December 1, 2012

Survey: An OR leadership crisis is looming, but is C-suite listening?

By: OR Manager
Awards  
PDF
Share

Perioperative nursing is facing a leadership crisis. Though 9 in 10 perioperative nurse leaders think a smooth succession is critical when they retire, they worry about who will take these positions. Most think the scope of their roles needs to be re-evaluated to attract younger RNs, a new OR Manager succession planning survey finds.

Leaders are also concerned about who will staff their ORs. Two-thirds foresee problems filling staff positions in the next 5 years (related article, p 13).

The crisis isn’t far off.

“I think we have about a 3-year window before we see the start of intense shortages,” says Rose O. Sherman, EdD, RN, NEA-BC, FAAN, of Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton, who collaborated with OR Manager on the survey.

Three-fourths of the survey respondents are over age 50, and 1 in 5 is over 60. Well over half— 59%—have more than 30 years of nursing experience.

Some 22% plan to retire within 3 years, and 65% say they will leave within 10 years. They will be exiting just as a surge of aging baby boomers and patients newly insured under health care reform is arriving for surgery.

Not only will that be a knowledge drain, but hospitals could also see a revenue drain if patients have to be turned away because not enough ORs can be staffed, Sherman points out.

The online survey, sent to 2,000 OR Manager subscribers, had 254 total responses, for a return rate of 12.7%. The inclusion criterion was perioperative nurse leaders, and not all subscribers are nurses or in leadership positions. Sherman, who is associate professor and director of Florida Atlantic University’s Nursing Leadership Institute in the Christine E. Lynn College of Nursing, presented the results at the 25th Annual OR Manager Conference October 24-26, 2012, in Las Vegas.

 

Succession plans lag

Despite the short time line, 50% of the respondents say their organization doesn’t have a succession plan for their role. There’s also concern about the pipeline: 72% say that based on conversations with staff, they worry about who will take OR leadership positions in the future. Close to 60% think the overall supply of perioperative leaders is inadequate.

Concerns extend to the top: More than 60% say their organization does not have a succession plan for senior nurse leaders.


Do you have a succession plan to replace your perioperative leaders?

Would you say you have a strong pool of candidates who can replace you?

How would you describe the leadership pipeline in perioperative nursing outside your organization?

Based on my conversations with staff, I worry about who will take perioperative leadership positions in the future

As part of succession planning, the responsibilities and span of control in my perioperative nurse leader role need to be re-evaluted

 

Management a tough sell

Some survey participants say they’re having difficulty getting senior management’s attention on succession planning. The subject “is often met with resistance from the C-suite,” one person wrote in.

Sherman observes that “it’s hard to get attention about a problem that will happen 2 to 3 years from now” given today’s financial pressures.

A number of OR directors who responded commented that their staff isn’t interested in management.

“I am unable to identify leaders who are willing to assume the director role,” one noted.

“It is becoming increasingly difficult to find nurses who have the ability and the desire to manage surgical services,” another observed.

“Most of the senior staff nurses don’t want the additional responsibility,” wrote yet another.

Of the 39% who are making succession plans, examples include grooming clinical coordinators for management and offering clinical ladder opportunities for nurses.

 

Changes needed to perioperative nurse leader role
Themes and change recommendations Frequency of mention
Reduce the span of control 40
■ Improve administrative support
■ Decrease scope of responsibilities
■ Hire assistant directors
■ Hire a business manager
■ Place perioperative director role as a VP position
■ Have perioperative director report to the COO
■ Hire a CMO for the perioperative area
■ Decrease meetings with no relevance to the OR
■ Add an educator to the perioperative area
■ Add a performance improvement role to help track data
Role compensation/work-life balance 29
■ Better compensation
■ Pay increases when additional responsibilities are added
■ Encourage work-life balance
■ Reduce expectations about 24/7 availability
■ Allow leaders to work 10-hour shifts 4 days a week
■ Reduce the justification needed for every request
Support from the executive team 29
■ Demonstrate more respect
■ More understanding about perioperative challenges
■ Support with problem surgeons
■ More autonomy in decision making
■ Support cultural changes to improve teamwork in the OR
■ BSN should be required
Leadership development 21
■ Both nurses and physicians need development
■ Should have a specialized surgical services leadership certification
■ Better education incentives/conference travel
■ More effective career planning
■ Mentoring program for new leaders
■ Ongoing business skill set training
■ Need a budget for continuing education
■ Development of a perioperative leadership pathway

 

Rethinking the role

Respondents were outspoken about the need to reshape the OR director’s role. Nearly 2 in 3—64%—say that’s necessary for succession planning.

Many of these roles have become unwieldy, Sherman says.

More than two-thirds of respondents manage not only the ORs but also the postanesthesia care unit, outpatient surgery, preadmission testing, and sterile processing, with a long list of other areas mentioned. Half oversee 80 or more staff.

“My assessment is that baby boomers have structured these roles to fit their workaholic personalities,” she says. “They have taken on more responsibilities, and there has been pressure on them to do that.”

But that’s created roles that are almost impossible to manage and that emerging leaders are reluctant to take on.

“If you are a young leader, looking at having multiple departments, a large number of staff, a $10 million budget, and maybe not a lot of executive support, it’s going to be a tough sell,” Sherman comments.

 

Skills needed by future perioperative nurse leaders
Themes and skill areas Frequency of mention
Understand the business of health care 72
■ Lean thinking
■ Budget and financial management
■ Data management
■ Quality improvement
■ Regulatory knowledge
■ Expertise with reimbursement
■ Technological savvy
■ Supply management
■ Hospital governance
■ Market awareness
■ Project management
■ Construction management
Interpersonal relationship expertise 62
■ Communication skills
■ Listening
■ Appreciation of diversity
■ Customer focused
■ Flexibility
■ Coaching
■ Sense of humor
Human resource management 26
■ Conflict resolution
■ Team management
■ Physician management
■ Negotiation
Strategic thinking 15
■ Visionary
■ Political savvy
■ Change management
■ Critical thinking
■ Decisive
Authentic leadership 12
■ Passion for perioperative nursing
■ Ethics
■ Professionalism
■ Compassion
■ Autonomy
■ Integrity
■ Diplomacy

 

Changes needed

There were plenty of ideas about the changes needed. Two-thirds of survey participants wrote comments, which fell under 4 major themes (sidebar):

• reduce the span of control

• role compensation/work-lifebalance

• support from the executive team

• leadership development.

“Perioperative nurse leaders are CEOs of companies,” said one. “It is one of the most complex and challenging positions in the organization.

“Many organizations do not understand the importance of this role,” the person continued, “and do not provide the tools or structure to be productive, efficient, and strategic in gaining business. I also believe that the span of control is often too large.”

Another suggested simply: “Provide adequate resources to get the job done. Span of control and expectations are too large.”

Hours are long, which some think deters younger nurses.

“The majority of staff want to put in their 8 hours; they don’t want the 24/7 responsibilities,” one wrote.

 

Commitment to leaders

Some think better compensation would help.

“Higher pay!” one remarked. “Sometimes I feel like the perioperative nurse leader needs combat pay.”

Said another: “It lies in the organization’s commitment to leaders, including compensation.”

Other participants mentioned the need for mentoring and support from managers and support personnel as well as from the senior administration and physicians.

“Job is huge—managers to delegate to or even an administrative assistant for leaders,” commented one.

The director’s place in the hospital’s management structure is also critical, some pointed out.

“Reporting structure is key,” one said, while another advocates that reporting by the perioperative director be elevated to the COO level.

Other key needs are intangible: authority, respect, and autonomy.

“More support from the C-suite that they [perioperative leaders] are not disposable if a surgeon makes noise,” one respondent wrote.

Another advocated that directors be “treasured as a valued member of the team and affirmed in their value and contribution to the organization. An equal voice at the table when surgeons, anesthesia, and nursing meet.”

 

 

Skills future leaders need

Respondents are equally vocal on skills they think future perioperative leaders need. Five themes emerged (sidebar, p 11):

• understand the business of health care

• interpersonal relationship expertise

• human resource management

• strategic thinking

• authentic leadership.

It’s a tall order. Respondents named a long list of attributes a leader should have: business skills, extensive hands-on experience, strategic thinking, diplomacy, people management, and change management, among others. One person added “therapist” and another called for a “crystal ball.”

One person cited not only business skills but also the ability to form strong relationships with the staff, senior leaders, and physicians.

 

Time is short

The survey results show that perioperative nursing directors recognize what’s needed to restructure these roles. But, says Sherman, “I don’t think that discussion [about succession] has taken place in the same way it has in the general nursing leadership group.”

She hopes the findings will give perioperative leaders the data they need to start a conversation about succession planning with their chief nursing officers and other senior administrators.

“I think we have a short window of time, and then we are going to see some serious effects,” she says. “It could be a snowball effect and could happen rapidly.” ❖

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat