The hazards of surgical smoke are well documented. As far back as 2004, AORN began publishing guidelines to reduce exposure to surgical smoke and aerosolized particles during operative and invasive procedures. These guidelines can also be adopted to help protect COVID-19 patients and frontline healthcare staff who are exposed to viral particles and virus-containing human tissue (sidebar below).
A resource document published by the Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic Surgeons highlights the increased concern related to COVID-19:
“There is a constant influx of new information regarding the virology of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) and the disease, COVID-19. What we know so far regarding the SARS-CoV-2, is the RNA virus has a size range of 0.06 to 0.14 microns. Along with the nasopharynx, the upper respiratory tract and lower respiratory tract, the virus has been found in the entire gastrointestinal tract from the mouth to the rectum. The virus has been found in nasal swabs, saliva, sputum, throat swabs, blood, bile, and feces. Urine and CSF [cerebrospinal fluid] evaluations have been negative. The virus has also been found within the cells lining the respiratory tract and gastrointestinal tract. It is suspected that the virus has multiple modes of transmission.”
With no vaccines to protect us against COVID-19, healthcare systems are looking to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) for guidance on how to protect healthcare workers as they care for both diagnosed and undiagnosed patients. The CDC recommends standard precautions, contact precautions, airborne precautions, and eye protection as personal protection equipment (PPE) for healthcare workers.
In this article, we discuss ways to mitigate the hazards of both surgical smoke and COVID-19, and we offer several algorithms to use as a roadmap for decision making in multiple types of surgical procedures, as well as during intubation and extubation.
Surgical smoke—also called aerosols, plume, bio-aerosols, vapor, air contaminants, or mist—results from the interaction of tissue and mechanical tools and/or heat-producing devices such as those used for dissection and hemostasis. More than 150 chemicals have been identified in surgical smoke, each with its own health concerns and side effects. Benzene, for example, is a trigger for leukemia in susceptible people, and the Occupational Safety and Health Administration sets permissible exposure limits to protect workers from the hazards associated with inhaling benzene.
The polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in smoke are odorous pollutants that are the byproducts of incomplete combustion and pose carcinogenic potential. Radiofrequency electrosurgery current produces significant PAHs, which can be inhaled. Tseng et al found that electrosurgery during mastectomy produced PAH concentrations that were 20 to 30 times higher than in outdoor environments. Using a toxicity equivalency factor for cancer risk, they determined that scrubbed personnel had higher calculated cancer risks and that the carcinogenic effects of PAHs on surgical staff should not be neglected.
A review of the published evidence indicates the danger of surgical smoke and its components to perioperative personnel (sidebar at right). Physical symptoms include dizziness, eye irritation, nausea, vomiting, headache, sneezing, weakness, and throat irritation. The symptoms and potential risks—including emphysema, asthma, bronchitis, dermatitis, and cardiovascular dysfunction—are consistent with anecdotal reports from healthcare professionals and researchers over the last four decades and reinforce the fact that there is no such thing as safe smoke.
Patients are also at risk from surgical smoke during laparoscopic surgery. Smoke inside the abdomen is absorbed through the peritoneal membrane. The result in the patient’s bloodstream is an increase in the methemoglobin and carboxyhemoglobin concentrations, which reduces the oxygen carrying capacity of red blood cells. Carboxyhemoglobin and methemoglobin are dsyshemoglobinemias, which give a falsely elevated oxygen reading that could result in unrecognized patient hypoxia.
What are the long-term health effects from exposure to surgical smoke? A definitive answer is unclear, but decades’ worth of evidence indicates that there are dangers. For example, a 2013 case report by Rioux and associates from Canada documents human papillomavirus (HPV) positive tonsillar cancer in two laser surgeons. Their history revealed no other risk factors for oropharyngeal cancer or HPV aside from occupational exposure. In a study by Ball, perioperative nurses reported twice the incidence of respiratory problems compared to the general population.
It took many years for society to accept that cigarette smoke was unhealthy and contributed to disease and death. Although we are well along the path where greater protection of healthcare workers should be routine and uniform, we are not there yet.
What do algorithms have to do with providing bedside care during a surgical or invasive procedure? Algorithms are written by programmers to tell computers what to do through complex numerical codes. Nurses are not computers. The task is to separate the definition from a complex computation and make it simple.
An algorithm is a simple set of instructions or steps. Writing out steps so that people can read and understand the steps is called pseudocode—coding for humans. A cake recipe is an algorithm written in pseudocode. Algorithms can also be expressed as a set of images depicting components of the algorithm or as flow charts.
In nursing, an algorithm is a step-by-step formula or set of rules for addressing a problem or explaining a procedure, basing the steps on practice guidelines. Algorithm steps enable perioperative nurses to evaluate types of surgical procedures and make practice decisions based on the amount of smoke or aerosolization generated.
Practice guidelines assist nurses in making decisions about appropriate use of smoke evacuation equipment based on specific clinical circumstances. Algorithms summarize practice guidelines into a logical methodology that allows for sound clinical decision making based on best evidence.
Use of algorithmic thinking when making decisions about smoke evacuation assumes use of the practice guideline for evacuating and filtering all surgical smoke or aerosolized particulate matter with the minimum of a three-stage ULPA (ultra low particulate air) filter. Before surgery, the perioperative nurse must determine the amount of surgical smoke or aerosolized particulate matter that will be generated, which can be done using these algorithms:
Examples of procedures with minimal smoke production include, but are not limited to, temporal artery biopsy, hand procedures, vocal cord polyps, tonsillectomy, laparoscopies, ear procedures, dermatological procedures, nasal procedures, thoracoscopy, back procedures, craniotomies, and breast biopsies. Steps for procedures like these include:
• A 0.1 micron in-line ULPA filter is placed between the wall suction and the suction canister connected to the sterile field.
• In-line ULPA filters are placed in every surgical or invasive procedure area that generates smoke.
• In-line ULPA filters are changed weekly.
• Suction tubing no longer than 12 feet long is used with a smoke evacuation electrosurgery pencil, or an electrosurgery pencil to which a smoke carriage is attached.
• Wall suction produces low volume rates of air flow (3 to 5 cubic feet per minute), which limits smoke evacuation capabilities but is permissible for minimal smoke evacuation.
• Contaminated filters and smoke evacuation supplies are disposed of using standard precautions with personnel using PPE.
Examples of procedures that require a smoke evacuation unit with evacuation tubing include, but are not limited to, abdominal surgical procedures, breast reduction procedures, large extremity procedures, vaporization of condyloma, thoracic procedures, excisional neck procedures, and spinal fusions. Steps for procedures like these include:
• A smoke evacuation unit with evacuation tubing is used.
• Corrugated smoke evacuation tubing with a smooth inner lumen is connected directly to the smoke evacuation unit. Fluid should not be suctioned with the smoke evacuation unit.
• If incidental fluid invasion into the smoke evacuator is anticipated, a device to capture small amounts of fluid should be attached to the smoke evacuation unit.
• The smoke capture device should be positioned close to the generation of the smoke (within 2 inches for electrosurgical smoke pencils).
• For larger lumen smoke tubing, position as close to the surgical site as possible; hands-free setup if feasible.
• For larger smoke evacuating tubing, a guard should be on the end of the larger lumen tubing to prevent pulling Raytec sponges or other items into the tubing.
• The tubing should be held or attached to drapes in a manner that will not impede the surgical or invasive procedure.
• Hands-free smoke capture devices should be attached and used according to the manufacturer’s instructions, such as the miniSquair™.
• If the smoke evacuation unit is activated by a foot pedal, the pedal should be positioned close to the foot of the operator.
• Simultaneous activation of the smoke evacuation unit (RF activation) when the electrosurgery unit activates should be considered as an option.
• The smoke evacuation unit ULPA filter should be monitored and replaced as recommended by the manufacturer.
• Contaminated filters and smoke evacuation supplies are disposed of using standard precautions with personnel using PPE.
Examples of minimally invasive procedures that require smoke evacuation include, but are not limited to, laparoscopic cholecystectomy, laparoscopic colon resection, laparoscopic hysterectomy, lap band procedures, robotic surgery, thoracoscopic chest procedures, and laparoscopic—other (sidebar at right).
Smoke produced during laparoscopic procedures should minimize perioperative practitioners’ exposure to the contents of smoke, which includes toxic chemicals, blood particles, other aerosolized human tissue, and anesthetic waste gases.
• Smoke should be evacuated throughout the procedure with a laparoscopic smoke evacuation system containing a 0.1 ULPA filter system.
• A 0.1 micron in-line ULPA filter should be attached to the wall suction system between the wall and the suction cannister.
• Release of the pneumoperitoneum following the procedure should be into a closed system and should never be released into the air.
• Contaminated filters and smoke evacuation supplies are disposed of using standard precautions with personnel using PPE.
Experience during severe respiratory outbreaks, such as SARS, determined that healthcare workers were infected despite the use of PPE. Such historical feedback supports the use of additional methods to decrease the possibility of exposure to aerosolized particles expectorated from an infected patient during intubation or extubation.
COVID-19 is spread by having direct contact with infectious secretions from a patient. Infectious secretions may include sputum, serum, blood, and respiratory droplets.
If anesthesia personnel determine that exposure to blood, body fluids, or aerosolized or splash fluid is possible during administration of local or general anesthesia, the following safety precautions can be instituted:
• A smoke evacuator is placed in the OR near the anesthesia provider.
• A fluid collection reservoir is attached to the smoke evacuation unit.
• A 6-foot corrugated tubing is attached to the smoke evacuator.
• The smoke evacuator collection system is attached to the tubing and placed within 2 inches of the mouth, to be activated during intubation and extubation. There are four possible collection systems that can be selected, based on provider preference:
Corrugated tubing is attached to a Yankauer suction tip to collect fluids and aerosolized particles.
Corrugated tubing is attached to a dental suction device and placed in the corner of the patient’s mouth to collect fluids and aerosolized particles.
Corrugated tubing is attached to a modified oxygen administration mask that rests at the level of the patient’s chin, allowing access to the mouth and nose and providing suction capture of fluids and aerosolized particles.
Corrugated tubing is attached to a smoke evacuation tubing arm and positioned by the anesthesia provider to facilitate collection of fluid or aerosolized particles during anesthesia administration.
• Extubate with deep fentanyl when possible to blunt cough reflexes.
• Avoid having the circulating OR nurse hold the patient to prevent the patient from rolling off the table, which puts the nurse inside the 6-foot distance during extubation.
• Move the patient to a stretcher prior to extubation.
• Raise side rails to enable the OR nurse to maintain 6 feet or greater distance from the patient, or double strap the patient to the OR table to prevent falling.
• Anesthesia provider should extubate in full PPE.
• Place a surgical mask over the patient to prevent viral spread via coughing during transport from the OR.
Room ventilation should be maintained as recommended by the CDC and the American Institute of Architects: There should be a minimum of 15 air exchanges per hour, and room air filters should be changed at specified intervals. The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health’s Hierarchy of Controls can be used to assist in controlling exposure to occupational hazards (https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/hierarchy/default.html).
Evidence supports that surgical smoke is a hazard to perioperative personnel and patients. Exposure to the dangers of surgical smoke is cumulative, and adverse health effects may not manifest for many years. Perioperative nurses and technicians should take the lead in ensuring a safe environment for surgical and invasive procedures.
Algorithms supported by clinical practice guidelines provide a useful tool for improving long-term outcomes for patients and healthcare workers. The above algorithms may be adapted to nurses’ specific perioperative environments to fit the needs of their organizations. ✥
Alp E, Biji D, Bleichrodt R P, et al. Surgical smoke and infection control. J Hosp Infect. 2006;62(1):1-5.
AORN. Guidelines for surgical smoke safety. In Standards, Recommended Practices, and Guidelines. Denver, CO: AORN. 2004. www.aorn.org.
AORN. Guidelines for surgical smoke safety. In: Guidelines for Perioperative Practice. Denver, CO: AORN. 2020;477-505. www.aorn.org.
Ball K. Compliance with surgical smoke evacuation guidelines: Implications for practice. ORNAC J. 2012;30(1):14-37.
Barrett W L, Garber S M. Surgical smoke—A review of the literature. Surg Endosc. 2003;979-987.
Caputo K M, Byrick R, Chapman M G, et al. Intubation of SARS patients: Infection and perspectives of healthcare workers. Can J Anaesth. 2006;53(2):122-129.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Guidelines for Environmental Infection Control in Healthcare Facilities. https://www.cdc.gov/infectioncontrol/pdf/guidelines/environmental-guidelines-P.pdf.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. What healthcare personnel should know about caring for patients with confirmed or possible coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/caring-for-patients.html.
Dennis V. Capstone: Surgical Smoke. 2019. Unpublished manuscript.
Hill D S, O’Neill J K, Powell R J, et al. Surgical smoke—A health hazard in the operating theatre: A study to quantify exposure and a survey of the use of smoke extractor systems in UK plastic surgery units. J Plastic Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2012;65(7):911-916.
Jablonski A M, DuPen A R, Ersek M. The use of algorithms in assessing and managing persistent pain in older adults. Am J Nurs. 2011;111(3):34-45.
Liu N, Filipp N, Wood K B. The utility of local smoke evacuation in reducing surgical smoke exposure in spine surgery: A prospective self-controlled study. Spine J. 2020;20(2):166-173. Mihashi S, Geza J J, Incze J, et al. 1975. Laser surgery in otolaryngology: Interaction of CO2 laser and soft tissue. Annals of NY Academy of Sciences. 1975;267:263-294.
Mowbray N, Ansell J, Warren N, et al. Is surgical smoke harmful to theater staff? A systematic review. Surg Endosc. 2013;27(9):3100-3107.
Munro M G. Reconstructive and Reproductive Surgery in Gynecology, 2nd ed. Volume 1: Fundamentals and Conditions. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. 2019, p 77.
Ott D E. Smoke and particulate hazards during laparoscopic procedures. Surgical Services Management. 1997;3(3):11-13.
Rioux M, Garland A, Webster D, et al. HPV positive tonsillar cancer in two laser surgeons: Case reports. J Otolaryngol.-Head & Neck Surg. 2013;42-54.
Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic Surgeons. Resources for Smoke & Gas Evacuation During Open, Laparoscopic, and Endoscopic Procedures. https://www.sages.org/resources-smoke-gas-evacuation-during-open-laparoscopic-endoscopic-procedures/.
Tseng H, Liu S, Uang S, et al. Cancer risk of incremental exposure to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in electrocautery smoke for mastectomy personnel. World J Surg Oncol. 2014;1-17.
Tynker: How to explain algorithms to kids. https://www.tynker.com/blog/articles/ideas-and-tips/how-to-explain-algorithms-to-kids/.
Ulmer B C. The hazards of surgical smoke. AORN J. 2008;87(4):721-734.