August 21, 2023

Survey: ASC volumes continue to rise amid staffing challenges

ASC leaders continue to see increased surgical volumes but are finding it difficult to staff their centers, according to the 2023 OR Manager Salary/Career Survey. More than half (56%) of respondents reported increased volume in the past 12 months, the same as last year. Yet the ability to recruit new staff remains a challenge, with more than two-thirds (68%) reporting that recruiting experienced OR nurses is more difficult than 12 months ago. Recruiting surgical technologists (STs) is also challenging, with 69% of respondents finding recruitment more difficult.

One small positive sign is that the percentage of ASC leaders reporting an increase in open RN positions declined from 50% in 2022 to 39% this year, and the percentage for increased RN turnover rate declined from 46% to 35%. However, the high percentages still indicate widespread difficulties.

Other survey highlights include:

  • The percentage of respondents reporting an increase in open positions for STs was 43%, and 39% reported an increase in ST turnover rate. Both percentages are comparable to 2022 figures—42% and 37%, respectively.
  • Even though recruitment was difficult, more than half (51%) hired more direct care staff in the past year, compared to 46% last year.
  • Loss of staff who left the ASC because the COVID-19 pandemic continued to trend downward (37% in 2021, 24% in 2022, and 14% in 2023).
  • Many (19%) ASC leaders have increased their use of agency and travel staff in the past year.

This article focuses on findings related to staffing. (Percentages may not add up to 100% due to rounding.) Results related to ASC leaders’ compensation, scope of responsibility, and job satisfaction will appear in the October issue of OR Manager.

 

Staffing trends

Survey results reflect a continued difficulty with staffing, particularly when compared to prepandemic levels.

Turnover. Although the percentage of respondents reporting that RN turnover rate had increased over the past year declined, the 35% figure is still much higher than the 26% from the prepandemic year of 2019. Only 9% reported a decrease, and the rate was unchanged for 55% of respondents. For STs, the 39% who reported increased turnover was far higher than the 17% seen in 2019, although comparable to 2022’s 37%. More than half (53%) said it had stayed the same, and only 8% reported a decrease.

Open positions. Similar to turnover, although the percentage of respondents reporting that the number of RN open positions that increased in the past year was lower than last year, the 39% is higher than the 2019 prepandemic level of 32%. Nearly half (48%) reported the rate was unchanged, and 13% reported a decrease. For STs, the 43% who experienced an increase is nearly double what it was in 2019 (26%). Almost half (49%) said the rate was unchanged, and 8% reported a decrease.

A third of respondents reported having no current open full-time equivalency (FTE) RN positions (comparable to 32% in 2022); 67% had at least one open position, comparable to 2022’s 68%, but much higher than 2019’s 56%. The breakdown for 2023 was: 23% for one open position, 25% for two, 6% for three, 1% for four, and 13% for five or more open positions.

For STs, 32% of respondents had no current open FTE positions; 68% had at least one, up slightly from 63% in 2022, but higher than 45% in 2019. The breakdown for 2023 was: 33% for one open position, 26% for two, 4% for three, zero for 4, and 6% for five or more open positions.

Recruitment. Recruiting for open positions remains problematic for most respondents, with 68% reporting it was more difficult to recruit experienced OR nurses, up from 63% in 2022; in 2019, the percentage was 58%. Interestingly, only 17% reported increased difficulty with recruiting new or inexperienced OR nurses, down from 34% in 2022, but only slightly higher than the 13% reported in 2019.

ST recruitment is not any easier. More than two-thirds (69%) reported that recruitment is more difficult, up from 58% last year and 55% in 2021. The 2019 prepandemic percentage was 49%.

Recruitment difficulty is reflected in the time it takes to fill positions. The average time was 82 days for RNs (down significantly from 115 days in 2022) and 98 days for STs (down from 109 days in 2022). According to a report from NSI Nursing Solutions, Inc, it takes an average of 98 days to fill an open OR nurse position in the hospital.

Staffing changes. The most common staffing change during the past year was hiring more direct care staff, reported by more than half (51%) of respondents, up from 46% in 2022 and 40% in 2021, although in 2019, 46% reported this change. The next most common changes were losing staff who transferred to another unit (28%) and reduced use of overtime (25%, up from 13% last year). Only 14% lost staff who left the organization because of the pandemic, down from 24% last year, and only 9% had to redeploy staff temporarily to another unit (down from 15%).

The 22 “other” comments related to staffing changes included loss of staff due to retirement, higher paying jobs, or travel positions.

Work characteristics

Most (40%) respondents work in a physician-owned ASC, with another third in a joint-venture ASC. The remaining start their day in a hospital-owned (12%) or corporate or LLC ASC (11%). Respondents were more likely to work in a multispecialty ASC than a single specialty one (60% vs 40%).

ASC leaders who work in multispecialty ASCs were asked to choose the specialties their facility offers. Orthopedics topped the list, with 84% selecting general orthopedics, 42% selecting total joints, and 29% selecting orthopedics (spine). Other specialties receiving more than a 60% response rate were general surgery (66%), pain management (64%), gastroenterology (62%), and gynecology (62%). Podiatry was the most cited specialty not on the list of options.

As in 2021 and 2022, ophthalmology was the most common single specialty (40%). The next two most common were orthopedics (24%) and gastroenterology (18%). No other specialty received more than 6%.

Although most respondents reported an increase in surgical volume over the past 12 months, 16% reported a decrease (vs 10% in 2022), and 27% noted it remained about the same. The average number of surgical procedures (including endoscopies) was 5,541, up from 4,242 last year and comparable to 5,115 in 2019. (The 2023 average omits an outlier figure of 300,000).

 

Pondering productivity

Maximizing productivity has always been vital in the ASC, but increased volumes and staffing challenges have driven its importance to new levels. We asked ASC leaders to share challenges associated with measuring productivity.

A common theme among the 101 comments related to difficulties in obtaining useful data, which some respondents attributed to the nature of the ASC setting. Sample comments in this area include:

  • “Does not take into account challenging patients or more complex procedures or physicians that take more time to do cases.”
  • “Difficult to calculate specific time needed to complete non-direct patient care tasks or non-procedure day processes for schedule daily…”

Obtaining useful data also was reported as a challenge, as indicated in these comments:

  • “Accuracy of data depends on EMR [electronic medical record] charting. Some data points require manual calculation…”
  • “Reports are only as accurate as the info that is input into the computer.”

Other issues raised by respondents included lack of time to analyze the data, difficulty in finding relevant comparison sources, volume variations, and inadequate software.

One ASC leader summed up the issue this way: “There are several challenges associated with measuring productivity in any setting, including healthcare. Some common challenges include difficulty in defining and standardizing work tasks: Measuring productivity requires defining specific tasks to be measured. However, tasks may vary in complexity, duration, and impact on outcomes, making it hard to create standardized measures.”

Read more about ASC productivity measurement in the November/December 2023 issue of OR Manager.

As surgical volume continues to rise, ASC leaders are faced with persistent staffing challenges. Given the financial pressures in healthcare and a workforce that will take time to return to prepandemic levels, leaders will need to call on all their skills to lead their teams in delivering safe patient care.

 

—Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.

 

Reference

NSI national healthcare retention & RN staffing report. NSI Nursing Solutions. 2023.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat