The US has been on a journey for the last several years to reduce the cost of healthcare. In 2017, the percent of gross domestic product attributed to healthcare goods and services was at 17.9%. This is expected to reach as much as 19.4% by the year 2027.1 Factors contributing to this include an increase in healthcare goods and services prices of 2.5% versus the 1.1% during 2014 to 2017.2 The average annual spend growth for healthcare is estimated at 5.5% for the years 2017 to 2027, and for Medicare specifically, an average annual spend growth of 7.4% is anticipated during the same period 1, 2 (Figure 1 below).
Surgery and OR utilization continue to grow to meet the increased demand for elective surgical services even as the aging population is leading to an increase in two of the major common emergency surgical procedures—fractured neck of femur and emergency laparotomy. Hospital expenditures are projected to grow by 5.7% per year, mostly because the shortage of physicians is expected to drive an increase in their compensation.1
In 2015, the Department of Health and Human Services announced goals to increase the percentage of value-based payments under the Affordable Care Act over a 3-year period so that, by 2018, 90% of Medicare payments would be tied to quality and value. Additionally, alternative payment models were to account for 30% of Medicare reimbursements by 2016 and 50% by 2018.3 Although progress is being made, the programs continue to fall short of these goals.
The Healthcare Payment Learning in Action Network reports the actual percentage of Medicare payments linked to quality for calendar years 2015 through 2017: 38%, 57%, and 59%, respectively. Other markets continue to lag behind, with commercial payers at 43.5% of payments linked to quality in 2017 and Medicaid at only 32.2%. For alternative payment models, the Medicare percent increased from 23% in 2015 to 34% in 2017.4
These quality links to payments are driven through programs such as the Hospital Inpatient Quality Reporting Program (IQR). Data collected as a part of IQR are available to the public on the Hospital Compare website and affect annual payment rates to hospitals as well as hospital star ratings. Some of these data overlap with other programs such as hospital value-based purchasing (VBP), the hospital-acquired condition (HAC) reduction program, and the hospital readmission reduction program (HRRP).5 The quality of care for surgical patients is represented in each of these programs.
In our introductory article, “Enhanced Recovery After Surgery: The new standard for perioperative care,” we shared the importance of ERAS principles to the delivery of high-quality care (OR Manager, October 2019; 1, 14-17). Implementing a hospital-wide ERAS program helps achieve key goals for payers, providers, and—most importantly—patients.
Government and private payers alike are moving from volume to value in order to control costs and place increased emphasis on better outcomes. Making ERAS principles the standard of care is one way to move providers in that direction. These value-based payment models mean hospitals and surgery centers must find a way to deliver care via reliable processes that afford better predictability of desirable outcomes, thus resulting in better cost control.
With ERAS, these savings are realized through less need for intensive care, reduced utilization of pharmaceuticals and parenteral nutrition, reduced complication rates, and shorter hospital length of stay (LOS) with fewer (or unchanged) readmission rates. 6, 7
A well-implemented ERAS program benefits everyone. Patients can expect to be actively engaged in the care process and enjoy better short- and long-term outcomes. Improved engagement and outcomes lead to improved satisfaction. Surgeons benefit from increased OR capacity and timely availability, predictable case booking, and avoidance of cancellations and delays caused by unprepared patients.
An ERAS program engages the entire care team across the continuum of care. Decreased nursing and attending work per patient leads to improved efficiency and, subsequently, a more positive work environment. Provider organizations benefit at the highest levels by improving throughput, increasing capacity, reducing costs to create financial stability for value-based payment models, and improving publicly reported measures, which make them more market competitive.
With all of these benefits, it is no wonder the American College of Surgeons launched an AHRQ (Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality) safety program for ERAS in 2017 to support hospitals in implementing the evidence-based protocols of ERAS.8
The first and foundational step the OR management must take is to articulate the “why” to the frontline staff. Kotter’s seminal manuscript (Leading Change, Why Transformation Efforts Fail) identifies his “eight steps.”9 In Kotter’s first step, leadership must establish a sense of urgency by articulating “Why [ERAS]?” and “Why ERAS Now?” In steps two through four, a powerful guiding coalition consisting of multi-professional, line-level leaders will set the vision for what the OR will look like and how patients will benefit, and will communicate this vision through multiple avenues such as grand rounds presentations, in-services, early success stories, posters, and data.
Daniel Pink, author of Drive, notes that the key drivers for intrinsic motivation are a sense of purpose, sense of mastery, and desire for autonomy. The insightful leader will immediately perceive that ERAS very easily connects to these drivers. The target audience—frontline staff—consists of individuals who have devoted a large portion of their lives to the care of other human beings. Hence, the purpose is to improve the care for patients in a measurably better way (patient-centered, clinically relevant outcomes), and to get better at taking care of patients. The desire for autonomy can be tied into Kotter’s “Step 5: Empowers Others to Act on the Vision.”
The leadership team bears responsibility for enabling the care team to develop standards of care; providing training, education, and access to measures that can be evaluated for alignment with clinically relevant outcomes; and identifying new opportunities for improving care. Consistent success depends on having a clinical governance model that includes surgeons, anesthesia providers, nursing, and operational leadership. Additionally, the clinical informatics, electronic medical record (EMR), and data analytics must align to ensure measures are relatively intuitive to frontline staff.
By recognizing that ERAS is a value stream for the patient, from the time the patient decides to have surgery through the return to baseline function and full recovery, the team can work together to provide the best possible care (Figure 2 above).
The OR team—surgeons, anesthesia providers, nursing, techs, and others—must work together to achieve sustained change of practice for the intraoperative period, stressing the importance of communication and focusing on treating the whole patient. Good process is the foundation on which to build a successful ERAS program in which the team knows what to do and when to do it, has access to the resources needed, and knows what to expect of others (Figure 3 at right).
The role of the surgeon can be divided into three periods:
• Decision for surgery until day of surgery: Define the acuity of surgery (ie, how quickly the surgery must take place). Participate and be aware of the need to optimize the patient’s comorbid conditions preoperatively.
• Surgery: Minimize the surgical stress response, and control the surgical factors affecting the perioperative course. Examples include appropriate choice of antibiotics and preoperative medications, minimally invasive approaches where applicable, and use of separate closure trays in appropriate cases.
• Postoperatively: Encourage mobilization, normalization of bodily functions, and removal of drains.
The role of the anesthesiologist can be divided into two periods:
• Prior to surgery: Many preoperative clinics for assessment and optimization are directed and staffed by anesthesiologists. This allows them to coordinate the medical optimization needed for the planned procedures.
• Day of surgery: Perform the nerve blocks used to decrease opioid consumption, and ensure administration of key perioperative medications (antibiotics, deep vein thrombosis prophylaxis, preoperative non-opioid analgesics) in addition to the anesthetic plan. For cases with moderate or significant fluid shifts, use a flow-based fluid approach to decrease with over- or under-intraoperative resuscitation.
The role of nursing can be divided into six periods:
• Decision for surgery until day of surgery: Provide guidance for the patient and family to maximize the patient’s ability to be well prepared and medically optimized for surgery. Educate patients about pain management and early recovery expectations.
• In the preoperative unit: Verify appropriate carbohydrate loading and hydration, avoiding unnecessary fluid infusion. Administer appropriate premedications to minimize opioid use for pain management. Actively warm patients to maintain normothermia in the OR. Reinforce education and expectations.
• In the OR: The surgery team manager ensures the equipment and supplies are appropriate for the procedure being done and applicable infection prevention protocols are followed.
• In the recovery unit: Closely monitor patients and actively advance the patient through de-escalation of care as soon as medically ready. Continue goal-directed fluid therapy. Reinforce patient education around pain management, including the use of scheduled medication to control pain, and minimize opioid need with the goal of enabling early mobilization. Start the digestive process early by offering clear liquids and advancing to low/no carb protein drinks as soon as tolerated to maintain glucose control.
• During acute care period: Continue to aid the patient through de-escalation of care with a focus on early return to baseline function.
• After discharge: Be a resource to the patient for continued recovery needs.
The informatics core team member provides the ability to measure outcomes in a valid and timely manner via configurations in the EMR system, alert systems, and management reports.
Pharmacists, anesthesia techs, and others involved in the OR supply chain must make sure the right drugs and right equipment are available at the right time to the correct OR team. This means understanding which operations are done in which ORs, and making sure drugs and equipment are stocked appropriately.
At its root, ERAS is a patient-centered and outcomes-based process. Successful surgery means avoiding negative outcomes while getting maximum benefit from the procedure.
When the members of the care team are all aligned, LOS, cost, and variation decrease. In order to do this, silos among different roles (surgeon, anesthesiologist, nursing, pharmacy, informatics) must be overcome. Goals must be centered on patient outcomes, not on a particular group’s financial performance or staffing needs. Focusing on the things that add value to the patient will improve outcomes and increase satisfaction. ✥
Paula Spencer, MSHA, PMP, CPHIMS, is director, office of clinical effectiveness at Virginia Commonwealth University Health System in Richmond. She is also adjunct professor, department of health administration, at Virginia Commonwealth University.
Pranav R. Shah, MD, is assistant professor, department of anesthesiology, at Virginia Commonwealth University Health System in Richmond.
Michael J. Scott, MB, ChB, FRCP, FRCA, FFICM, is professor and vice chair of research, department of anesthesiology and medical director, office of clinical effectiveness, at Virginia Commonwealth University Health System in Richmond. He is also adjunct professor, department of anesthesia and critical care medicine, at the Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, in Philadelphia.
2. Meyer H. Healthcare spending will hit 19.4% of GDP in the next decade, CMS projects. Modern Healthcare. February 20, 2019. https://www.modernhealthcare.com/article/20190220/NEWS/190229989/healthcare-spending-will-hit-19-4-of-gdp-in-the-next-decade-cms-projects.
3. Burwell S. Setting value-based payment goals—HHS efforts to improve US health care. N Engl J Med. 201;372(10): 897-899.
4. https://hcp-lan.org/2018-apm-measurement/#1466615406342-d34e0eeb-f073.
6. Gaëtan-Romain J, Ljungqvist O, Wasylak T, et al. Beyond surgery: Clinical and economic impact of enhanced recovery after surgery programs. BMC Health Services Research. Published online December 29, 2018. https://bmchealthservres.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12913-018-3824-0.
7. Sanchez J, Barach P, Johnson J K, Jacobs J P, eds. Surgical Patient Care: Improving Safety, Quality and Value. 1st ed. New York: Springer International Publishing. 2017.
8. http://bulletin.facs.org/2017/03/acs-launches-ahrq-safety-program-eras/.
9. Kotter J. Leading change: Why transformation efforts fail. IEEE Engineering Management Review. 2009;37(3):42-48.
Aggarwal P, Young-Fadok T M. Cost benefit of implementing enhanced recovery after surgery (ERAS) program in colorectal surgery: A single institution study. J Am Coll Surg. 2016;223(4):Suppl 2, e6-e7.
Chung R D, Hunter-Smith D J, Spychal R T, et al. A systematic review of intraoperative process mapping in surgery. Gland Surg. 2017;6(6):715–725.
Ljungqvist O, Scott M, Fearon K C. Enhanced recovery after surgery: A review. JAMA. 2017;152(3):292-298.
McIlvennan C K, Eapen Z J, Allen L A. Hospital readmissions reduction program. Circulation. 2015;131(20):1796–1803.
National Quality Forum. All-Cause Admissions and Readmissions 2017: Technical Report. September 21, 2017. https://www.qualityforum.org/Publications/2017/09/All-Cause_Admissions_and_Readmissions_2017_Technical_Report.aspx.
Papanicolas I, Woskie L, Jha A. Health care spending in the United States and other high-income countries. JAMA. 2018;319(10):1024-1039.