According to the 2022 OR Manager Salary/Career Survey, many ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) are facing a critical shortage of surgical technologists (STs). The percentage of leaders reporting an increase in the number of ST open positions jumped from 22% in 2020 and 28% in 2021 to 42% in 2022, and nearly two-thirds (63%) had at least one open position, with 22% having three or more. In addition, more than a third (37%) reported increased ST turnover, compared to 25% in 2021 (13% in 2020), and 58% are finding it more difficult to recruit STs in the last 12 months.
“I’m hearing about shortages of STs across the country,” says Sherridan Poffenroth, CST, CRCST, FAST, a member of the board of directors for the Association of Surgical Technologists (AST). Poffenroth also works as lead ST at Spokane Valley ASC and as a per diem ST at Columbia Surgery Center, both in Spokane, Washington. Shortages are occurring in ASCs of all types of ownership.
“[The ST shortage] is as much of a problem as the nursing shortage,” says Beverly Kirchner, MSN, RN, CNOR, CASC, chief compliance officer for SurgeryDirect, LLC in Salt Lake City, Utah. “Trying to find them is almost impossible in many areas.”
The shortage has placed recruitment and retention of STs in the top tier of challenges for ASC leaders. But how did this current situation evolve?
The COVID-19 pandemic prompted many STs to leave healthcare or to work in areas outside the ASC. At the same time, the pipeline from schools to replace those leaving narrowed as enrollment decreased and student attrition increased.
Ronald Kruzel, MA, CAE, CST, FAST, executive director for ARC/STSA, which accredits education programs in surgical technology and surgical assisting in collaboration with the Commission on Accreditation of Allied Health Education Programs (CAAHEP), says, “The pandemic created a number of crises in the education community.”
One problem was the shift to online instruction, which impeded learning hands-on skills in a lab, and another was the lack of clinical sites. “Programs couldn’t offer the usual clinical
experience, so many had to go to half-enrollment over a 2-year period,” Kruzel says. “We’re just now starting to emerge from that.” Many students opted out of programs instead of waiting for clinical sites to become available. Kruzel says that over the 2-year time frame, graduation rates decreased by about 15% to 20%.
The throughput problem with STs is spilling over to throughput in the ASC. “ASCs are running with rooms shut down because of the staffing shortage,” says Rose O. Sherman, EDd, RN, MEA-BC, FAAN, a leadership expert and professor emeritus for Florida Atlantic University in Boca Raton. “Throughput is a serious issue.”
Many ASC leaders have turned to a temporary solution traditionally used with nurses—travelers. Sherman says that in recent focus groups, most ASC leaders said they are using fewer nurse travelers, but more ST travelers.
“Some [leaders] said they have to pay ST travelers more than nurse travelers,” she adds. According to VMG Health’s Multi-Specialty ASC Benchmarking Study, employee salary and wages already account for an average of 21% of ASCs’ operating expenses, so paying more for travelers is a significant financial issue.
Some ASCs are using RNs to fill in for STs, as is the case with Heartland Surgery Center in Kearney, Nebraska. “They already have the training,” says Tracy Hoeft-Hoffman, MSN, MBA, RN, CASC, administrator for the center, which has four ORs and four procedure rooms and is a partnership between CHI Health Good Samaritan and a group of healthcare providers.
Historically, the advantage of better work hours that an ASC offers was enough to entice STs, but now that is not always the case. “The work-life balance is no longer working as a recruitment tool,” says Cindy Hess, MSN, RN, FNP-C, CNAMB, director of nursing for Northeast Missouri Ambulatory Surgery Center in Hannibal. The center has two ORs, a GI room, and a procedure room, and is owned by two hospitals and an orthopedic physician group.
Some ASC leaders have turned to other options, such as recruiting students, which begins with serving as a clinical site for an ST school.
“Clinical sites are limited so allowing local colleges to use your facility is crucial,” Poffenroth says. Although some ASCs turn down requests for clinical experiences, others see it as an opportunity to mine for staff. “Having students in the ASC is an ongoing job interview,” says Kirchner. “If the student is awesome and we have a job opening, we hire them before they graduate.”
Northeast Missouri ASC serves as a clinical site for an ST program, so when she has open positions, Hess asks clinical instructors for recommendations of students who would be a good fit for the center.
“It’s been a good mutual relationship,” says Hess. “The students we hired right out of school have been great.” She hired two new graduates in the past year (one before graduation); a first in 22 years. However, she notes that students’ knowledge about sterile processing, which in the ASC is often incorporated into the ST role, tends to be weaker, so she has students rotate through the sterile processing department.
In the past, the ASC required STs to have previous OR experience, so the shift required a change in perspective. “We had to educate some of our surgeons who were resistant by explaining the need and training process, but it’s worked out well,” Hess says.
Before making the final offer, job shadowing can help ensure that the potential employees fully understand the ASC work environment. “It’s a good way to make sure you are offering a job to someone who truly wants to work there and knows what to expect,” Poffenroth says (sidebar, More recruitment strategies).
Several strategies can help retain STs, as well as other staff. Here are some strategies offered by the experts interviewed for this article:
Provide growth opportunities.
The smaller staff and flat structure in an ASC provide many opportunities for STs to grow in their careers. For example, Poffenroth likes having the ability to work in multiple specialties while also working with vendors. “I’m using all my skills,” she says.
Kirchner says giving STs more responsibility can help with their growth. For example, at some of the ASC facilities she works with, a lead ST is responsible for ordering all the implants for spine cases from the prescribed vendor. “They are excellent at it, and it takes the burden off of nurses,” she says. Another example comes from Hess—one of her STs oversees preference cards.
At The Surgery Center LLC, in Franklin, Wisconsin, which is jointly owned by Aurora Health Care and physicians who are members of Associated Medical and Surgical Specialists, LLC, each ST is assigned as the lead for a specialty. The lead is responsible for tasks such as working with vendors to obtain information about a new product in which a surgeon is interested.
“It gives surgical techs a greater sense of purpose,” says Fawn Esser Lipp, MBA, RN, CNOR, CASC, executive director for the center, which has four ORs and two GI suites. Committee work also provides growth opportunities. Hoeft-Hoffman says STs serve on quality committees and the inventory committee.
Kirchner cautions that additional roles and responsibilities should come with the ability for STs to earn some extra money and not simply add to their workload.
Support education.
“Education is one of the biggest things we do for retention,” Kirchner says. “We use different techniques and different kinds of technology so it’s not boring.” For instance, the traditional scavenger hunt for equipment and supplies has been turned into a game where staff earn points for speed and accuracy. Top earners receive their pick of a gift card.
“We’re going to see a big shift in how we educate staff” to meet the needs of younger STs (and RNs), Kirchner predicts. She is currently working with a virtual reality (VR) expert to develop VR programs for fire and disaster drills. Participants will assume an avatar and work through a scenario specific to the ASC that will test competencies. “We won’t have to disrupt our day because they can do this at home,” she says.
Another education strategy is tuition reimbursement for certification as an ST or in sterile processing and for continuing education. “Promoting education is just as important for STs as for RNs,” Esser Lipp says. Several of those interviewed mentioned the need for more education for STs, beyond vendor sponsored programs.
Create a positive work environment.
As is the case with any employee, a positive work environment, including involving staff in decisions, will help retain STs. “You need to involve employees in decisions and give them autonomy,” Esser Lipp says. At weekly meetings, staff can make suggestions that the group considers from a feasibility standpoint.
One example is the team that developed laminated “cheat sheets” to improve confidence with sterile processing procedures. Esser Lipp assigns a staff person to work alone or with a manager as the point person for a project team, and staff receive a gift card as a thank you after completion.
Poffenroth suggests managers include STs on key committees. “Often the first person asked is a nurse, but include a surgical tech as well,” she says. “You want to be sure they have a voice in the decisions you make in your facility.” One area where STs are particularly adept is infection prevention. “We are experts in it,” Poffenroth says.
“It’s important to value both the nurse and the surgical tech,” Kirchner adds. “They have to be seen as partners, and it’s leadership’s role to provide an environment that fosters that partnership.”
Simple actions can send a powerful message. For instance, at Heartland Surgery Center, everyone, including surgeons, share the same lounge. “We have a flat organizational structure and treat surgical techs as an equal part of the team,” Hoeft-Hoffman says. The smaller size of the ASC facilitates positive relationships. “Our surgeons regularly thank techs, and they know them and their families,” Hoeft-Hoffman says.
During Ambulatory Surgery Center Week, which occurs every August, the center celebrates all employees, including STs. Past events have included a coffee truck and chair massages, and last year, staff members received a rocker lawn chair as a gift. Everyone also receives a $20 gift card on their work anniversary. Leaders choose from a variety of gift cards so the reward is individualized to the recipient.
Shared fun is important too and helps build the team. For example, an ST and RN planned a trick or treat activity in the center’s parking lot. “None of these cost very much, but they help people feel recognized and part of the team,” Hoeft-Hoffman says.
“It’s not all about money,” Kirchner says. “They are looking for timely, accurate, and transparent communication. They are looking for praise, they are looking for honesty, and they are looking for flexibility” (sidebar, More retention strategies).
One factor that may be hampering efforts to recruit and retain STs is a lack of data about what works. Compared to the plethora of articles on how to recruit and retain nurses, an online search on these topics for STs yields few results. The little available research related to topics such as work engagement has been conducted in Iran.
Some organizations are “growing their own” STs by providing internal training. But internal training options come with some drawbacks. For example, some courses last as few as 12 weeks.
Kruzel at ARC/STSA says short courses such as these are inadequate. “There is a huge differentiation in knowledge base in those individuals, especially because the surgeries we are doing now are not the same as the ones we were doing even 5 years ago,” he says, noting that STs require a high level of technical expertise (sidebar, Preparing surgical technologists).
Kruzel says he understands the “panic mode” that many employers are in but cautions that organizations using short-term training solutions put themselves at legal risk. If, for instance, a patient is injured when a non-certified ST is part of the team, yet certified STs were also working in the ASC, an attorney could question why the employer did not provide qualified staff. And the bottom line is that a patient was hurt. “It’s a patient safety issue,” Kruzel says of home-grown programs.
Three other factors come into play. First, many states have specific requirements for education and certification of STs, which an organization could be in violation of with an internal program.
Second, in its position statement on delegation in perioperative practice settings, AORN notes that according to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, STs in the scrub role are under the supervision of an RN. Kruzel says this means that legal action related to patient injury could affect RNs too. (AST’s position is that the ST works under the supervision of the surgeon.)
And finally, a person who completes this type of training cannot become certified, so they cannot work at another facility in the ST role. That could be a dissatisfier for the employee and lead to turnover.
Kruzel acknowledges that most accredited ST programs are in urban and suburban areas and suggests ASCs without a local ST school reach out to their area’s community college to encourage establishing a program. If there is no local community college, another option is to partner with a school in another state.
For example, students in a rural area could complete coursework online and the local employer could offer facilities for labs and clinical experience, as well as sponsor a certain number of students. The school would only need to provide the supervisory component. This solution is currently being used in the hospital rather than the ASC setting, but a coalition of area ASCs might be able to implement it. “We are very open to dialoging with our partners in the community about solutions,” Kruzel says. “We want to make sure we have the best qualified people in the OR.”
The good news is that the ST shortage may be temporary. Kruzel is working with schools on strategies for expediting program completion. These accelerated models are similar to nursing programs that, for example, fast-track students with previous general education credits and compress schedules.
Another idea is for schools to partner with employers who are willing to sponsor students’ education so they are ready for work upon graduation. “I think we will see the shortage resolve in the next year or two, as graduations increase again,” he says.
If nothing else, the shortage has reminded leaders of the importance of the ST role. “Their contribution is huge, especially during today’s nursing shortage,” Kirchner says. “They enhance the whole team because of their specific skills.”
—Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.
AORN position statement on delegation in perioperative practice settings. AORN. 2021.
Association of Surgical Technologists. Core curriculum for surgical technology. 7th ed. 2021.
Imani B, Zandi S, Mostafayi M, et al. Presentation of a model of the work engagement in surgical technologists: A qualitative study. Periop Care Oper Room Manag. 2022;26.