October 19, 2017

Track ASC metrics to produce a healthy bottom line

By: Cynthia Saver, MS, RN
Share

Each day seems to bring new tasks for leaders of ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs), adding to their already overflowing plate. One task that can easily fall off that plate is collecting and analyzing metrics, yet failing to do so can have serious financial consequences. OR Manager recently asked ASC leaders to share strategies for managing financial and clinical metrics.

 

Tracking financial metrics

“ASC administrators need to know they are maximizing their profitability because that’s what the board is expecting,” says Ann Geier, MS, RN, CNOR, CASC, chief nursing officer for Surgical Information Systems in Alpharetta, Georgia. Profit margin goals for most ASCs are in the 30% range or less, according to Geier.

Although ASC leaders are on firm ground when it comes to clinical metrics, Geier says they may struggle with financial ones. She recommends tracking a core group of high-impact financial metrics (sidebar, p 26).

“The most expensive items in an ASC are supplies and payroll,” says Deborah Comerford, BSN, RN, CNOR, CASC, LHRM, senior vice president of operations for Ambulatory Surgical Centers of America, based in Hanover, Massachusetts.

“You want to make sure those costs don’t creep up, which can easily happen,” she cautions.

Supplies

“Too many administrators haven’t entered their inventory into the computer,” Geier says. “That leads to bad contract negotiations because you don’t know how much supplies cost.”

A good benchmark is that about 21% of the collections coming into the facility covers supplies. “Knowing that number will let you know if you aren’t paying the best price,” Geier says.

Deborah Comerford, BSN, RN, CNOR, CASC, LHRM

ASC leaders might want to trim their item master because centers tend to use only 12% of what’s on the list. Managing supplies can also improve the operating cash flow of the ASC.

A group purchasing organization (GPO) can help control costs, Comerford notes, but ASC leaders should still check frequently to ensure that the center is getting the best price.

“The GPO should be able to tell you what you should be paying, so you can compare against what you are paying,” she says. Leaders responsible for multiple ASCs should compare costs among centers.

Comerford recommends using case costing to compare surgeons doing the same procedure. If one surgeon’s supply costs are unusually high, drill down to find out why, and bring it to the surgeon’s attention.

“[The surgeon] may have not thought about the cost for that particular item, and might be willing to evaluate a similar, lower-cost item,” she says, adding that even surgeons who aren’t ASC owners understand the need to control costs. “We don’t dictate that they have to change, but they might consider it if there is a comparable product at a lower price,” Comerford notes.

Case costing also helps assess overall financial health. “You want to know total costs for each case and what you will be reimbursed,” says Ann Shimek, MSN, RN, CASC, senior vice president of clinical operations for United Surgical Partners International in Addison, Texas. “If a self-pay case takes up to 6 hours, but you could have done five knee arthroscopies during that time, it would be better to do the knee cases.”

 

Payroll

Geier recommends tracking staff hours as percent of collections and staff hours per case. “If you are a fast throughput center [eg, GI, ophthalmology, pain management], your total staff hours per case should not be higher than 7 or 8, and that includes everybody [such as business office staff],” she says.

For longer cases, such as spine and orthopedics, the target number should be about 10 to 12 hours. Of course, case mix factors into hours per case.

Staff hours should be tracked on a daily basis. “It’s easy for nurses to head into overtime, and that can hit your finances,” Shimek says.

The type of employee also plays a role. “Don’t use a lot of full-time employees,” Geier says. “Part time gives you more flexibility.”

Other financial metrics to track include those related to payment, volume, and patient satisfaction.

 

Payment best practices

Ann Geier, MS, RN, CNOR, CASC

“Send billing paperwork out the same day or the day after the procedure,” Comerford recommends. Ideally, it should take fewer than 30 days to receive payment, although many factors affect that figure, including case mix, number of patients out of network, and number of specialties.

For instance, ophthalmology ASCs may receive payment quickly because most patients are on Medicare, but cases with multiple billing codes may take longer.

If accounts receivable (AR) days are high, Geier suggests hiring another collector. “The cleanup can pay for itself 10 times over,” she says.

Geier says ASC leaders should also track AR percentage current, which refers to what has just been billed; best practice is that 72% of the amount billed should be less than 30 days.

“If you don’t get paid quickly, it’s very difficult to collect, particularly after 90 days,” she says. “You should be aggressively working on anything over 60 days because if you don’t get [payment] then, you probably aren’t going to get it.”

To avoid payment delays, ensure that patients are precertified by their insurance provider, and collect any costs not covered by insurance before the procedure. Recovering costs becomes more difficult as time passes, Geier says.

She recommends tracking how each patient plans to pay uncovered costs. If it’s by credit card, business staff should obtain payment information during the preoperative call with the patient. At the other end of the spectrum, refunds owed patients should be processed promptly to avoid dissatisfaction.

ASC leaders can use a simple Excel spreadsheet to track denials and help them identify trends, such as whether an insurer is denying a particular CPT code.

The denial rate should be not more than 1% to 2%. Geier recommends appealing denials immediately and tracking the results.

She also advises watching for trends in payment such as unexpected drop in collections, increase in denials, and not obtaining patient payments at the time of service.

 

Volume

“The more cases you do, the more you can spread out overhead costs,” Geier says. If the ASC isn’t meeting the industry standard of 19.4 cases per day (which will vary somewhat by case mix), explore how ORs are being utilized.

If there are only enough cases for two ORs and the ASC has four open, for example, it may be necessary to consolidate cases into a smaller number of rooms.

Leaders should also track volume by surgeon. According to VMG Health’s Multi-Specialty ASC Intellimarker 2017, the top two physicians in the ASC perform nearly one-third (31%) of cases, the top five account for 54% of volume, and the top 10 account for 73%.

Turnover time can affect volume and physician satisfaction. Geier notes that tracking turnover time when “flipping” rooms is difficult, and adds that flipping typically isn’t helpful financially because the practice doesn’t allow the ASC to generate additional revenue.

Another volume-related metric to measure is on-time starts for the first case of the day.

Unhappy patients lead to lower reimbursements. Unfortunately, return rates for patient satisfaction surveys are typically only 15% to 20% for ASCs. To improve return rates, Shimek asks staff to tell patients on the preoperative call to expect a survey after the procedure and explain why it’s important for surveys to be returned.

 

Tracking clinical metrics

Many clinical metrics are required by state and national regulatory agencies. For example, each year the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) lists measures that will factor into payments. The measures, which are updated each year, can be found at https://www.cms.gov/Medicare/Quality-Initiatives-Patient-Assessment-Instruments/ASC-Quality-Reporting/.

Many have been consistent for several years, including patient burn; patient fall; wrong site, wrong side, wrong patient, wrong procedure, wrong implant; hospital transfer/admission; prophylactic intravenous antibiotic timing; and safe surgery checklist use.

The number of measures has risen from five in 2014 to 12 for 2018, but some relief may be in sight. “CMS is considering taking away measures such as the timing of antibiotic administration because everyone got the message, and now it’s not a problem,” Comerford says, cautioning that metrics will likely continue to be added.

Other clinical metrics include those based on standards from the AAMI ST 79 Comprehensive Guide to Steam Sterilization and Sterility Assurance in Health Care Facilities. For example, the guide states immediate use steam sterilization should only be used in “urgent clinical situations,” so this should be monitored.

ASC leaders should also track metrics related to clinical standards from organizations such as AORN and the American Society of PeriAnesthesia Nurses.

Shimek recommends administrators have a binder or folder for unexpected events and track them on a spreadsheet. “You want to identify people involved, not from a finger-pointing perspective, but from the perspective of what actions might be needed to improve practice,” she says. For instance, a nurse involved in multiple medication errors might need education on prevention.

Shimek also suggests tracking good catches—problems that were caught before patients or staff were injured. “If you don’t address these problems, harm will ultimately occur,” she says.

 

Collecting and analyzing data

An electronic health record helps with collecting data. “We log ‘wheels in’ and ‘wheels out’ in our computer system,” says Mary Jo Turner, MSN, RN, CEN, an OR charge nurse at Lowry Surgery Center in Denver.

Of course, no system, electronic or manual, is infallible. That’s where double-checking can help. Staff at Lowry, for instance, enter billing numbers from a reference sheet. Sometimes the numbers are transposed, so at the end of the day, the billing office staff verify the entries. Turner also reviews billing records daily for accuracy.

“It’s not enough to collect the data; you have to do something with it,” Shimek says. Analyze results against internal, regional (if possible), and national benchmarks, checking closely for trends (sidebar, p 28).

“If you find a deficiency as a result of a quality improvement project, that’s another way to set a benchmark,” Comerford says.

Survey results can be a source of internal benchmarks. For instance, if a state survey found that 45% of history and physicals weren’t complete, the ASC could work on improving the percentage and collect data to track results.

“You should also look at medical records to see if regulatory requirements are being met,” Comerford says. She recommends using a checklist to review a sample of charts every month to verify practices such as obtaining a complete history and physical before surgery.

Financial metric results should be compared with the business plan for the center. “Administrators may not have seen the business plan, but they need to see it,” Geier says.

The plan can help the leader identify problem areas. For instance, orthopedic centers are highly profitable, so if a center is losing money or earning only a small profit compared to what was anticipated in the plan, the leader should compare the number of cases per day to what was forecasted.

Geier doesn’t routinely recommend an annual budget for the ASC because the most important measure is whether the center is completing the number of cases planned for in the business plan. Once a center reaches the final year projected in the plan, the leader should continue to grow the case volume.

Shimek says that multiple people should be involved in the analysis, depending on the metric. For instance, the safety officer would want to examine data related to equipment failures.

“You have to stay on top of the data,” Turner says. She and her colleagues check many metrics daily, using some of the data to manage staffing. Staff hours are categorized by department: preoperative, postanesthesia care unit (PACU), administration, OR, overnight PACU, pain management, and the business office. Hours for the sterile processing department are listed with the OR’s hours, and hours for materials management are included in administration.

If you have short cases, [the system] works great, but if you have long cases or a surgeon who tends to run over, it works to your disadvantage,” Turner says. “It’s best to have a mix of short and long cases for this method to work.” Hours not used can be carried over and applied to low census days within a pay period.

 

Communicating results

“Communication is vitally important,” Shimek says. “We post results in the physician and staff lounges and share them at meetings.”

During monthly staff in-services, she talks about what the ASC is doing well and opportunities for improvement. “You also want to get from the front-line staff where the pain or pressure points are,” she says. “The whole team has to be engaged.”

Reporting is typically done monthly or quarterly, depending on the metric. “Turnover times and late starts are reported monthly to the ASC committee and the staff,” Turner says.

Shimek adds that it’s important to foster the right culture when sharing information. “You want to make sure it’s not a blame game, but instead it’s about the process of what we are doing and how we can improve.”

Turner says it helps to explain the meaning behind the statistics. For instance, preoperative staff need to understand that if patients are delayed because of an incomplete history and physical, the entire schedule will be affected.

When it comes to improvement initiatives to correct deficits identified by metrics, Turner says, “you have to clean up your own house before you venture into others’.”

Problems are first addressed in the OR and preoperative care unit before Turner approaches physicians. “You need to pick champions,” she says, adding that it’s important to give feedback about what is and is not working when improvements are made.

A good resource for improving patient safety metrics is the Toolkit to Improve Safety in Ambulatory Surgery Centers, from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. A free download is available at https://www.ahrq.gov/professionals/quality-patient-safety/hais/tools/ambulatory-surgery/index.html.

To encourage forward progress on quality goals, ASC leaders should acknowledge staff when goals are met. “We reward the entire team for starting on time because it takes a team effort,” Turner says. That includes those in the OR, the preoperative staff, and those who accurately filled the case cart so nothing was missing.

 

Improving efficiency and effectiveness

How can ASC leaders be more efficient and effective in managing metrics? Comerford suggests scheduling report reminders in electronic calendars and using software such as QuickBooks or AdvantX to analyze data.

Data from many software programs can be exported into Excel for additional analysis. “Excel is great for analyzing information, and it’s on your computer already,” Comerford says.

Shimek says to delegate to others when possible. For example, staff in materials management could analyze costs per case, and the business office manager can have a white board that shows collection status and how it relates to goal.

Delegating to those who do the work can pay off financially. “A scheduler who tracks block time and who sees an open block can call surgeons to notify them of the available time,” Shimek says.

“Be organized, delegate what you can, and have good communication across the organization,” she adds. ✥

 

 

References

Dryda L. 110 ASC benchmarks & statistics to know—2016. Becker’s ASC Review. Oct. 5, 2016. http://www.beckersasc.com/asc-turnarounds-ideas-to-improve-performance/110-asc-benchmarks-statistics-to-know-2016.html.

VMG Health. Multi-specialty ASC study intellimarker 2017. http://vmghealth.com/publications/intellimarker/.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat