier work environment and contribute to the overall well-being of the team.

One solution being considered by department leaders is the implementation of creative scheduling practices. Recognizing the importance of work-life balance, they are exploring alternatives to the traditional 5-day work week. They also are reevaluating block scheduling and hours of operation, so that surgeons and staff can have more flexible schedules that accommodate their personal needs.

Kawana Mitchell, MBA, RN, CNOR, an OR manager at a major hospital in Chicago, acknowledges that “the concept of a fixed 5-day work week is becoming outdated, especially in light of the work-life balance expectations of the younger generation of nurses, known as Generation Z.” She notes that embracing a culture of balanced lifestyle is becoming the new norm and what attracts this new generation.

With over 30 years of experience in surgical services, including roles in the OR, PACU, and sterile processing, Mitchell has witnessed the changing dynamics of nurses across generations, from Boomers to Generation Z. As a director and manager, she has valuable insights into the evolving attitudes and expectations of nurses in the workplace.

Reflecting on her experiences, Mitchell highlights the contrast of working cultures between the Boomer generation and Generation Z. Boomers often embrace a work-centric mentality, prioritizing long hours and being available for on-call duties. In contrast, Generation Z places a strong emphasis on work-life balance and recognizes the significance of personal time. They are willing to make sacrifices, even to the point of accepting a $20,000 annual pay cut, in order to have more flexibility.

Mitchell emphasizes that this shift in perspective should not be mistaken for laziness. On the contrary, the focus on work-life balance is a healthier approach that helps to retain nurses. By recognizing the importance of personal well-being and creating an environment that supports balance, healthcare organizations are cultivating a more satisfied and engaged workforce. This will not only benefit the nurses, but also the patients for whom they care.

 

Addition of travelers

One resource an OR leader can provide to the surgical team is the addition of nurse and surgical technologist travelers. They can play a vital role in the department, providing temporary staffing solutions and filling staffing needs to ensure the scheduled cases run smoothly. As travelers join new teams and navigate unfamiliar environments, it is important for OR leaders is ensure their smooth integration and provide necessary support.

Nurse travelers also can be instrumental in alleviating burnout among permanent staff. Advantage Support Services Executive Director Denise Velazquez, who has coordinated nurse travelers for over 30 years, says, “Travelers are often welcomed by department staff, easing day-to-day operations. These travelers are typically acclimated to the travel experience and are prepared to work with more challenging cases or provide relief for permanent staff. Offering breaks to permanent staff can help prevent burnout, and travelers provide the temporary relief needed in such situations. Their presence eases the stress and anxiety experienced by full-time staff, and they contribute to covering cases that may have had to be canceled due to staffing shortages.”

The travelers eventually create sustainability in the department and help to retain local staff. While the travelers are helping to augment staff, managers are offered time to interview and hire permanent staff. Travelers help maintain a high level of satisfaction among surgeons and the staff overall and, ultimately, help increase revenue.

 

Orientation of travelers is key

As travelers join new teams and navigate unfamiliar environments, it is essential for OR leaders to ensure their smooth integration and provide the necessary support and orientation.

OR leaders may consider a mindful approach to recognizing the unique circumstances of nurse travelers, including facing unfamiliar protocols and team dynamics, and foster an environment of empathy and understanding, considering the challenges and adjustments that travelers may experience. By actively listening to their concerns, providing clear communication, and offering guidance, OR leaders can promote a sense of inclusion and support.

Each healthcare organization has its own unique culture, workflow, and OR practices. OR leaders must ensure that travelers are aware of these facility-specific differences by providing comprehensive orientation sessions that cover protocols, equipment usage, and interdisciplinary collaboration. Additionally, OR leaders should encourage open dialogue and welcome questions and feedback.

The process of orienting nurse travelers can vary in duration, ranging from 4 hours to 2 weeks, and time constraints often limit the availability of an extensive orientation process. Velazquez explains that many facilities conduct a brief 4-hour orientation because of the expectation that travelers can quickly adapt and assist in surgical cases.

When orienting nurse travelers, Mitchell focuses on two to three surgical specialties based on the nurses’ clinical expertise and personal preferences. Concentrating on specific services not only enables nurse travelers to become more efficient, but also fosters relationships with the specialty teams, including the surgeons. According to Mitchell, this approach breaks down hierarchies and promotes deeper professional connections, granting nurses the freedom to speak up and contribute to a collaborative environment.

 

Sustainability

The reliance on nurse travelers is not a sustainable long-term solution for cost-effective healthcare. Many ORs set expected end dates for travel staff, only to find themselves unable to meet the surgical caseload without their assistance. As a result, the healthcare industry is exploring new strategies to attract and retain permanent staff nurses.

One approach is to integrate nurse travelers into the permanent staff by fostering teamwork, implementing mentorship programs, promoting collaboration, and creating a sense of belonging within the team. By facilitating a positive working environment, leaders benefit both travelers and the permanent staff.

Another approach for attracting and retaining permanent staff is to adapt to the generational shift in work cultures. “Healthcare is behind,” says Mitchell. “Other industries have addressed the generation shift in work cultures, from Boomers, who have a history of staying in an OR for years to Generation Z staff, who typically do not stay with an organization after 5 years.”

Mitchell adds that her team is proactively addressing the OR staffing shortage by exploring the option of transitioning patient care nurses to the OR. They point out that the nurse has a one-to-one patient-to-nurse ratio in the OR, unlike the ratios and demands of a patient care unit.

Like many hospitals, Mitchell says they also are reaching out to local nursing schools to attract new graduates to the OR. By adopting this approach, they aim to create a pipeline of new graduates and offer a work environment that aligns with the expectations and needs of the newer generation. The goal is to reduce turnover and ensure a sustainable workforce that can effectively meet the demands of the surgical community in the long run, she says.

By fostering a positive work environment, promoting open communication, providing support and resources, and integrating nurse travelers effectively, leaders can reduce burnout, enhance team cohesion, and create a resilient and thriving surgical team capable of delivering exceptional care to their patients while maintaining their own well-being.

—Angela Lewellyn, LPN, CRCST, CER, CHL, is director of Development & Research at Advantage Support Services, Inc. She has a combined 20 years of experience in surgical services as a cross-trained circulator / surgical scrub and as a surgical technologist educator.

 

Resources

Burn-out an “occupational phenomenon”: International Classification of Diseases. World Health Organization. May 28, 2019.

Meet the experts. Advantage Support Services, Inc. June 13, 2022.

NurseJournal Staff. What is nurse burnout? NurseJournal. March 23, 2023.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat