Nurse leaders know that a successful workplace fosters and celebrates teamwork. In the OR, teamwork among surgeons, surgical technologists, circulating nurses, anesthesiologists, and first assistants, to name a few, is critical to ensure patient safety and positive outcomes. And teamwork does not have to be reserved for inside the surgical suite. Perioperative leaders know this and often strive for strong collaborations within their surgical departments—and they know that involving surgeons in their collaborative efforts and initiatives can sometimes be difficult.
Surgeons recognize the need for collaboration with OR staff as well as with perioperative management, and they often participate in conversations with outside administration, surgical equipment representatives, financial departments, and more. So how can OR leaders who may be struggling to effectively collaborate with surgeons successfully bridge that gap?
OR Manager spoke with two surgeons: Jimmy Chow, MD, an orthopedic specialist, has his own practice called Chow Surgical Hip & Knee Specialists and is affiliated with Abrazo Hospital in Phoenix, Arizona, and Andrea Matson, DO, chief of surgery at Samaritan Healthcare in Moses Lake, Washington. They provided some insights on teamwork and collaboration inside and outside the OR.
“Take operations in the business world, like the Toyota assembly line for example,” says Dr Chow. “They know that the people on the bottom end of the assembly line are the ones who know how to do the work, not the managers at the top, so they empower those folks to participate in the decision making.” That same philosophy can be applied to the surgical department when it comes to OR flow and management, he says. “The goal for us is to keep patients safe and to deliver excellent care. To that end, we need to keep the line running smoothly.”
The key to a smooth-running workflow is collaboration, but to first achieve it, he says, everyone must be on the same page. Here are some steps OR leaders can take to facilitate collaboration with surgeons:
• Clearly communicate everyone’s roles and expertise. Every team member has a specific role in the OR, and the surgeon staff—especially medical students, residents, and new surgeons—may have limited knowledge of the OR team members’ skill sets. Taking the time to present and delineate distinct roles for each team member (or for specific titles depending on the size of the facility) can prevent miscommunication.
• Establish a continuing education process. Continuous education on the aforementioned defined roles, as well as on any procedures or guidelines specific to the facility or department, will keep the teams updated on any changes and address clarification needs. This is a critical practice for any facility struggling with frequent turnovers or employing seasonal workers or travelers.
• Set up regular meetings and surgical debriefings. Standing meetings can be used to consistently check in with one another, address potential hurdles in the collaboration process, and prevent a breakdown in communication.
• Create a collaboration team. A specialized team that focuses on coordinating collaborative efforts for specialized surgical procedures or interdepartmental communication can help build trust in the OR.
• Assign roles and delegate. Particular surgeons, procedures, or equipment may need a dedicated member to take ownership of a particular expertise. Having one team member collaborating with one specific area can keep the collaborative efforts from feeling overwhelming or too complex to handle.Having a team that defines the collaborative approach between surgeons and healthcare staff can help make sure plans do not stay theoretical. This team can set clear goals and ensure the collaborative effort from all parties remains ongoing. Responsibilities of the collaboration team may involve facilitating communication to enhance interactivity, creating guidelines for handling specific needs for different procedures, and a collaborative approach to problem solving.
Dr Chow feels everyone involved in the surgical procedure is just as important as the surgeon. He recalls a conversation with a surgical technologist where he said: “You’re doing just as much of the surgery as I’m doing. And if you’re not doing the surgery with me, then I’m hurting, which can hurt the patient.” He says bringing the focus to patient safety was what drove his point home.
“That’s important because it puts pride in the work they’re doing and gives them a level of responsibility. They know that the job is more than just clocking in, clocking out, and handing the right tool at the right time.”Dr Matson agrees. “Collaborating with staff is important. Everyone needs to know the expectations and next steps, all the way from preoperative to patient recovery.” And while the patient is the focus, it’s not just about what happens inside the OR, she says. “There are material, equipment, and operation needs that are crucial to the success of any procedure. A good team is a team that is well-informed and knows what is required of them.”
Educating staff takes time and resources, which can be a struggle for OR leadership. Having time as a surgeon to educate OR staff on what to expect during a procedure can be even more challenging. Dr Matson makes an effort to meet with the OR team before significant or complicated cases to ensure everything will run smoothly. She also tries to notify leaders immediately if any complications arise that need to be corrected and meets with them at least once a month to discuss any changes that can be implemented in the department.
While it may not be possible for all surgeons or leadership to find time to do this, having scheduled meetings to review processes that may need to change can improve efficiency and patient care. “Having huddles, either routinely scheduled or before complicated cases, helps everyone not to lose touch,” says Dr Matson.
Leadership is critical to create, change, and sustain culture. A surgeon’s relationship with OR leadership differs depending on the person and the specialty; not to mention the politics of any given facility.
Dr Chow keeps a close relationship with the OR manager and nursing leadership. “So much of it is understanding what can be done together. Most physicians have almost no administrative power, and the nurse leader is in a unique position because they most likely have that reach.”
For Dr Matson, she has the number of her facility’s OR manager in her phone. “When I have an issue, I approach the manager with respect in order to have my request met. I am not treated like a complainer, which helps to establish a good culture,” she says. “Most staff don’t get offended or take it personally if you offer to help them get more experience or training. Everyone knows it comes down to what is best for the patient, and management knows that as a surgeon, that is my number one priority.”
Another consideration for OR leadership is educating staff on everyone’s role, so everyone’s actions are understood and can be shared as needed. A recent study (Rosen et al) showed that patients who received care from teams that had more clarity of everyone’s role experienced lower levels of postoperative pain, shorter length of stays, and higher postoperative mobility.
Having clearly defined roles has also been proven to reduce workplace injuries, illness, and violence. On the flip side, units with poorly defined roles and lack of teamwork have led to higher levels of burnout, lateral violence, bullying, and conflicts.
Dr Matson finds that the aforementioned huddles lead to better outcomes. During these meetings, she says, “we discuss any problems that occurred because of a lack of collaboration so they can be handled immediately.”
In one example, the preoperative antibiotic was being skipped. When that was brought to management’s attention, they added a new policy to give antibiotics to all patients preoperatively unless otherwise noted or contraindicated. “We may even take votes at these regular meetings to make sure we’re actively finding solutions. These meetings have led to better patient outcomes at my facility.”
Challenges that surgeons face when collaborating with OR staff, they say, usually stem from workflow and patient safety issues. Advocating as a surgeon to make changes in the OR may also prove difficult when managers are under pressure to collect data and improve facility metrics. In hospitals and ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) that are not physician run, surgeons may also find it challenging to collaborate directly with senior leadership who may not have medical training or work directly in patient care.
At another facility where Dr Matson used to work, complaints were not treated seriously. “I had to keep track of my complaints and lack of changes for patient betterment,” she says. “I knew upper management was hindering the nurse managers from making changes, and I tried to help their efforts with documentation.” She adds that surgeons and nurse leaders can team up when working with non-clinical leadership so they can help one another find the right terms to use that will get them to understand the issue.
Alternatively, when facing challenges to collaborating intraoperatively with staff, Dr Chow recommends correcting the actions postoperatively by explaining what was done wrong and what needs to be done right moving forward. “It’s very hard to correct issues during surgery. But you can certainly use that area as a learning tool for the next procedure.”
An appropriate time to correct mistakes happening in the OR is during surgical debriefings. A study (Zuckerman et al) found that surgical debriefings play a valuable role in helping staff learn from mistakes fast. In the study, a surgical debriefing protocol was implemented across 102 facilities, and it successfully revealed certain instrumentation and equipment challenges that were then corrected.
Collaboration with OR management differs between hospitals and ASCs. Hospitals have several layers of care that may get involved when addressing patient needs, which usually translates to slower action but can also mean that it is easier to get different specialists to come together in one place.
On the other hand, facilitating collaboration in an ASC will sometimes feel easier because the complexity of the cases might be lower, and the number of procedures to consider are fewer. Dr Chow’s experience with collaboration in an ASC is the end result. “Preparedness becomes more important,” he says. “If you are prepared to show the things you need and why, ASCs are more likely than hospitals to give them to you when you ask.”He adds that, in hospitals, it all depends on the relationship with administration.
When it comes to hospital-owned ASCs, he explains, preparedness still helps, but a direct line to the top is what will get you the result you want. “There has to be a good reason for whatever the item you ask for, but beyond that, you need to learn to speak the language the CEO or the CFO speaks,” he says. “Otherwise, they won’t understand or be convinced that you need what you need.”
A breakdown in collaboration, especially when surgeons and OR leadership are involved, will negatively impact patient outcomes. OR leadership can help avoid that by ensuring that all members of the OR staff know everyone’s roles—including the surgeons’—and are well informed to the needs of the department.
Surgeons can help foster collaboration by treating OR staff with respect and recognizing that OR leadership sometimes navigates spaces not available to them. Regularly scheduled meetings are an important strategy to achieve better knowledge of the team, more respectful communication, and fast-acting solutions.
And finally, different facilities may impact how surgeons collaborate with OR staff, and depending on the facility, the key to success may very well be a strong partnership between the surgeon and the nurse leader.
—Breann Kakacek, BSN, RN, has been an RN for almost 10 years, and her experience includes the OR as a circulating nurse and CVICU. She has always had a passion for writing and enjoys using her nursing knowledge to create meaningful content.