Major changes at a facility such as reorganizing service lines or adding new ORs can be highly disruptive, cutting into productivity and potentially loss of revenue. What can OR managers do to avoid this situation?
At Vanderbilt University Medical Center in Nashville, OR leaders were facing several simultaneous challenges: planning for transition of service lines between three OR locations that operated differently from one another, opening four new ORs, and relocating cases from a freestanding outpatient venture back to Vanderbilt. They took a proactive approach to shatter silos and promote teamwork.
Vanderbilt, which has 56 onsite ORs, nine off-site ORs, and two freestanding ambulatory surgery centers, completes more than 45,000 surgical procedures a year, so rapid throughput is essential.
“We couldn’t afford to lose any efficiency,” says Barbara Sanders, MMHC, BSN, RN, director of performance improvement and operations for adult perioperative services at Vanderbilt. “We needed to tackle that head on.”
She adds that surgeons had already voiced concerns about how the changes would affect efficiency.
Sanders and Cindy Kildgore, MSHA, BSN, RN, CNOR, peri-operative services director at Vanderbilt, defined the overall challenge as having four components:
• cultural, including provider resistance to change and lack of teamwork
• operational, such as suboptimal turnover times and staffing shortages
• communication, in particular, a reactive communication model
• data, including perceptions of inefficiencies that didn’t align with the data.
On the basis of their analysis, Sanders and Kildgore decided to start with turnover time (TOT)—an area they identified as needing improvement. They worked with a multidisciplinary team to standardize processes for a reliable and predictable turnover through innovations such as creating a dispatcher role, identifying predominant causes for delay, and, more importantly, addressing the cultural challenges.
The multidisciplinary team included surgeons from the service lines most worried about losing efficiency, perioperative nurses, anesthesia providers, and representatives from the sterile processing and supply management departments.
One of the first tasks was to dispel a myth often repeated by surgeons: “It takes too long to clean the room.” That’s where data came in. Time stamps recorded through formal observations and time studies proved that the time it took to clean the room wasn’t as long as surgeons thought. But that didn’t mean there weren’t opportunities for improvement.
“We needed to move from a reactive to a proactive, anticipatory communication model for room turnover,” Sanders says, adding that the goal was to reduce the time an OR is in “non-ready” status.
The anticipatory model required a shift in thinking from a grocery store to an airline industry queue model. In a grocery store, people wait in separate lines behind multiple people for checkout, but at the airline ticket counter, agents pull from one line, which is more efficient.
Vanderbilt created the OR dispatcher role to mimic the airline approach.
“The dispatcher serves as an air traffic controller to deploy turnover staff to the right room at the right time,” Sanders says.
Rather than assign peri-operative support staff to a set of rooms or hallways, the dispatcher directs staff to go to rooms as needed, based on what she sees on a bank of room monitors stationed in the OR’s command center, as well as color changes on the OR’s electronic board:
• Turquoise—case is closing.
• Dark purple—procedure is completed. When the drapes have been removed and the surgical dressing is in place, support staff go to the room to start removing trash and linen, and they place the next case cart outside the room.
• Pink—patient leaves room. At this stage, full turnover begins.
• Support staff are also cross-trained to obtain blood from the blood bank, deliver specimens to the laboratory, and retrieve needed equipment—fostering a team approach to improve efficiency.
In addition to the dispatcher, the charge nurse, medical receptionist, and an attending anesthesia provider are also based in the command center, creating an ideal arrangement for enacting the anticipatory model.
“The dispatcher has a high level of situational awareness of clinical needs,” Kildgore says, which streamlines information flow so the circulator rarely has to stop and call for assistance.
The first dispatcher in the position was a perioperative support technician who received additional training for the role. “She is someone with good critical thinking and logistical skills,” Kildgore says. (An additional dispatcher has been added since the original position started 2 years ago.)
Once the dispatcher role was in place, Kildgore and Sanders were ready to launch three phases to improve TOT. The ultimate goal is to have efficient flow on the day of surgery (sidebar above right).
Like many hospitals, Vanderbilt didn’t have a consistent procedure for when to call for the next patient. In some cases, the surgeon made the decision; in others, it might be the command center staff. The preoperative holding area staff didn’t own the process, even though they were the ones with the best situational awareness of the space and circumstances at any given time.
“We had to put the ownership with the people doing the work,” Sanders says. “The holding area charge nurse knows best what is the right amount of time to get a patient ready for surgery.”
That insight was part of two Kaizen sessions that lasted 4 to 5 hours each. Participants in the sessions developed an algorithm, which used 90 minutes as the best estimate of the time it takes to prepare a patient for surgery.
“We did a 2-week trial [of the holding area charge nurse using the 90-minute algorithm] without announcing it and saw measurable improvement in that short amount of time,” Sanders says. That improvement has been sustained over 2 years (sidebar above right).
Some tweaks have been made along the way. For example, to avoid multiple calls from the holding area to the circulator, a pop-up box appears on the OR’s electronic record screen about an hour before the planned end of the case, asking if it will be completed on time. If the answer is no, the OR circulator updates the anticipated case end time in the electronic record, so the holding room staff can adjust the time to call for the next patient.
The answer to this simple question can vary, depending on who is asked. “‘Room ready’ does not mean when the surgeon or the patient is ready,” Kildgore says. “It simply means that the room is ready to receive the next patient.”
The Vanderbilt team focused on reducing the “wheels out” to “room ready” time by identifying causes for delays and setting expectations for when the team should be back in the room for the next case.
Service lines set individual goals for room ready, which presented a challenge because standards for turnover time don’t exist, and surgeons, nurses, and anesthesia providers have different expectations.
“The complexity of the case and amount of equipment needed make a big difference in turnover,” Kildgore says. “You can’t expect the turnover to be the same for a cystoscopy versus a robotics case.”
Target times were reviewed and adjusted along the way as needed. Wheels out to room ready times improved by 1 to 6 minutes across all hours of the day for the same 3-month period from 2015 to 2016 (sidebar, p 23).
This phase of the Vanderbilt initiative refers to the time from room ready to “wheels in”—a phase Kildgore says is “a work in progress.” She is preparing to hire a navigator for the holding area who will facilitate throughput from the holding area to the OR. For example, the navigator can identify potential delay issues, such as not having a signed consent, early in the process.
Sanders says the earlier phases laid the groundwork for the final phase. “We wanted to tighten up things nurses have control over and then go to our anesthesia and surgeon colleagues for their partnership in accomplishing the last phase of our work,” she notes. “We can demonstrate that the room is ready reliably and consistently in a timely manner, so now it’s time to decrease the room ready to wheels in time, thus closing the gap.”
This phase of the process has the greatest opportunity for successfully decreasing overall TOT. Anesthesia providers, surgeons, and nurses are now collaborating to close the gap (sidebar, p 23).
Kildgore and Sanders advise OR managers who want to tackle their own TOT issue to evaluate the current situation. “If we hadn’t broken down the problem so we understood it, we wouldn’t have been successful,” Sanders says, adding that sequencing improvements, instead of trying to accomplish too much at once, optimizes outcomes.
The two leaders also note the value of ongoing monitoring and follow-up. “You can expect normal variation, but you need to know when you’re outside that normal variation,” Sanders says.
“You need data analyzed and reported accurately,” Kildgore adds. “Once the stakeholders believe in the analysis, it becomes easier to get buy-in.” ✥
Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.
Kildgore C, Sanders B. The paradigm shift from a siloed approach to team methodology for reliable turnovers. OR Business Manager Conference, January 31, 2017.