October 17, 2016

Survey: OR staff low in volume, experience, engagement–Part 2

By: OR Manager
Awards  
Share

Part 1 of this series on staffing challenges, published in October OR Manager, explored the challenge of increased demand. In Part 2, we turn to lack of experience, again including examples of how OR leaders are responding.

 

Recruiting for experience

Mary Diamond, MBA, RN, CNOR, PMP

Mary Diamond, MBA, RN, CNOR, PMP

In all, 70% of respondents to the 2016 OR Manager Salary/Career Survey noted that recruiting experienced RNs is more difficult compared to 2015. To attract experienced candidates, “you have got to get creative about recruiting and be more nimble when responding to applicants,” says Mary Diamond, MBA, RN, CNOR, PMP, senior director of nursing at TriCity Medical Center in Oceanside, California.

That includes work hours. “I’m finding most applicants do not want to work the traditional 8 hours, 5 days per week, but prefer longer hours on fewer days,” she says. “I have been flexible with 10- or 12-hour shifts, working to balance what the applicant wants with meeting the needs of the organization.”

Martha Stratton, MSN, MHSA, RN, CNOR, NEA-BC, president of AORN and vice president for perioperative services at Doctors Hospital in Augusta, Georgia, cites her past experience of paying a nurse to take call full time for the postanesthesia care unit (PACU). The nurse was paid a flat fee and then received additional pay once she passed an established threshold of work hours.

Diamond notes the return of sign-on bonuses; her hospital is offering $10,000 for OR nurses. Diamond also reports that some hospitals exempt nurses over a certain age from call.

Tom Fee

Tom Fee

“Many hospitals are now realizing they aren’t going to get experienced staff, so they are using [AORN’s] Periop 101 to teach nurses to be OR nurses,” says Tom Fee, managing partner of Verity Partners, LLC, in Alpharetta, Georgia. “We are seeing a Periop 101 or something similar in almost every hospital,” adds Alecia Torrance, MBS, BS, RN, CNOR, senior vice president of clinical operations and chief nurse executive at Surgical Directions in Chicago.

This type of intensive training takes time and money. “Hospitals have to pay them [new staff], but during the course [about 1 year], they’re not getting full-time work from them,” Fee says. However, the structured program helps ensure nurses are well prepared for the role.

Whether or not OR managers use a formal program, Diamond says, leaders have to accept the fact that orientation may take longer.

Torrance says hospitals are questioning just how long those orientation times should be. Some OR leaders find that, even after a year, certain employees are still not up to speed. The reason is often unclear. “Is it the program, the person, or our expectations?” Torrance asks. Certainly individuals vary in learning speed, but at what point should an OR manager say they have had long enough to learn? “There are no easy answers,” she says.

 

Grow your own

Martha Stratton, MSN, MHSA, RN, CNOR, NEA-BC

Martha
Stratton,
MSN, MHSA, RN, CNOR, NEA-BC

Some hospitals are “growing their own” OR staff. At Verde Valley Medical Center, part of Northern Arizona Healthcare in Cottonwood, Lori Smithson, MSN, RN, CNOR, LSSBB, director of surgical services, cites the example of a housekeeper who moved into the sterile processing department (SPD) and then became a surgical technologist (ST). “Most of our SPD staff started out as housekeepers,” she says, adding that several STs have gone on to become RNs.

Verde Valley Medical Center has six ORs and two endoscopy suites that see nearly 3,000 patients each year.

Grooming a nurse for the OR doesn’t always work. “Unfortunately, a lot of people don’t understand what it means to be an OR nurse,” says Sarah Germanovich, MSN, RN, CNOR, the OR clinical educator at Thomas Jefferson University Hospital in Philadelphia. “We don’t see that many people coming with a long-term commitment.”

She thinks part of the reason they don’t understand the role is the lack of background. “In school you get maybe a day of observation in the OR,” says Germanovich, who has 11 years of OR experience. “You can’t get the full scope of the role when you do that.”

Action item: Germanovich has partnered with Thomas Jefferson School of Nursing to launch an immersion practicum for senior students in January 2017. Four students will spend 7 weeks in the perioperative environment. Students will spend time in the same-day admission unit, holding area, OR, and PACU. Germanovich, who is an adjunct faculty for the school, built the syllabus for the practicum. The students will have a clinical instructor and a preceptor. “It will give them a really good idea of what it means to be an OR nurse,” Germanovich says. “We hope to recruit and retain knowledgeable graduates to bridge the gaps in our staffing.”

Smithson finds it hard to attract staff to the rural community. Students at the local community college rotate through the OR, preoperative, and endoscopy areas, but that’s not the norm in the US. “It’s very difficult to get a full perioperative nursing program into the schools of nursing,” Stratton says. “Most offer a very abbreviated form of OR experience.” That might consist of simply having the student follow a medical-surgical patient to the OR to observe surgery.

Action item: AORN has developed Fundamentals of Perioperative Practice, a shortened version of Periop 101, for schools of nursing, Stratton says. “It provides basic concepts of perioperative nursing and basic information about aseptic technique and how to work as part of a team. It’s designed to coincide with a clinical student rotation in the OR.”The fundamentals course has 10 modules (vs 27 for Periop 101) that include course outlines, goals, objectives, and a final exam. Stratton says one challenge in getting students OR experience is, faculty aren’t generally familiar with the OR, so they tend to steer students away from the specialty. An AORN task force is investigating ways to partner with schools of nursing to increase use of the fundamentals course and support faculty who will be teaching it. Recommendations are expected by the end of 2016.

Diamond says hospitals may want to consider a program like the one developed in San Diego in the early 2000s, when hospitals in the area partnered to create a community OR training program for nurses. An advantage was that the hospitals knew the person’s baseline education. Although there is always a risk that the person will leave, she says, “You can at least take pride in that you were responsible for launching the career of a great nurse.”

It’s not just new staff who need education. “I hear at conferences that new nurses are completing Periop 101, but when they get into the OR, the tenured nurses aren’t practicing that way,” Stratton says. “We have to look at ways to keep staff current because evidence-based practice changes.”

Alecia Torrance, MBS, BS, RN, CNOR

Alecia Torrance, MBS, BS, RN, CNOR

One option is AORN’s Periop Mastery Program; modules in the program cover critical areas and issues related to the perioperative environment. Staff can take one or all of the modules. Stratton says that at Doctors Hospital, they are considering having tenured staff complete Periop 101.

 

The experience gap

Once OR leaders find experienced staff, they have to keep them engaged. In an upcoming issue, OR Manager will explore ways to do that and how such employees are making a difference in the perioperative services environment. ✥

Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat