February 1, 2011

Benchmarking the OR’s key indicators

By: OR Manager
Share

Surgeons at St Vincent’s Hospital in Bridgeport, Connecticut, were frustrated because the scheduled start times for their cases during the day seemed to vary a lot.

Using their new dashboard, OR leaders were able to see that they were below the benchmark for scheduling accuracy.

“We were not doing a good job with accurately posting the case durations,” says Brooke Karlsen, BSN, MSN, RN, the director of surgical services.

To address the situation, she and her colleagues are starting a project to measure setup and cleanup times for the top 10 surgeons and their top 10 procedures. “We think we have underestimated those numbers and have made some adjustments,” she says.

Karlsen, with the chief of surgery, Douglas Ross, MD, who joined the organization 2 years ago, have been on a mission to create a more data-driven OR. The hospital recently subscribed to the OR Benchmarks Collaborative (ORBC), a collaboration between OR Manager, Inc, and McKesson.

“We worked with ORBC to create a custom dashboard based on the corporate goals for our hospital,” Karlsen says. Metrics include:

  • main OR first case on-time starts
  • main OR turnover time
  • total joint volume
  • ambulatory surgery first case on-time starts
  • ambulatory surgery turnover time
  • same-day canceled cases
  • first-case start delays caused by improperly prepared case carts
  • subsequent-case delays caused by improperly prepared case carts.

The OR had made some progress before, such as bringing its first-case on-time start percentages from the teens to the 70s. But these efforts required custom reports developed by its IT specialist.

“We really didn’t have a way to benchmark how we compare with others,” Karlsen says.

With ORBC’s web-based service, St Vincent’s submits its data monthly and then can access an online scorecard and dashboard showing how the OR is doing on key performance indicators. The scorecard can be used to drill down for more detail, identify causes of poor performance, and create custom reports.

For some metrics, it’s going to be a stretch, Karlsen acknowledges. “On others, we were kind of surprised—we were doing better than we thought.” Same-day case cancellations and block time utilization, for example, were at or above the 90th percentile for the benchmark.

Dashboard summary

Audience: OR leadership team (chief of surgery, director of surgical services, chief of anesthesia, managers, assistant nurse manager, OR scheduling manager, sterile processing manager, educator); staff; and physicians.

Metrics: OR operational performance indicators.

Frequency: Monthly.

Software: The dashboard is created using ORBC’s vendor-neutral business intelligence software. St Vincent’s uses McKesson’s PerSe OR information system.

More information on ORBC is at www.orbenchmarking.com

St Vincent’s Surgery Dashboard

Indicator Actual Peer Group Mean Achievement against Benchmark
% First Case On-Time or Early ± 5 71.7% 54.8% 130.84% ✓
% Subsequent Case On-Time or Early 26.2% 42.8% 61.21% ×
Patient In to Patient Out (min) 115.7 144.0 124.46 ✓
Patient In to Anesthesia Ready (min) 16.6 14.0 84.34% ×
Patient In to Incision (min) 16.7 34.0 203.59% ✓
Incision to Close (min) 88.4 97.0 109.73% ✓
Close to Patient Out (min) 10.7 12.0 112.15% ✓
Average Turnover Minutes (min) 31.9 33.0 103.45% ✓
% Scheduling Accuracy 35.1% 32.4% 108.33% ✓
% Utilized 7am-3pm 69% 77.2% 89.38% ×
% Utilized 3pm-5pm 60% 75.5% 79.47% ×
% Utilized 5pm-7pm 48% 68.4% 70.18% ×
% Utilized 7pm-11pm 10% 65.5% 15.27% ×
% Same Day Add-On 3.8% 14.6% 384.21% ✓
% Block Utilization 68.4% 65.0% 105.23% ✓
% of Schedule Blocked 25.2% ‡ +
% Same Day Cancelled/Postponed 4.6% 15.8% 343.48% ✓
% Patients Screened Prior to Surgery ‡ 58.7% +
% Surgical Checklist/Timeout Compliance 100.0% 98.5% 101.52% ✓
% Returns to Surgery within 24 hrs 0.1% ‡ +

Legend

✓ Measure meets or exceeds target

× Measure does not meet target

‡ Information unavailable

+ Achievement cannot be calculated

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat