As healthcare strives to become an industry of high-reliability organizations, identifying problems proactively is key. ECRI Institute’s annual Top 10 Patient Safety Concerns for Healthcare Organizations list highlights looming patient safety challenges and offers resources for addressing them.
In selecting this year’s list, ECRI Institute relied on data regarding events and concerns as well as expert judgment. ECRI Institute PSO and its partner PSOs have received more than 2 million event reports since 2009. That means that the 10 patient safety concerns on this list are very real. They are causing harm—often serious harm—to real people.
Each year, at least 1 in 20 adults experiences a diagnostic error.1 Diagnostic errors have many causes. Miscommunication among providers or between providers and patients, as in cases involving failure to communicate test results, frequently plays a role.
Communication is often not the only issue. Diagnostic errors can be the result of cognitive or systemic factors, or a combination of both. Some patient safety issues are easily quantifiable, such as harm from falls, wrong-site surgery, and medication errors. Diagnostic errors, on the other hand, are challenging to measure and learn from because they often go undetected until after a patient leaves the hospital or emergency department (ED). Healthcare organizations must establish a nonpunitive culture that supports learning and open discussion as well as an ongoing quality initiative to tackle diagnostic errors throughout the organization.
The opioid epidemic has brought attention to outpatient prescriptions and illicit drugs. But the impact stretches across the healthcare continuum. Some patients overdose repeatedly, often returning to hospitals or EDs. It’s a patient safety concern because of the seriousness of the side effects, which can range from minor to serious, including respiratory depression and death.
The opioid epidemic has caused many organizations to rethink how pain is managed. Strategies include comprehensively assessing patients, using nonpharmacologic modalities and non-opioid pain medications, and accounting for patients’ individual needs, opioid tolerance, and comorbidities. Sedation scales and, for high-risk patients, continuous monitoring can help detect respiratory depression.
Today, multiple healthcare providers and specialists provide lifesaving care to patients throughout the care continuum. Poorly coordinated care puts patients at risk for preventable events like medication errors, lack of necessary follow-up care, and diagnostic delays. Communication continues to be a contributing factor in sentinel events. Indeed, a September 11, 2017, Joint Commission Sentinel Event Alert noted that inadequate handoff communication can lead to wrong-site surgery, delay in treatment, falls, and medication errors.
Checklists and safety huddles can help ensure that providers communicate effectively at every stage of a patient’s care. Communication training and leadership support are also essential. Whenever multiple providers and specialists are responsible for a patient’s treatment, care coordination will continue to be an issue that must be addressed.
Workarounds are pervasive in healthcare. They occur when staff bend work rules to circumvent or temporarily fix a real or perceived barrier or system flaw. Sometimes staff resort to workarounds when they are dealing with exceptional patient care circumstances.
ECRI Institute PSO has received numerous reports of dispensing cabinet overrides, as well as other workarounds involving technology, such as bar-code medication administration (BCMA) systems, electronic health record systems, and computerized provider order entry systems.
Fortunately, organizations can adopt strategies to minimize reliance on workarounds. Organizations should encourage staff to speak up about workarounds. Frontline staff especially may have answers to help make the process better. To foster information sharing by staff, the organization must promote an open, nonpunitive environment where staff feel at ease talking about workarounds.
For processes susceptible to workarounds, conduct a gap analysis to look at policies and processes as they are scripted, and compare them to what is really occurring. Match policy and practice by doing a “hands-on” walkthrough of the process. And, given that workarounds can occur with technology, organizations should ensure that an ongoing maintenance plan is in place for the technology to perform reliably.
A health information technology (IT) safety program can play a pivotal role in improving the safety and quality of healthcare, but its success depends on the ability of users to recognize, react to, and report health-IT-related events for analysis and action. When health IT systems are poorly designed, or when an organization’s culture fails to embrace health IT safety, patients can suffer.
Health IT can play a part in everything from selecting a wrong drug from a menu to ordering an incorrect dosage. What may seem like a medication error may have health IT implications.
To successfully implement a health IT safety program, ECRI Institute recommends focusing on three areas: integrating health IT safety into the existing safety program, collaborating with stakeholders, and embedding health IT safety into the organization’s culture.
Patients in hospitals and EDs may have behavioral health needs—whether as primary or secondary conditions. When behavioral health needs go unmet, resulting challenges can include self-harm or violence toward others, leaving against medical advice, poor behavioral health outcomes, or interference with care of the acute medical condition.
A major challenge is under-recognition of these problems. In hospitals and EDs, assessment for behavioral health needs is often inadequate. Stigma, preconceptions about patients with behavioral health needs, and lack of training in responding to those needs are common problems as well.
Hospitals and EDs can identify needs in the community served and seek creative ways to develop expertise in behavioral health. Other strategies include assessing the behavioral health needs of all patients, training staff to work with patients who have behavioral health needs, and conducting frequent drills on how to de-escalate behavioral health crises. Consider working with partners such as psychiatrists, behavioral health treatment programs, clinics, medical schools and teaching programs, and law enforcement.
The year 2017 saw major hurricanes, mass shootings, and ransomware attacks, each bringing a host of challenges for healthcare facilities. Facilities should prepare for such crises knowing it is not a matter of whether, but when, a disaster lies in their future.
Facilities should conduct a hazard vulnerability assessment (HVA) or a threat and hazard identification and risk assessment (THIRA) to systematically identify high-risk hazards such as areas that are potentially prone to power outages or computer systems that are susceptible to cyberattack. Facilities should also be ready to evacuate if the need arises, and an evacuation plan should always be in place.
Following a mass casualty event, the capacity of a hospital to treat incoming patients is essential to saving lives. Coordinated efforts between first responders and the hospital emergency service are essential, as are preparation and practice.
Most facilities conduct annual or semiannual fire drills, but active shooter drills are equally important. Facilities should participate in community-wide mass casualty drills, and active shooter or mass casualty drills at a healthcare facility should include local law enforcement.
Failure to follow proper cleaning, disinfecting, and sterilization protocols at any point can result in a compromised device—and devastating effects for patients. To avoid outbreaks of potentially deadly diseases, a proactive approach is important.
Healthcare facilities must ensure that sufficient staff and equipment are available to handle the reprocessing workload, that staff follow current guidelines and manufacturer recommendations, and that the facility’s water and environmental filtration system undergoes regular surveillance and maintenance.
Proper cleaning and disinfection of devices involves coordination and collaboration between the OR team and the central sterile processing (CSP) team. It’s important to view the CSP department as a critical part of the surgical team. Facilities can create a team environment by sending an OR nurse to CSP to observe or assist, or by having a member of CSP scrub in for a surgical procedure.
Patients have many responsibilities in managing their health. Healthcare organizations should involve patients and families in identifying, planning, and testing health literacy and patient engagement initiatives. Experts recommend taking “universal precautions” for health literacy—making all materials and discussions easy to understand.
Ways to engage patients include bedside rounds, daily goal sheets, and patient coaching. Eliciting patients’ goals and connecting them with recommended actions is a key step. If patients still do not adhere to the plan of care, investigate why. Organizations can also partner with government and community groups to tackle social determinants of health.
Leadership engagement in patient safety efforts is essential to their success. Your C-suite and/or board must be engaged intellectually and emotionally, and leaders have to be willing to listen to what you’re saying.
To build support, the patient safety, risk, or quality manager should recruit champions across the organization who can support the cause both up and down the chain of leadership. Once you’ve achieved champion buy-in, it’s important to take this with your champions to your leadership. Share stories of real-world events that have presented risk in your facility. Present crisp, on-target data that demonstrate needs for a patient safety initiative. Explain how you show value to the community you serve, and how you can enable change and ensure excellence. Leadership will also want to know what resources would be required to implement and maintain any patient safety initiative.
For this year’s list, ECRI Institute synthesized data from these sources:
• review of events in the ECRI Institute PSO database
• PSO members’ root-cause analyses and research requests
• topics reflected in weekly Healthcare Risk Control Alerts from ECRI Institute
• voting by a panel of experts from inside and outside ECRI Institute.
Most organizations know what their high-frequency, high-severity challenges are. This list identifies possible new risks, existing concerns that are changing because of new technology or care delivery models, and persistent issues that need focused attention or pose new opportunities for intervention.
Healthcare organizations can investigate whether they are experiencing these kinds of problems and whether they have processes and systems in place to address them.
The full report, which Healthcare Risk Control and ECRI Institute PSO members can access by logging in at www.ecri.org, discusses key strategies in more depth.
Adapted and reprinted with permission from ECRI Institute’s Healthcare Risk Control . This is an excerpt of the free executive brief of the Top 10 Patient Safety Concerns for Healthcare Organizations: 2018, posted on ECRI Institute’s website in March 2018. Download and view resources at www.ecri.org/patientsafetytop10. To learn more, contact ECRI Institute at by telephone at (610) 825-6000, ext. 5891, or by e-mail at clientservices@ecri.org. ✥
1Singh H, Meyer A N D, Thomas E J. The frequency of diagnostic errors in outpatient care: Estimations from three large observational studies involving US adult populations. BMJ Qual Saf 2014;23:727-731.