June 16, 2015

Checklists help staff keep cool in the heat of an OR crisis

By: OR Manager
Share

An emergency situation in the OR can rattle even the most experienced surgeons, anesthesiologists, and staff. To help reduce anxiety and prompt a more effective response to emergencies, clinicians increasingly are turning to cognitive aids. These cognitive aids, routinely used for years in aviation and other high-hazard industries, are an integral part of crisis resource management, as developed and taught for decades by David Gaba, MD, Steven Howard, MD, and their colleagues.

Sara Goldhaber-Fiebert, MD

Sara Goldhaber-Fiebert, MD

“Cognitive aids help clinicians retrieve rarely used information, which is challenging at best under stress,” says Sara Goldhaber-Fiebert, MD, who has led Stanford’s clinical implementation of emergency manuals for all perioperative and procedural anesthetizing locations since 2012.

Goldhaber-Fiebert is also one of the founding members of the Stanford Anesthesia Cognitive Aid Group as well as the global Emergency Manuals Implementation Collaborative (EMIC), along with Dr Gaba and Dr Howard, and clinical assistant professor in the department of anesthesiology, perioperative and pain medicine at Stanford University School of Medicine in California.

“They enable clinicians to focus on assessing the crisis, organizing the team, and communicating effectively, all of which benefit our patients,” she says.

According to a review article by Stuart Marshall in Anesthesia & Analgesia, several studies using simulation found that technical performance improved with use of cognitive aids. However, positive results aren’t universal, pointing to the need to base aids on clinical guidelines when possible, consider the design of the aid, and test usability through simulation before implementation.

A common cognitive aid is the crisis checklist. Checklists are typically part of an emergency manual, which may also include other cognitive aids. Although potentially valuable, checklists can be challenging to implement. Leaders need to understand the rationale, create an effective team, and provide education.

 

Why checklists?

Laura Ardizzone, DNP, CRNA, DCC

Laura
Ardizzone, DNP, CRNA, DCC

Checklists mean people don’t have to rely only on memory in a crisis situation. “We have good information that shows when people rely on memory, they miss crucial steps,” says Laura Ardizzone, DNP, CRNA, DCC, director of nurse anesthesia services at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center (MSKCC) in New York City, which has been using checklists in the OR for about 1.5 years. “Checklists keep people on task.”

Checklists contain detailed information organized in an easy-to-use format. “The culture is changing to increasingly recognize that it matters what management actions reach our patients, not what information we hold in our heads,” Dr Goldhaber-Fiebert says. For instance, nurses and anesthesiologists might need to know how to mix dantrolene for management of malignant hyperthermia (MH) only once in their careers. Having those detailed instructions readily available, and knowing how to use them rather than relying on memory alone, makes sense. Checklists also prompt the team to remember simple things, such as turning off the volatile anesthetic, which can continue to trigger the MH reaction.

“They [checklists] provide the team the right information at the right time,” Dr Goldhaber-Fiebert adds.

 

Developing checklists

David Borshoff, MBBS, FANZCA

David Borshoff, MBBS,
FANZCA

David Borshoff, MBBS, FANZCA, director of anesthesia and pain medicine at St John of God Hospital in Perth, Western Australia, and author of The Anesthetic Crisis Manual, North American Edition, says he included many OR caregivers in developing checklists. Team members were consulted to review guidelines for the treatment of different emergency conditions and discuss how they would act.

“By eliminating as many nonessential components as possible, a clear, concise checklist of prioritized, essential steps is created,” he notes.

Several websites have posted checklists and emergency manuals based on evidence (sidebar below). Modifications are based on review of the literature and feedback from those who use them.

ORM_070115_SB-p27

 

To help evaluate checklists, organizations might want to consider the properties of an ideal cognitive aid defined by Stuart Marshall:

• Its content must be derived from best practice guidelines or protocols.

• Its design should be appropriate for use in an emergency situation.

• It should be familiar—in a format used in practice and training.

• It should also help other team members to perform their tasks in a coordinated manner.

When it comes to implementing checklists in an OR, “people shouldn’t feel the need to recreate the wheel; that wastes time,” Ardizzone says. “Instead, adapt what’s already available.”

MSKCC adapted checklists from Stanford and Brigham and Women’s Hospital. For example, Ardizzone says, they added how to convert a robotic procedure to an open one in an emergency situation. Even small adaptations, such as using the term epinephrine or adrenaline depending on local preference, help make checklists more meaningful.

However, Ardizzone adds that the project team needs to remember that checklists are evidence based. “In the beginning, a lot of people wanted to tinker with them and adapt them to their own room,” she recalls. “You want to balance between local adaptation and consistency,” Dr Goldhaber-Fiebert says.

In addition to Ardizzone, the team that developed the checklists at MSKCC included nurses, surgical technologists, surgeons, anesthesiologists, the director of the department of quality and safety, and a representative from information technology.

“What’s most important is that everyone needs to be on board,” she says. “It needs to be a group effort.”

 

Applying in practice

Now that the checklists have been implemented, ongoing work related to reviewing and revising them is the responsibility of an OR multidisciplinary safety group that meets monthly. The group, cochaired by a surgeon and an OR nurse manager, includes surgical technologists, OR nurses, anesthesiologists, and certified registered nurse anesthetists.

At MSKCC, checklists are stored in the online health information system. “We have large LCD screens so the checklists can be displayed on all the monitors,” Ardizzone says. “Some areas of the country are just printing off the checklists and keeping them in the room; that works, too.”

Dr Borshoff supports what he calls a three-level implementation: a hard copy on the anesthesia cart, an electronic version on monitors in the room, and an app for the smartphone.

“It’s important to remember, and this is supported by some groups with simulation testing, that despite the technology revolution, hard copy is still the simplest, most readily available, and most user-friendly option for OR staff,” Dr Borshoff says.

Experts vary as to whether there should be a “reader” who calls out items in the checklist. “I think most of us agree that a reader is useful, but personally, I don’t like to lose any flow by making it a formal process,” Dr Borshoff says. “I just ask an OR staff member to get the manual and check with me that we have not missed any crucial steps.” How to use the checklists in practice depends on the country, culture of the OR, and culture of the organization, he notes.

Effective use of checklists depends on excellent teamwork; that’s where interdisciplinary education comes into play. “If people don’t know about them, they can’t use them,” Dr Goldhaber-Fiebert says. “Everyone has a role to play, for example, any team member can ask the event leader, ‘Do you want me to get the emergency manual?’”

 

Providing education

Dr Goldhaber-Fiebert says training increases the probability that clinicians will use checklists and emergency manuals more effectively. Simulation exercises are used at Stanford and elsewhere so team members can practice applying the emergency manuals and improving teamwork and communication.

“Education not only promotes familiarity and recognition of cognitive aids, it also creates an awareness of the importance of good crisis management and helps prepare the practitioner for the unexpected,” Dr Borshoff says.

At MSKCC, Ardizzone says, team members taught staff by service line. “We did 10 to 15 minutes of simulation in an OR and showed a video illustrating how to use the checklists.”

Nurses are an important part of the education, along with other key participants during a crisis. Dr Borshoff highlights the benefits of crew resource management, which focuses on a team approach.

“The important thing is, everyone involved has to be aware, receptive, and flexible,” Dr Borshoff says, referring to the response to an emergency situation. “It also helps if egos are left at the door.”

 

Meeting challenges

Dr Borshoff says that another useful tool to supplement checklists is the mantra: Call, communicate, and delegate. This mantra was derived from the aviation mantra: Aviate, navigate, communicate.

“In other words, keep the plane flying and away from danger before attending to troubleshooting,” he says. Similarly, the primary caregiver should stay focused on the patient’s immediate needs while obtaining extra help and delegating tasks so situational awareness is not lost.

The mantra also encourages getting help early. “Simulation has often demonstrated people can become fixated with solving the problem at hand [fixation error], and forget to share the burden until late into the developing crisis—sometimes too late,” Dr Borshoff says.

 

Avoiding complacency

“I can’t say it’s been easy,” Ardizzone says about implementing the checklists. “We’ve had bumps and bruises.” Many staff and physicians are unfamiliar with cognitive aids and thus have to learn about their use and advantages.

Success stories can help facilitate checklist adoption. “Find those who have successfully used them,” she says. “They will be the best champions for their group.”

Another challenge is the plethora of checklists in the OR. “People are tuning out when you say ‘checklists,’” Ardizzone says, adding that not every problem is solved by creating a checklist.

Dr Borshoff agrees champions are important. “The more case presentations, lectures, discussions, or similar educational sessions, the better,” he says.

 

Pitfalls of checklists

Like any other tool, checklists aren’t a panacea, and they have their pitfalls. Dr Borshoff outlines three potential problems:

• A poorly designed checklist will limit its usefulness. “Simplicity, precision, and good prioritization of tasks are important,” he says. “Overwhelming users with information will turn people away, and a lack of thought about color and design results in failure to connect with the user.”

• Use of checklists may be limited because some clinicians feel they undermine their experience and clinical acumen, he notes. “There is no substitute for experienced practitioners, for example, Captain Chesley Sullenberger’s Hudson River landing, but the message we need to get out is that these are simply cognitive aids designed to support the caregiver during stressful crisis scenarios.”

• If the wrong checklist is used, unintentional errors can occur. Dr Borshoff notes that, in addition to checklists, situational awareness is required. There should be intermittent pauses in the process for patient review in case the diagnosis needs to be reassessed.

“Emergency manuals should never replace good teamwork or good judgment, nor should they be used before starting necessary clinical actions such as chest compressions,” Dr Goldhaber-Fiebert adds.

 

A tipping point

“Emergency manuals have really taken off in the past 3 to 4 years,” Dr Goldhaber-Fiebert says. As a matter of fact, she says, many institutions are encouraging their use as a patient safety initiative. “We are reaching a tipping point.”

Dr Borshoff recognizes there is another implication of checklists and emergency manuals: “Not only do I think the benefits of cognitive aids for patient safety will become more apparent with time, there may eventually be legal implications of not having a checklist manual in each operating room.” ✥

 

 

References

Arriaga A F, Bader A M, Wong J M, et al. Simulation-based trial of surgical-crisis checklists. N Engl J Med. 2013;368:246-253. http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsa1204720#t=articleTop.

Borshoff D. The limitations of crisis checklists. Anesth Analg. 2014;118(6):1387-1388. http://journals.lww.com/anesthesia-analgesia/Citation/2014/06000/The_Limitations_of_Crisis_Checklists.32.aspx.

Goldhaber-Fiebert S N, Howard S K. Implementing emergency manuals: Can cognitive aids help translate best practices for patient care during acute events? Anesth Analg. 2013;117:1149-1161.

Marshall S. Use of cognitive aids during emergencies in anesthesia: A review of the literature. Anesth Analg. 2013;117:1162-1171.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat