July 13, 2017

Diverse workforce a boon, not a burden

By: Judith M. Mathias, MA, RN
Share

Generational diversity issues in the workplace have never been more present or more complex. As many as six generations are now working side by side, and a great generational shift is underway. At one end of the spectrum, the workforce is aging, while at the other end, it is getting younger. In the middle, there is a gap, with the prime age workforce shrinking as an overall percentage of the workforce.

Understanding this phenomenon and the forces that influence workers’ attitudes and behaviors can spell success for managers at any level of their careers. Although some OR leaders may think they know a lot about generational differences, many still struggle with how to manage staff with widely varying ages and values systems. In part, that’s because they believe some of the myths that have evolved about characteristics associated with each generation. But by abolishing those myths and replacing them with fresh insights, generational diversity can become an opportunity rather than a burden.

 

‘Epic turning point’

Bruce Tulgan

“This generational shift is the post-baby boomer shift that demographers and workforce planners have been predicting for decades,” says Bruce Tulgan, founder of RainmakerThinking, Inc, a research, training, and consulting firm in New Haven, Connecticut (http://rainmakerthinking.com/). “It is not only a generational shift in the numbers in the workforce, but it is an epic turning point.”

Bruce TulganTulgan, whose team has been tracking generational change in the workplace for 24 years, says this shift is affecting all members of the workforce, including employers, workers, leaders, managers, and supervisors.

“Our research shows it’s getting harder to manage people,” he says. “It’s harder because the workplace is becoming more high pressure and more high maintenance.”

Examination of today’s increasingly high-maintenance workforce cannot be done without looking at the multiple generations working side by side, says Tulgan.

They include:

• Silent generation: This is the oldest, most experienced generation of workers. They were born before 1946 and make up 0.5% of the workforce.

• Baby boomers: These workers were born between 1946 and 1964 and make up 27% of the workforce. Baby boomers came in two waves. The first wave, born between 1946 and 1954, makes up 11% of the workforce. The second wave, born between 1955 and 1964, makes up 16% of the workforce.

• Generation X (Gen X): This group was born between 1964 and 1978 and makes up more than 27% of the workforce.

• Millennials: These workers were born between 1978 and 2000 and make up more than 44% of the workforce. Millennials are split into two groups. The first wave, born between 1978 and 1989, makes up a little over 17% of the workforce. The second wave, born between 1990 and 2000, already makes up 17% of the workforce.

Tulgan noted that the millennials will be “the most high-maintenance workforce in the history of the world and also the highest performing workforce.”

 

Generational differences

Though there have always been different generations working side by side, there are three things that are different about generational change in the workplace today, says Tulgan.

 

The numbers problem

The numbers problem “in a nutshell,” says Tulgan, is that the workforce is aging.

Each day in North America alone, 8,000 to 10,000 baby boomers turn 65.

“The grownups are leaving,” he says, “and they are taking with them their collective skill, knowledge, wisdom, institutional memory, relationships, and the last vestiges of the old-fashioned work ethic.”

By 2020:

• Baby boomers will be less than 20% of the workforce.

• The pre-baby boomers will be gone from the workforce.

• Less than 6% will be first-wave baby boomers, and a dwindling percentage will be second-wave boomers.

• Second-wave millennials will be 24% and will outnumber all the baby boomers.

An easy way to remember the numbers problem, says Tulgan is to remember 20, 20, 20, 20. By 2020, baby boomers will be less than 20%, and second-wave millennials will be more than 20%.

This has huge implications for the whole range of human capital management strategy, for leadership, and for day-to-day management, he says.

For those at the oldest end of the spectrum, the issues are succession planning, which includes not only knowledge transfer but also wisdom transfer, which is harder to replace.

For those at the youngest end, the issues include staffing strategy, attraction, selection, onboarding, training to get up to speed, performance management, rewards, and incentives.

However, says Tulgan, the number one strategic issue in the world of nursing at both ends of the spectrum is retention.

At the oldest end, the problem is “how to get the grownups to stick around,” he says. Tulgan refers to this as “flexible retention,” or “please don’t leave, but if you do, you can still come back.”

On the youngest end, the retention issue is somewhat different. He calls it the “development-investment paradox.” Managers who hire young workers have to develop them so they can use their technical skills in the real world.

However, the more they develop them, the more valuable these workers become, and the more valuable they are, the greater the danger of selling the manager’s development investment to the highest bidder.

All of these issues are affected by the numbers problem, notes Tulgan. “There is a great demographic tidal wave underway in the workforce, and it has huge implications for the whole range of human capital management strategy, planning, and execution.”

 

The seniority system

The second big change in the workplace today is that there used to be a simple way of sorting out generational differences. “It was called the seniority system,” says Tulgan. “The more experienced people were in charge, and it worked like a charm.”

In the past, he says, new employees didn’t show up on day 1 making demands of their managers. They showed up, paid their dues, and climbed the ladder.

That old system has been breaking down for decades, however, and it’s not because young people are “a bunch of disloyal upstarts,” he says. “It’s because of broad, profound changes in the employer/employee relationship and broad changes in the economy.”

Nobody trusts the system to take care of them in the long term, least of all the youngest, inexperienced people, he says, which is why they look to their immediate managers to take care of them in the short term.

Unfortunately, Tulgan points out, many managers and supervisors have not found a way to replace that long-term hierarchical logic with a new logic of leadership that fits with the constant change and uncertainty in today’s environment.

 

Older, younger interchange

The third big thing that is different is that the older, more experienced people used to look at the younger, less experienced people and assume they would settle down as they grew older, and at some point would become like them, says Tulgan.

However, he notes, every so often in history, that doesn’t happen. Things change so much, so fast that the older people become more like the younger people, instead of the other way around, and this is one of those times.

Everyone is being affected in profound ways by globalization technology, he says. Institutions are in a state of constant flux because they have to be. There’s an information tidal wave that provides more information in a day than everyone working together in the past could have mastered in a lifetime.

Older workers have begun thinking about their lives and careers in ways similar to those of younger workers. For example, he says, older workers are now choosing what’s best for themselves and their families instead of what’s best for the organization. They are thinking more along the lines of: “I’m with you, kid. I don’t want to work on Thursdays, either, and I’ve been here 30 years.”

Tulgan says he first stumbled onto these changes in the early 1990s, when many young Gen Xers were entering the workplace. Older, more experienced workers described Gen Xers as people who had a short attention span, didn’t want to work early, wanted everything their own way, and wanted everything immediately.

To see if this change was just about the Gen Xers being young or something else, Tulgan and his team began studying this generation closely. They found that half of their actions were because they were young, but the other half, he says, “was the result of what happens when the natural, developmental life stages everyone goes through intersect with accidents of history.”

Gen Xers entered the workplace in the late 1980s and early 1990s, when the first waves of restructuring and reengineering were occurring and unemployment was at record lows because of the.com boom. By the time the first-wave millennials entered the workplace in the 2000s, everything was changing. The.com bubble was bursting, and they were faced with career delays that kept them stuck in place.

As they started to get a little bit of momentum around 2006 to 2008, the recession hit. Now they are just starting to get some steam again, but they are no longer the youngest.

The new young workforce is the second-wave millennials, which are like the first-wave millennials on “fast-forward with self-esteem,” says Tulgan.

In some ways, the second-wave millennials, who grew up in the 2000s during an era of war, terrorism threats, environmental cataclysm, and economic uncertainty, are similar to children of the 1930s, says Tulgan. The difference, he says, is that second-wave millennials have been raised by “helicopter parents on steroids,” and they have learned to think and communicate attached to a handheld “supercomputer” (ie, cell phone). This, he says, is why they seem like “a new species of superhuman from another planet.”

 

Profiles of second-wave millennials

After talking to many managers about second-wave millennials, Tulgan says, his team has found they comprise nine different profiles that fall into two basic categories.

The first category is made up of young people who keep their heads down, keep their mouths shut, do as they are told, don’t make demands, don’t make suggestions, and don’t even make requests. They’re trying to stay below the radar.

Managers might hire such workers because they seem low maintenance, and they remind managers of themselves 20 or 30 years ago. However, Tulgan advises not hiring these “way station” employees. They take the job because it’s the best they can do at that time, and they will soak up a lot of resources while they figure out what they really want to do.

The second category is made up of young people who are engaged in the profession, and are excited about getting started as soon as they walk through the door. These individuals will be high maintenance, but they are the ones to hire, he says.

First and foremost, second-wave millennials have great expectations for themselves. “They want to make an impact with their name on it, and they want to start building themselves up using your resources,” says Tulgan. Specifically, they want to identify problems that nobody else has identified, solve problems that nobody else has solved, invent new things, and make existing things smarter, faster, and better.

Though many believe second-wave millennials won’t do “grunt” work, that is not true, says Tulgan. “They will do the grunt work, and will do it very well, very fast, and with a great attitude all day long.”

There are two catches, however:

• They will not do the grunt work or anything else in exchange for vague promises about long-term rewards that may or may not manifest in the distant future.

“The second-wave millennials are onto something here,” says Tulgan. In a highly uncertain world, it makes less sense to think about the long term and hierarchical relationships. It makes much more sense to think about the short term and transactional relationships.

“It’s not because they’re disloyal, and it’s not because they have short attention spans,” he says. ‘It’s because they are plugged into the profound uncertainty of today’s world, and they’ve never known it any other way.”

• They will not do the grunt work or anything else if they start to fear that nobody’s keeping score or nobody’s keeping track.

“These young people have grown up during a time when you can keep track of everything, whether it’s number of steps or number of friends, so they like to keep score,” says Tulgan. “The idea that they want everything on a ‘silver platter’ is wrong, and that thinking leads older, more experienced workers and managers in the wrong direction of how to work with them,” he says.

