Imagine this scenario in your ambulatory surgery center (ASC): A husband and wife in their early 80s arrive for the husband’s knee replacement surgery. His wife will drive him home after surgery, and their daughter will arrive from out of state the next day to help at home while he convalesces.
The discharge instructions involve multiple medications, durable medical equipment, and a continuous passive motion machine. The daughter has asked her parents to record the discharge instructions on their cell phone. However, the ASC has a policy of no cell phones in pre- or postoperative patient areas.
The ASC nurse assures the patient and his wife that they will get the discharge instructions in writing, and they can call the ASC if they have questions. But they insist on recording.
What should the ASC do? Can the ASC meet the patient’s request while protecting other patients’ privacy in perioperative areas?
As mobile devices increasingly become extensions of ourselves, ASCs must grapple with the potential for violations of patient privacy, distractions, and increased hazard and complication risks.
“My concern is that one patient innocuously recording his or her experience may pick up a video image of another patient walking by or audio of another patient’s protected health information,” says attorney William Miller, a partner at Higgs Fletcher & Mack LLP in San Francisco.
Miller and Debra Stinchcomb, MBA, BSN, RN, CASC, an ASC management consultant at Progressive Surgical Solutions in Poway, California, presented on mobile device usage in the ASC at the 2017 ASCA annual meeting.
“There’s not a lot of good that can come from cell phones in a healthcare setting. The risks far outweigh the benefits,” Miller says. “Unless the law in your state allows it, my overriding counsel is, ‘just say no,’” Miller says.
A legal case in Reston, Virginia, brought the issue of patient privacy rights dramatically to light—or, in this case, YouTube. After recording discharge instructions, a male endoscopy patient left his cell phone recording device on. During the procedure, his phone recorded a conversation between the anesthesiologist, surgeon, and medical assistant in which the anesthesiologist made several mocking and derogatory comments about the patient. She also placed a false hemorrhoid diagnosis in his chart.
“After five minutes of talking to you in preop,” the anesthesiologist said to the sedated patient, “I wanted to punch you in the face and man you up a little bit.” This was just one of the disparaging comments. Others can be heard on YouTube, as long as the patient chooses to post the audio recording.
The patient sued for defamation and malpractice and received a $500,000 settlement.
“In 20 years of working in ASCs, I have never heard anyone in an OR act that unprofessionally, even without a recording device,” says Stinchcomb. “It’s a sensationalistic, one-off case, but it made us all consider how to address the clinical and legal ramifications of mobile device use in the ASC.”
Another case made headlines when a female patient sued Torrance Memorial Medical Center in Southern California for breaching her privacy rights. The patient was a medical assistant at the hospital, and while she was sedated, the anesthesia provider decorated her face with a black mustache and teardrops under her left eye. The nurse’s aide took a photo. Although the plaintiffs denied it, some witnesses reported seeing the photo posted on social media.
The patient’s attorney filed a complaint in California Superior Court, and the patient sued for monetary damages. The verdict is unknown, but the staff involved were disciplined, and the medical center spent significant money on its legal defense and licensing claims.
Indeed, fines for breaching the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act are significant, ranging from $100 to $50,000 for a first violation and about $1.5 million for a second violation. “Even if it is one patient violating another patient’s privacy with a recording device, the ASC could be responsible for creating an environment in which this was allowed,” Miller says.
Some patients are litigious and will try to hide recording devices so they can catch something for which they can sue, said Stinchcomb. Although this rarely happens, Stinchcomb recalls a case in which a female patient tried to hide a recording device in her hair extensions.
Pam Hooper, BSN, recalls a similar incident with a breast biopsy patient. Hooper is owner and administrator of Consultants in Healthcare, LLC, which developed and manages four ASCs in Little Rock, Arkansas. “We were suspicious from the start because she told her nurse the wrong breast, and then acted like it was just a mistake,” Hooper says. “Then she wanted the procedure performed on her gurney, not the OR table. It was because she hid her iPad underneath her so she could record audio of the procedure.”
Miller and Stinchcomb say it is imperative that ASCs develop written policies and procedures for mobile device use at their facilities and educate patients, staff, and physicians on these requirements (sidebar, p 33).
“Some ASCs ‘encourage’ limits on mobile devices, but do not have written policies,” Stinchcomb says. “I don’t advise this. Clearly there is not an effective compliance level when just encouraging.”
At the Little Rock ASCs, mobile device policies are located in the employee policy and procedures manual and are posted throughout the facilities. Patients are informed about the no mobile device policy during the preoperative phone call so that there are no surprises. Employee phones must be in silent mode at all times. They can use their phones on breaks and at lunch.
“We got on this issue right away,” Hooper says. “If I see an employee with a cell phone in a patient care area, I’ll give them one warning. After that, I take their phone and keep it in my office. Generally it doesn’t take more than once for that to stop.
“Somehow we all managed our lives before cell phones. If any staff member needs to be reached, their families can call the ASC front desk,” she says.
To ensure patient compliance with the mobile device policy, Hooper says, patients must show their device is turned off before entering the patient care area. The only exception to mobile device use in the perioperative suite is if a procedure has been delayed. “We occasionally let patients read on their devices while they wait,” she notes.
Another exception may be cases like the octogenarian couple who insisted on recording discharge instructions for their daughter. Is there an argument that this is a legitimate use for cell phones and other recording devices in the ASC?
“In this case, I recommend using a private room where no other patients can be heard or seen,” Miller says. “And then make sure the phone is turned off and out of the patient care area during surgery.”
Even though it’s best to anticipate these situations in advance, requests to record discharge instructions are trending upward, according to Miller. In fact, legislation was introduced, but did not pass, in Wisconsin and Massachusetts to allow patient recording. In Indiana, the National Medical Malpractice Advocacy Association is promoting a similar bill, he notes.
“It’s not that I’m dead set against all mobile devices at an ASC,” Miller says. “I’m against the careless use of mobile devices without considering the ramifications. We need to pick and choose when it is appropriate and set limits.”
More data are becoming available about the association between mobile device use in the perioperative setting and increased distractions. Also negatively impacted are cognitive skills such as reaction time, focus, and performance of tasks requiring concentration and decision making.
Research at an Australian hospital demonstrated that each interruption to medical care workflow by a mobile device was associated with a 12.1% increase in procedural failures and a 12.7% increase in clinical errors.
A 2010 study of perfusionists showed that 55.6% of 439 perfusionists admitted that they used a cellular phone while working. Of the 439, 49.2% said they had sent text messages while performing a cardiopulmonary bypass, 7.3% admitted that the cell phone negatively impacted their performance, and 33.7% said they observed another perfusionist distracted by the cell phone. Also, 21% reported accessing email, 15% used the Internet, and 3.1% were on social networking sites during procedures.
“If we don’t want people driving their car and texting, why is it ever permissible that someone on the OR team is texting?” Miller asks. “When something bad happens and we’re preoccupied, and the patient ends up with an anoxic brain injury, a jury will not be looking favorably at the ASC.”
Miller described one legal case of a 17-year-old male undergoing surgery. While on his cell phone, the anesthesiologist administered epinephrine instead of Decadron. The patient coded and was transferred to an inpatient facility. He recovered, but was awarded more than $100,000 in damages.
John Halamka, MD, MS, chair of the US Healthcare Information Technology Standards Panel and chief information officer of Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston, discussed the case of a medical resident who was distracted by a text message she received on her smart phone.
She forgot to stop an anticoagulation medication for a postoperative patient. On the patient’s fourth day in the hospital, his heart began racing, and he was gulping for air. Blood had filled the sack around the heart because he had received too much blood thinner. He was rushed into emergency open-heart surgery and survived.
“These cases perfectly illustrate why staff and physician mobile devices should be banned in patient care areas,” Stinchcomb says. “ASCs constantly have to ask themselves, ‘Is a cell phone worth the risk of a medical error?’”
A 2011 study at Ain Shams University Children’s Hospital in Cairo, Egypt, revealed patient phones carry more pathogens than those of healthcare workers (39.6% to 20.6%), and the pathogens on the phones are more drug resistant. These pathogens include Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, Escherichia coli, Klebsiella, high-level aminoglycoside-resistant Enterococcus, and carbapenem-resistant Acinetobacter baumannii.
”In a sterile environment, never pick up your cell phone,” Stinchcomb says. “The phone is a wonderful breeding ground for pathogens. It’s warm, and we hold it close to the mouth, face, and skin.”
If hand-held devices are allowed in perioperative areas, Stinchcomb says AORN recommendations should be followed. For example, clean the device with a low-level disinfectant according to the manufacturer’s instructions, both before and after being in the perioperative setting.
Also add mobile device cleansing to hand hygiene posters, focus on hand hygiene when teaching patients about postoperative care, and add mobile device usage into hand hygiene surveillance, she says.
Although uncommon, the electromagnetic fields emitted from mobile devices could interfere with anesthesia machines, cardiac monitors, and alarms. Even less common is a device causing a spark and a patient sustaining burns, Miller says.
But if a plaintiff’s attorney can establish the injuries would not otherwise occur in the absence of negligence related to the use of the mobile device, the burden of proof could shift from the plaintiff (patient) to the defendant (ASC) in a legal determination known as res ipsa loquitur.
“You can bet a very good plaintiff’s attorney is going to say that a fire like this would not have occurred in the absence of someone’s negligence around the mobile device,” Miller says. “This is exactly where res ipsa loquitur would apply, and now the burden of proof shifts to the defendant. That’s not a scenario you want to be in.
“If you say no to mobile devices in the first place, then you don’t have to spend money on lawyers defending you in a civil case.” ASCs are in the business of providing high-quality healthcare, not paying lawyers.” ✥
Leslie Flowers is president of Flowers Communications in Indianapolis, Indiana.
Al-Mudares, et al. Mobile phone contamination by microorganisms in health facilities: Comparing health care workers and patient visitors in a postoperative pediatric IUC. Inquiries. 2012;4(8):1.
Gill, P, et al. Distraction: An assessment of smartphone usage in the health care work settings. Risk Management in Healthcare Policy. 2012;5:105-114.
Stinchcomb, D, Miller, W. Smart Phone Usage in the ASC by Patients/Patient Representatives, Staff, and Physicians. Presented at ASCA 2017.