June 21, 2023

Contract standardization for endo-mechanical supplies saves millions

By: Judith M. Mathias, MA, BS, RN
Share

Takeaways

  • One of the lessons learned when it comes to data was to make sure you do it right the first time.
  • A big drive for standardization was to leverage the distribution center to send excess inventory that some sites had to sites that needed them.
  • Another drive was the decision that more than $2 million worth of inventory could not just be written off.

Identifying and decreasing hidden costs related to endomechanical supply standardization and contract deviations saved the Canyons Region of Intermountain Health millions of dollars.

Intermountain Health is based in three geographical regions—the Peaks Region in Denver and Montana, Canyons Region in the Salt Lake City area and some in Boise, and the Desert Region in Las Vegas.

The job of the surgical operations team for the Canyons Region is to standardize and implement initiatives across all 23 hospitals. The initiatives include safety initiatives, policies and procedures, compliance, and contract compliance.

Dusty Clegg, MS, RN

“In a very matrixed organization, what this means is that we have all of the accountability of operationalizing these initiatives without the direct line structure support to make that happen,” says Dusty Clegg, MS, RN, operations officer for surgical operations for the Canyons Region. “We have learned that to get our initiatives accomplished, we have to use influence and team building. It is also important that we use data and communicate such data and the initiative at the facility level,” she says.

As the surgical operations officer, Clegg is accountable for contract compliance and noncompliance. While examining a contract for endomechanical category that was coming to an end, she saw that the annual spend for this portfolio was $5.5 million.

Further inspection of these costs found that they had:

• 900 stock keeping units (SKUs)/inventory items contracted

• 593 active SKUs being used

• 130 SKUs that were contract noncompliant and had been given an exception.

“What we found is that we had no process,” says Clegg. If a surgeon wanted to use product Y instead of the contracted product X, the request was granted. Those 130 SKUs drove contract compliance down to 50%. “We were spending just as much on the 130 noncontracted SKUs as we were on the contracted 593 SKUs,” she says. “We had to find out why and prevent it from happening in the future. We also wanted to make sure that whatever contract we moved to or if we stayed with the present contract, that we had contract compliance.”

A survey of providers found that about 80% wanted to change vendors. The move to a different vendor meant they would have to mitigate the cost of $2.6 million in inventory they still had on hand. “That was a lot of money to leave on the table,” Clegg notes.

The operations team set two goals for the initiative—to mitigate the loss of the owned inventory and to create a robust process for contract compliance improvement going forward. “We wanted to make sure we had a process in place for when a provider wanted to have a deviation,” she says. “Key to this was data.”

 

Data informs decisions

John Sturzenegger, MBA

“One of the things I have learned with data is to make sure you do it right the first time,” says John Sturzenegger, MBA, continuous improvement manager for supply chain operations for the Canyons Region. “You can ask people for data, and you will get 15 different answers. I wanted to make sure we had three things going for us: That the data was standardized, so when it was presented, it was the same week after week; that the data was repeatable; and that it could be accessed in a timely manner,” he says.

A lot of the time spent on the initiative, which took about a year to complete, was in gathering the data. There were three sources of data Sturzenegger worked with:

• Owned inventory—“First, we wanted to know how to mitigate the owned inventory risk,” says Sturzenegger. He looked at the inventory items, locations, costs, and PAR levels for questions he knew would be coming up and that he would have to answer.

• 24-month physician utilization—“Once we knew the inventory, we needed to know how we were using it across the board, looking at quantity variations over 24 months according to provider, procedure, and specialty,” he says.

• Contract commitments—“These were our costs, contracts, and commitments; what we were using, what our actual volume was, rebates, and more,” he says.

It took about 3 months to hone in on the source, final scope, and the items impacted by the initiative. “Spending the time up front to get the data was key. It allowed us to speak with confidence when we reported the who, what, where, and when,” says Sturzenegger.

 

Conversion matrix foundation for data

For the data to work, Sturzenegger says they needed to have a conversion matrix, and they needed to know what the inventory items were at a granular level and what was happening to them at the SKU level (sidebar, Conversion Matrix).

“We had a very high level of confidence in this matrix because we made sure our samples, volumes, and codes were correct up front. Then we did surveys and trials to see if there were any issues,” he says.

Once the conversion matrix was done, the team started providing the next level of data to leadership.

System level data. This includes SKUs, inventory in dollars, utilization, and days on hand (sidebar, System Level Data).

“Facilities, providers, and specialties wanted to know how they would be impacted, and we wanted to start small,” says Sturzenegger. “We wanted to keep it at the SKU level, and we wanted to know which items and dollars would be impacted,” he says. “Some were heavy dollars and some were light.”

In addition, Sturzenegger notes they wanted to consider utilization, whether high or low inventory turns, which then equates to days on hand. Once they had the four pieces at the system level, which comprised the $2.6 million and how it was broken down by category, they were ready to present it to leadership.

Facility level utilization data. “Working with 23 facilities is not easy, no matter how you do it,” says Sturzenegger. The important piece at this level was the volume (sidebar, Facility Level Utilization Data). Some facilities had high volumes and high turns, and some had low volumes and low turns.

Another part of this was geography. Looking at different sites and volume, he says, they decided to examine the data and break the project into four areas—Central, North, South, and Southwest. This allowed them to manage the project down into simpler steps.

Provider level data. Sturzenegger says they started by reviewing the North area’s six care sites at the specialty, provider, and procedure levels. “Whether part of the leadership team or a provider, we wanted them to be able to drill-in and see how their volume was being impacted,” he says (sidebar, Provider Level Data).

 

Distribution center

The next part was how to make sure, from a data perspective, that the initiative was successful. “It was hard to provide transparency and data weekly that showed this initiative was a success, when inventory levels changed week over week,” says Sturzenegger.

One of the things that contributed to their success was a central distribution center that looked at all inventory items and where they were being used. “We wanted to leverage the distribution center to send excess inventory that some sites had to sites that needed them. The last thing we wanted was for sites to place orders for items that were available in-house and not being used elsewhere,” he says.

They also started keeping track of credits/exchanges at the site level, providing available inventory to facilities where items were backordered, and monitoring expected versus actual write-offs.

 

Change management

Larissa Jimerson, BSN, RN

“The takeaway is that we have been very successful in our initiative,” says Larissa Jimerson, BSN, RN, clinical operations manager for surgical operations for the Canyons Region. “We decided we just couldn’t write off more than $2 million of inventory.”

Relying on the data provided by Sturzenegger, Jimerson says they began with an assessment of utilization data for the noncontracted supplies. “That’s where we got into trouble,” she says. “We were impacting our contracts negatively with those outliers, so we had to identify the outliers,” she says.

Next, they surveyed the physicians to find out which of the noncontracted endomechanical items they were using, on what procedures they were using them, in which facility they were using them, and whether they would consider converting to a contracted item.

Then, Jimerson says, they realized they had to coordinate transition support not just with surgeons but across the entire system. They began by issuing an all-points bulletin to stop ordering so many items, in large volumes.

“Now that we had the data to show our PAR levels were based on utilization, not clinicians, we went to staff and said there are 20 of these items on your shelf. We can show you that you only need six. You don’t have to hoard that inventory. We can redistribute it,” she says.

They decided on a phased approach because they knew they did not have the resources or ability to change every care site at once. Inventory was moved to the distribution center and then redistributed to care sites that showed historical use of the supplies.

“We didn’t want to just send supplies to a care site where they were rarely used, so we used the weekly data utilization review to redistribute the inventory,” she says. The data were critical because the teams did not want to let their inventory go. She says they had to monitor it weekly and provide the teams with the support and data to convince them they did not need to hoard their supplies.

 

Implementation plan

“We knew one of our biggest challenges would be communication because of message and change fatigue,” says Jimerson. She adds that they did a “saturated communication” to all stakeholders, including clinical teams, physicians, surgeons, and inventory teams.

“We made sure our message was consistent, that we were all on point, and that we would provide the support needed to transition to the new inventory process and new contract,” she says.

Actionable data was provided to the inventory teams so that they didn’t place initial orders for new products haphazardly, such as five of those, 10 of those, and 20 of those.

Inventory teams placed initial orders based on the surgeon utilization map to ensure the supply ordered was in-line with clinical utilization to prevent excessive and zero-use inventory. “We then began implementing the phased approach, whereby old inventory was moved from facilities with low utilization to those with high utilization,” says Jimerson.

The newly-contracted manufacturer’s clinical education team provided on-site education, support, and resources at every hospital. They had one-on-one time with the surgeons and clinical service line champions to help them become familiar with the new products. The manufacturer’s representatives also were available intraoperatively, and they remained on-site for a week after “Go Live.”

“We provided individualized support to meet the surgeons’ needs, and to make the transition to our new manufacturer comfortable for surgeons and safe for the patients,” she says.

The last part of the transition was contract compliance and monitoring. “We got into this situation before because we weren’t adhering to our contract compliance, and now we wanted to make sure we stayed engaged with all stakeholders, monitored our compliance data, and allocated time for comprehensive deviation reviews,’ says Jimerson. “We didn’t want to receive a request for a deviation and be in such a rush to approve it that we didn’t take a step back and look at why the request was being made,” she says. “Was there a clinical rationale for this, or was it just a preference?”

 

Demonstrated lessons and successes

A six-step process was set up to handle deviation requests:

• Discuss clinical rationale for request with associate medical director

• Submit deviation request into a queue

• Perform clinical rationale and financial data review

• Clinical program physician leader provides recommendations

• Clinical program and surgical operations leaders review and render a decision

• All stakeholders are informed of the decision.

Currently, 973 providers use the new contracted supplies, for a compliance of about 96%. In the past year, there have been 89 deviation requests, and 13 have been approved. The projected deviation spend is $537,000.

When the project began, and the decision was made to change contracts, there was $2.6 million worth of inventory on hand. “We projected that we would use about $1 million to $1.5 million of this inventory before the contractual change, but the pandemic produced a lot of backorders that we were able to fill with our inventory, plus we merged with a healthcare system in Colorado that was using the previous contracted manufacturer,” says Clegg.

“In the end, we only had to write off $350,000 of the $2.6 million inventory we had on our shelves,” she says. Sturzenegger added that if they had done nothing with the old contract at $7.8 million annually, the off-contract purchases would have run the costs up to $9.5 million annually. The new contract now costs $5.2 million annually. ORM

 

—Judith M. Mathias, MA, BS, RN, is clinical editor of OR Manager and was previously clinical editor of the AORN Journal.

 

Reference

Clegg D, Jimerson L, Sturzenegger J. Commodities standardization: Waste not, want not. OR Business Management Conference. 2023.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat