May 18, 2018

Surgical Council facilitates service line moves between hospitals

By: Judith M. Mathias, MA, RN
Share

To improve healthcare delivery and eliminate duplication, hospitals are banding together into systems in which specialties such as labor and delivery and smaller surgical cases are performed at satellite hospitals, and larger, more complex procedures are done at the main campus.

This is the approach taken at the Cleveland Clinic, which includes a 165-acre main campus, 10 regional hospitals, and 18 full-service family health centers throughout Northeast Ohio, as well as sites in Florida, Nevada, Toronto, and Abu Dhabi. A new London location is set to open in mid-2019.

In 2012, the Cleveland Clinic formed an Enterprise Surgical Council (ESC) to optimize its surgical footprint across its system. The ESC evaluates the current state of surgical services and programs across the various locations and analyzes each proposed move of a service line.

“We had to stop being individual facilities and start operating as a whole and looking at the bigger picture,” says Carol Pehotsky, DNP, RN, NEA-BC, ACNS-BC, CPAN, associate chief nursing officer, surgical services, Cleveland Clinic Health System.

This article describes the evolution of the ESC. Although much of the information applies to large hospital systems, facilities of any size can adopt the lessons learned in establishing multidisciplinary collaboration and decision making to improve efficiency.

 

The Cleveland Clinic model

Carol Pehotsky, DNP, RN, NEA-BC, ACNS-BC, CPAN

The Cleveland Clinic system employs 50,000 caregivers, including 3,500 physicians and 12,000 nurses. A total of 60,000 inpatient and 148,000 outpatient surgeries are performed each year.

“Our model, which feeds into some of the challenges we had to surmount initially with the ESC, is that we are a physician-led group,” says Pehotsky.

The main campus was founded in 1921 by four physicians who wanted to do something different with the way healthcare was run.

Today, especially at the main campus, physicians are employees. They have 1-year contracts that may or may not be renewed based on a variety of factors including quality, behavior, and performance.

“The physicians have ‘skin in the game’ in terms of continuing their employment with us,” she says. “We do not give bonuses. We provide other incentives, but their main incentive is to continue working with us.”

Some of the regional hospitals are a mix of private and employed physicians, and some of the smaller hospitals are up to 50/50 private and employed.

Taking this model where some physicians are employed and some aren’t, and getting them all on the same page about how to do surgery at the Cleveland Clinic, was a big challenge, notes Pehotsky.

 

Institute model

Adding to the challenge was that the Cleveland Clinic is aligned in an institute model, which means that instead of having a department of surgery and a department of nursing, the institute is aligned by clinical specialties. Within that alignment is an institute leadership and a department leadership.

For example, there is a digestive disease and surgery institute, which has an institute chairman, department chairmen, and institute and department administrators. They all have their own ideas, plans, and strategies about how to optimize digestive disease and surgery across the organization.

Some institutes are cross specialty, such as the nursing institute, anesthesia institute, quality and patient safety institute, and the cancer institute, which looks at cancer across the continuum. All nurses report to the nursing institute, all anesthesia providers report to the anesthesia institute, and quality care is delivered across the continuum, no matter the specialty.

Instead of a department of surgery or institute of surgery, there is surgical operations, which is a service provider to the surgeons and the patients.

Surgical operations includes:

• surgical support—eg, cleaning the ORs, transporting patients, taking specimens to the lab

• surgical supplies—ensuring supplies are available for specific patients and cases

• surgical scheduling—working with the schedulers to adjust and optimize the OR schedule

• administration

• capital—funding of the OR

• finance—paying the bills and staff

• OR infrastructure—ensuring the infrastructure is up to date.

The institutes have a vision about improving care for all patients, and the operationalization of that is what the ESC is all about, says Pehotsky.

 

ESC is born

As an organization, the Cleveland Clinic has 230 ORs, says Pehotsky. “We had to ask ourselves: Is that enough, is that too much, and are they being properly utilized?”

The community hospitals, which came into the fold of the Cleveland Clinic one at a time, had to decide if they were going to continue to be everything to everybody in their local communities or if they were going to be a part of something bigger.

The Cleveland Clinic actually started this process 8 years before the ESC was born. Because fewer babies were being delivered each year at the main campus, the decision was made to stop providing labor and delivery services there, says Pehotsky.

Instead, resources were put into two nearby hospitals where most women were going for labor and delivery, and into redirecting other women to those facilities.

Similarly, Pehotsky says, surgical patients were increasingly following their surgeons to other hospitals for surgery instead of going to their local hospitals, and the Cleveland Clinic decided to provide a structure for it. Thus, the ESC was born, with these members:

• surgical department chairman

• institute chairman

• medical operations chairman

• regional leadership (chief of surgery or surgical director)

• hospital presidents

• regional hospital’s chiefs of surgery

• surgical quality and surgical operations (chairman runs the ESC meeting)

• surgical nursing personnel

• anesthesia personnel.

 

ESC responsibilities

The roles and responsibilities of the ESC include the following.

OR recapitalization. With 230 ORs at different facilities that are aging at different intervals, some are in desperate need of recapitalization, and some are fine, notes Pehotsky. Finding an equitable way to divide the money and also think strategically about which ORs need to be recapitalized and how to execute it is the responsibility of the ESC.

Electronic medical record governance. The Cleveland Clinic uses both Epic and OpTime. Epic was started in 2004, and Epic’s electronic intraoperative record, OpTime, started in 2009. Each hospital went live on Epic at different times, so there are 10 different versions of Epic in use.

“It took a year and a half of a long, grueling process to have OpTime look the same at all of the facilities,” says Pehotsky. The ESC helps to mediate requests for changes and upgrades because a change in Epic now means a change for all facilities and locations.

Surgical policies. “We had a lot of policies, but the question for the ESC was how to get to a core amount,” says Pehotsky. The ESC first looked at nursing policies, but they didn’t want a nursing policy for counts and a physician policy for counts.

They also needed documents that spoke to the expectations of everyone in the room when doing the safety checklist, not just the nurse. “It has been good to have the ESC as a vetting body for these documents and to say, ‘if you agree to this policy, you also agree to hold people accountable to it.’”

Scheduling guidelines. There are scheduling guidelines for when block times are released, how to do it, and how to make sure block times for surgeons at multiple hospitals don’t overlap.

Allocation. Each facility has its own local allocation committee in addition to the Enterprise Allocation Committee. The local committee oversees changes within the same facility and removal of block time.

The Enterprise Allocation Committee ensures allocation decisions are in alignment with organizational strategy and maximizes OR utilization and workforce efficiency across all facilities. It looks at the new and existing surgeons and their services and manages duplicate block times.

“Before the Enterprise Allocation Committee, we were setting our surgeons up for failure,” says Pehotsky. “They had blocks in two different facilities that were 45 minutes away from each other, and because we were managing everything locally at that point, no one noticed why the surgeons were always late.”

The Enterprise Allocation Committee is made up of:

• 12 surgeons (voting members)

• two anesthesiologists (voting members)

• three nurses

• administration.

 

Decision making process

“The original goal of the ESC was service line optimization, but we are also a decision-making body, and we have been challenged with due diligence,” says Pehotsky.

If the ESC says yes to moving a surgical specialty to another location, they send it to the executives for their approval. Sometimes the executives say yes and sometimes they don’t because they have to consider larger strategic initiatives.

If they say yes, a project team is formed that includes clinical leaders and surgical operations (sidebar below).

The project team interviews stakeholders, completes an analysis, shares recommendations with the executive sponsors, and then takes the idea back to the ESC for their endorsement.

“The formation of the project team to dig into the ideas before ‘pulling the trigger’ was what really took the process to the next level,” says Pehotsky.

If the ESC endorses the proposed idea, the clinical leaders and project team present recommendations for executive endorsement. If the executives approve, the ESC creates an operational team to drive implementation.

“When you have an idea as to which facility you’d like to receive the volume of the moved specialty, then you involve the local leaders. If you are looking at a couple of different locations, the chief nursing officer, president, nursing directors, and surgical director are involved along with an unaffected department representative,” she says.

The unaffected department representative may be a department chairman or physician and is “the true honest broker,” says Pehotsky. “This person makes a big difference in that he or she can pull a surgeon colleague aside and say: ‘I know I’m not the one affected, but here is what I am seeing that is good. Here is what I am seeing that is challenging. Here are the questions I would have if it affected me.’”

Service line evaluation

Before a change in location is made, the project team goes through a step-by-step process.

Define the program. This includes types of cases, capital equipment, instrumentation, supplies, and other requirements (eg, ancillary needs, laboratory/pathology, research, residents, space).

“We try to get as specific as possible,” says Pehotsky. Examples would include: What is the case mix? Are there outpatient fillers? What types of capital equipment are needed? Could needed equipment be moved from the current facility to the new destination? What instruments and supplies will be needed?

Other requirements come from input by the department administrators and physicians. For example: Is there a lab and pathology at the new site? Are they doing research? What is needed in terms of on-call coverage, residents, space, and clinical space?

Data collection and assessment. Included are volume, geospacial analysis, reimbursement, impact on utilization, capital and operating requirements, and staffing and competency.

“We look at how much volume we will be moving and if the OR, preop, postop, and patient care floors are big enough to handle the volume,” says Pehotsky. “We want to know what this is going to do to their throughput,” she says.

The team also examines utilization at the new site and what it will do to the old site. “Do we save one hospital but handicap another in terms of their utilization and their cases?” she asks.

In addition, staffing requirements and competency needs are examined, not just for the OR, but for all the affected departments.

“This is where I sometimes had to elbow my colleagues and remind them it wasn’t just about the OR,” notes Pehotsky.

Scorecard. After a lot of back and forth discussion, the next step is to develop a scorecard and customize it to the project. This includes requirements such as OR time available, floor capacity, office space, financial implications, nursing staff, resident coverage, and beds.

Site visits. Next comes the “road show,” says Pehotsky. The project team decides which facilities they want to visit and what they want to see.

This is another point at which it is important to have that unaffected surgeon along to look at a facility with unbiased eyes, she says. Also, many of the surgeons operate at multiple locations, and they can be the best endorsement and the best champions. Because of this, Pehotsky says, they have to be selective about who goes on the road show.

Final recommendation. A final recommendation is made—not by the project team but by the ESC. The project team tells the ESC what it has found and asks them what they think. The ESC gives the move a thumbs up or thumbs down. If the ESC likes it, they make it happen, says Pehotsky.

 

Keys to success

The keys to success of the ESC are that it has been a collaboration among surgeons, anesthesiologists, nurses, and administrators, and that the Enterprise Allocation Committee is physician led, says Pehotsky.

“We needed people who were willing to listen and who were willing to keep nursing and administration at the table so it wasn’t seen as their personal agenda. That has been a big difference for us,” she says.

“The ESC has become a vetted, authoritative decision-making process instead of just floating things up and down, but we are still a work in progress,” says Pehotsky. “We are only going to get better.” ✥

 

Reference

Pehotsky C. An Enterprise Surgical Council designed to live long and prosper. OR Business Management Conference. 2018.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat