January 19, 2018

Planning can relieve ‘growing pains’ of hospital mergers

By: Cynthia Saver, MS, RN
Share

Healthcare mergers and acquisitions are becoming as common as add-on cases in the OR, with hospitals struggling to stay profitable in a financially challenging environment. Between 2008 and 2014, the United States had nearly 400 hospital mergers and acquisitions (M&A), with more than 750 hospitals being acquired or merged.

“It’s becoming more difficult to operate smaller health systems in an environment where costs continue to outpace revenue and the trend is toward value-based care,” says Jimmy Peterson, CFA, healthcare and life sciences mergers and acquisitions leader for Deloitte Advisory. Peterson, who was a coauthor of a 2017 Deloitte Center for Health Solutions and Healthcare Financial Management Association (HFMA) report on M&A, adds that the results of these transactions aren’t always what was expected (sidebar below).

So what’s it like to be acquired? Leaders at UPMC Altoona, in Altoona, Pennsylvania, shared the ups and downs of being acquired with OR Manager.

 

A hospital finds a buyer

Dana Kopera, MBA, BSN, RN, CNOR

Altoona Hospital was founded in 1883. Times—and the business of healthcare—have changed since then. A 2004 merger with Mercy/Bon Secours Hospital formed Altoona Regional Health System, with the two campuses combining in 2012. UPMC Altoona was born in 2013 after UPMC—a large health network based in Pittsburgh—purchased the system, making it part of what is now a 34-hospital network.

Altoona was a willing partner. “It was like thinking about marriage,” says Barbara Nosek, MHA, sharing the analogy the chief executive officer used. “We went on dates and explored who would be the best fit with us.”

Nosek, who is now process consultant for Pensiamo, Inc, a division of UPMC, was the OR business manager for UPMC Altoona at the time of the purchase.

Barbara Nosek, MHA

At first, little changed. “It was quiet for about 18 months, and then it was like a big fire hose turned on,” Nosek says.

Nosek and Dana Kopera, MBA, BSN, RN, CNOR, administrative director of surgical services at UPMC Altoona, say they saw the most significant changes in four areas: supply chain, electronic health record (EHR), systemwide metrics, and OR policies.

UPMC Altoona was already ahead of the game when it came to supply chain efforts, but having corporate oversight brought both advantages and challenges.

“We were happy that corporate recognized we had better pricing on some things, but overall you can’t really compete when you’re independent because you don’t have enough volume,” Nosek says.

 

Benefits of a bigger system

Being part of a larger system makes for a stronger negotiating position. But it also meant matching the 12,000 products on Altoona’s item master with the more than 60,000 on UPMC’s list. “The time it took to finalize the item master is one of the reasons it took 18 months for clinicians to see change,” Nosek says.

Nosek and Kopera cite the “product road show,” held before the changes to the item master, as a positive UPMC change. “All of the products that corporate is asking you to change to are displayed alongside the current product you use. You can see them, touch them, and talk about them,” Nosek says. “It’s very valuable because you get to see the product before it’s implemented; it doesn’t just show up in the OR one day,” Kopera notes.

The purchase process changed with the acquisition. UPMC Altoona now participates in systemwide value analysis team conference calls held at least quarterly. The corporate supply chain staff run the call; other participants include supply chain representatives and sometimes OR directors from the hospitals.

A hospital that wants to change a product or purchase a new one presents a cost analysis to the group for discussion. “Every facility has a say before you vote,” Nosek says.

An item has to be approved by all the hospitals before it can be purchased, and, of course, not all decisions are popular. For example, some surgeons are still unhappy with the switch to the current suture provider even though the change saved the system more than $1.1 million in 1 year.

 

EHR conversion

Before the acquisition, UPMC Altoona’s EHR system, like that of many hospitals, was fragmented. Different areas used different systems, and some, such as the postanesthesia care unit and same-day surgery, still used paper.

The hospital created an 18-month plan to convert to a Cerner EHR. “Some things with Cerner are not as good as our previous system, but from a safety perspective, the integration is a huge benefit,” Kopera says. Now OR clinicians can review x-rays and see what treatment patients received in the physician’s office or the emergency department. “It’s all right there in front of you,” she says.

Making the switch, however, meant reviewing multiple preference cards. “We had to build more than 1,000 cards because you couldn’t copy and paste from the current system to the new one,” Kopera says. “And it all had to be done in addition to our daily operations.”

OR leaders focused on the highest volume cases for the initial implementation. “The key is getting the right people to do it,” Kopera says. “You need to have people with sufficient experience.”

Staff worked on laptops at home and on weekends, and regular reports helped leaders track progress. The reports, which could be sorted by specialty, included surgeon name, procedure, who was assigned to review the card, and when the card was completed.

“Having that tool really helped,” Kopera says. “You have to make reviewing and entering cards a priority because it’s easy to let that slip.”

Scheduling provided its own challenges. With the previous system, a surgeon’s office could schedule a patient via computer, and the information would populate the OR schedule. Although the office can still schedule a patient by computer, the information also must be manually entered into the surgery system, Kopera says.

UPMC Altoona also had to devise a plan for scheduling anesthesia off location (such as interventional radiology) and scheduling after hours (OR staff do this now).

A trainer from corporate services presented the scheduling changes as a webinar to staff in more than 60 physician offices. “It was important for us [leaders at Altoona] to be on the line, too, because the office had questions specific to Altoona,” Kopera notes.

The EHR go-live date (Saturday, April 15, 2015) was referred to as “the big bang.” UPMC corporate sent more than 350 volunteers from other hospitals to help with implementation, and staff had access to a corporate help line.

“There was one nurse for each OR for the entire week of the implementation, and they worked all shifts,” Kopera says. UPMC Altoona also had its own superusers, and a resource nurse to help with the charging system was on hand for 2 weeks.

One downside was that the week after going live, OR leaders discovered that the volunteers had introduced workflow changes based on what they did in their home facilities. “There were a lot of inconsistencies and a lot of commotion, so we had to revisit workflow,” Kopera says.

Another EHR change that proved challenging was procedure name. UPMC corporate names procedures based on the charge master, so sometimes the procedure in the system did not match the term used by clinicians.

“A procedure that we would list on the OR schedule as a transposition left upper arm brachiocephalic arteriovenous fistula would be listed more generically as transposition vein (site) (left),” Kopera says. This kind of discrepancy posed a risk for error, so after some discussion, the system was changed to include both names.

 

Systemwide metrics, policies

Large systems like UPMC use transparency when sharing metrics, and that transparency isn’t always comfortable. For example, in June 2015, only 19% of first cases started on time at UPMC Altoona, far below the target of 70%. Altoona was in the bottom three of UPMC facilities.

“It was embarrassing because everyone saw it,” Kopera says. “We had tolerated and accepted it in the past, but that had to change.”

Based on best practices from top-performing UPMC hospitals, Altoona changed its workflow in August 2015. Previously, OR staff completed their assessment in the preoperative area, and waited until the patient was ready to be taken to the OR. Now, staff return to the OR after their assessment to avoid wasted time, and CRNAs bring patients to the OR.

“We also changed how we measure start time from ‘wheels in’ to ‘anesthesia ready,’” Kopera says. Anesthesia ready is defined as the time the anesthesia provider has completed induction and released the patient to the OR staff so they can start positioning, prepping, and draping. The change meant that staff had to be ready sooner.

In addition, nurses started using codes to identify sources of delays, which helped in preparing daily reports of first case on-time starts. The report includes the OR number, case number, anesthesia ready time, surgeon, anesthesiologist, the reason for a delay, and the length of the delay. The percent of on-time cases appears at the bottom of the report.

By September 2015, the OR had started to improve and was ready for the next step—setting expectations for surgeons. The medical director of surgical services sent a letter to surgeons, which included a goal of 70% on-time first case starts. Surgeons were asked to update electronic orders and the history and physical, and to mark the site by 6:30 am for 7 am start times and 6:45 am for 7:30 start times.

The OR started posting daily metrics related to start time by physician name on bulletin boards in the surgeons’ lounge and in the restroom to tap into surgeons’ natural competitiveness.

“We had fun with it,” Kopera says. “Surgeons who did well had their photos displayed. When the entire OR achieved 100% on-time starts, the whole group got pizza in recognition of a job well done.”

Surgeons receive individual quarterly reports that show their percentage of first case on-time starts and the reason for any delays. Surgeons who are late 25% or more of the time face consequences:

• After the first quarter of noncompliance, the surgeon receives a written warning from the medical director of surgical services and has to meet with the medical director to discuss an improvement plan.

• After the second quarter of noncompliance, the surgeon loses the ability to schedule cases at the start of his or her designated block time for 1 month, which means that another case can be scheduled ahead of the assigned block time.

Those who improve receive a letter from the OR medical director recognizing the improvement.

“One surgeon who was late every day starting changing and told the OR medical director that his days go better now because of it,” Nosek says. “Another surgeon who didn’t change lost his first case position and ultimately left the hospital.”

By January 2016, UPMC Altoona had improved to 65% for first case on-time starts. Currently they range from 75% to 100%.

Being part of a system requires systemwide policies. “Standardization is non-negotiable,” Kopera says. The team reviewed current and corporate policies to prioritize changes and determine when and how to implement them.

“We educated staff and physicians by using a PowerPoint presentation that highlighted key changes,” she says. Fortunately, because both sets of policies were based primarily on AORN standards, changes were not too burdensome.

In rare cases, exceptions are made. For example, the surgeons at Altoona didn’t want to have to mark surgical sites in the case of bilateral surgery. They petitioned for change and received approval to omit this step.

 

People challenges

Staff reaction was an important component of managing the change. Nosek likens the reaction to the stages of grief:

• Denial—“We’re profitable, so we really aren’t going to join another system.”

• Anger—“I’m leaving. I can’t work for an organization that big; I’ll just be a number.”

• Bargaining—“If they would just delay it until I retire, I won’t have to deal with it.”

• Depression—“I’m just a cog in the wheel now. I don’t have a say.”

• Acceptance—“There’s value to this. We have more name recognition and can offer services we couldn’t offer before.” (For example, patients used to have to drive to Pittsburgh for pre- and post-transplant clinics, but now UPMC Altoona offers them locally.)

“You have to get staff involved early on,” Kopera says. Senior leadership held regular meetings with the hospital management staff, who, in turn, provided information to staff through unit meetings.

“Being acquired is a lot of work on the front end, but it’s a huge benefit,” Kopera says. For example, physician recruitment is up, and new service lines have been added.

“We had trouble recruiting surgeons to our [rural] area, but now that they have support from surgeons in Pittsburgh who will come onsite when they are starting to do new procedures, they are more likely to come here,” she says. UPMC surgeons are a mix of independent and hospital employed.

“There will be some things you like and some things you don’t like, but you have to be open-minded,” Nosek says. “We email our peers all the time, visit other hospitals to see how they do things, and encourage other hospitals to come visit us, too. It has been great for our community.”

 

Keys to success

What are the keys to a successful acquisition from the perspective of the acquiring organization? The Deloitte/HFMA report found three key factors boosted the chance of a high-value transaction, where both quality and cost efficiencies improved. The acquirer:

• has a clearly defined rationale for the transaction that enables the organization to achieve strategic goals

• understands the cultural fit between organizations and communicates throughout the transaction process

• has a detailed integration plan focusing on the deal’s core value drivers. “Those who do best have a robust integration plan and have communicated that plan to the team members so they don’t lose time with the transition,” Peterson says. “They take best practices from the seller and the acquirer from day 1.” They also establish concrete targets and milestones and hold leadership accountable for integration efforts.

He adds that the most important part of the acquisition is the management team. “If the acquiree has a strong management team and the acquirer has a strong management team, the chances of success are much greater,” he says. “You have to have the right people in place for executing the plan and making decisions, including the hard decisions, quickly.”

Peterson says the two biggest factors for success are culture and communication. “The better the cultures meld, the better the transition,” he says. “Health systems with disparate cultures often fail [at successful mergers.]”

It’s important to manage culture early in the process. “You need a plan just like you do when you’re talking about replacing or upgrading information technology systems or revenue cycle service providers,” he says. That plan should include getting nurses and physicians involved in the transition. “Too many transactions don’t have enough clinical involvement,” Peterson says. He suggests having a committee that provides clinician perspectives. “If you can get that group behind you and get some excitement, you can go a long way.”

Communication is essential to successfully meld the two cultures. “People want to know what’s going on,” Peterson says. However, communication effectiveness often depends on your point of view. The Deloitte/HFMA report notes that although 60% of the acquiring organizations said communication efforts related to the transaction were “very” or “extremely” effective, only 26% of respondents from acquired organizations held the same opinion.

Overall, it’s important to plan ahead and consider best practices (sidebar, below).

Coming soon

If you haven’t been affected by a merger or acquisition yet, you’re likely to have the experience in the future. “It’s happening everywhere in healthcare,” Nosek says, adding that for those being acquired, there can be a significant upside. “Smaller hospitals get access to more resources, including new equipment and staff.”

OR leaders should know that mergers and acquisitions aren’t going away anytime soon. “It’s going to continue for 10 plus years,” Peterson says. “The deals will just keep getting bigger. Nobody or no market is immune to it.” ✥

 

References

Knapp C, Peterson J, Gundling R, et al. Hospital M&A: When done well, M&A can achieve valuable outcomes. Deloitte Center for Health Solutions and Healthcare Financial Management Association. 2017. https://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/pages/life-sciences-and-health-care/articles/hospital-mergers-and-acquisitions.html.

Noether M, May S. Hospital merger benefits: Views from hospital leaders and econometric analysis. Charles River Associates. 2017. http://www.crai.com/sites/default/files/publications/Hospital-Merger-Full-Report-_FINAL-1.pdf.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat