April 20, 2016

Surgical development teams save millions in clinical costs

By: OR Manager
Share

Surgeon champions can make or break a perioperative initiative. But it’s not enough to simply identify a single champion. OR leaders must engage a wide range of physicians to improve the organizational structure of the healthcare system.

At Intermountain Healthcare, a 22-hospital system based in Salt Lake City, Utah, surgical development teams led by physicians have been created to improve patient care and save money. Using clinical and operational best practices, these development teams helped Intermountain save $42.9 million in 2013 (the first year of the program) and $39 million in 2014.

Jeannette Prochazka, MSN, RN, ACNS-BC, surgical development teams, clinical cost saving

Jeannette
Prochazka, MSN, RN, ACNS-BC

Jeannette Prochazka, MSN, RN, ACNS-BC “The development teams are changing the conversation around outcomes, supplies, and variation in general,” says Jeannette Prochazka, MSN, RN, ACNS-BC, clinical operations director for the surgical services clinical program at Intermountain.

Prochazka cites the example of the general surgery development team, which is implementing an updated best practices protocol for colon surgery across the system.

“It’s this team that is driving the evidence-based practice and the change management that goes along with it,” she says.

According to Prochazka, an important component of success is that the teams are embedded into system’s clinical programs, similar to service lines. “The development teams are where the work of the clinical program gets done,” she says. “Our development teams are more than just a group of people who get together and meet. They have some decision rights within our system.”

For example, the robotics development team has to approve robot purchases before they are reviewed by the capital expenditure committee, and the bariatrics development team is responsible for deciding which hospitals in the system will pursue becoming Bariatric Centers of Excellence.

Here is a closer look at how the development teams work.

 

An integral part of clinical programs

Clinical programs such as surgical services are part of the leadership structure of Intermountain Healthcare, which contains 250 ORs, including a level 1 trauma center, two level 2 trauma centers, and two ambulatory surgery centers, along with an orthopedic specialty hospital.

Intermountain’s medical group employs about 1,200 physicians, but independent physicians also practice in the system.

The success of clinical programs depends on clinical management information infrastructure and information management infrastructure.

Development teams are part of the clinical management infrastructure and receive support not only from clinical staff but also from information technology experts who help ensure accurate, useful data are obtained and analyzed.

Ann Putnam, MSN, BSN, CNOR, surgical development teams, clinical cost saving

Ann Putnam, MSN, BSN, CNOR

“We know that if we show people what we’re measuring and the outcomes, they’re more likely to support changes,” says Ann Putnam, MSN, BSN, CNOR, ProComp project manager at Intermountain Healthcare. “Information technology shows us if the implementations we’ve made have been successful.”

ProComp is an initiative that helps develop cost awareness among physicians and staff through provider and procedure comparisons. ProComp nurses also provide support services such as data analysis to the development teams.

Ann Putnam, MSN, BSN, CNOREach month, the clinical program leadership convenes a guidance council meeting to present and discuss development team meeting highlights. In addition to the ProComp team members, the guidance council includes physician leaders from the development teams, OR directors from across the system, and supply chain representatives.

Currently, Intermountain has 11 development teams: general surgery, urology, bariatrics, geriatric hip fractures, robotics, anesthesia, spine, total joints, endoscopy, gynecology, and blood management; plastics and ENT are planned to start this year.

 

Establishing a successful team

Development teams are led by a physician who is paid by Intermountain for dedicating 15 hours each month to the team’s work. “The key to a successful development team is the leader,” Putnam says, adding that OR nurse leaders need to assess the motivation of potential surgeon leaders before choosing one (sidebar, p 23). “It’s a problem if they want to lead for their own benefit.”

Other physicians from across the system, who may or may not be paid by their local facilities, participate in the team meetings, with at least one representative from each of Intermountain’s five regions.

Additional members include OR leaders, clinical experts, data analysts, and supply chain staff. During monthly meetings, team members discuss progress made and how to move projects forward.

A key part of the team’s responsibility is standardization, which improves outcomes and saves money. For instance, the anesthesia development team decided to limit the types of anesthesia machines to two. “This was a safety issue,” Prochazka says.

The team is also working on incorporating and optimizing anesthesia information into the existing electronic health record.

Cross-team collaboration thrives. During the monthly guidance council meetings, the development team leaders highlight specifics that are meaningful to the other specialties. For example, the bariatric development team revised a shared decision-making tool for use by primary care physicians, and then decided to share it with other development teams. Those teams, in turn, shared it with some patients. The updated tool defines surgical weight loss surgery and explains the different types of surgery available, why a patient should consider surgery, how it is done, what to expect after surgery, and how to get more information.

To avoid silos, representatives from each facility take part in a monthly clinical program ProComp call via Webex, which pulls together surgical services leadership as well as finance and quality improvement representatives from all 22 hospitals to share ideas. On each call, the ProComp nurses direct conversation around the annual goals.

“There are a tremendous number of ideas generated and shared within the monthly call,” Putnam says. “A facility in Utah can share with a facility in Idaho a strategy that worked; now we’ve saved the Idaho hospital the time it took to figure that out.”

 


Surgeon champions

What makes a good surgeon leader, whether it’s for an individual project or an overall initiative?

Kirk Reichard, MD, MBA, FACS, FAAP, surgical development teams, clinical cost saving

Kirk Reichard, MD, MBA, FACS, FAAP

“The ideal leader is influential, compassionate, courageous, unbiased, respected, open-minded, credible, and collaborative,” says Ann Putnam, MSN, BSN, CNOR, ProComp project manager at Intermountain Healthcare. “They also have to understand standardization and be a diplomat.” Leaders set the tone for meetings, so they must be willing to hear input.

Many of these characteristics are echoed by Kirk Reichard, MD, MBA, FACS, FAAP, surgical director of operating rooms and clinical director for pediatric surgery at Nemours/Alfred I. duPont Hospital for Children in Wilmington, Delaware. “The first thing a surgeon champion needs to be is credible,” he says. The surgeon doesn’t need to be the chair or the most experienced physician in a specialty, but should not be the most junior member.

“Surgeon champions have to be trusted by their peers, and they need to be trusted by the administration,” Dr Reichard adds. He also includes good communication abilities and persistence as other important factors. “You have to be able to build consensus and collaboration and have a continuous improvement mindset,” he says.

Currently, about 35% of physicians in the department of surgery at Nemours/Alfred I. duPont Hospital for Children are involved in continuous improvement efforts. “We’re pretty proud of that,” Dr Reichard says. “Once you begin to engage scientists, they really get into the continuous improvement plan because it is science, after all.”


 

Defining cohorts

Meaningful data are essential for a successful team. “We have to decide what we want to measure so we can keep close tabs on it,” Prochazka says. Teams are held accountable when goals aren’t met.

An important role of the development team is to establish cohorts for surgical procedures. The cohorts, based on ICD-10 codes, establish which types of cases will be included in data analysis. “We get very detailed,” Putnam says.

The goal of defining these cohorts is to establish the ideal group of cases for a specific procedure that the surgeons identify as “like cases.” Comparing variation of the costs and outcomes of these like cases generates constructive conversation about outliers.

“When surgeons have input into the cohorts, they will trust the data,” Putnam says, adding that this practice eliminates common surgeon complaints such as, “My patients are sicker and more complicated, so you shouldn’t include them in the analysis.”

A data analyst and one of the three ProComp nurses work with surgeons to define and refine the cohort definitions.

Subsequent reports are based on the cohort definitions. Examples of report elements include case volume, OR minutes, surgery minutes, postoperative hours, length of stay hours, return to the emergency department, readmissions, return to the OR, blood usage, and supply costs.

“We build specific reports for each development team,” Putnam says (sidebar at right). Those reports include patient outcomes and cost-per-case comparisons down to the physician level. Surgeons and staff in the OR can also access an application for information on supply costs and comparable alternatives that are less expensive.

 


Development team resources

ProComp, an initiative at Intermountain Healthcare, provides the following reports and resources to its development teams.

ProComp development team resources

Source: Intermountain Healthcare. Used with permission.


 

Effective data sharing

When it comes to engaging physicians in conversation about variation in costs and outcomes, Putnam says. “Be consistent with the data you are showing physicians, and be consistent in showing them what they want to see.”

She recommends transparency with individual surgeon data. “Nothing changes behavior more than showing them the data unblinded,” she says. “At first, it ruffles some feathers, but that passes and then the conversations change among physicians.”

For instance, one surgeon recently asked his colleagues how they were able to perform a particular procedure without some costly supplies he always used. During the discussion, the inquiring surgeon realized his technique was not the only way to perform the procedure.

Surgeons also can see how their data compare with those of others across the health system. If they notice they are the only ones using a more expensive stapler, for example, they are more likely to switch if they believe they can still get the same quality outcomes.

Putnam notes that an unexpected benefit of better data analysis is that because surgeons like the data they are receiving, they are publishing more often. “It’s another sign that they’re engaged in what we are doing,” she says.

The development teams at Intermountain Healthcare engage physicians by providing decision-making authority to implement evidence-based practices, giving them input into what metrics are measured, reporting data that they can trust, and helping them understand that cost savings are important for patients, not just hospitals.

“Reduction in supply costs has translated to a reduction in premiums for those patients,” Putnam says. (Intermountain’s SelectHealth insurance plan has more than 700,000 members.)

In addition to motivating surgeons, development team efforts also put the hospital in a favorable light in the community. View an Intermountain Healthcare video highlighting the ProComp program at www.youtube.com/watch?v=39ItDsc2ZJY. ✥

 

Reference

Putnam A, Prochazka J. Sustain what you gain: Replicate savings year after year. OR Business Management Conference, 2016.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat