Healthcare is striving to become an industry of high-reliability organizations, and part of being a high-reliability industry means staying vigilant and identifying problems proactively. ECRI Institute’s annual Top 10 list helps organizations identify looming patient safety challenges and offers suggestions and resources for addressing them.
ECRI Institute relied on event data from its patient safety organization (PSO), concerns raised by healthcare provider organizations, and expert judgment to select the topics for the 2019 list. Since 2009, when ECRI Institute’s PSO began collecting patient safety events, the PSO and its partner PSOs have received more than 2.8 million event reports and reviewed hundreds of root-cause analyses. That means that the 10 patient safety concerns on this list are very real. They are harming people, sometimes seriously.
When diagnoses and test results are not properly communicated or followed up, patient harm can result. Providers rely on the electronic health record (EHR) to help with clinical decision support, track test results, and flag issues. However, “technology is just a tool—there’s currently not an algorithm that is going to identify all the key elements and analyze them to give you the correct diagnosis,” says Lorraine B. Possanza, DPM, JD, MBE, program director, Partnership for Health IT Patient Safety.
The EHR must clearly communicate the diagnosis, treatment plan, and follow-up plan. “The information must be accurate and must be written so that future clinicians looking at the EHR can understand it,” says Patricia Stahura, MSN, RN, senior analyst and consultant, ECRI Institute. “If you have faulty information or missing test results, you are predisposed to making a diagnostic error.”
“We need to combat antibiotic resistance before the situation gets worse,” says Stephanie Uses, PharmD, MJ, JD, patient safety analyst/consultant, ECRI Institute PSO, noting that not many newly approved drugs are antibiotics. As antibiotic resistance increases, “your treatment options can be limited,” she explains.
Acute care organizations can help physician practices and aging services settings by lending their expertise and communicating about infection and antimicrobial susceptibility patterns. Health systems that include physician practices and aging services settings may extend their antimicrobial stewardship programs to these settings, which can further aid coordination.
“Antibiotic stewardship does not mean withholding necessary treatment,” emphasizes Sharon Bradley, RN, CIC, senior infection prevention and patient safety analyst/consultant, ECRI Institute. “But we have casually and cavalierly handed around the candy dish of antibiotics without a second thought as to how we may be harming our patients.”
Burnout is indiscriminate, affecting physicians, nurses, allied healthcare providers, and organizational leaders alike. Healthcare providers “increase demand on themselves and have high expectations for their own performance, which is laudable,” says Ellen S. Deutsch, MD, MS, FACS, FAAP, CPPS, medical director, ECRI Institute. “But it can also be problematic.”
Reprioritizing what a clinician needs to do is one way to reduce burnout, but ultimately the system must change. If burnout is to be addressed effectively, organizations must listen to providers’ concerns about workload, performance criteria, and suboptimal resource allocation, and fix these problems at a system level. Moving to a culture that recognizes a job well done is necessary. Leadership must strive to make providers feel they are treated as human beings, whose opinions and abilities are valued, rather than as cogs in a wheel.
Mobile health technology opens up a world of opportunities by transporting healthcare into the home. It also opens up a world of risks. These include lack of regulation, barriers to ensuring accurate data collection, and incorrect use—or nonuse—by patients.
Healthcare organizations must ensure the safety and validity of any device they recommend and be certain the device will work when the patient leaves the facility. Organizations must also clearly define objectives before recommending any care plan featuring mobile health, assess ease of use, identify the right candidates for mobile health, and train providers and patients on how to use the device. “It’s no use to have a technology that the patient is supposed to use at home if the patient is not going to use it,” says Juuso Leinonen, senior project engineer, Health Devices Group, ECRI Institute.
When working with individuals who have behavioral health needs, “you fear what you don’t know, and fear can make you react defensively,” says Nancy Napolitano, BS, patient safety analyst, ECRI Institute. This fear can cause situations to escalate, with consequences for patients and staff.
Healthcare organizations can develop internal support systems (eg, behavioral emergency response teams). They can also work with external resources to improve care coordination and identify ways to develop behavioral health skills and support in non-behavioral-health settings.
All providers and staff need to be equipped with communication and de-escalation skills. Options include certified training, training led by internal experts, and community behavioral health first-aid workshops.
Opportunities to practice (eg, mock codes) are key to reducing fear and keeping skills sharp. “The only way not to be afraid of something is to experience it positively over and over again,” says Napolitano.
Failure to detect changes in a patient’s condition is a concern across the continuum of care. “Transitions of care and handoffs are critical times for care delivery, and they’re fraught with danger,” says Mary Rodger, BSN, RN, CPASRM, senior risk management analyst and consultant, ECRI Institute. “Passing along and receiving the correct information sets providers up for success.”
Many healthcare organizations encourage providers to develop multidisciplinary team-building skills to break down silos that can impede communication. Teams may use structured opportunities, such as bedside rounding, to promote information sharing. In addition, staff must be trained in how to set and respond to alarms.
Staff must also listen to patients’ concerns and be the patients’ advocates. “We should be their eyes and ears,” says Kelly C. Graham, BS, RN, patient safety analyst, ECRI Institute. “They should be able to trust us.”
ECRI Institute has received reports of adverse events occurring because a healthcare professional was unfamiliar with equipment, such as robotic-assisted surgical systems, or lacked competence with procedures and processes. “There are a range of skills that providers need, and there are a range of providers who need the skills,” says Dr Deutsch. Simulations can be designed for individuals to practice and learn technical skills or for healthcare teams to conduct drills of situations that may occur infrequently but require knowledge of other team members’ roles.
Simulation training need not be costly or complex. “There’s a lot you can do with what’s at hand,” says Dr Deutsch. Studies have proven that patient outcomes can be improved using simulation-based education. “Simulation has been repeatedly proven in meta-analyses to be effective,” she says.
Sepsis can be difficult to detect, but early recognition is vital because sepsis can quickly turn deadly. “We’re in a time rush,” says James Davis, MSN, RN, CCRN-K, HEM, CIC, FAPIC, senior infection prevention and patient safety analyst/consultant, ECRI Institute. “The challenge is: Can we intervene quicker to get patients the care they need to prevent shock and death?” Davis adds.
One key is sharing information across the continuum. For example, knowing that an individual normally has only mild confusion can help providers suspect sepsis when that person seems very confused. Settings across the continuum can also identify opportunities for collaboration. Hospitals and nursing facilities may collaborate by, for example, ensuring safe discharge, communicating necessary information, sharing strategies, and establishing a consultation system. “Foster that cooperative behavior,” advises Davis. “Are there things we can do to help each other out?”
Peripheral intravenous (PIV) catheters are commonly used in healthcare. Often, PIVs are inserted upon admission as a matter of course. However, PIVs can expose patients to a significant risk of infection—one that is underreported, underrecognized, and often ignored, Davis says.
Tracing infections back to the PIV line can be difficult. “If a patient gets both a peripheral line and a central line and later develops a bloodstream infection, clinicians will often attribute it to the central line without even considering the PIV line,” Davis notes. Increased awareness of PIV-catheter-related infections, coupled with routine active surveillance and follow-up reporting, can help reduce the risk. “Staff need to understand that it can happen, and that it can be serious,” says Davis.
“Healthcare organizations as we used to know them are now becoming nationwide ‘mega-systems,’” says Sheila Rossi, MHA, manager, ECRI Institute PSO. As this evolution occurs, “how do you keep patient safety at the forefront?” she asks. “How do organizations internally structure themselves to address patient safety needs?”
Regardless of organization size, the goal is to institute structures that effectively allow patient safety leaders to support organization leadership in engaging with patient safety priorities. Foundational principles of continuous communication up and down the chain of command, clear organizational structure, consistent committee configuration, and universal strategic planning and implementation can help the organization reduce inconsistencies and focus on patient safety. And as health systems grow and expand across the continuum, it is beneficial to leverage the protections that a PSO affords to all affiliated providers within the health system.
In selecting this year’s list, ECRI Institute synthesized data from these varied sources:
• routine review of events in the PSO database
• PSO members’ root-cause analyses and research requests
• topics reflected in weekly HRC Alerts
• voting by a panel of experts from inside and outside ECRI Institute
But development of the list is not an exercise in simple tabulation. The list does not necessarily represent the issues that occur most frequently or are most severe. Most organizations already know what their high-frequency, high-severity challenges are. Rather, this list identifies concerns that might be high priorities for other reasons, such as new risks, existing concerns that are changing because of new technology or care delivery models, and persistent issues that need focused attention or pose new opportunities for intervention.
Healthcare organizations can investigate whether they are having problems with these or related concerns, and whether they have processes and systems to address them. The full report, which Healthcare Risk Control (HRC) and ECRI Institute PSO members can access by logging in at www.ecri.org, discusses key strategies for each issue.
This is an excerpt of the free executive brief of the Top 10 Patient Safety Concerns: 2019, posted on ECRI Institute’s website in March 2019. Download and view resources at https://www.ecri.org/patientsafetytop10. To learn more, contact ECRI Institute by telephone at (610) 825-6000, ext. 5891, or by e-mail at clientservices@ecri.org. ✥
1. Diagnostic Stewardship and Test Result Management Using EHRs
2. Antimicrobial Stewardship in Physician Practices and Aging Services
3. Burnout and Its Impact on Patient Safety
4. Patient Safety Concerns Involving Mobile Health
5. Reducing Discomfort with Behavioral Health
6. Detecting Changes in a Patient’s Condition
7. Developing and Maintaining Skills
8. Early Recognition of Sepsis across the Continuum
9. Infections from Peripherally Inserted IV Lines
10. Standardizing Safety Efforts across Large Health Systems