April 21, 2017

Can infrared sensors reliably measure OR traffic?

By: OR Manager
Share

The incidence of surgical site infections (SSIs) is estimated to exceed 290,000 cases per year, and costs can range from $11,874 to $34,670 for inpatient hospital services. Studies have demonstrated a link between SSI rates and airborne bacterial counts in the OR. Some facilities have used trained observers to monitor door openings in an attempt to reduce traffic during procedures, but this method involves having an additional person in the sterile environment.

An alternative approach is to use automated door counters. To gauge their effectiveness, we compared data recorded by a trained observer and by automated door counters for 137 primary total joint arthroscopy (TJA) cases at a large academic center in 2014.

We hypothesized that automated door counters would be less effective than trained observers because of high false positive rates and variations in what constitutes door openings. However, similar results were found for both methods, and we believe automated door counters should be considered a valid way to monitor traffic.

 

What’s in the air?

A major source for airborne bacteria comes from the dispersal of contaminates from OR personnel. Airborne bacteria are routinely filtered out of the OR via positive pressure ventilation systems. However, frequent door openings disrupt airflow patterns and positive pressure environments within the surgical suite.

Although there are no guidelines on what constitutes an acceptable amount of OR traffic, experts recommend reducing OR traffic to help curb SSIs. The literature suggests an average of 40 movements in and out of the room per hour for primary TJA cases. These averages were tracked manually by a trained observer, but this method has the potential for error and has never been compared with other methods of data collection.

 

Automated vs manual

For our study, automated door counters (GOJO Industries, Akron, Ohio) used infrared beams to track foot traffic whenever someone entered or left the room. Additionally, a single trained observer manually monitored foot traffic for each case.

All OR staff were blinded to data collection. Data were only collected in ORs with the automated door counters installed during cases for which the observer was also present. Data captured by door counters were compared with data recorded manually by the observer, and each OR was monitored individually.

Each OR had two points of entry: a double-door entrance into the outer corridor and a single-door entrance into an internal sub-sterile corridor. Each entrance in the selected ORs had inward-opening doors.

Automated door counters were placed on the ceiling above all OR entrances, but only inside the OR to avoid capturing unrelated traffic occurring in the hallway. The observer stood away from both entrances and away from the surgical staff to avoid interfering with the workflow.

Parameters recorded in each case included:

• OR room number

• number of door openings counted by the observer

• number of door openings counted by the automated door counter

• length of recording.

Data collection started at incision and stopped either at closure or after 10 minutes when there was inactivity in door movements. Data were analyzed using a two-tailed T-test with a P value < 0.05 reflecting statistical significance.

 

Analyzing the results

The observer recorded a total of 2,067 door openings. Automated door counters recorded a total of 2,204 door openings—an overestimate of 137 additional movements, but a difference that was not significant.

The mean number of door openings recorded for all cases by the observer was 15.1 (SD = 19.2) vs 16.1 (SD = 21.2) by the automated door counters. There was no difference in the method of data collection ( P = 0.682).

Examining each OR separately, we compared the number of door counts recorded by the observer to those recorded by the individual automated door counter. In each OR there was no statistical difference in mean door openings per case ( P = 0.64–0.96; sidebar below).

To establish a baseline, we first studied the cases that were monitored for exactly 10 minutes (sidebar below). Of the 94 cases that were monitored for exactly 10 minutes, automated door counters averaged 7.14 movements per case compared to 7.27 movements per case for the observer ( P = 0.85).

For the 43 cases monitored for longer than 10 minutes, automated door counters averaged 35.65 movements per case compared to 32.19 movements per case for the observer ( P = 0.56; sidebar below).

The observer may have missed valid door openings (false negatives), whereas the automated door counters may erroneously count door openings (false positives). False positives can occur when an individual walks very close to the OR door, passing through the infrared beam without actually entering or exiting the door, for example, while obtaining supplies.

For our room setup, supplies located by doorways tend to include items circulating staff need many times during the case, such as gloves and hand sanitizer. False positives also occur any time a team member approaches the door, such as to make room for another team member or to communicate with someone in the hallway. This kind of traffic may explain why there was a larger discrepancy in tracked movements for the cases monitored for longer than 10 minutes. However, these discrepancies are insignificant.

Recommendations

We accounted for the possibility that one or more automated door counters might not have functioned properly, which would have skewed our data. After analyzing the data for each OR separately, we verified that the door counters operated as intended.

In addition, there were times when the Internet connection was lost during data collection. Fortunately, this happened only when there was no movement to be tracked. Thus, having reliable Internet service is one aspect to consider when using this technology.

Facilities that adopt automated door counters should ensure they are properly calibrated. Once that is done, they offer a way to monitor traffic and compare the performance of different surgical teams without the need for additional staff in the OR.

Although we collected data only for TJA cases in a single hospital, our purpose was to verify whether the automated door counters worked as efficiently as trained observers—not to compare OR traffic across multiple hospitals. We tracked TJA cases because there was already a strict OR culture for limiting traffic flow, which meant there would be less chance of getting false negatives and false positives during OR tracking.

Automated door counters provide an effective way to compare surgeons to one another in their ability to maintain a sterile surgical environment. The ability to collect OR traffic data and provide immediate feedback can help increase staff efforts to limit OR traffic flow. Ultimately, this reduction in OR traffic may reduce the risk of SSIs. ✥

 

(L-R) Ricardo W. Pulido, BA, is a medical student. Benjamin Kester, MD, and Ran Schwarzkopf, MD, are orthopedic surgeons. All are affiliated with New York University-Hospital for Joint Diseases, New York City.

 

References

Andersson A E, Bergh I, Karlsson J, et al. Patients’ experiences of acquiring a deep surgical site infection: An interview study. Am J Infect Control. 2010;38:711-717.

Andersson A E, Bergh I, Karlsson J, et al. Traffic flow in the operating room: An explorative and descriptive study on air quality during orthopedic trauma implant surgery. Am J Infect Control. 2012;40:750-755.

Babkin Y, Raveh D, Lifschitz M, et al. Incidence and risk factors for surgical infection after total knee replacement. Scand J Infect Dis. 2007; 39(10):890-895.

Birgand G, Saliou P, Lucet J. Influence of staff behavior on infectious risk in operating rooms: What is the evidence? Infect Control & Hosp Epidemiol. 2015;36:93-106.

Lynch R J, Englesbe M J, Sturm L, et al. Measurement of foot traffic in the operating room: Implications for infection control. Am J Med Qual. 2009;24:45-52.

Panahi P, Stroh M, Casper D S, et al. Operating room traffic is a major concern during total joint arthroplasty. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2012;470(10):2690-2694.

Parikh S N, Grice S S, Schnell B M, et al. Operating room traffic: Is there any role of monitoring it? J Pediatr Orthop. 2010;30(6):617-623.

Rovaldi C J, King P J. The effect of an interdisciplinary QI project to reduce OR foot traffic. AORN J 2015;101:667-678.

Scott D R. The direct medical costs of healthcare-associated infections in US hospitals and the benefits of prevention. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. http://www.cdc.gov/HAI/pdfs/hai/Scott_CostPaper.pdf.

Smith E B, Raphael I J, Maltenfort M G, et al. The effect of laminar air flow and door openings on operating room contamination. J Arthroplasty. 2013 28:1482-1485.

World Health Organization. WHO guidelines for safe surgery 2009: Safe surgery saves lives. http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstr.

Young R S, Regan D J. Cardiac surgical theatre traffic: Time for traffic calming measures? Interactive Cardiovasc Thorac Surg. 2010;10:526-529.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat