April 22, 2019

Vigilance best protects ASCs from workplace violence

By: Jennifer Lubell
Share

Violence is a fact of life in healthcare settings. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration estimates that, on average, healthcare workers are four times as likely to be victimized as those in private industry. Most types of violent incidents involve patients or visitors acting out against staff, accounting for 93% of all assaults and 75% of all aggravated assaults in hospitals, according to a 2014 study in the New England Journal of Medicine on hospital crime.

Ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) are no strangers to workplace violence, and because they often have more limited resources than hospitals, it can be challenging to ensure the safety of patients and staff alike. OR Manager recently spoke with several individuals who advise raising awareness of potential conflicts in the ASC setting, putting safety measures in place, and taking action to protect people from harm.

 

When familiarity breeds contempt

Jennifer Dickman, DNP, RN, CPN

Jennifer Dickman, DNP, RN, CPN, recalls the time a domestic situation at her surgery center nearly reached a boiling point.

Incidents commonly arise between a patient’s parents at North Surgery Center, a pediatric ASC that is part of the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center (UPMC). Things escalated when a mother estranged from the family decided to visit the day of her child’s surgery. “The father was upset, and one of my nurses was concerned about how heightened he was onsite,” says Dickman, the center’s director. Staff called the local police, alerting them to a potential domestic situation and possible interaction. “It turned out to be a non-issue—the mother didn’t even show up—but it’s a good thing police were there” to speak with the father and ensure that things didn’t escalate further, she says.

Most of North Surgery Center’s security concerns have involved potential domestic disputes that resolve with minimal police or security staff intervention. “However, we cannot get away from the realities in the world. This is at the forefront in the minds of staff,” says Dickman. She has sent leaders to classes in crisis management, and has scheduled sessions and drills with local police on workplace violence response strategies.

The microcultures of smaller facilities like ASCs make them particularly vulnerable to domestic violence, says Ronell Myburgh, MBA, MHA, RN, manager, orthopedic certifications and specialty programs at DNV GL Healthcare, an accreditation and certification company in Milford, Ohio. In 2017, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that seven intentional shootings resulted in fatal injuries, and there were more than 1,300 intentional injuries by “other persons” in these facilities.

ASCs usually involve a small group of people working together in a family-type atmosphere. Such environments pose a threat to a partner of a staff member who seeks control. This individual will act on the threat with violence, notes Myburgh, who once lost a coworker to domestic violence. “These partners recognize that it’s easy to access the organization,” she says.

Incidents may also involve someone the patient knows. In 2013, the family member of an admitted patient at Good Shepherd ASC in Longview, Texas, launched an attack on staff, visitors, and patients with a knife, killing two people. Quick actions by staff and police likely prevented further casualties.

In many instances, ASCs have found it necessary to partner with local police to de-escalate situations. Others have been fortunate to employ former law enforcement officers to guide and train staff.

 

Security staffing challenges

Large health systems usually have the capital to increase police presence, offer response training and security drills for staff, install 360-degree digital cameras, and place metal detectors at emergency department entrances. Some hospital groups have fought against violence through unique communication strategies (sidebar at right).

Since the 2013 attack, Good Shepherd ASC has instituted more frequent security rounds and installed keypad access on stairwells and radiofrequency identification badge access to clinical areas.

But not all ASCs have the adequate funds or staff to invest in security equipment or hire armed guards. Most ASCs are for profit, which means that they don’t qualify for grants to support additional resources. Environmental controls such as security at all entrance points aren’t always an option for these types of smaller organizations. “Transparency and awareness are the only mitigation strategy to keep personnel safe,” Myburgh says.

Cost, and the fact that the facility is located in the suburbs and not in a higher-incident city environment, are reasons why North Surgery Center doesn’t have onsite security. Fortunately, “the local police department knows us and is very responsive,” Dickman says. Staff try to be judicious in its 911 calls. “We don’t call the police on every case, but we do if something doesn’t sit right with us.”

 

Jim Donlon

Even some of the bigger ASCs face security issues. At the Center for Advanced Medicine, an ASC that’s part of New York-based Northwell Health, staffing enough security is a challenge because of the facility’s large size. “We’re so big that we have 18 entrances,” says Jim Donlon, manager of corporate security operations. Donlon and his assistant manager, both retired law enforcement officers, are in the process of hiring more staff, and they are continually updating their security measures and plans.

As is the case at North Surgery Center, police are located near the Center for Advanced Medicine. “We have a great relationship with the men and women of the Lake Success Police Department, and we have access to three other police agencies just a couple of blocks away: Nassau County, New York State, and New York City police departments. If something happened, police would be everywhere,” says Donlon.

 

Options to run or hide

Jason Venturella

The Department of Homeland Security instructs people to “run, hide, or fight” in active shooter situations. But for healthcare workers whose primary responsibility is to take care of patients, this is a difficult formula to comply with.

“Most of these workers don’t have the comfort of running away or hiding because of their obligation to protect patients,” says Jason Venturella, president of Stealth Security Consulting in Economy Borough, Pennsylvania, which specializes in helping community businesses prepare for emergency situations. “As opposed to a corporate setting where you’re only responsible for yourself, healthcare workers have to find secure areas while looking out for other people.” This is why so many hospitals have armed guards, he adds.

If patients are ambulatory, Donlon says his staff are trained to help patients, visitors, and employees evacuate the building during an active shooting or other catastrophic event.

In his view, if an active shooter enters the building and starts firing a gun, staff should follow the “run, hide, or fight” protocol. If shots are fired while a patient is still in recovery after surgery, a staff person should lock the door to that room. The choice to run or secure themselves in the room with the patient is up to the clinicians. They won’t be abandoning their patient if they leave—they will be conserving their resources, ie, they will be able to return and continue patient care or help treat any wounded people, Donlon adds. “Just remember: You’re no good to the patient if you become a patient yourself and are bleeding on the floor from a gunshot wound,” he says.

Venturella says he talks to facility administration to see which areas of the building need to be secured. The ability to lock down is much like the procedure in a school classroom. “It’s important to ensure that you have doors capable of keeping people from coming in. Facilities do have that ability, but you have to set that in place.”

There also has to be a communication process whereby everyone understands their roles immediately in the event of an attack. A comprehensive plan that is not understood by all employees or practiced could lead to tragedy. “All the pieces of a plan have to flow together,” he says.

 

Local incident spurs additional training

Northwell Health, including its Center for Advanced Medicine, decided to up its game on emergency response training following a shooting that took place at nearby Bronx-Lebanon Hospital Center (now BronxCare Health System) in 2017. A disgruntled former employee, who happened to be a physician and hadn’t yet turned in his ID, entered the hospital dressed as a physician and shot and killed a half-dozen people with an automatic weapon.

“Northwell has been conducting active shooter training since 2016, but this incident—as well as others around the country—helped us rethink some of our security measures,” says Donlon. The health system continues to conduct active shooter trainings at its 23 hospitals and hundreds of nonhospital locations.

Donlon has yet to witness any active shooter or other violent incidents at his facility. “Thankfully, nothing violent has ever happened where we had to call police.” Still, the Center for Advanced Medicine provides active shooter training to all new employees, going into great depth on “run, hide, fight” scenarios. They get a tutorial on the building, including the location of items such as the fire extinguisher and panic buttons, and how to use these devices.

Donlon also makes himself available to meet with employees in smaller groups, offering refresher training and providing advice on handling emotionally distressed people. In all training, “we go over the whole culture of care system, and how to deal with and respond to patients,” he says.

North Surgery Center has also begun organizing active shooter drills with local police. So far, local police have done two in-service programs about active shooter situations, sharing information about identifying suspicious vehicles and items, calling 911, and building a response plan.

“The next step is doing an actual drill” at the facility, says Dickman.

Some ASCs schedule multiple drills throughout the year (sidebar at right).

 

Education is everything

Venturella conducts his active shooter mass casualty incident training in three parts. His team does an initial evaluation at the facility to determine any vulnerabilities and assess where the most common threats may arise in order to recommend a plan.

The next step is education. Most facilities have some kind of plan, but education is critical and must be followed by training that covers everything from prevention to response.

If people aren’t properly trained, the response plan is not going to have an impact on their ability to survive an attack, Venturella says. “Even in some of the bigger hospitals, not everyone quite understands their role in the event of an emergency.”

There are many inconsistencies. Some staff members are unsure of what actions should be taken, whereas others have a basic understanding but fill in the holes with whatever plan they’ve created in their minds.

The last piece is to carry out the training, where people gain an understanding of what this looks like in their environment and what they need to do.

Prevention—identifying behavior before it happens—is what Venturella strives for in his training of facility staff. This involves educating people to be aware of their surroundings and to look for suspicious people, vehicles, and items. “If someone is approaching the facility with a gun, sounding an alarm can save lives.”

Surgical facilities that want to ramp up on security and violence prevention should be proactive about it, says Venturella. “Any ASC worker who thinks there’s value in having this type of training should express that to facility managers and/or leadership to get the proper security they need.”

 

Retraining through redirection

At UPMC, hospital and system leadership have been very responsive to North Surgery Center’s concerns about active shooters and what they see on the news. All of its departments have been asked to do crisis management training, which teaches de-escalation and interaction techniques. Training has been open to leadership as well as primary care practitioners and nursing.

The ASC has also gained some knowledge through its hospital emergency preparedness group. It’s not always apparent where to look for resources on workplace violence prevention, says Dickman. Sometimes people don’t know where to start. “We recently had two staff members at the surgery center join that group to give us better ties to resources [in the community]”, she says.

Very often, staff feel out of their depth with assessing these types of situations, Dickman says. “Nurses are good at physical assessments and talking with patients, but they’re not always sure if they should escalate something they hear on a phone call.” They don’t want to be alarmists, but they also don’t want to miss something.

One strategy is to redirect the conversation and remind a parent that his or her child is having surgery. It’s important to ask: Is there anything that will interfere with our ability to provide a safe outcome and experience for your child the day of surgery? With children, the stakes and emotions are high, and the stress response takes over sometimes, Dickman notes.

 

The power in a cup of coffee

There’s a delicacy in handling a patient who is growing agitated because of a long wait time to see a physician. In these scenarios, it’s important to exercise common sense and remain calm—no matter what the person is saying, Donlon advises.

“You tell them, ‘I’m terribly sorry, I can find out how much longer you have to wait. Can I get you a cup of coffee or water?’ A cup of coffee goes a long way, especially if you ask them what they want in their coffee. You offer that hand of assistance,” Donlon says.

Employees at the Center for Advanced Medicine are trained to inform a supervisor if a situation appears to be escalating. Donlon says there are times when he steps in. “I tell the staff, ‘let me give it a try.’ When I show up, things always seem to calm down,” he says.

Leadership should also remain cognizant of the emotional pulse within their facilities. It’s not enough to check a box and say “we did workplace violence training,” Myburgh says. If an incident occurred, everyone should get together, talk about it, and discuss ways to prevent such incidents in the future.

Staff may be facing their own potential domestic violence situations at home. “People don’t want to bring that shame to the workplace. But they need to overcome that. Leadership needs to establish venues where people feel comfortable talking about these situations,” Myburgh says. Staff in need of help should receive counseling about safe spaces and a possible exit plan.

“Look out for each other,” she advises. No one should have to sort this out for themselves. ✥

Jennifer Lubell is a healthcare writer based in Rockville, Maryland.

 

References

DeJohn P. Fatal attacks at ASCs spur stronger safety measures. OR Manager. 2016;32(8):28-31. https://www.ormanager.com/fatal-attacks-ascs-spur-stronger-safety-measures/.

 

https://www.bls.gov/iif/oshwc/cfoi/cftb0314.htm.

 

https://www.bls.gov/iif/oshwc/osh/case/cd_r4_2017.htm.

 

Joint Commission. Sentinel Event Alert. April 17, 2018. https://www.jointcommission.org/assets/1/18/SEA_59_Workplace_violence_4_13_18_FINAL.pdf.

 

https://www.stealthsecurityconsulting.com.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat