Virtual presentations have burgeoned in the wake of COVID-19, and nurse leaders have had to become more adept at both disseminating and receiving information this way. Choosing the right platform, learning the technology, avoiding distractions and system glitches, and using good communication are the primary criteria for success with
this format. And although a virtual presentation cannot duplicate some aspects of in-person events, the technology is here to stay, says Kay Ball, PhD, RN, CNOR, CMLSO, FAAN, adjunct professor at Otterbein University in Westerville, Ohio, and perioperative consultant.
“Nurses are presenting virtually much more than in the past,” Ball told OR Manager. “Their meetings are online, or maybe they have to give a report online, or they’re on the board of a nursing association.” She says they are adapting to attending and presenting in virtual settings. Knowing how to optimize the technology is important, but there are many other aspects to consider when presenting virtually.
As president of the AORN of Greater Houston Chapter for 2020-2021, Daphny Peneza, MSN, RN, CNOR, CSSM, faced not only a new leadership role but a whole new way of communicating with chapter members because of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Peneza, an education resource specialist III at Memorial Hermann Hospital—Texas Medical Center, Houston, had taken on other new responsibilities related to the pandemic. In March 2020, she was commissioned to serve as the lead for the hospital’s personal protective equipment task force, teaching staff in critical care units or other units dedicated to COVID-19 how to don and doff properly. In August, she became the full-time OR educator, after having been a “hybrid” nurse educator in the OR, splitting her time between scrubbing/circulating and educating. Peneza was also elected chair of AORN’s Clinical Nurse Educator Specialty Assembly in 2019.
After the March 2020 in-person Houston chapter meeting was canceled, the first virtual chapter meetings had low participation, Peneza says, so she recommended changing to the Zoom platform, which she felt was safer and more user-friendly. Participation rose from 30-some participants to more than 100.
Peneza says she has used several approaches to boost attendee engagement and enable the chapter to meet its goals during the pandemic.
Anticipating that the pandemic would worsen, Peneza stressed to her chapter leaders that their mission was to support their members. They were asked to focus on a four-tiered goal:
• member engagement
• perioperative nursing practice and nursing education
• community service
• improving disciplinary partnerships.
“We have achieved all of these goals during the pandemic,” she told OR Manager. “We have engaged our members—doubling or sometimes tripling our attendance at virtual events. We’ve given presentations that focus on empowering them in their nursing practice. And our community service activities have been amazing.”
“Always know your audience,” Ball advises. “You may have people both in person and online, and speakers sometimes forget to query people online.”
Having presented both nationally and internationally, Ball knows the importance of understanding the different cultures and levels of language proficiency in a given group. “When I do international lectures where English is not the audience’s first language, I always make sure my slides carry the message, too, in case they don’t understand everything I’m saying, and I speak more slowly,” she says. “That’s the art of knowing your audience.”
As a long-time researcher and expert on the hazards of surgical smoke exposure, Ball has presented multiple times on this topic. But it’s not just a matter of presenting data; it’s presenting data that matter to the different stakeholders in the audience. For example, she says, there might be a hospital president online learning about the need for smoke-free facilities, and discussing the impact of the hospital’s budget constraints will be of interest to both top management and frontline staff as they consider the changes that will need to be made.
But there will also be differences in what matters most to various audience members, she notes. “The nurses and techs in surgery will be interested in whether surgical smoke will make them sick, whereas the C-suite will be interested in the price of devices designed to eliminate smoke.”
To make a compelling argument for purchasing the device or equipment, she says, one tactic might be to explain the cost of onboarding staff versus potential turnover because of an unhealthy work environment. She stresses the importance of knowing the audience’s chief interests and the goal of making the presentation.
“As a chapter leader, it’s important for me to provide support for my members—both the clinical and psychological components,” Peneza says. Chapter meetings are held monthly on Tuesdays, with 1 hour spent on business and 1 hour on continuing education (CE), and every other month on Saturdays. Peneza has added “Inspirational Bites,” which are 10- to 15-minute non-CE presentations by inspirational speakers that include a Q&A. She believes these inspiring messages, some of them delivered by past AORN presidents, have boosted attendance.
Peneza also finds it helpful to structure chapter meetings by opening with a welcome message followed by Inspirational Bites and a board report from a national board member. In addition, she says, there’s a different theme for each meeting. In April 2020, the theme was “a beautiful ride” in honor of Earth Day. More recently, she presented on “the three S’s: share love, spark hope, spread joy.”
Ball says presentations must be informative and entertaining to enhance audience members’ retention. “You have to pick a topic that’s timely and informational, and put a humorous slant on it to make it memorable,” she says.
Audience engagement tools like polls with multiple choice questions or a chat box can make a presentation much more interesting and dynamic. However, it can be hard to monitor and respond to questions that crop up during a presentation, Ball notes. She suggests having a “wing man” to monitor the chat box.
Branding and advertising are other key components to attract an audience, Peneza says. Creating a consistent look across platforms, agendas, and invitations was something she stressed to her board members early on, she says. “We always try to advertise at least a month in advance and sometimes 2 months before the chapter meeting,” she notes, adding that messaging makes it clear that AORN members, non-members, and students are welcome. Meeting reminders are sent the day before and the day of the meeting.
Another early initiative was to hold the chapter board meeting 1 week before the chapter meeting instead of 1 day before. “This serves as a mini-practice session before the event,” Peneza says. “This gives me enough time to prepare, and if board members have to speak, they are prepared, and it gives us time for last-minute changes like a speaker change.”
Although Peneza considers herself a good planner, she says she does not like to read from her notes during a presentation—except when introducing speakers—because speaking rather than reading is a better way to connect to the audience.
“Another best practice is to review the recording [after the meeting],” she says. “My secretary and adviser review the recording, too. Feedback is a gift—they will tell me the good and not-so-good points so I can improve for next time.”
For the Saturday meetings, Peneza says, they use a 50/50 approach: For example, at one recent meeting, speakers talked about mentoring and journaling, and the last 20 to 25 minutes were spent on team sharing. “This gives attendees an opportunity to also be part of the presentation,” she notes.
Virtual platforms can be ideal for some types of education, Ball says. “At Otterbein, we’re doing team-based learning. The nurses are given a quiz on a certain subject. Then they break into groups and re-take the quiz, to see how the group did and to learn from each other.” The faculty member goes over what people missed on the quiz, and the chat rooms provide a forum for discussion, she adds.
Ball notes several other advantages to virtual presentations, especially the ability to reach a wider audience. “You can get people involved from all across the world. I did an inspirational message about the silver lining of COVID-19 for the Houston chapter of AORN, and it worked so well, the Austin chapter wants me to do it, too.”
For the 2021 AORN Surgical Congress & Expo, Ball says, some presentations may be videotaped or presented live virtually with a moderator. “This has opened up so many avenues,” she says. “When we had to do the Surgical Congress virtually in 2020, a lot of people attended. They met with industry on the display floor. In the future, we’ll be offering hybrid presentations. That’s a silver lining of COVID-19.”
Peneza also is enthusiastic about the wider audience reach and engagement level that can be achieved with virtual presentations. She foresees presentations evolving into a hybrid format that combines virtual and live components. “I have a dual format. The room is set up for Zoom attendees and live attendees,” she says. “This will enrich programming and give everyone an opportunity to participate.”
As a millennial and a chapter leader, Peneza also believes the virtual format has allowed her to demonstrate her creativity and use that—along with guidance from her chapter advisers—to meet the chapter’s goals. “I’m really grateful for all of the global mentors and chapter members who have supported me and helped the chapter to find balance in this crisis,” Peneza says.
Ball has used virtual technology to advance her advocacy of surgical smoke-free environments. In October 2020, she says, she met virtually with a Republican senator, a Democrat senator, and AORN representatives. “I moderated and asked them questions, and the nurses realized it was easy to reach a legislator. We introduced them to the surgical hazards of smoke, and now a bill has been written that both senators support, so it’s moving legislation along,” she says. The bill, Ohio Senate Bill 161, was introduced to the senate on April 15, 2021. Without the virtual platform, Ball notes, it probably would not have been possible to bring together both senators for a meeting.
“We’ll always love the gold standard of face-to-face meetings because you can see nonverbal communication,” Ball says. “We have that on virtual, too, but it’s heightened when you see people face to face.” However, she believes virtual presentations will enhance and advance teaching in the future.
Ball will share her expertise during the annual OR Manager Conference, October 20-22, in Chicago. For more information or to register, visit www.ormanager.com. ✥