A sterilization failure is a significant event. Receiving a positive biological indicator (BI) result from a sterilizer can be devastating and presents a patient safety concern because it could result in infection. This article addresses the proper action to take in the event of a positive BI result and biological recall.
The BI is used to test the sterilizer to ensure it is working properly. BIs, which are intended to demonstrate that the sterilization conditions were adequate to kill a large number of highly resistant bacterial spores, are the only sterilization process monitoring devices that provide a direct measure of the lethality of the process. For steam sterilization, the BI is the one monitor used in a cycle that can detect inadequate steam quality, along with all the other critical sterilization variables.
Sterilizers are tested by placing a BI in a process challenge pack (PCD) designed to further challenge the sterilization process in an area most resistant to the sterilization cycle. A cycle is initiated, and the cycle is then monitored with the sterilizer’s physical monitors (eg, printouts or graphs).
Upon completion of the cycle, a qualified person should review quality monitors. The physical monitors are reviewed to ensure they have met the sterilization parameters.
External chemical indicators (CIs) are reviewed to ensure they met their endpoints. The PCD is removed from the sterilizer and opened, and the BI is incubated according to the BI instructions for use.
A negative result showing no biological growth is the accepted result. Although a negative BI does not prove that all items in the load are sterile or that all were exposed to adequate sterilization conditions, it does show that all the necessary conditions to achieve sterilization have been met.
If the test shows a positive result, meaning that the biological spores are still viable, the load should be quarantined and the sterilizer removed from service. The department head should be notified immediately, and specific steps must be carried out.
The first step is to investigate the cause of the positive BI: operator error, sterilizer malfunction, or utility malfunction.
A review of the physical parameters can show that the sterilization cycle that was selected met the sterilization parameters, such as time and temperature. If the physical parameters are correct, review the practices used by the sterilizer operator to see whether the positive BI was attributed to operator error.
Common operator errors include failing to load the BI PCD correctly or overloading the sterilizer using the incorrect BI PCD for the sterilization cycle.
If operator error caused the positive BI, the error should be corrected by reprocessing all items. In this case, because the error was confined to one load and was caused by operator error, there would not be a need to conduct a recall.
If the positive BI was not the result of operator error, the load should be considered non-sterile, and the items must be reprocessed. The sterilizer should be removed from service, and the hospital engineer or maintenance professional should investigate the possible reasons for the failure and resolve the problem.
A sterilization failure recall is immediately initiated, recalling all items processed in that specific sterilizer back to the last negative BI result. All items in the recall must be reprocessed. A sterilization failure is a critical matter, so verbal communication (either in person or via telephone) should be followed by a written order.
The affected items should be listed on the load record (a detailed list of items sterilized in each sterilizer load, along with the specific lot number for each load). The load record can be either handwritten or digitally recorded in an instrument tracking system.
Every package that undergoes sterilization has a lot control number that identifies the specific sterilizer used and the date, which means that every package sterilized is traceable to the sterilizer used, date of sterilization, and specific load.
The load record is used to identify all items for recall and to monitor for item retrieval. The inventory area must be checked for the recalled items for reprocessing. Items that have been issued must be retrieved for reprocessing. Affected items may be located by using either an instrument tracking system or a manual system.
Note that an instrument tracking system can provide a list of all affected items, and most instrument tracking systems can also provide a detailed listing of where the items were distributed.
When contacting areas where the items were distributed, the item name (as it is labeled on the package) and lot control number should be provided to identify all recalled items. The specific action to take must be clearly communicated.
Typically at this stage, items are either returned to central service/sterile processing (CS/SP) or destroyed. The actions taken for each item should then be recorded.
Detailed records of actions taken must be kept for review and follow-up. The following should be included in the recall record:
• time and date of the incident, including the sterilizer identification number and load control number
• identification by sterilization lot number of the items to be recalled
• identification of the people or departments to whom the recall was communicated
• record of recalled items, including the item type and quantity
• list of the items obtained in the recall
• specific action taken by the persons receiving the order (eg, returning the affected items to CS/SP)
• a description of the incident, including any information about patient(s) potentially affected
• results of physical monitoring and of internal CIs
• any additional relevant information.
A sterilizer failure isn’t limited to recalling the items sterilized. An interdisciplinary team should thoroughly investigate sterilization process failures in a standardized, systematic manner. Results of the investigation must be documented and reported to the affected departments, infection preventionist, the quality assurance or risk management department, and any additional stakeholders.
If all packages have not been retrieved, the packages that have been used should be traced to patients in which the items may have been used, and a list of potentially exposed patients should be prepared. The interdisciplinary team should assess whether the failure increases patients’ risk for infection and determine if patient notification is necessary.
If patients need to be notified, the team should determine whether these patients require medical evaluation for possible postexposure therapy and follow-up to detect infection.
After the sterilization failure has been identified and corrected, the sterilizer may need to undergo qualification testing before being placed back into service. If failure was caused by the sterilizer or its utilities, qualification testing will need to be performed to ensure the sterilizer performs to specifications.
Qualification testing is based on the type of sterilizer or sterilization cycle used. If a sterilizer is designed to use two different types of cycles, both cycles should undergo qualification testing. The sterilizer cycle is run for three consecutive cycles with only a BI PCD validated for that cycle. Upon completion of the cycle, all the physical monitors should be reviewed and verified to show the sterilization parameters have been met.
It’s also important to review the CIs to ensure that they have met their endpoints. If a dynamic air removal cycle is used, upon completion of the BI PCD testing, three consecutive Bowie-Dick tests should be run, with the test results demonstrating sufficient air removal.
A detailed plan should be developed to prevent this type of failure from occurring again, and all these actions should be recorded.
Every healthcare facility should have a policy and procedure regarding biological monitoring and recalls. When developing such documentation, healthcare leaders will find best practices described in AORN’s Guideline for Sterilization and ANSI/AAMI ST79, Comprehensive Guide to Steam Sterilization and Sterility Assurance in Health Care Facilities.
Policies should be developed and reviewed by an interdisciplinary team with the responsibility and authority for establishing and implementing quality assurance and performance improvement programs for sterilization processes. The policy should cover:
• the circumstances for issuing a recall
• the department or individual(s) responsible for initiating the recall and what actions to take
• which personnel to contact
• a notification process that complies with regulatory (federal, state, local) and accrediting agency requirements.
Recall policies and procedures can prevent delays and accelerate the retrieval of suspected non-sterilized items. They also provide directions to ensure adequate follow-up actions, such as quarantine of the sterilizer, notification of physicians and affected clinical departments, and surveillance of patients. ✥
Susan Klacik, BS, CRCST, CHL, CIS, ACE, FCS, is clinical educator for IAHCSMM (International Association of Healthcare Central Service Materiel Management) and a representative to AAMI. She also serves on AORN’s Guidelines Advisory Board.
AORN. Guideline for Sterilization. In: Guidelines for Perioperative Practice.Denver, CO: AORN, 2019. www.aorn.org.
Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation. Comprehensive guide to steam sterilization and sterility assurance in health care facilities. ANSI/AAMI ST79:2017. www.aami.org.
International Association of Healthcare Central Service Materiel Management. Central Service Technical Manual, Eighth Ed. 2016. https://www.iahcsmm.org/publications/central-service-technical-training-8.html.