They just want to know what they need to do to earn enough points to get something else that they want, like days off or a better shift, and they want to know how to score those points and who is keeping track of those points.

“That’s how they think, and that is the new logic, and that is how you drive discretionary performance to longer-term retention with this group,” says Tulgan.

 

Hit the ground running

Second-wave millennials see themselves as valuable, says Tulgan. They think they are valuable because they don’t know about the learning curve. They have a handheld supercomputer that supercharges their abilities and shortens their learning curve, he explains.

They also think they are valuable because they are, he says. They have tremendous self-confidence. They will not want to sit tight and get a feel for a place for a couple years before anyone starts taking them seriously. They want to hit the ground running. They want to do things in a month that in the past took a couple of years for someone to do proficiently.

This makes them high maintenance because they require a lot of support. But the fact that they want to hit the ground running is valuable, he says.

One of the biggest myths about today’s young people is that somehow, they want to be humored. They do not want to be humored; they want to be taken seriously, and that takes strong leadership, says Tulgan.

It takes a strong leader to teach new leaders how to lead and followers how to follow. “No one teaches young people how to follow anymore,” says Tulgan.

To do this, managers have to create an environment of self-building in which young people can learn marketable skills that are not just technical but also transferable.

They need an environment where they can learn experience, context, and wisdom from older, more experienced people; where they can build relationships that are going to make them stronger; and where they can collect proof of their ability to add value.

Managers need to look at their organizations and the chain of command, and ask themselves: “What can we do to make sure there’s no one in charge of anyone who is not drilling on the basics of supervision? How can we grab hold of those young people as they walk through the door and teach them some of the old-fashioned basics, so they know how to follow?”

It’s an old-fashioned solution to a newfangled problem, says Tulgan. “There is no newfangled solution. The solution is back to the old-fashioned fundamentals. That’s what’s missing, and that’s what works.” ✥

 

Reference

Tulgan B L. Generational shift: Leveraging generation diversity in the workplace. AORN Global Surgical Conference & Expo, 2017.

 

Managing generational differences

OR Manager asked some of our Editorial Advisory Board members about their experience in managing generational differences.

Amy L. Bethel, MPA, RN, NE-BC

UnityPoint Health

Des Moines, Iowa

It is hard sometimes to generalize about generations because we all know those who don’t fit the profile. I think you can summarize it by communication styles and how the generations apply social media and technology.

Millennials like texting and all aspects of social media. They prefer not to have to go to meetings.

Leaders can adapt by using computerized scheduling, online learning, and text messages. (My own kids will answer my text messages but won’t answer their phones.)

Using social media to apply for jobs is very appealing to millennials. However, I think a job interview is an opportunity to teach millennials how to interact face-to-face and develop relationships, which can’t happen with social media. Our organization is working hard to educate the workforce on the pitfalls of social media and how to use it appropriately.

Older generations must learn to use the various technologies and use strategies to keep current in the workforce. Some left the profession when we all went to computerized documentation.

Bottom line: We all have to adapt and communicate with each other.

 

Mary Stewart, BSN, RN

Former Chief Clinical Officer (Retired)

Springfield Clinic

Springfield, Illinois

During orientation, a new employee (millennial) told a baby boomer numerous times, “I already know all that,” when in fact she did not. The baby boomer chose to ignore the comments and continued teaching her how to do the procedures.

On the flip side, the millennial taught the baby boomer a faster and better way to do charting in the electronic medical record.

Soon the two employees, one with 40 years and the other with 3 years of nursing experience, realized they made a great team.

They remain friends today inside and outside of work.

 

Patricia C. Seifert, MSN, RN, FAAN, CNOR 

Independent Cardiac Consultant

Falls Church, Virginia

In my work as an RN first assistant and educator at Inova Heart and Vascular Institute in Falls Church, Virginia, I saw, first hand, the silent generation and baby boomers working very effectively with millennials.

I think this was due in part to the silent generation’s minimal need for acclaim and the willingness to “share the wealth.” It may also have been due to the realization that one’s career is approaching its denouement, and the knowledge and wisdom one has accumulated need to be passed on.

The millennials make good recipients because they are enthusiastic learners who have a certain skepticism and curiosity. Pushback from a millennial or novice rarely threatens the older nurse, and their questioning and skepticism provide the older nurses with some amusement and opportunities to keep learning.

Millennials have a fierce need to engage in new projects. One millennial approached the cardiac OR manager (a baby boomer) and asked if she could reorganize the cardiac surgery inventory and make some operational changes at our sister hospital. Cardiac RNs staff both hospitals.

The manager gave her free rein, and she did not disappoint. The millennial created a notebook of photographs showing in detail where supplies and equipment were kept, and she presented an in-service on the changes she had made.

Millennials want to be respected for their contributions, not their length of tenure.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat