November 20, 2024

Why bullying, incivility demand distinction

By: Phyllis S. Quinlan, PhD, RN, NPD
Share

Think of that colleague you would not miss if they called out sick. You may be short-staffed, but you know you are going to have a better shift without their chronic complaining, drama, and lack of productivity sucking all the energy and joy out of the department. Tolerated for too long, such behavior can breed contempt for leadership that will eventually morph into a contagion that spreads throughout the team. As the work environment deteriorates, talented staff members will be more likely to evaluate all their practice options and move on.

As documented by Ricciotti, people who engage in uncivil behavior are irritating, rude, and have low emotional intelligence. However, even the worst offenders stop short of making people feel humiliated, vulnerable, or threatened. And when bad behavior crosses the line from chronic incivility to bullying, the consequences can be more severe than a damaged departmental culture and brand. To respond effectively, perioperative leaders must understand the distinction.

 

Disruptive vs destructive

Both bullying and chronic incivility present as disrespectful, demeaning, egocentric, self-serving, or otherwise disruptive behavior. The difference is that uncivil behavior is rarely destructive (sidebar, Bullying versus incivility: Distinguishing characteristics).

Incivility is the result of ignorance, poor life-skills, weak personal boundaries, and the depletion of appropriate coping mechanisms. In contrast, bullying is a form of abuse, described by The Joint Commission in 2016 as behavior that is aggressive, ongoing, and deliberate.

Like all abusive behaviors, bullying is about power, often taking the form of a long-term campaign to undermine a colleague or even a manager. All abusive behaviors, from bullying to domestic, elder, and child abuse, also follow a predictable cycle: an event followed by a period of remorse and promises of reform.

As depicted in the graphic on this page, the abuser becomes repentant and overly kind for a time, but this reformed conduct cannot be sustained. Eventually, the abuser becomes triggered, and another incident happens. It is vital to understand that the bully is incapable of sustaining any stated guarantee of reform and will repeatedly resist responsibility for their actions by insisting the onus lies elsewhere.

Source: Quinlan, P. Used with permission.

Due diligence

Allegations of bullying should be treated the same as a sharp’s exposure: Immediate action is required. Instances of chronic incivility demand prompt action as well. Regardless, adhering to the following recommendations can increase the likelihood of a positive result.

• Seek support. Never attempt to manage the situation alone. First, form an alliance with administration and HR. Have a second person with you for any meetings that involve obtaining a statement or issuing a disciplinary action. Follow HR’s recommendations on having a representative for the staff members as well. If your organization has coaching or mentoring resources, or an employee assistance program, make a referral.

• Document everything. A standardized format can help ensure thoroughness and objectivity. For example, when collecting initial statements after an incident, consider the five ‘Ws’: Who was present, what transpired, why did it happen, where did the event take place, and when did the event take place?

• Adhere to any collective bargaining agreements.

• Be persistent. Managing bad behavior is likely to be time-consuming, arduous work, but staying the course is essential. A critical record of whether the behavior continues despite repeated coaching, counseling, retraining in performance standards, a performance improvement plan, progressive discipline, or whatever other remedies could require months of documentation.

Whatever the nature of the problematic behavior, thorough documentation and organizational support help mitigate risk—and not just for the organization. A true bully’s skill in using plausible deniability, playing the victim, and playing one entity off another could misrepresent a leader’s intent, potentially ruining their reputation and career (sidebar, Masterful manipulators). In less extreme cases, it can be important to demonstrate that terminating the employee was a last resort.

With a foundation of due diligence established, the right approach depends on whether the offending activity constitutes bullying or redeemable (if uncivil) behavior.

 

Strategies for bullying behavior

Penny and Spector submit that disruptive behaviors associated with bullying are often closely aligned with the mentality and noxious temperament of a narcissist in action. I could not agree more (sidebar, Masterful manipulators). Narcissists form relationships based on usefulness, not a sense of human connection. Once someone is no longer useful, they’re ignored.

This mindset can make it impossible for bullies to demonstrate progressive, sustained improvement in their behavior or work performance. As detailed in the next section, developing emotional intelligence and embracing new behaviors begins with self-awareness. However, a narcissistic mindset—seeing oneself as special, and expecting the world to make every accommodation to appease that specialness—precludes self-awareness. A bully’s inability to take ownership of their behavior will compel them to insist that an outside force was responsible for the repeated or new behavior.

Nonetheless, bullies should be offered every available resource, including training in emotional intelligence, anger management, communication, and reviews of organizational policies. The bully may decline help, and they may even leave voluntarily. If their exit is involuntary, ongoing documentation can prove to any third parties that the decision was preceded by months of failed compliance and/or refusal to accept offered support. In the meantime, perioperative leaders should keep the following tips in mind:

• Anticipate a retaliatory response from the bully, particularly if interventions involve a performance improvement plan (PIP) or disciplinary action. Some will use every nagging, manipulative tool, and threat in their arsenal to sabotage you and influence the people you report to. In the OR, a common practice among bullies is soliciting the help of a surgeon by arguing that replacing them will reduce efficiency or negatively impact clinical outcomes. Anticipate this concern and be ready with a plan to ensure the surgeon of a smooth transition if necessary.

• Prepare for public confrontation, particularly if a bully’s efforts to convince you they can change fall flat. They are driven to showcase themselves as a victim of your bullying. Cognitive rehearsal for such events may be needed. Practice a few professional replies that are clear but do not lend fuel to the fire. For example, say you are confronted with the statement, “You’ve always been out to get me.” Simply say, “I’m sorry you feel that way,” then walk away before you get baited into a melodrama in front of the staff.

• Be mindful of your own needs throughout the intervention process. Bulllies will try to wear you down. Self-care can go a long way toward maintaining your resolve in the face of their relentless pushback.

 

Strategies for chronically uncivil behavior

The chronically uncivil are perpetually irritating and distracting, but not abusive or manipulative. This important difference implies there is potential for the uncivil staff member to benefit from a well-thought-out approach for remediation.

For example, training in emotional intelligence requires a level of personal commitment that a true bully is less likely to embrace. Developing emotional intelligence requires the awareness to lean into habitual ways of thinking and behaviors that are self-sabotaging. From there, success depends on accepting ownership for one’s own behavior and developing the self-discipline to respond to personal triggers more appropriately.

Developing one’s emotional intelligence is akin to chewing on glass—acknowledging past indiscretions and resolving to do better can be painful and agonizing. Leaders can help by offering formal and informal feedback. Acknowledging small gains can help the staffer build the energy to continue the personal work they need to improve.

Source: Quinlan, P. Used with permission

Long-term solution: A culture of civility and citizenship

Organizations cannot afford to bleed talent. Therefore, the leadership imperative for the 21st century is to create and sustain a work culture that fosters civility, citizenship, and growth. This culture of civility is built not by a department’s employees, but by its citizens—citizens invested in offering their personal best each day. Staff members are resilient. They lean in, and they dare to grow.

Fostering such a culture requires leadership with the courage to insist on nothing less than civility. It also requires understanding that in the modern era, achieving success in a caring profession like perioperative nursing requires more than academic preparation and strong clinical skills. Supporting the growth of the whole person is vital.

To that end, consider weaving ongoing emotional intelligence training as an essential part into your annual professional development offerings. Also consider rethinking how you interview and select potential team members. For example, you might include a combination of behavioral and clinical questions. Yes, it is important to get a sense of the candidate’s ability to do the job, but it is more important to have a level of comfort that their onboarding will lend an added dimension of humanism and solidarity to your team.

 

—Phyllis S. Quinlan, PhD, RN, NPD, has practiced nursing as a staff nurse, educator, nurse executive, and internal coach in a variety of clinical settings. Her full-service consulting firm, established in 1994, specializes in executive coaching, leadership development, and personal coaching. As a legal nurse consultant specializing in defense, she is a frequent keynote/plenary speaker, published author, and social media influencer on issues addressing nursing practice, nursing support staff, and risk management.

 

References

Incivility, bullying, and workplace violence. American Nurses Association (ANA). July 22, 2015.

Ricciotti N. Emotional Intelligence and Instigation of Workplace Incivility in a Business Organization. Walden University Scholar Works. 2016.

Hershcovis M S, Reich T C, Niven K. Workplace bullying: causes, consequences, and intervention strategies. Society of Industrial and Organizational Psychology. 2015.

Kacel E L, Ennis N, Pereira D B. Narcissistic Personality Disorder in Clinical Health Psychology Practice: Case Studies of Comorbid Psychological Distress and Life-Limiting Illness. Behav Med. July-September, 2017.

Quinlan P. Bringing shadow behavior into the light of day: understanding and effectively managing bullying and incivility in healthcare. Louisville: Professional Woman Publishing. 2018.

 

Resources

AACN Standards for Establishing and Sustaining Healthy Work Environments: A Journey to Excellence 2nd edition. American Association of Critical Care Nurses. 2016.

Garcia M G, Allen S, Griffis L, et al. Incorporating a Civility Program Into a Healthcare System: Journey or Expedition? Clinical Nurse Specialist. July-August 2021.

How carewashing alienates employees. Harvard Business Review. June 10, 2024.

Pfeifer L E, Vessey J A. An Integrative Review of Bullying and Lateral Violence Among Nurses in Magnet® Organizations. Policy Politics & Nursing Practice. August 2017.

Protect Yourselves, Protect Your Patients. American Nurses Association.

Stoddard J. Civility Matters: Overcoming workplace incivility using an interactive education intervention. University of New Mexico. May 8, 2017.

The Workplace Bullying Institute

The Workplace Bullying Project

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat