Providing ideal patient care is the fundamental purpose behind Adaptive Design, an innovative systems approach that engages frontline staff in problem solving and focuses on improving patient care as part of everyone’s daily work.
“More access to better care at a continually lower cost is the promise of doing Adaptive Design,” says John Kenagy, MD, a vascular surgeon who developed the concept. “It’s a self-sustaining system for designing, doing, and improving complex work within and across disciplines. It works in real time in the workplace.”
Dr Kenagy, author of the best-selling book Designed to Adapt: Leading Healthcare in Challenging Times, will be a keynote speaker at the annual OR Manager Conference, October 7-9, in Nashville, Tennessee. The book was named Healthcare Management Book of the Year by the American College of Healthcare Executives in 2011.
In addition to his clinical experience, Dr Kenagy has been a chief of surgery, a visiting scholar at Harvard Business School, Boston, clinical professor of surgery at the University of Washington, Seattle, and a faculty member of the American College of Surgeons’ course on leadership.
Dr Kenagy began thinking about a different approach to patient care when he became a patient himself. “In 1992, I fell out of a tree, broke my neck, and was totally disabled for 6 months,” he told OR Manager. What impressed him most about the care he received was having individuals commonly go the extra mile for him to be sure he got what he needed. “The system in and of itself didn’t necessarily help, and in fact could get in the way of what I needed,” he says.
When he recovered, he became regional vice president of a managed care system for several years, and then he took a year-long sabbatical at Harvard’s Kennedy School. He was invited to be a visiting scholar at Harvard Business School, and he worked with Toyota on a project to better understand the Toyota Production System.
Although Toyota has long been the poster child for Lean management systems, Dr Kenagy’s experience there took him down a different path. “I spent 2 years working directly with Toyota and discovered that the Toyota Production System is different than traditional Lean. I never did a value stream map, I never used 5S, I never did a Kaizen event, or a rapid-cycle process improvement workshop,” he says. “Lean is a great project-based process improvement approach—it’s a great process to build on. Adaptive Design is a natural extension of Lean into a more powerful system.”
The big difference between Lean and Adaptive Design, he says, is that in traditional management, you gather data, analyze it, and then use that information to implement solutions. With Adaptive Design, the data collection analysis, design, and improvement all happen as part of the everyday work. Therefore, the system captures the knowledge and creativity of frontline staff as well as management in real time. At Toyota and in Adaptive Design, improvement is not a project, Kaizen event, workshop, or huddle; it’s everyone’s work, every day.
Another way to think of it, he says, is that the traditional management approach is to “make, optimize, and sell,” whereas the Adaptive Design model is to “sense, respond, and adapt.” Adaptive Design has evolved the “center of excellence” concept into a “center of value and excellence,” or CoVE. These CoVEs begin as learning lines, or teams that are charged with developing real-time problem solving and learning. Once that capability is developed and validated, it can then be replicated and scaled within the organization to become a CoVE.
“A fundamental concept of Adaptive design is that all improvements are designed as small, rapid, fail/safe experiments,” Dr Kenagy says.
“Toyota’s great advantage is that they know they don’t know. They know that every process they design will fail because they’re human. And even if they design a perfect process, it will fail because the environment around them will change.”
The essence of Adaptive Design, he says, is to expect failure to occur and be able to adjust quickly. Having a very structured disciplined systems approach to sense, respond, and adapt creates a huge competitive advantage, he believes.
Key components of Adaptive Design for healthcare include:
• a clear, consistent, meaningful purpose (ideal patient care)
• inspirational role models within the organization to learn, lead, and teach the system
• a small, specific place within an organization to start, for example, a particular service line rather than the entire OR
• a low-risk, high-reward, replicable, scalable, reproducible system of improvement based on simple rules.
Organizations have achieved remarkable results with Adaptive Design, Dr Kenagy says. For example, a Minnesota medical-surgical unit met all Institute of Medicine safety recommendations in 6 months without the need for task forces, committee meetings, quality improvement projects, or new technology. Staff turnover decreased by 51%, and $1,700,000 was saved.
Also within 6 months, one Massachusetts hospital OR saved $625,000 in improved charge capture and supply chain management while increasing surgical volume by 16% and decreasing overtime by 14%, he notes.
Dr Kenagy believes surgery can take the lead in creating more access to more and better care at continually lower cost. His next book will develop new opportunities for leadership in creating CoVEs. Instead of moving information up the decision-making chain, he says, highly adaptive leaders are decision architects who structure their organization’s work so that people can make choices wisely and continually learn.
“They’re designing a system in which decisions will be made close to the work, much more rapidly than if they have to go up the chain of command. That’s the role of highly adaptive management,” he says. ✥
For more information, visit www.ormanagerconference.com.