December 15, 2022

Scheduling OR travel staff at a large academic institution

By: University of Pittsburgh Medical Center
Share

In 2020, the World Health Organization focused on promoting nurses to fill the anticipated need for 9 million nurses and midwives to achieve universal health coverage by 2030. The COVID-19 pandemic significantly amplified this pre-existing need.

Additionally, the “Great Resignation” has impacted technology and healthcare disproportionally, and the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center (UPMC) is no exception. UPMC has seen a 30% to 33% decline in our surgical services workforce over the past 18 months, encompassing shortages of both RNs and surgical technologists.

In order to alleviate these staff shortages, we created an institutional internal traveling RN and surgical technician program and named it the University Travel Service. As part of the program, which was initiated on January 3, 2022, traveling staff could spend 6 weeks at any given location within UPMC.

In this article, we describe our experience with integrating and scheduling travelling staff in the OR at UPMC.

 

Methods

Our data were collected from January 3, 2022, to March 11, 2022, at a single site within the UPMC system. Using the internal scheduling data, traveling staff usage over time and traveling staff scheduling trends were analyzed.

Statistical analysis was completed using the independent T-test and the Chi-squared test on the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences software (p-value of <0.05 indicates statistical significance).

Results

We analyzed 1,432 ORs during 48 weekdays; 176 ORs (13%) were staffed by either a traveling RN, traveling surgical technician, or both. From January to March, the percentage of ORs covered by travelers increased from 7.6% to 22.5% (Table 1).

Traveling staff were most frequently assigned to rooms in which cases performed were for general surgery (31.8%), orthopedic surgery (19.3%), and non-cranial neurosurgery (14.2%). Travelers were never assigned to rooms where cases performed were cardiac surgery, ophthalmic surgery, and urgent trauma surgery. Travelers also were never assigned to rooms that were not originally scheduled to be opened (Table 2).

Compared with non-travelling staff, travelling staff were statistically more likely to work in ORs being used for general surgery and orthopedic cases (Table 3). The total average case volume per day remained steady.

 

Discussion

Usage of OR traveling staff started gradually. Only 7.6% of ORs in January 2022 were staffed with a traveling RN and/or surgical technician. By March, 22.5% (p-value of 0.000) of all ORs were staffed with a traveler.

The University Travel Service was intended to increase surgical volume because, in theory, we would be maximizing the use of additional staff. However, total case volume remained the same, with an average of 29.85 ORs being used per day in January and 29.22 ORs being used per day in March. The stable OR case volume can be attributed to a persistent attrition of regular staff and the inability to schedule backlogged cases on short notice.

As stated, the University Travel Service staff primarily covered cases performed by general surgery, orthopedic surgery, and non-cranial neurosurgery. These three surgical services accounted for about 65% of all cases staffed by travelers (Table 2).

The preferential use of traveling staff in general and orthopedic surgery is due to their familiarity with these common types of procedures. Subspecialty training may be necessary for services such as cardiac surgery, which members of the traveling staff may or may not have. OR staff directors even reported instances in which travelers requested relief from a particular assignment because they were not comfortable with the complexity of the given case.

 

Conclusion

Staffing shortages across the US have caused ORs to decrease surgical service time and to even shut down. Employing traveling RNs and surgical technicians can help alleviate this strain.

At UPMC, usage of traveling staff increased from January 2022 to March 2022. Traveling staff preferentially worked in ORs with general surgery and orthopedic cases. However, due to a combination of factors, average OR case volume remained unchanged for the duration of the University Travel Service program.

 

—This case study from the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center is authored by Wu Yin, MD, MBA; Justine Kim, MD; Kim Mignona, BS; Anita Soltez, BSN; Jason Miller, BSN; Ave Perrino, BSN; Shawn Beaman, MD; Kimberly Cantees, MD, MBA; and Mark Hudson, MD, MBA.

 

References

Cook I. Who is driving the Great Resignation? Harvard Business Review. September 15, 2021.

Year of the nurse and the midwife 2020. World Health Organization (WHO) Campaigns. April 2020.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat