Healthcare costs in the US have increased exponentially in recent years. Surgical procedures are especially costly. Cost control without sacrificing high quality care is the ultimate goal for many surgical practices and payers. Alternative practices and payment models have been explored to meet this goal. Episode-based payments, more commonly known as bundled payments, provide promising outcomes for ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) to better serve patients, save payers money, and help ASCs gain market share.
The traditional fee-for-service model is a volume-based payment model that is not tied to care outcomes. On the other hand, a value-based payment model ties payments to care outcomes and even rewards healthcare providers for providing quality care. Value-based care focuses on the “Triple Aim” as defined by the Institute for Healthcare Improvement: Improving patient care (including quality and satisfaction), improving the health of populations, and reducing the healthcare cost.
Bundled payments are a specific form of value-based payment model. Created by the Center for Medicare & Medicaid (CMS) as an attempt to improve health outcomes and control costs, bundled payments have been deployed beyond the Medicare population. HealthAffairs reported lower episode prices in selected procedures in commercially insured populations, resulting in savings for employers (almost 10%) and patients (almost 28%). Under this payment model, all costs associated with the episode of care, including surgeon and anesthesia fees, staff costs, supply costs, facility fees, and any other indirect costs, are lumped together into one payment. This requires a high level of care coordination among different provider groups, surgeons, anesthesia providers, and healthcare administrators. The goal is to create a seamless experience for patients with high quality care and outcomes, and simple billing.
Becky Ziegler-Otis, MHA, CASC, RHIA, CPHQ, CHC, has been a seasoned administrator in the ASC space for more than 14 years. She has been speaking at various conferences about the model based on her experience in implementing bundled payments at a surgery center in Wisconsin. She saw bundled payments as a way to provide quality care, or value-based care, with transparent pricing. Patients know upfront how much a procedure will cost and can plan and budget accordingly. The key is simplicity, beginning with the first consultation through the surgical episode and billing. She does not see bundled payments as a “race to the bottom” as some do. Her experience with an ASC demonstrated that outside Medicare and traditional commercial insurers, direct payers provide an opportunity for bundled payments. By bypassing their insurance, the surgical procedure and billing process is simpler and more efficient. “Simplicity is the key to bundled payments,” she emphasizes.
Self-pay patients: It is commonly thought that self-pay patients are those without insurance. However, this is not always true. The self-pay segment also includes people with very high deductible health plans who may choose to pay out of pocket for procedures and use their insurance as a catastrophic policy.
Cost-sharing patients: The second type of patients are people who have a healthshare plan such as Medi-Share, Liberty HealthShare, Sedera, US Healthshare, Samaritan Ministries, and Christian Healthcare Ministries. These plans operate like self-pay entities.
Self-insured employers: Many small- and medium-sized employers are self-insured. They seek preferred providers with fixed pricing for a favorable agreement in services and costs. Employees who go to these preferred providers do not go through the regular insurance route, which eliminates any copay, co-insurance, or deductibles. Some employers even provide a financial incentive to steer their employees toward these preferred providers.
For self-pay patients, the benefits are manifold. Before their procedures, patients know what is included and the cost. This helps them plan and budget accordingly. When their surgical procedures are over, patients receive only one bill that matches the quote given before the procedures. This format removes the stress of dealing with medical bills, allowing the patient to focus on recovery. In a study of US consumers’ healthcare system literacy, Accenture found that the US healthcare system is so complex that more than half of consumers do not understand how to navigate the current healthcare environment.
For self-insured employers who are payers, knowing the costs upfront helps with planning and budgeting healthcare costs. As healthcare costs continue to rise, cost control is imperative for employers, especially those of small and medium sizes. In addition, having a relationship with a preferred provider helps employers ensure that their employees’ medical needs are met at desirable quality and costs. Employers (as payers) will receive one explanation of benefits and one bill. This helps save administrative time in reviewing and processing payments.
For healthcare providers and surgery centers, it is an opportunity to focus on providing quality care to patients while helping minimize costs. This alternative payment model also attracts patients looking for fixed pricing and helps practices gain market share in the process. The billing process is simpler as only one bill is generated and sent directly to the payer, whether it is the patient, the employer, or another entity. There are no complex claims to file or insurance red tape to navigate.
Ziegler-Otis sees bundled payments as a win-win-win situation for patients, payers, and providers. She describes this payment model as a patient-centered approach where quality and safe care underscores the value ASCs can provide at lower costs than the traditional volume-based payment model.
Just because other ASCs are doing it, does not mean that bundled payments are a good fit for every ASC. Ziegler-Otis stressed that surgery centers need to do their due diligence before committing staff and resources to the new payment strategy. Bundle payments are complex to understand and implement, and a thorough evaluation helps reduce costly mistakes.
Before even considering adopting the new payment model, the surgery center needs to deliver high quality and safe care. Cost effective procedures alone will not drive patients to the center, and even if they do, if the quality of care is lacking, the costs may not help in the long run. Before entering into a contract with a preferred provider, payers want to know about the performance of the center, including its transfer rates to a hospital, infection rates, complication rates, and patient satisfaction. In order to earn the business of future patients, the practice must earn the satisfaction and trust of current patients. This assessment phase is critical to ascertain the needs and readiness of the center before investing time and resources in the bundled payments model (sidebar, Assessment phase).
Ziegler-Otis recommended the following steps in implementing bundled payments.
Stakeholder engagement: All key people involved in the assessment phase should be part of the implementation phase. This is a long process, and leadership buy-in is important to work toward the same goals and objectives.
Target specialties and procedures: In a multispecialty surgery center, some specialties are a better fit than others for bundled payments. Once the specialties leaders are on board for bundled payments, the team needs to decide which procedures will be part of the new payment model. Choose procedures that are low risk, predictable, use feasible supplies and equipment, and are timely. Before expanding the process to more complex specialties and procedures, it is a good idea to pilot one specialty with simple procedures and learn from this experience. Orthopedics, for example, is a good specialty to start, and carpal tunnel surgery would be a good procedure to pilot before progressing to anterior cruciate ligament repairs, and joint replacements. Urology and podiatry could be the next specialties to potentially implement.
Case costing: Prices need to be set for each procedure based on the cost of each case. Case costing includes full costs of all direct and indirect costs. Direct costs would include ASC personnel directly involved with assisting the case (nurses or surgical technologists), drugs, supplies, implants, and any other costs from the pre-, intra-, and postoperative care. Indirect costs may include capital and overhead costs such as general administration, maintenance, utilities, and information technology.
Because case costing is complex, it needs to be done right in order to set correct prices. Take time to consider all details in the procedure to calculate the full cost. Past data and the Healthcare Bluebook can help administrators set some benchmarks. Oftentimes, there is a variance between what the providers think their fees should be and the market rates. The business side and the clinical side need to agree on the rates that are competitive within the target market and profitable for the center. Many successful surgical centers have implemented bundled payments and publish their bundled prices on their websites. Check out these resources to see what they are charging and what they include in their bundled prices.
Surgeon-anesthesia collaboration: As highlighted under the assessment phase, the collaboration between surgeons and anesthesia is essential for the success of the implementation. They need to work collaboratively in a team and fully support the new payment model as their compensation corresponds with the same payment model. The leadership alignment in the assessment phase is now tested in the implementation phase. If new surgeons or anesthesia providers are introduced, they need to fully understand the new approach and its implications.
Internal processes: Bundled payments are a complex process involving many moving parts in addition to the surgical procedures: scheduling, registration, billing, disbursement of payment to providers and staff, withholdings for administration, and record keeping. Providers and staff need to be aware of the process and how it will impact them. For example, they need to know when the payment will be disbursed to them and what amount will be withheld for administrative costs. The processes need to be well defined so bundled payment patients are treated accordingly. If a surgery center applies bundled payments to only some specialties or procedures, there needs to be a process to recognize these patients so that no copay or co-insurance is collected. Some surgery centers may benefit from having a “shell” company that handles the billing and disbursement.
Contract agreement: While internal processes are important to create a well-oiled machine, contract agreements are critical in managing external entities, whether these entities are direct patients, employers, or third-party administrators (TPAs) acting on behalf of employers. The contract agreement should spell out what procedure is to be performed at what cost, what is included and for how long. Consider value-added services as a differentiator. For example, some patients may need durable medical equipment (DME) after their procedure, which could add value to what the center provides. If DME is included, it should be stated in the contract, but if it is not, it should be clarified in the exclusion. Most contracts with patients would have one preoperative consultation with the surgeon, the procedure, and postoperative visits. In the case of Ziegler-Otis’ surgery center, there are a maximum of three postoperative visits up to 90 days after the surgery. The number of postoperative visits and the time limit vary across surgery centers, but this needs to be stated in the contract.
Surgery Center of Oklahoma, Oklahoma City
https://surgerycenterok.com/pricing/
Surgery Center of Allentown, Allentown, Pennsylvania
https://scoallentown.com/for-patients/cash-pricing-program/
Lonestar Surgery Center, Houston, Texas
https://lonestarsurgeryctr.com/pricing/
Pacific Surgery Center, Longview, Washington
http://Pacificsurgicalwa.com
QuikSurg, Chattanooga, Tennessee
https://quiksurg.com/#prices
(Skin removal procedures)
Texas Free Market Surgery, Austin, Houston, Dallas (coming soon), Texas
https://texasfreemarketsurgery.com/
OrthoIllinois, Rockport, Illinois
https://www.orthoillinois.com/bundled-pricing/surgical-procedures/
The contracts with employers and TPAs are more involved:
• There is usually a contract review date. Make sure that this date is fair so that the surgery center will not be locked into rates and terms that are not suitable in a changing market. Beware of automatic renewals. A contract review date should be annual, but if that is not feasible, have a clause in the contract to review pricing and terms yearly.
• Some employers and TPAs may want to put copays or other requirements in the contracts. Copay and filing defeat the purpose of this simplistic payment approach, so try to avoid these requirements. The bureaucracy of insurance-related payments will take up time, encumber efficiency, and increase operating costs.
• Prior authorization is another contentious issue. Administrators need to know what prior authorization is required and make it streamline. A simple form with the provision of a few pertinent medical records, for example, would ease the process for patients.
• Exclusions and inclusions should be consistent in all contracts. Carefully consider all scenarios and thoroughly state them. Do not leave room for (mis)interpretation.
• Payment terms need to be stated in the contracts. If the process is set up to simplify preauthorization (if required) and meet payer requirements, payment time should not exceed 15-30 days.
An attorney should review all contracts as surgery centers start bundled payments. Eventually, administrators become very familiar with these agreements, and may not need to take each contract to an attorney. If there are unfamiliar terms and conditions, take the contract to the attorney.
“Not all agreements are created equal, and be prepared to walk away. It’s got to be something that makes sense for your facility,” Ziegler-Otis advised.
Quality measures are critical in establishing an ASC as a center of excellence. Bundled payments require even more rigorous quality measures to monitor the performance of the bundle. The metrics should capture the quality of care, including complication and infection rates, patient safety and experience, and resource utilization. The metrics should be patient-centered rather than center-driven.
Driven by CMS, the bundled payments model has spread beyond Medicare settings. If ASCs spend the time to do their due diligence and ask all pertinent questions before implementing the new payment model, they can enjoy the many benefits bundled payments offer: coordinated care that provides a good value (high quality at lower cost) to patients and payers while expanding market share and improving the bottom line. The process is not without difficulties and barriers, but they are not impossible to overcome. Simplicity is the goal to solve the complexity of care delivery. Bundled payments are not contained to just core specialties and procedures. Once surgery centers master their bundled payments model, they could consider other related but independent bundled payment packages such as OT/PT, nutrition counseling, and wellness. “Bundled payment is not a race to the bottom. I think it’s about the value you can provide,” Ziegler-Otis says.
—Uyen Vo, BSN, MBA, is a freelance writer with more than 20 years of experience in healthcare.
Accenture. The hidden cost of healthcare system complexity. 2018.