With tighter budgets and long lists of technology requests, organizations need a fair and systematic way to set priorities. At Virginia Mason Medical Center (VMMC) in Seattle, where Lean manufacturing principles are part of the culture, it was natural to apply Lean to the review of new surgical supplies and technology.
The existing process was more like “a speed bump to yes,” Steve Schaefer, vice president for finance, told OR Manager.
The new more robust process, which includes a more active role for physicians, also takes less time, 15 to 16 days compared to 45 days before.
Previously, new product requests were submitted using an online form to the purchasing department. The purchasing department gathered the information it could and forwarded the request to the appropriate VP, who often held the request, awaiting more information. The requesting physician would pressure the VP, who would generally say yes. The 45 days left physicians tapping their feet, and there was little coordination with other departments, such as finance.
The new process helps to build consensus among specialists and to align technology acquisitions with the organization’s goals (sidebar). Schaefer estimated the improvements will yield supply cost savings of $1 million in 2009, about 1% to 2% of its supply spend. Costs will also be avoided because of items not purchased.
VMMC, a nonprofit integrated delivery network, is a national leader for Lean in health care, having embraced the Toyota-pioneered approach to quality improvement in 2000.

“It’s the water we swim in,” Schaefer, says. Simply stated, in a Lean culture, everyone strives to eliminate waste and inefficiency. All VMMC personnel are trained in Lean, including the physician CEO Gary S. Kaplan, MD, other senior executives, and physicians. Many travel to Japan for 2 weeks to observe Lean in action.
All of the stakeholders realized product review needed improvement. Because most technology requests come from physicians, VMMC needed a way to bring them into the process.
Two major steps were to:
The oversight team, described in a report from the Health Care Financial Management Association, Engaging Physicians for Supply Chain Savings, includes not only senior executives but also the chief medical officer, medical director, and physician advisor.
The team’s role is to maximize the value of the supply chain by ensuring all materials are used effectively and processes are cost-efficient. Having physicians on the oversight team creates a sense of ownership in the supply chain, Schaefer said. Rather than being viewed as a separate department dictating policy, the supply chain “gets enterprise commitment and accountability,” he said.
The second major step was to enlist a senior orthopedic surgeon, Paul Benca, MD, as the physician advisor to serve as a bridge between the administrators and physicians.
“I can go back and forth between the camps so we have good communi-cation,” he says. His position is split between clinical and administrative duties.
Dr Benca says he can go to the physicians and ask for more information about their requests. He also brings the physicians information about costs and discusses how the purchase fits with the organization’s objectives.
“A lot of the section heads—including myself as head of the orthopedics section—weren’t even aware of products our staff members were requesting,” Dr Benca said.
“I think physicians understand the need to be good stewards. If you give them examples of what things are going to cost, they can make a better choice.”
Dr Benca has worked to break down walls between specialties to help get consensus on technology decisions. This is one improvement that came out of a rapid process improvement workshop on the product review process. The workshops, a Lean method, are short, intense projects that bring a team together to improve a process.
Three surgeons were involved in the product review workshop, along with nurses and administrative staff from radiology, cardiology, and gas-troenterology,
Improvements that helped Virginia Mason’s product review to become leaner and more robust:
More expertise was added to the product review team, including clinical experts and representatives from the finance department, chargemaster and coding units as well as purchasing and contracting. Dr Benca brings the physi-cians’ voice. VMMC’s group purchasing organization, Amerinet, lends data analysis and benchmarking expertise.
The product review team must gather complete information about the product before forwarding the request to the finance office for review.
The team encourages product trials. “We are happy to approve trials,” Dr Benca says. “Trials can be very helpful.”

“You need a breadth of people in the room,” says Schaefer. “It’s eyeopening when you realize how each section deals with its own issues.”
To make it easier for physicians to participate, VMMC sometimes shortens the workshops to 1 or 2 days rather than the usual 5 days. That’s possible, Dr Benca notes, because physicians already have a background in Lean.
He also brought together physicians from technology-intensive areas— gastroenterology, interventional radiology, and the OR—to find out what they expect from the process. They, in turn, asked their sections. He learned that physicians wanted a process that is:
Laparoscopic equipment is a popular but pricey request, particularly for general surgery, urology, and gynecology. Two recent requests had annual price tags of $100,000 with no increase in reimbursement.
To help vet these requests, Dr Benca formed an ad hoc task force of representatives from each specialty. VMMC is conducting a trial on single-incision laparoscopic surgery, new instrumentation that allows surgeons to operate through a single incision in the umbilicus.
“The questions are, ‘Is it worth what it is going to cost us? Does it really add anything?’” Dr Benca says. “We will go back after the trial to see if it makes sense to the requesters and ask them to justify the expense.”
Dr Benca plans to meet soon with the orthopedics section to review implant selection for hip and knee replacements. Part of the new approach will be to share implant costs with the physicians, which VMMC previously did not do.
Implant pricing does not seem to be an issue. “We have found through outside parties that our costs for orthopedic prostheses and cardiac implants are very competitive,” he says.
Dr Benca plans to lead a cost analysis of newer approaches to treating joints, including partial knee replacements, hip resurfacing, and newer types of implants such as ceramic-on-ceramic components.
“We are going to look at the true costs of these products with the discounts and what our payers pay,” he says. “I think that will help our physicians make intelligent choices to do what is best for patients but also try to keep the costs under control.”
Schaefer and Dr Benca stress the product review process is a work in progress.
“The whole concept behind Lean methodology is one of continuous change and improvement,” Schaefer says. “The process to eliminate waste never ends.”
Breaking down the walls among specialties for technology decisions has been a major improvement “that will pay dividends year after year,” Schaefer says.
–Pat Patterson