February 1, 2010

What makes an OR “highly reliable”?

By: OR Manager
Share

What makes an organization “highly reliable”—able to avoid the rare but serious breakdowns that can have devastating consequences for patients?

A highly reliable organization is one that is “exceptionally consistent in accomplishing their goals and avoiding potentially catastrophic errors,” notes the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ). Some familiar examples—the airlines, nuclear power, and aircraft carriers.

Becoming “highly reliable” isn’t a matter of adopting a new quality improvement method, “roadmap,” or checklist, AHRQ cautions. It’s a mindset or a culture that is essential for those approaches to work. The goal is to have a “culture and processes that radically reduce system failures” and respond effectively when there is a failure.

The highly reliable OR

What makes a perioperative department highly reliable? Kaiser Permanente’s (KP) California regions have introduced Highly Reliable Surgical Teams. Features include a team-based culture and standardized approaches to processes like preoperative verification.

Highly Reliable Surgical Teams have their roots in 2 Kaiser studies. The most recent, published in 2009, found surgical teams with lower scores for team behaviors were linked to worse patient outcomes (sidebar).

An earlier study, reported in 2003, one of the first to investigate the effect of preoperative briefings, found briefings were associated with better staff morale, reduced nurse turnover, and improved staff ratings of the safety climate.

The 2009 study added qualitative data to the 2003 results and has helped in getting physicians on board, notes Suzanne Graham, RN, PhD, director of patient safety for KP’s California regions.

Focus on safe care

The goal of Highly Reliable Surgical Teams is to “create teamwork, engagement, and a culture of safety where everyone is focused on giving safe care,” says Laura Moreno, RN, BSN, MBA, clinical practice leader for patient safety for KP’s Northern California region.

Some characteristics are:

  • open communication
  • a flattened hierarchy in the OR
  • standardizing processes like the time-out and briefings
  • becoming a “learning organization”—an organization that enables learning and continuously improves
  • adopting best practices.

Expert teams

For the 19 KP Northern California medical centers, the high reliability effort is guided by an expert team of physician and nurse leaders. In developing the program, they studied the literature and KP’s own data, including root causes of sentinel events, and found, not surprisingly, common themes were teamwork and communication.

The experts began meeting with representatives from the medical centers and asked, “What does the ideal OR look like?” They developed surgical safety tools, such as a preop briefing script and piloted the tools in 3 medical centers.

The project was rolled out to all 21 facilities in 2007 and 2008. Each medical center was asked to:

  • identify a Highly Reliable Surgical Team leadership group with a surgeon champion, OR manager or director, and quality representative
  • conduct human-factors and critical-event training
  • administer the Safety Attitudes Questionnaire (SAQ) to measure how physicians, nurses, and support staff currently feel about issues such as teamwork, communication, and perceptions of management
  • develop a standardized template for preoperative briefings
  • begin performing consistent briefings in every OR for every case.

Visual aid for briefings

As an aid to briefings, KP’s San Jose Medical Center came up with a visual tool that can be used as a poster or a laminated sheet on a clip board (illustration).

“They put the poster up in the OR so everyone understands the roles and the script,” Moreno says.

KP teams are asked to do the briefing before anesthesia induction with the patient in the OR, which raised some eyebrows at first, she notes. There are exceptions, such as pediatric cases.

“Everyone comes together before induction,” she explains. “The patient is awake. They introduce themselves and start the briefing.

“We have made it a hard stop,” she adds, “and the staff and surgeons will not hand over the knife until the briefing is completed.”

Despite some hesitation about patients hearing the briefing, teams have found patients actually find it reassuring. Some patients even join in, volunteering their name and the procedure to be done.

The tipping point

To reach the tipping point where a highly reliable culture is a way of life, Graham says support by 3 parties is critical—senior leadership, surgeon champions, and perioperative directors and managers.

“Our top surgical leader for Northern California is a staunch backer in supporting culture change,” Graham says. At the facility level, surgeon champions have intervened when peers have resisted briefings and other safety strategies.

To aid the evolution, project leaders from the regional office visit the medical centers to conduct independent observations of briefings and offer feedback.

Scoring safety

The KP medical centers track their progress by keeping a “surgical safety dashboard” that includes:

  • conduct of briefings
  • compliance with metrics for the Surgical Care Improvement Project (SCIP), such as on-time administration of antibiotics and venous thromboembolism prevention
  • any “never events” (events that should never happen to patients)
  • SAQ scores for the safety culture and teamwork. The briefings are scored on 3 elements:
  • Leadership: Was the surgeon leading the briefing and actively engaged?
  • Script: Was the script followed by each participant?
  • Engagement: Was everyone attentive during the briefing?

“We set a benchmark that we want these to happen 90% of the time,” Moreno says.

Over a year, the medical centers were able to bring their SCIP scores, which had varied, closer together and into the 90th percentile.

“We think the briefings were a key element in improving our SCIP scores,” she notes.

The GLITCH list

KP medical centers are also encouraged to adopt debriefings at the end of surgical cases. The purpose is to discuss what went well and what could be improved.

Some centers are compiling information from the debriefings into what they call GLITCH lists-Gather Little Insights That Can Help. The lists include issues that need to be addressed, such as equipment problems or systems problems. The manager is responsible for seeing that GLITCH issues are followed up and addressed. The issues are reviewed monthly by the leadership team.

“The debriefings have really heightened communication between the staff and surgeons and helped to address some of the ‘pebbles in their shoes,'” says Moreno. Equipment issues seem to be the most common topic.

“This really has been a collaborative effort that has brought together our departments of quality patient care services, and the physicians,” Moreno says. “They have been able to effect change by having this triad work together.”

References

Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. Becoming a Highly Reliable Organization: Operational Advice for Hospital Leaders April 2008. www.ahrq.gov/qual/hroadvice/

Leonard M, Graham S, Bonacum D. The human factor: The critical importance of effective teamwork and communication in providing safe care. Qual Saf Health Care. 2004;13(Suppl):i85-i90.

Mazzocco K, Petitti D B, Fong K T. Surgical team behaviors and patient outcomes. Am J Surg. 2009;197:678-685.

“Preflight checklist” builds safety culture, reduces nurse turnover. OR Manager. 2003;19(12):1, 8-10.

Five traits of high reliability organizations

Sensitivity to operations

Leaders and staff have constant awareness of the state of systems and processes that affect patient care. This awareness is key to noticing risks and preventing them.

Reluctance to simplify

Simple processes are good. But simplistic explanations of why things work or fail are risky. Avoiding overly simple explanations—unqualified staff, inadequate training, communication failure, etc—is essential to understand the true reasons patients are placed at risk.

Preoccupation with failure

Near misses are viewed as evidence of systems that should be improved to reduce potential harm to patients.

Deference to expertise

Leaders and supervisors listen and respond to insights of staff who know how processes really work and the risks patients really face.

Resilience

Leaders and staff are trained and prepared to know how to respond when system failures do occur.

Source: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. Becoming a High Reliability Organization. www.ahrq.gov/qual/hroadvice/hroadviceexecsum.htm

Study of teamwork behaviors

The Kaiser Permanente study involved RN observations of 300 surgical procedures and an assessment of 30-day postoperative outcomes.

Observers rated each surgical team from 0 to 4 based on team behaviors that have been shown to contribute to performance. Examples are briefing, information sharing, and assertion. The procedures were rated for low, medium, or high risk of complications. The 30-day outcome for each procedure was determined by medical record review.

Each procedure team was given a single behavior score. The researchers then calculated the relationship between the behavior score and the odds ratio for complications and death.

In findings, patients whose surgical teams showed less teamwork behaviors were at a higher risk for death or complications, even after adjusting for their risk category.

The authors say the results provide “general support for the development of team training for surgical teams.”

Source: Mazzocco K, Petitti D B, Fong K T. Am J Surg. 2009;197: 678-685.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat