August 22, 2017

ASCs struggle to match staffing to demand

By: Cynthia Saver, MS, RN
Share

Hiring experienced staff remains a challenge for leaders in ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) even as many organizations increase case volume and specialties, according to the 2017 annual OR Manager Salary/Career Survey.

More than two-thirds (67%) of respondents said that recruiting experienced RNs had become more difficult in the past 12 months, up from 56% in 2016.

The same is true for surgical technologists (STs), with 55% reporting more recruitment difficulties, up from 36% last year.

Recruitment challenges exist in an environment where the number of open positions is higher for many leaders. Nearly a third (29%) said that open positions had increased in the past 12 months for RNs, with 23% reporting an increase for STs.

Nearly half (48%) of ASC leaders reported increased surgical volume in the past 12 months, down from 56% in 2016, but still significant. The increase may be attributable in part to a spike in specialties: 42% of respondents said the number of specialties had increased in the past 12 months, compared with just 26% in 2016.

Other key staffing findings from the survey include:

• More than half (53%) of ASCs now have an electronic health record, with 10% planning to implement one in the next 12 months.

• Turnover rates were comparable to those of last year. Most respondents said turnover had remained the same over the past 12 months (59% for RNs and 69% for STs). However, that good news is offset by continued reports of increased turnover for both RNs and STs.

• Only 6% said recruiting experienced RNs or STs had become easier in the past 12 months, and only 23% found it easier to recruit new or inexperienced OR nurses.

• Only 6% are considering a merger or a sale within the next year, and 17% are unsure of their plans.

 

About the ASC

Most respondents (36%) work in physician-owned ASCs, followed by joint venture (28%), hospital owned (23%), and corporate/LCC (9%). In all, 28% work in a single-specialty ASC.

The top three specialties among these respondents were the same as in 2016: ophthalmology (33%), orthopedics (20%), and gastroenterology (15%).

Among those working in multispecialty ASCs, the top three specialties were general orthopedics (87%), general surgery (76%), and otolaryngology (75%), followed by cosmetic/plastic surgery (72%) and ophthalmology (70%).

Only 3% said the number of specialties had decreased, with more than half (55%) reporting no change.

 

All about staffing

ASC leaders continue to make staffing adjustments to meet work and financial demands. Many (42%) hired more direct care staff, and 41% reduced use of overtime, up from 23% in 2016.

Turnover remains a concern for ASC leaders, with percentages nearly the same as last year. Over the past 12 months, 30% (the same as 2016) saw an increase in RN turnover, and 18% had higher ST turnover (vs 19% in 2016).

Similarly, the survey found little difference in the number of open RN and ST positions for 2017 vs 2016. More than half (52%) reported they had no open positions for STs, with 44% reporting the same for RNs. A small percentage (10% for RNs and 6% for STs) had five or more open positions.

The skill mix of RNs to STs is 59% to 40%, consistent with findings from 2016 and 2015.

Challenges

When asked about their biggest challenges, responses from ASC leaders fell largely into two familiar categories: staffing and finances. Here is a summary of comments from more than 100 respondents.

 

Staffing

Nearly a third of ASC leaders called staffing their top challenge.

Recruitment. Several respondents are finding it hard to hire experienced staff, particularly RNs.

Retention. A key factor in retaining staff is engagement, and many participants reported problems in this area, as well as general staff dissatisfaction. Sample comments reflecting this challenge include:

• keeping staff engaged

• having poor staff morale because of no raises

• lacking continuity because of staff turnover

• educating and retaining quality staff.

In addition to recruitment and retention, a few participants worry about balancing staff. For example, one respondent cited “finding RNs and the right staffing model that does not burn out my staff” as a challenge, and another said, “finding the perfect balance for staffing, per diem vs part time/full time.”

 

Finances

Money was on the mind of many ASC leaders.

Volume. Volume drives revenue, and nearly one-fourth of respondents listed increased case volume as one of their challenges. Some said they were striving to boost volume, and others indicated they’re already coping with higher volumes.

Unfortunately, a few said they were struggling with lower caseloads, and one respondent noted the difficulty of “maintaining profitability in light of the decrease in surgery volume.”

Reimbursement. Fifteen ASC leaders cited concerns about decreased reimbursement, and many respondents overall said they were working to reduce costs.

Regulatory requirements and electronic health implementation were also noted as difficult areas to manage. Several respondents cited more than one challenge.

For example, one respondent described the biggest challenge as “keeping staff engaged in doing more with less as volume increases and cases become more complex in the ASC,” whereas another simply said, “too many to list.”

 

Looking ahead

ASC leaders have many challenges to face as changes in healthcare continue to evolve. It will require all of their skills to keep the ASC on a steady course of profitability and maintain the satisfaction of their physicians, staff, and patients. ✥

Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.

 

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat