Protecting patient safety in the OR is everyone’s business. No single group should shoulder the full responsibility for reducing healthcare-associated infections (HAIs). In addition to infection preventionists, epidemiologists, and environmental services personnel, it is the duty of everyone involved in patient care to provide an optimal clean and aseptic surgical and procedural environment.
Contributors may include perioperative staff, surgeons, infection control staff, anesthesia providers, the sterile processing department, building services, quality control or risk management, executive leadership, and, of course, perioperative management. It is imperative to create a multidisciplinary community of allies with the united goal of preventing HAIs in the OR.
Unfortunately, hospitals and surgery centers have been facing challenges that have made progress increasingly difficult. ECRI listed staffing shortages as the top patient safety risk; supply shortages are another risk. Meanwhile, ongoing COVID-19 cases coupled with unexpected outbreaks of RSV, monkeypox, and other viral diseases have stretched healthcare teams beyond the breaking point. Added to continuous pressures to expedite OR turnover, teams have little time to adequately clean between cases, let alone address the intricacies of HAI prevention.
In challenging times like these, it is even more important to create an OR safety culture built on collaboration, shared data, and support to optimize infection prevention outcomes.
Surgical site infections (SSI) are the most common and costly of all HAIs. The National Nosocomial Infections Surveillance system of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimates that SSIs account for 38% of nosocomial infections. Of roughly 30 million surgical procedures performed in the US each year, up to 5% result in SSIs—that is approximately one in 24 inpatient surgery patients. While advances have been made in infection control practices in terms of OR ventilation, sterilization, barriers, and so forth, SSIs remain a substantial cause of patient deaths at a mortality rate of approximately 3%.
Research exists proving contaminated surfaces and objects (fomites) in healthcare settings are a primary source of nosocomial infections. The OR environment is rife with opportunities for indirect contamination from reservoirs of bacteria on surfaces, medical devices, or instruments used during surgery, which can be transferred to other areas or to the hands of surgical personnel—and ultimately to the patient. There is also a growing body of literature showing anesthesia work areas can be contaminated with pathogenic microbes, particularly areas not subject to regular cleaning procedures.
The most common bacteria in OR contamination are staphylococcus species including Staphylococcus aureusand Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, followed by Acinetobacter, Enterobacter, Escherichia coli, and other gram-negative bacilli. These organisms can be transmitted to patients through direct contact with contaminated equipment or with the hands of providers. Studies have shown that the incidence of cross contamination in the intraoperative environment is linked to fomites and the hands of healthcare providers. Contaminated hands are key drivers of cross transmission, as they frequently touch equipment and devices during surgical procedures. Moist surfaces such as damp gloves increase the risk of transmitting Staphylococcus epidermidis from one surface to another.
Regardless of extensive evidence confirming significant risks of fomite transmission, recent studies show that only 32% of the 110,000 objects in healthcare facilities are thoroughly cleaned. Experience has shown that traditional approaches are not effective at reducing HAIs. If current approaches to OR cleaning and disinfection do not evolve, environmental bioburden will continue to threaten patient safety.
The surgical setting is a physically complex and uniquely challenging environment that requires OR-specific infection prevention and control policies. Historically, there has been confusion and conflict over which faction is responsible for OR cleanliness. Yet, in such a complex environment with so many variables, one group cannot possibly address every aspect.
Diverse perspectives from interdisciplinary team members would allow a wider view of the potential risks and the viability of solutions for combatting HAIs. However, for collaborations to be successful, there must be a clear delineation of each stakeholder’s role in preventing OR infections.
Traditionally, environmental services personnel are tasked with cleaning and disinfecting OR floors, surfaces, furnishings, etc, while the OR staff is responsible for equipment cleanliness. The same applies to anesthesia teams and areas. The infection preventionists’ job typically involves developing comprehensive plans to reduce infections while epidemiology assesses pathogen trends in the OR environment. The quality control department is usually in charge of regulatory compliance and surveillance protocols, while OR management evaluates the efficiency and efficacy of cleaning methods to ensure quality patient care. No matter how the duties are delegated, it is vital that all stakeholders understand the important role they play in reducing HAI rates.
Keep in mind, not every OR is the same. Staffing and workflow are specific to each facility and are often dictated by surgical specialty and the location of the OR. Nonetheless, though team integrations may vary, the focus on raising patient safety remains the same.
OR cleanliness is crucial to patient health and safety. Though national guidelines are in place to prevent bacterial contamination in the OR, adherence is not always guaranteed. There is also a general misconception that every team member has the same scope of knowledge when, in reality, most perioperative staff have had no formal training on how to thoroughly and quickly clean and disinfect rooms. Collaborative education and sharing evidence-based data empowers stakeholders and creates a roadmap toward better outcomes.
Initial and continuous training and competency verification on core principles for maintaining a clean and aseptic OR environment are essential to process improvement for existing, intermittent, or rotating staff. Because turnover among healthcare workers is high, vigilance when it comes to training is a crucial part of onboarding for new hires.
There is much to learn about processes for mitigating pathogen transmission and cross-transmission in the OR. Teams must consider the cleanliness of the whole surgical environment, from the scrub sink and sub-sterile room to the OR. The transmission ecosystem is a complex mix that involves infectious agents, patient susceptibility, and infection control practices. Team members who are educated on the primary pathogenic threats and transmission routes are better equipped to break the chain of infection.
AORN and the CDC published guidelines that determine cleaning frequencies for OR and procedure rooms based on the degree of soiling, level of patient contact, and whether objects are used for every patient, with an enhanced focus on the highest risk zones such as doorknobs, switches, handles, patient monitoring devices, IV poles, and the like. Specific areas must be cleaned at specified time intervals—environmental cleaning schedules may occur between cases, terminal cleaning at the end of the day, and weekly.
The CDC recommends that surfaces close to the patient and commonly touched surfaces are cleaned and disinfected on a more frequent schedule than other surfaces. Equipment that comes in direct physical contact with patients should receive high priority for thorough cleaning and disinfection. Components most likely to be contaminated should be cleaned and disinfected between OR uses to reduce the bioburden of organisms and the risk of transmitting such organisms to patients.
AORN also publishes best practices for cleaning and disinfecting anesthesia equipment, which mandates that anesthesia work areas be cleaned and disinfected between every patient. Terminal cleaning by anesthesia staff should be done in accordance with the Infection Prevention Anesthesiology policy.
The overarching theme of all training programs should support the three key elements that impact infection prevention outcomes: efficiency, efficacy, and safety. OR-specific cleaning and disinfection protocols should be standardized to simplify training and streamline processes for higher levels of adherence and compliance. Armed with the proper knowledge and tools, every team member can be empowered to play a vital role in OR safety. Cross-departmental training and education of all healthcare personnel in the OR enables smarter decisions and more effective infection prevention practices.
Environmental audits are critical to success, yet audits of infection prevention and control practices in the OR are not always routine. Continuous process improvement depends on audits that are designed to identify issues that could create patient infection risk.
Though audits may include other safety concerns related to skin disinfection, hand hygiene, traffic control, etc, to reduce fomite transmission in the OR, the focus should be on environmental risks. There are distinct benefits to having multiple parties performing environmental rounds, not the least of which is more comprehensive feedback. Observation of procedures may also reveal opportunities for improvement. During surgery, vigilant supervision is crucial to eliminating indirect contamination, which can lead to patient HAIs.
Effective cleaning and disinfection hinges on having the right tools. The ideal cleaning and disinfection chemical should be Environmental Protection Agency registered against as many HAI-causing pathogens as possible. But because some disinfectants can be harmful to staff and patients, best practices recommend using safer chemicals with low/no inhalation toxicity or health hazard warnings. The chemical should also be pH neutral and compatible with surfaces/equipment, as opposed to high pH solutions that can damage finishes.
New disinfection technologies like electrostatic spraying equipment have shown promising results in further reducing bioburden after standard cleaning and may be considered for terminal cleaning of ORs. Touchless electrostatic sprayers enable faster, more complete surface disinfection without risk of cross-contamination.
Raising awareness about infection prevention in the OR among hybrid professions fosters collaboration and teamwork. When everyone is on the same page, process improvements are inevitable. Though it may be challenging to implement new intervention strategies, the results are well worthwhile. Integrated infection control in the OR is key to increasing patient safety and making inroads in the reduction of HAIs.
—Steve Wilson, CEO of EvaClean Infection Prevention Solutions and EarthSafe Chemical Alternatives, plays an integral role in new product development, creating disinfection protocols, and training programs for healthcare partners.