A guest column on regulatory standards.
In mid-December, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) issued an 18-page Survey and Certification memorandum that clarifies and adds new requirements and interpretive guidelines for anesthesia services in Medicare-certified hospitals.
Given the Joint Commission’s requirement to mirror CMS regulation, we should anticipate that Joint Commission surveyors will pick up on these expectations in hospital surveys. (Note: The new rules do not apply to Medicare-certified critical access hospitals or ambulatory surgery centers.)
The document attempts once again to define the various forms of anesthesia on the continuum from general anesthesia to basic analgesia. Some of the changed or new requirements apply to all forms of anesthesia, and some apply just to the higher forms of anesthesia (ie, general anesthesia, regional anesthesia, and monitored anesthesia care, or MAC). For that reason, drawing the correct conclusions about what is required is a challenge. Also, some requirements, especially related to pre-moderate sedation assessment back away from what we expect Joint Commission surveyors to look for.
The new rules make explicit a requirement for there to be a single anesthesia service or department responsible for developing policies and procedures for all anesthesia services including sedation and analgesia. This department shall also determine the minimum qualifications for each practitioner permitted to provide anesthesia services of all forms in all locations within the hospital. Further, the medical staff bylaws or rules and regulations must include criteria for granting anesthesia clinical privileges.
Additionally, the preanesthesia evaluation must now be performed within (or inside) 48 hours prior to surgery; the first dose of anesthesia marks the end of the 48-hour period. The minimum elements of the pre-anesthesia or presedation evaluation have grown to make explicit what has long been implied:
Of note, while the interpretive guidelines do require some form of premoderate sedation evaluation, they are clear that the content of the evaluation may differ from a preanesthesia assessment because moderate sedation is not anesthesia.
Thus, the decade-and-a-half-old expectation that the presedation assessment include an evaluation of the airway seems no longer to be required. Furthermore, there is no mention of the expectation to reassess the patient prior to induction of anesthesia or administration of sedation.
It will be interesting to see if these changes stick and whether the Joint Commission will follow suit in allowing us to simplify the presedation assessment and eliminate the reassessment prior to anesthesia or sedation.
Finally, CMS has pinpointed the earliest point in the patient’s recovery that the postanesthesia evaluation within/inside 48 hours may occur. In 2007, CMS made the subtle change in this regulation to remove the word “inpatient” from the requirement for a postanesthesia recovery evaluation—having the effect of requiring a postanesthesia evaluation for all patients—inpatient and outpatient.
The performance of a postanesthesia evaluation/note has never been particularly problematic for inpatients. Extending this practice to outpatients did not seem to be a problem initially because anesthesia personnel simply conducted the evaluation as they moved the patient from the procedure suite to the recovery room and handed the patient off to the postanesthesia care staff.
Early in 2008, however, CMS began to instruct surveyors to cite hospitals if the evaluation was documented prior to the patient actually recovering from anesthesia. In essence, CMS was citing anesthesia personnel for making a premature postanesthesia evaluation, and in some cases, bordered on citing the more serious charge of fabrication of clinical documentation. In their view, performing the postanesthesia evaluation at the time of arrival to the recovery area was, by definition, premature.
In the December 2009 S&C memo, CMS clarified its position by stipulating the following:
These last 2 points will likely pose a logistical challenge to an anesthesia service because it would seem the only way to accomplish the evaluation within the time frame that begins with having a “sufficiently recovered patient” and ending “prior to discharge” is to have someone from anesthesia assigned to float all day long within the recovery area.
One of our clients has devised a simple statement to include on forms or computer screens used to document the postanesthesia evaluation (sidebar).
It would be important that vital signs (via timed nursing notes) be in the record prior to the anesthesia personnel signing and timing this statement so it would be clear to anyone that the anesthesia personnel’s note/conclusion is based on objective vital sign data in the nursing notes.
This may not be the last word. The American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) has posted a pointed critique of these new rules www.asahq.org/news/asanews011810.htm) that raises numerous concerns with the new regulations. In addition, ASA makes the case that the changes were made outside the normal federal rule-making process and thus failed to allow adequate input from the field. All I can say is—stay tuned! ?
–John R. Rosing, MHA FACHE
Patton Healthcare Consulting
Thiensville, Wisconsin
Access the CMS memorandum at www.asahq.org/Washington/12-11-09%20RevisedANHospitalInterpretiveGuidelines.pdf
Visit Patton Healthcare at www.pattonhc.com/