When launching a new ambulatory surgery center (ASC), owners must consider a myriad of issues—financing, design, building construction or purchase, regulatory compliance, certification, staffing, and marketing. Underlying all of these considerations are which procedures the center will provide and whether the ASC will be single specialty, like gastrointestinal (GI) or ophthalmology centers, or multispecialty, offering numerous service lines.
“From the very beginning, ASC owners need to ask themselves what they want to be when they grow up,” says Sandra Jones, MBA, MSM, CPHRM, LHRM, CHCQM, CASC, FHFMA, founder of Ambulatory Strategies Inc in Dade City, Florida, a certified risk manager, and a surveyor for the Accreditation Association for Ambulatory Health Care. “Do they want to start out offering multiple specialties or begin as a single specialty with room to expand later?” Jones asks.
She has seen many ASCs design their facilities as single specialty, which leaves them no room to expand later. “Some ASCs are overbuilt, so their overhead is really high. Others are underbuilt, and within a couple of years they’re bursting at the seams,” Jones says. “The first ASC I ever opened designed the facility so a third OR could be added if it had a need based on volume. They never needed it, but it was there if they wanted to.”
She points to orthopedics and pain management to illustrate this balance. “If I’m in an orthopedic surgery center, I will need fewer pre- and postop bays than if I also have pain management. But if I add pain management, those procedures turn over more quickly, and I will need those postop bays to get patients in and out. It’s certainly more cost-effective to think about this up front and plan not just for the short term but also for what the future might hold,” Jones says.
Like orthopedics and pain management specialists, physicians within the same or complementary specialties often join to form single- or multispecialty ASCs. Other complementary specialties are GI and urology or ENT combined with ophthalmology and plastic surgery. “GI and endoscopy more often operate as single-specialty ASCs because they do not require sterile corridors and historically have generated enough volume to justify running independently,” Jones says.
There are both advantages and disadvantages to operating single- or multispecialty ASCs.
“A multispecialty center offers a broad, diversified procedure base, maximizes payer relationships, and enhances recruitment of staff who find working with a mix of specialties more appealing,” says Beth Derby, MBA, BS, RN, senior vice president for clinical and facility development at Compass Surgical Partners, a surgery center management, acquisition, and development firm in Raleigh, North Carolina. “Because of its diverse service lines, a multispecialty center is not dependent on the swings of either technology or reimbursement.”
Multispecialty ASCs may have lower cost per case, depending on the case mix, because the costs are spread across multiple specialties. They are also in a better negotiating position with contract payers, Derby says.
“Multispecialty ASCs have more negotiating power,” Derby adds. “They can say to payers, ‘I’m not just asking you to execute a contract for a single specialty. I can offer you five different specialties at a lower cost than the hospital HOPD [hospital outpatient department].’ The more procedures you can offer them, the more appealing you are as a facility.”
“The mix of surgical specialties provides a challenge to staff,” says Marsha Rowe, MBA, BSN, RN, administrator and clinical director of Southeastern Ambulatory Surgery Center, a majority hospital-owned ASC in Lumberton, North Carolina. “Today was an eye day, tomorrow is pain management, and the next day is orthopedics and podiatry. It really keeps us on our game. The variety is very good for our professional development.”
Rowe says the ASC has had almost no turnover of the clinical staff, most of whom came from the hospital and were familiar with a range of cases. “They really like the variety,” she says.
Southeastern Ambulatory Surgery Center performs about 3,200 procedures a year, including ENT, ophthalmology, gastroenterology, gynecology, orthopedics, and pain management. The 4-year-old center’s annual goal is 4,000. With four operating rooms, two gastroenterology suites, and a procedure room, the center’s utilization is at 50%. “We’ll get there,” Rowe says. “We’re ramping up. We just added a gastroenterologist and an ophthalmologist, and we’re recruiting more ob-gyns.”
When Southeastern was getting off the ground, the hospital signed loans for the building, instruments, equipment, and supplies. “As a multispecialty center, it’s always a fine dance of coming up with capital,” Rowe says. “We have to purchase a lot of different kinds of equipment and supplies.
“If we were just an eye center, we would know what we need every week, but our materials vary based on the procedure and physician preference. And we want each of our specialties to have what they feel they need.”
Southeastern works to standardize equipment preferences and purchases among surgeons. “When orthopedics need implantables, we need to make sure they don’t cost an arm and a leg, no pun intended.”
Streamlined, bulk purchasing is an advantage single-specialty ASCs have over multispecialty ASCs.
“When you buy six of one item instead of three, you’re going to get a better price,” says Michele Bossi, MSN, RN, director of clinical operations and administrator of OSS Health Ambulatory Surgery Center, an orthopedics-only center in York, Pennsylvania. “Because we only do orthopedics, we can negotiate with our vendors and standardize as much as possible.”
Bossi says that in addition to cost control, other advantages to managing a single-specialty ASC are consistency in scheduling as well as cohesion and team building among surgeons and OR staff who work together regularly.
“We have very thorough historical data on our physicians and their procedures, so we can accurately assign them block times. And because we have the same staff assigned to a physician each time, they have much faster case times and turnover,” Bossi says.
Although some staff thrive on variety, others prefer predictability and the opportunity to become an expert in one specialty, Bossi says.
“When the caregiver group is small, the physician-staff relationships become a greater partnership, and teambuilding is maximized,” Derby says. “A single-specialty ASC can appeal to the kind of person who doesn’t want to wonder, ‘Am I working on orthopedics or eyes today?’”
Single-specialty ASCs are not without their disadvantages, including dependence on fewer physicians and higher exposure to changes in reimbursement.
“You are at much higher risk if one of the three partners, who is the heaviest practitioner, is no longer able to work,” Derby says. “Your center can take a big hit. When you are dependent on fewer people, each active provider becomes much more critical.”
Also, changes in Medicare reimbursement for that one specialty can greatly compromise a center’s revenue stream and its ability to cover costs. For example, some pain management codes took an increased hit in 2017. Medicare reduced payment for some high-volume epidural injection codes by 16% to 25%, depending on the code. Nipple/areola reconstruction was reduced 18%, and repair of anorectral fistula with plug was reduced 17%.
At GI centers, most of the revenue comes from just three CPT codes. “We have to be efficient, maintain our volumes, and work in bundled arrangements,” says Lawrence Kosinski, MD, managing partner, Illinois Gastroenterology Group, and president, SonarMD, LLC.
Although single-specialty ASCs require less equipment than do multispecialty centers, the surgeons need to share it. “You definitely don’t want to schedule all of your foot and ankle surgeons on the same day. You won’t have enough equipment,” Bossi says.
Any ASC, whether single- or multispecialty, must determine its market share before investing resources into its center.
“Perform an analysis of current and future volume by CPT code, and ensure there is enough volume in your community to justify each specialty,” Jones advises. “Your analysis needs to factor in what percentage of your cases are appropriate for the ASC setting and what percentage will always be done in the hospital, such as patients with higher comorbidities.
In the end, physician interest in performing surgeries at an ASC will determine the caseload.
“Make sure your physicians are happy and want to come to your center,” Bossi says. “While we specialize in orthopedics, we wouldn’t turn away anyone who wants to come in and do their procedures at our center. But the surgeon needs to bring enough cases to support new equipment purchases and training staff in a different procedure.” ✥
Flowers L. Do Medicare’s latest code changes help or hurt ASCs? OR Manager. 2017;33(8),28.
2017 Surgery Medicare Updates. Cook Medical. https://www.cookmedical.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/SUR-BEI-SURMU-EN-RE_201701.pdf.