Kermit the frog famously said, “it’s not easy being green.” He longed to be some other color, and OR leaders faced with managing a bully have probably wished they, too, could be someone—or somewhere—else. Using some recommended approaches can help.
In Part 2 of this three-part series on bullying, OR Manager looks at effective strategies, including how to have that difficult conversation.
When managers receive a complaint about bullying, they should interview the person lodging the complaint, any witnesses, and the bully. It’s important to use open-ended questions and create a nonjudgmental atmosphere.
Karen Michael, JD, president of Karen Michael Consulting in Bon Air, Virginia, suggests asking the victim and witnesses to rate departmental morale and their job on a scale of 1 to 10. Typically, the targeted employee will respond with “zero.” If the manager asks the bully if there is anyone who has any reason to make allegations against him or her, the bully usually names the target. “Listen carefully to what you are being told,” says Peggy Ann Berry, PhD, RN, COHN-S, SHRM-SCP, PLNC, a founding fellow of the US Academy of Workplace Bullying, Mobbing, and Abuse. “Nurses are trained to listen to patients, but we aren’t well trained to listen to each other.” She also says it’s important for managers to be in the OR, monitoring the situation.
Once managers know someone has been acting as a bully, they need to clearly define the behavior before having a conversation with the person, says Renee Thompson, DNP, RN, CMSRN, a workplace-bullying expert. “You can’t pull them into your office and say, ‘you might not know it, but you’re a bully and you’re bullying people,’” she says. “You don’t want to label people.” Instead, focus on the specific behavior and use scripting, such as, “I have witnessed this [description of behavior], and this is not OK.” Or, if you didn’t witness the behavior: “It has been brought to my attention that [description of behavior], and this is not OK.”
Share expectations, saying, for example, “I don’t want to learn that you treated a new employee like this again.” Then add, “Can I count on you?”
What if the bully denies his or her behavior, and you didn’t witness it? Thompson says if you believe the reports, say so: “You’re right, I didn’t observe this, but I believe it to be true and whether you agree with me or not, it’s an expectation that [describe behavior, such as ‘you won’t throw your pen when you don’t like an assignment’].”
Managers commonly find that the employee isn’t aware of his or her behavior. “Sometimes people have been behaving that way for a long time, but no one has had that conversation with them,” Thompson says.
“Often there is a lack of self-awareness about how an individual is coming across to others, which can ultimately impact the patient care environment in a negative way,” adds Cynthia Clark, PhD, RN, ANEF, FAAN. Clark, strategic nursing advisor for ATI Nursing Education, is the founder of Civility Matters™ and served as co-chair for the American Nurses Association Professional Panel for Incivility, Bullying, and Workplace Violence.
Bringing the behavior to the attention of the person is often enough to stop it, as was the case at an organization where Sue Tetzlaff, RN, previously worked (sidebar, right). Tetzlaff is cofounder of Capstone Leadership Solutions, Inc, in Sault Ste Marie, Michigan, and coauthor of The Employee Experience: A Capstone Guide to Peak Performance.
Another example of raising self-awareness comes from Brenda Burk, MSN, RN, who spoke about bullying at the 2017 OR Manager Conference. Burk, an experienced perioperative manager, says a nurse leader approached her after another presentation she had done in the past and said, “I’m a bully. I didn’t know that; no one ever told me about it. I’m going back to the office to apologize to my staff.”
Even when bullies aren’t aware of their behavior, Clark says, “When we speak up, when we constructively engage, and when we use evidence-based frameworks to structure our responses, the likelihood of behavior change is very high.”
Thompson adds that one of two things will happen after the intervention: “They either step up and start acting in a professional manner, or they step out by voluntarily leaving or through performance management.” She acknowledges that having these conversations isn’t easy. “It’s never comfortable, but we have an ethical responsibility to the public to hold people accountable.”
If the behavior continues, consult with human resources (HR). “If you pull in HR early, they can help guide you,” Thompson says. Involving HR also helps gain support if you decide you want to fire the employee. Managers often complain that HR personnel put up roadblocks when they want to fire someone. However, some HR staff say that they first hear about a problem employee when the manager wants to fire the person, and that leaders have poor documentation of actions taken to date or none at all.
While managing the bully, the manager mustn’t forget the victim. Burk suggests that referral to the organization’s employee assistance program may be helpful for some employees.
Mobbing is bullying by a group of people. “It’s the most severe form of bullying,” Berry says, and Clark calls it “bullying on steroids.”
Mobbing can take different forms. For example, Thompson notes that one OR had a gang that was bullying. A gang usually has something that identifies them as a group, such as the same color of headband.
Thompson recommends consulting with HR, then calling all of the gang members into the office at the same time. The conversation is similar to the one held with an individual: Specify the behavior and state that it’s not acceptable. The manager should also insist that they remove their gang symbols.
Thompson cautions leaders not to confuse cliques with gangs. “It’s OK to have cliques as long as they aren’t treating people outside of that clique in a manner that’s excluding them or being disrespectful to them, or that’s affecting patient care and the ability of the team to communicate with each other.” If a manager tries to break up the clique, a new one will likely form.
Tetzlaff says she was bullied by the chief executive officer (CEO) when she was a vice president of nursing. “He wanted to set people up to fail; it wasn’t just me,” she says.
The CEO tried to discredit her, even to the extent of creating erroneous reports for her units. “He threatened me with my job, and I stopped putting in extra work because every moment was painful.”
When Tetzlaff went to the hospital board, the members questioned her motives, although ultimately, the CEO’s behavior led to the loss of his position. Like too many others with similar experiences, however, Tetzlaff says the fallout was long lasting. Even though the CEO was fired before his contract ended, Tetzlaff says, “The board made it clear that when CEO jobs [a role she desired] became open, I would not be welcomed to apply.”
What should you do if you find yourself in a situation similar to Tetzlaff’s?
Thompson advises first having a conversation with the manager along the lines of, “I’m not sure you’re aware, but [description of the behavior] caused me to feel [describe how you felt]. The relationship I have with you is important to me, so I wanted to talk with you about it.”
Tetzlaff agrees, noting that it’s best to solve problems at the lowest level. “Even when there is a power differential, if you can confront that person one on one, it can be a great tactic to immediately halt the bullying,” she says. “It sets an expectation and a boundary.”
She recommends letting the person know what steps you will take if the behavior doesn’t change, based on your organization’s chain of command and policies related to disruptive behavior. Those next steps could be alerting the bully’s supervisor or HR.
If the conversation doesn’t bring change, Thompson says to start a documentation trail that includes what the behavior is, the fact that you are being targeted, and that the behavior has occurred over time. “Document the facts, and have witnesses document the facts,” says Burk. “Otherwise, you forget the details as time goes by.”
Thompson notes that in some cases, the employee might not have viable options; for example, the bully might be friends with the chief nurse executive. Or, as Tetzlaff says, some people might have narcissism or another personality disorder that can’t be corrected.
Leaving the job—although not an ideal solution—might be best for the individual.
“For nurses to become a kinder, more powerful workforce, we need to master the skill sets for constructively managing conflict, communicating effectively, and advocating for our patients,” Clark says. “We also need an organization that supports a healthy work environment, and we need to hold people accountable.”
Learn more about how to create that healthy work environment in part 3 of this series. ✥
American Nurses Association. ANA position statement on incivility, bullying, and workplace violence. July 22, 2015. http://www.nursingworld.org/MainMenuCategories/WorkplaceSafety/Healthy-Nurse/bullyingworkplaceviolence/Incivility-Bullying-and-Workplace-Violence.html.
Berry P A, Gillespie G L, Fisher B S, et al. Psychological distress and workplace bullying among registered nurses. OJIN. 2016;21. http://www.nursingworld.org/MainMenuCategories/ANAMarketplace/ANAPeriodicals/OJIN/TableofContents/Vol-21-2016/No3-Sept-2016/Articles-Previous-Topics/Psychological-Distress-and-Workplace-Bullying.html.
Dean P J, Shepard M D. The Bully-Proof Workplace: Essential Strategies, Tips, and Scripts for Dealing with the Office Sociopath. New York: McGraw-Hill Education. 2017.
Dellasega C, Volpe R L. Toxic Nursing: Managing Bullying, Bad Attitudes, and Total Turmoil. Indianapolis: Sigma Theta Tau International. 2013. http://www.aornjournal.org/article/S0001-2092(16)30831-6/pdf.
Farrell J S. Taming the workplace bully: 10 signs your employees are being bullied. HR Daily Advisor. 2017. http://hrdailyadvisor.blr.com/2017/06/21/taming-workplace-bully-10-signs-employees-bullied/.
Thompson R. Stop nurse bullies in their tracks: Four steps to success. 2014. https://www.reneethompsonspeaks.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/4StepsStopNurseBullies.pdf.
Thompson R, George L E. Preparing new nurses to address bullying: The effect of an online educational module on learner self-efficacy. MedSurg Nurs. 2016;25(6):412-416,432.
Wood E. Managing disruptive behavior will remove bullies from the OR. OR Manager. 2016;32(1):1,15-17.